Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2009-0010
www.capp.ca communication@capp.ca
Disclaimer
This publication was prepared for the Canadian Association of Petroleum
Producers (CAPP). While it is believed that the information contained herein is
reliable under the conditions and subject to the limitations set out, CAPP does
not guarantee its accuracy. The use of this report or any information contained
will be at the users sole risk, regardless of any fault or negligence of CAPP or
its co-funders.
www.capp.ca communication@capp.ca
Contents
1
Overview.......................................................................................................................1
Pitting Corrosion..............................................................................................3
Other Failure Mechanisms ..............................................................................3
Figures
Figure 2-1: Natural Gas Pipeline Operating FailuresTotal Failures and Failure Frequency by
Reporting Year .................................................................................................................2
Figure 3-1: Internal Corrosion in a Water Injection Pipeline Prior to Grit Blast Cleaning .............4
Figure 3-2: Internal Corrosion in a Water Injection Pipeline After Grit Blast Cleaning.5
Tables
Table 3.1: Contributing Factors and Prevention of Internal Water injection Corrosion...............7-8
Table 3.2: Contributing Factors and Prevention of Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipelines.............9
Table 4.1: Recommended Practices - Design and Construction................................................ 10-11
Table 4.2: Recommended Practices - Operating Practices ........................................................ 12-15
Table 5.1: Corrosion Mitigation Techniques .............................................................................. 16-17
Table 6.1: Corrosion Monitoring Techniques............................................................................. 18-19
Table 7.1: Corrosion Inspection Techniques .............................................................................. 20-21
Table 8.1: Leak Detection Techniques........................................................................................ 22-23
Table 9.1: Repair and Rehabilitation Techniques....................................................................... 24-26
Overview
Corrosion is a dominant contributing factor to failures and leaks in pipelines. To
deal with this issue, the CAPP Pipeline Technical Committee has developed
industry recommended practices to improve and maintain the mechanical integrity
of upstream pipelines. They are intended to assist upstream oil and gas producers
in recognizing the conditions that contribute to pipeline corrosion incidents, and
identify effective measures that can be taken to reduce the likelihood of corrosion
incidents.
This documents addresses design, maintenance, and operating considerations for
the mitigation of internal corrosion in oilfield water handling systems. Within this
document, oilfield water pipelines are defined as those constructed with carbon
steel materials and transporting fresh or produced water. Typically, these would
be pipelines used to convey fresh source water, produced water for water flood
purposes, or water sent for disposal down disposal wells. This document does not
address the deterioration of aluminum and non-metallic pipelines.
This document is complementary to CSA Z662 and supports the development of
corrosion control practices within Pipeline Integrity Management Programs, as
required by CSA Z662 and the applicable regulatory agency. In the case of any
inconsistencies between the guidance provided in this document and either Z662
or regulatory requirements, the latter should be adhered to.
This document is intended for use by corrosion specialists involved with the
development and execution of corrosion mitigation programs, engineering teams
involved in the design of gathering systems, and operations personnel involved
with the implementation of corrosion mitigation programs and operation of wells
and pipelines in a safe and efficient manner. It contains a consolidation of key
industry experience and knowledge used to reduce oil effluent pipeline corrosion;
however it is not intended to be a comprehensive overview of all practices.
Additional recommended practices developed by the CAPP Pipeline Technical
Committee are:
Page 1
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Failure Statistics
In 2008, oilfield water pipeline systems accounted for 22% of the total
pipeline incidents in Alberta.
In 2008, internal corrosion was the cause of approximately 35% of the 170
oilfield water pipeline incidents in Alberta. This is the largest of any
individual cause for oilfield water pipeline incidents.
