Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Page 42 - 1
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
6995 k
5753 k
4200 k
diameter
area
q operate
53 ft
2206 ft2
2.61 k/ft2
60'
row 20
3.5' deck
15'
4' cap
Piling
Top
row 30
1.59 k
5.89 k
7.48 k
21 each
157 k
gross opr
row 40
wt steel
wt conc.
4 ft
2102 k
5753
1839
157
2102
k
k
k
k
sum
9851 k
sum
11093 k
1k
485 lb/ft3
150 lb/ft3
1000 lbs
row 50
A flat bottom 60 foot diameter, 60 foot tall, liquid nitrogen storage tank
is supported on a pile foundation at 15' above grade.
Pile foundation and pedestal structure to support:
Tank and contents normal operating weight of 5,753,000 lbs.
Test weight of 6,995,000 Lbs.
Life of the structure is 30 years.
Planar tilt is limited to 1/2" in 60' during the life of the structure. Out-of-plane, differential
settlement is limited to 1/8" in 30' and 1/4" in 60' during the life of the structure.'
row 60
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 2
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
Settlements will govern this design as much or more than seismic and wind forces.
row 70
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 3
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
tank
W contents
1.25
0.304 *W
1
1.1
importance factor
from seismic worksheet
estimated redundancy factor
'97 UBC 1612.2.2.1 Exception 2
for concrete columns
seismic
DL shear ult
741
row 80
Structure Movement
33.85
5012
weight
741
32.1 ft CG of effective
contents mass
5012
1183 k ASD API calculations
1656 k ult
and tank
E tank and contents
692
49.10
deck
1839
1839
769
11.5
15.25
col/piles
157
15.0
157
66
2102
row 100
springs
V story
7749
pile cap
2102
9851
1527 k ult
to top of deck
inflection
879
restraint
2405 k ult
approximate DL +
Liquid to top of piling
Figure 42-2 Tank and structure with seismic forces.
Check Redundancy
Overly simplify the model: apply loads to the nodes of the mid-line frame.
Area
3503 ft2
row 110
110 k ult
112 k ult
222
1527 k ult
0.145
222 / 1,527 ratio of any two adjacent column shears to the sum of all column shears
112 + 110
row 120
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 4
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
1 unitless
274483639.xls
F
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 5
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
82
45 piling total
Pile lateral
90 k
pile @ 14'
17 each
82 k/each
1387 k
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
82
Structue
Earth Movement
pile @ 7'
pile sum
soil lat
face
depth
soil p
28 each
52 k/each
1457 k
2843 k service pile soil lateral
250
78
4
156
pcf
ft
ft
k
82
Figure 42-3 This is the piling plan view.
row 150
90 k
52 k
pile cap
2999 k ASD
V pile cap
2405 k ult
compare
1 logic
1718 k ASD
V pile cap
22.5
82 k
14 ft
7 ft
6 k
Figure 42-4 Piling lateral resistance -- spacing
2,405 /1.4 = 1,718 < 2,999
OK
versus capacity.