80
70
500
460
425
419
438
378 379
400
365
350
315
49.3
42.0 40.8
40
45.1
284
30
300
40.1 39.1
214 205
31.2
20
212
201
178
26.0
22.4
185 185
180
161
159
153
170
250
200
150
19.8 18.318.2
14.1 12.9
10
0
450
Total WA Incidents
60
50
# WA Incidents / 1000km
19851986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
100
50
0
# WA Incidents / 1000km 49.3 42.0 40.8 45.1 40.1 39.1 31.2 26.0 22.4 19.8 18.3 18.2 14.1 12.9 10.8 9.4 10.0 10.8 8.3 9.0 8.9 7.1 7.7 9.6
Total WA Incidents
419 378 379 460 425 438 365 315 284 259 254 264 214 205 178 161 180 201 159 185 185 153 170 212
8.5 9.0 9.3 10.2 10.6 11.2 11.7 12.1 12.7 13.1 13.9 14.5 15.2 15.9 16.5 17.1 18 18.6 19.1 20.5 20.9 21.7 22.1 22.1
Figure 2-1 Total Oilfield Water Pipeline Incidents and Oilfield Water Pipeline
Incidents/1000km by Year in Alberta (source: ERCB)
Figure 17b - Water Pipeline Incidents by Cause
Corrosion (Internal) (CI)
Unknown (UN)
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
1985
1990
1995
2000
2005
2010
Figure 2-2 Oilfield Water Pipeline Incidents by Cause in Alberta (source: ERCB)
Page 2
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Pitting Corrosion
Pitting corrosion along the bottom of the pipeline is the primary corrosion
mechanism leading to failures in uncoated carbon steel water pipelines. The
common features of this mechanism are:
3.2
the water contains any of the following; O2, CO2, H2S, bacteria, chlorides,
scale, or suspended solids
the presence of fluid traps where solids can accumulate
Figure 3-1: Internal Corrosion in a Water Injection Pipeline Prior to Grit Blast Cleaning
Page 3
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Figure 3-2: Internal Corrosion in a Water Injection Pipeline After Grit Blast Cleaning (same
pipeline as above)
Page 4
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Figure 3-4: Internal Corrosion on Flange Face. Note Corrosion Caused by Use of Metallic
Rather than Non-Metallic Gasket.
Page 5
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Tables 3.1 and 3.2 describe the most common contributors, causes, and effects of internal
corrosion in oilfield water pipelines. The tables also contain corresponding mitigation measures
commonly used to reduce oilfield water pipeline corrosion. It is applicable to both internally bare
carbon steel pipeline systems and to coated or lined pipelines where deterioration or damage has
allowed water contact with the steel substrate.
3.1 Contributing Factors and Prevention of Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipelines Mechanisms
Contributor
Cause/Source
Effect
Mitigation
Oxygen
Oxygen can
accelerate pitting
corrosion at
concentrations as low
as 50 parts per billion
Present in surface
source waters
Typical organic
inhibitor effectiveness
can be reduced by
the presence of
oxygen
CO2 dissolves in
water to form
carbonic acid
Effective pigging
and inhibition
Corrosion rates
increase with
increasing levels of
dissolved CO2
H2S dissolves in
water to form weak
acidic solution.