row 160
structure seismic movement
grade
200 k-ft
row 180
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 6
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
row 190
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 7
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
horizontal component
1.0 * 1,527 * 1.1
1679
+
+
vertical component
0.5 * 0.360 * 1.25 * 9,851 * 1.1
2438
row 200
horizontal component
400
vertical component
581
Eh / D
0.170 * D
row 210
400 /2,345
and
Ev
Ev / D
0.248 * D
581 /2,345
1.4 D
(12-5)
1.2 D
1.0 Eh
1.0 Ev
(12-6)
0.9 D
1.0 Eh
1.0 Ev
row 220
1.4 D
2 (12-5)
1.2 D
0.170 D horizontal
0.248 D vertical
3 (12-6) a
4 (12-6) b
0.9 D
0.9 D
+
+
0.170 D horizontal
0.170 D horizontal
+
+
+
-
0.248 D vertical
0.248 D vertical
row 230
row 240
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 8
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
row 250
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 9
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
deck
columns
sum
1839
79
1918
sum
7671
horizontal
vertical
nodes
23
row 260
114
457
6
114
457
12
114
457
18
57 k
228
21 node
457
1826
row 270
columns
pile cap
79
2102
2181
sum
nodes
spring resistance
519
43
2
82
87
5
52
87
8
52
87
11
52
87
14
52
87
17
52
43 k
20
82 k/inch
519
row 280
nodes
13
16
19
row 290
row 300
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 10
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
row 310
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 11
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
LOADS to DECK MID-LINE by CASE and LOAD COMBINATIONS per '97 UBC
Load combinations are:
1
(12-1)
1.4 x Case 1 D only
node
1.4 D
node
2
(12-5)
1.448 x Case 1 D
0.148 x Case 2 E
1.0 x Case 3 E API
node
1.448 x Case 1 D
0.148 x Case 2 E
node
1.2 D
3
(12-6) a
1.148 x Case 1 D
0.148 x Case 2 E
1.0 x Case 3 E API
node
1.448 x Case 1 D
0.148 x Case 2 E
node
0.9 D
4
(12-6) b
0.652 x Case 1 D
0.148 x Case 2 E
1.0 x Case 3 E API
node
0.652 x Case 1 D
0.148 x Case 2 E
node
0.9 D
228
3
457
6
43
2
87
5
+
228
57
3
43
43
2
+
228
57
3
43
43
2
+
228
57
3
43
43
2
457
12
87
8
87
11
0.170 D horizontal
457
114
394
6
15
87
87
87
87
5
8
0.170 D horizontal
457
114
394
6
15
87
87
87
87
5
8
0.170 D horizontal
457
114
394
6
15
87
87
87
87
5
8
87
14
457
18
228
21
87
17
43
20
row 320
0.248 D vertical
457
114
12
87
87
11
87
87
14
457
114
18
87
87
17
21
43 where: 1.2 + 0.248
43
20
457
114
18
87
87
17
21
43 where: 0.90 + 0.248
43
20
457
114
0.248 D vertical
457
114
12
87
87
11
87
87
14
0.248 D vertical
457
114
12
87
87
11
87
87
14
18
87
87
17
21
43 where: 0.90 0.248
43
20
row 350
Axial and moment forces were generated from a subsequent computer run.
These loads are:
axial
moment
460 k ult
1174 k ult
row 360
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 12
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
row 370
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 13
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
1.0 unitless
SDS
from above
short period spectral response 9.4.1.2.5-1
Cs
0.719 g ult
0.299 g ult
9851 k
from above
Vert story
1417 k ult
2945 k ult
row 380
V story
0.299 * 9,851
horizontal component
701
0.238 * 2,945
vertical component
337
0.238 * 1,417
ratioed loads
row 390
E1
QE + 0.2 SDS D
Case 5 2.3.2
1.2 D
2815 vertical
1.2 * 2,345
E2
QE
- 0.2 SDS D
Case 8 2.3.2
0.9 D
2111 vertical
0.9 * 2,345
Eq. 9.5.2.7 - 1
E1
701 horizontal
1.0 * 701
0.2 SDS D
0.2 SDS D
337 vertical
337
Eq. 9.5.2.7 - 2
E2
701 horizontal
1.0 * 701
row 400
337 vertical
337
QE /D =
701 /2,345 =
0.299 * D
and
0.2 SDS D /D =
337 /2,345 =
0.144 * D
These factors are to be used in the computer finite element analysis "Load Combinations."
row 410
1.4 D
2 5 2.3.2
1.2 D
0.299 D horizontal
0.299 D vertical
3 8 2.3.2 a
4 8 2.3.2 b
0.9 D
0.299 D horizontal
0.144 D vertical
0.9 D
0.299 D horizontal
0.144 D vertical
row 420
These results are slightly less conservative than the '97 UBC results above
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 14
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
row 430
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 15
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
LOADS to DECK MID-LINE USING ASCE 7-05 STRENGTH DESIGN for Comparison
This frame is an elastic ordinary moment resisting frame.