Effective pigging
and inhibition
programs
Corrosion rates
increase with
increasing H2S levels
Hydrogen sulphide
can form protective
iron sulphide (FeS)
scales
Small amounts of
H2S (less than 500
ppm) can be
beneficial as a
protective FeS film
can be established
Localized breakdown
of FeS scales results
in accelerated pitting
Carbon
Dioxide (CO2)
Hydrogen
Sulphide
(H2S)
Often present in
waters
CO2 concentration
can be increased
through miscible
floods (CO2 floods)
Sometimes present in
waters
H2S concentration
can be increased
through formation
souring
Can be generated by
sulfate reducing
bacteria
Page 6
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Contributor
Cause/Source
Effect
Mitigation
Bacteria
Effective pigging
program
Solid deposits
provide an
environment for
growth of bacteria
Eliminate the
introduction of
bacteria (i.e. treat
the source of the
problem)
Install pigging
facilities and
maintain an
effective pigging
program
Acid removal of
scale
Scale inhibitor
chemical
treatments
Install pigging
facilities and
maintain an
effective pigging
program
Control corrosion
through effective
inhibition
Scale
Deposition
Solid
Accumulations
Contaminated drilling
and completion fluids
May include
corrosion products
from upstream
equipment
Accumulated solids
and debris may
increase the pitting
rate by creating
localized corrosion
beneath the deposit
(i.e. under deposit
corrosion)
Solids can reduce the
corrosion inhibitor
concentration
available to protect
the pipe
Page 7
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Cause/Source
Effect
Mitigation
Detrimental
Operating
Practices
Ineffective pigging
Design pipeline to
be piggable
Ineffective inhibition
Inadequate pipeline
suspension
Design pipelines to
allow for effective
shut-in and
isolation
Commingling of
incompatible waters
(i.e. mixing waters
can create scale
problems)
Develop and
implement proper
suspension
procedures,
including pigging
and inhibition
Limit operating
temperature
Implement an
effective MOC
process
Maintain integrity of
pipeline operation
and maintenance
history and records
Re-assess
corrosivity on a
periodic basis
Exceeding
Maximum
Operating
Temperature
Management
of Change
(MOC)
Change in operating
temperature
Change in production
characteristics or
operating practices
Well re-completions
and work overs
Lack of system
operating history and
practices
Accelerated
corrosion
Coating deterioration
and corrosion
damage
High temperatures
can damage both
internal and external
coatings
Unmanaged change
may result in gaps in
the effectiveness of
an Integrity
Management
Program
Changing personnel
and system
ownership
Page 8
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Recommended Practices
Tables 4.1 describes the recommended practices for mitigation of internal corrosion in oil
field water pipelines during design and construction.
Tables 4.2 describes the recommended practices for mitigation of internal corrosion in oil
field water pipelines during operation.
Note:
The primary method for controlling corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline systems
is the use of properly installed coated, lined, or non-metallic pipelines.
Recommended
Practice
Benefit
Comments
Materials of
Construction
Non-metallic
materials are
corrosion resistant
Properly coated or
lined steel pipelines
are corrosion
resistant
Consider use
corrosion resistant
materials nonmetallic materials as
per CSA Z662
Clause 13
Reinforced
composite,
thermoplastic-lined
and polyethylene
pipelines
Non-metallic
materials may be
used as a liner or a
free standing
pipeline depending
on the service
conditions
Consider use of
internally coated
carbon steel pipeline
systems (i.e. nylon
or epoxy coated)
with an engineered
joining system
Page 9
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Element
Recommended
Practice
Benefit
Comments
Pipeline
Isolation
Removes potential
deadlegs from the
gathering system
Be aware of
creating deadlegs
between isolation
valve and mainline
at tie-in locations
(i.e. install 12
oclock tee tie-ins,
or above ground
riser tie-ins)
Develop shut-in
guidelines for the
timing of required
steps to isolate and
lay up pipelines in
each system
Multi-disc/cup pigs
have been found to
be more effective
than ball or foam
type pigs
Receivers and
launchers can be
permanent or
mobile
Pigging
Capability
Install or provide
provisions for pig
launching and
receiving capabilities
Page 10
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Element
Recommended
Practice
Benefit
Comments
Inspection
Capability
Install or provide
capability for
inspection tool
launching and
receiving
Internal inspection
using inline
inspection
(intelligent pigging)
is the most effective
method for
confirming overall
pipeline integrity
Consideration
should be given to
the design of
bends, tees, and
risers to allow for
navigation by the
inspection devices
Page 11
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Recommended
Practice
Benefit
Comments
Corrosion
Assessment
Evaluate operating
conditions
(temperature,
pressure, water
quality) and prepare a
corrosion mitigation
program
Effective corrosion
management comes
from understanding
and documenting
design and operating
parameters
Define acceptable
operating ranges
consistent with the
mitigation program
Communicate
corrosion assessment,
operating parameters,
and the mitigation
program to field
operations and
maintenance
personnel
Re-assess corrosivity
on a periodic basis
and subsequent to a
line failure
Page 12
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Element
Recommended
Practice
Benefit
Comments
Corrosion
inhibition and
monitoring
Refer to Section 5
for Corrosion
Mitigation
Techniques
Refer to Section 6
for Corrosion
Monitoring
Techniques
Number and
location of
monitoring devices
is dependent on the
predicted corrosivity
of the system
Consider provisions
for chemical
injection, monitoring
devices, and
sampling points
Develop and
communicate the
corrosion inhibition
and monitoring
program to field
operations and
maintenance
personnel
Allows for an
effective corrosion
mitigation program
NOTE: Ensure
personnel
understand their
responsibilities and
are accountable for
implementation and
maintenance of
corrosion
management
programs.