.
SDS
1.00 unitless
from above
Cs
0.719 g ult
0.299 g ult
9851 k
from above
Vert story
V story
1417 k ult
2945 k ult
row 440
Basic Load Combinations ASCE 7-05 Where 12.4.2.3 is used in lieu of 2.3.2
ratio
0.238
= 5 mid-line columns /21 columns total
D
2345
0.238 * 9,851
horizontal component
701
0.238 * 2,945
vertical component
337
0.238 * 1,417
ratioed loads
row 450
Case 5
Case 6
E5
701 horizontal
1.0 * 701
0.2 SDS D
337 vertical
337
- 0.2 SDS D
337 vertical
337
E6
701 horizontal
1.0 * 701
row 460
QE /D =
0.2 SDS D /D =
701 /2,345 =
337 /2,345 =
0.299 * D
0.144 * D
row 470
These factors are to be used in the computer finite element analysis "Load Combinations."
1.4 D
2 Case 5
1.2 D
0.299 D horizontal
0.299 D vertical
3 Case 6
0.9 D
0.299 D horizontal
0.144 D vertical
row 480
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 16
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
row 490
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 17
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
1.0 unitless
SDS
from above
0.719 g ult
0.299 g ult
Cs
D
9851 k
from above
Vert story
1417 k ult
2945 k ult
V story
9,851 * 0.299
row 500
E1
horizontal component
701
QE + 0.2 SDS D
vertical component
337
Eq. 9.5.2.7 - 1
row 510
Case 5 2.4.1
E2
1.0 D
2345 vertical
QE
Case 8 2.4.1
- 0.2 SDS D
0.6 D
1407 vertical
0.7 E1
491 horizontal
0.2 SDS D
337 vertical
Eq. 9.5.2.7 - 2
0.7 E2
491 horizontal
0.2 SDS D
337 vertical
row 520
where:
QE /D =
491 /2,345 =
0.209 * D
and
0.2 SDS D /D =
337 /2,345 =
0.144 * D
ASD levels.
row 530
1 5 2.4.1
2 8 2.4.1 a
1.0 D
0.209 D horizontal
0.144 D vertical
0.6 D
0.209 D horizontal
0.144 D vertical
3 8 2.4.1 b
0.6 D
0.209 D horizontal
0.144 D vertical
Use these applied strength design (ASD) loads to compute deflections in the computer finite element analysis
"Load Combinations."
row 540
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 18
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
GENERATE ASD ASCE 7-05 LOADS for DEFLECTION CALCULATIONS for Comparison
SDS
1.0 unitless
from above
0.719 g ult
0.299 g ult
Cs
D
9851 k
from above
QE
2945 k ult
9,851 * 0.299
where QE = V
row 550
Basic Load Combinations ASCE 7-05 Where 12.4.2.3 is used in lieu of 2.4.1
ratio
0.238
= 5 mid-line columns /21 columns total
D
2345
Case 5
horizontal component
701
Case 6
0.2 SDS D
row 560
337 vertical
Case 8
491 horizontal
368
177
+
+
0.7 QE
491 horizontal
0.14 SDS D
row 570
236 vertical
1.0 D
0.6 D
0.6 D
+
+
+
0.209 D horizontal
0.157 D horizontal
0.209 D horizontal
+
+
0.144 D vertical
0.075 D vertical
0.101 D vertical
row 580
Use these applied strength design (ASD) loads to compute deflections in the computer finite element analysis
"Load Combinations."
row 590
PILE FOUNDATION
Page 42 - 19
42
TANK SUPPORT
Christy
15:00
06/24/15
274483639.xls
F
row 600