Inspection
Program
Develop suspension
and lay up
procedures for
inactive pipelines
Develop an
inspection program
or strategy
Communicate
inspection program
to field operations
and maintenance
personnel.
Refer to Section 7
for Corrosion
Inspection
Techniques
Provides assurance
that the corrosion
mitigation program is
effective.
Risk assessments
should be used to
prioritize
inspections
Page 13
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Element
Recommended
Practice
Benefit
Comments
Failure
Analysis
Recovery of an
undisturbed sample
of the damaged
pipeline
Conduct thorough
failure analysis
Improved
understanding of
corrosion
mechanisms
detected during
inspections or as a
result of a failure
Inspect to determine
extent and severity
of damage prior to
carrying out any
repair or
rehabilitation
Prevents multiple
failures on the same
pipeline
Refer to Section 7
for Corrosion
Inspection
Techniques
Prevents
reoccurrence of
problem
Refer to Section 8
for Leak Detection
Techniques
Technique utilized
depends on access
and ground
conditions
Repair and
Rehabilitation
Leak
Detection
Based on inspection
results, use CSA
Clauses 10.9 and
10.10 to determine
extent and type of
repair required
Implement or make
modifications to
corrosion control
program after repairs
Develop a leak
detection strategy
Permits the
detection of leaks
Page 14
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Element
Recommended
Practice
Benefit
Comments
Management
of Change
Implement an
effective MOC
process
Maintain integrity of
pipeline operation
and maintenance
records
Unmanaged
change may result
in accelerated
corrosion, using
inappropriate
mitigation strategy
for the conditions
(outside the
operating range)
Page 15
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Description
Comments
Oxygen
Control
Pigging
Application procedure is
important in determining
effectiveness (i.e. volume of
chemical, diluent used, contact
time, and application interval).
Batch
Corrosion
Inhibition
Page 16
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Technique
Description
Comments
Continuous
Corrosion
Inhibitor
Chemical
Treatment
Biocide
Chemical
Treatments
Page 17
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Description
Comments
Water Analysis
Production
Monitoring
Mitigation
Program
Compliance
Page 18
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Technique
Description
Comments
Corrosion
Coupons
Electrochemical monitoring
should be used in conjunction
with other monitoring and
inspection techniques
Bio-spools
Electrochemical
Monitoring
Page 19
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Technique
Comments
Inline
Inspection
NonDestructive
Examination
(NDE)
Page 20
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Options
Video Camera
/Boroscope
Destructive
Examinatio
n
Technique
A visual inspection tool to locate
internal corrosion
Comments
Page 21
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Description
Comments
Production
Monitoring
Leak Detection
Systems
Right-of-Way
(ROW)
Surveillance
Infrared
Thermography
Flame
Ionization
Survey
Odor Detection
Page 22
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Description
Comments
Pipe Section
Replacements
Page 23
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Technique
Description
Comments
Repair Sleeves
Polymer Liners
Page 24
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems
Technique
Description
Composite or
Plastic Pipeline
Pipeline
Replacement
Comments
Refer to Section 4
Recommended Practices in this
document for details
Page 25
June 2009
Recommended Practice for Mitigation of Internal
Corrosion in Oilfield Water Pipeline Systems