Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JEWM
Research Article
One of the threats to global environmental health is waste generation. Growth in population
as well as rise in the quantity of municipal solid waste generated has made it difficult to
locate appropriate site for waste disposal in most urban areas. Land filling is now accepted
as the most widely used method for addressing this problem in all countries of the world.
However, appropriate site selection for land filling is a problem in waste management and
therefore needs to be addressed. This research sought to identify a suitable landfill site for
waste disposal in Sekondi-Takoradi Metropolis of Ghana. To achieve this, Geographical
Information System (GIS), Fuzzy Logic and Multi-criteria Evaluation (MCE) were applied in
order to display and rank candidate sites. The analysis was limited to criteria that were
selected and relevant to the area under investigation. The results obtained provide clear
areas for landfill sites in the study area and finally arrives at suitable areas.
Keywords: Fuzzy, GIS, landfill, multi-criteria, weighted linear combination
INTRODUCTION
One of the unavoidable products of the human society
is Municipal Solid Waste (MSW). The increasing trends
in the generation of MSW in time past led to the
establishment of a management system known as the
municipal solid waste management system (MSWMS)
which has gained popularity in recent past (Rafiee et
al., 2011). The MSWMS is an integrated approach of
managing MSW and involves several techniques
involving
recycling,
recovering,
reuse,
incineration/gasification, composting and landfilling
(Tchobanoglous et al., 1993). Even though, there is a
worldwide convergence on waste reuse and recycling,
landfill stills becomes unavoidable in the MSWMS
especially in most developing countries such as Ghana.
In most developing countries, the technical know-how
and the finance required to engage recycling of MSW is
readily non-available and therefore many resort to the
use of landfill as the cheapest mean of managing
MSW.
In Ghana, the country is seriously plagued with several
waste generation problems. According to GEPA (2002),
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment
071
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment
072
Dataset
Scale or Resolution
Source
DEM
30 m By 30 m
US Geological Survey
Properties (Settlement)
1 : 50 000
Roads
1 : 50 000
Water Bodies
1 : 50 000
Materials
In this research, several datasets, both vector and
raster at different scales were used. These data were
obtained from different sectors based on availability
and suitability for the purpose of the study. Table 1
show the datasets used together with their sources.
Methods
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment
073
Rating
Suitability Level
Road
Water Bodies
Property
Elevation
0.0000 - 0.1172
0.0000 - 0.1211
0.0000 - 0.1133
0.0000 - 0.1133
Highly Suitable
0.1172 - 0.3633
0.1211 - 0.3633
0.1133 - 0.3398
0.1133 - 0.3398
Suitable
0.3633 - 0.6133
0.3633 - 0.6133
0.3398 - 0.5898
0.3398 - 0.5898
Fairly suitable
0.6133 - 0.8672
0.6133 - 0.8672
0.5898 - 0.8555
0.5898 - 0.8555
Low Suitability
0.8672 - 1.0000
0.8672- 1.0000
0.8555 - 1.0000
0.8555 - 1.0000
Unsuitable
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment
074
Criteria
Weight
0.35
0.30
0.20
0.15
Total
1.00
Suitabilit y Index w i x i
Equation (2)
Where wi is the weight of each criterion i and xi is the
standardised score (0-1) of each criterion.
Suitabilit y Score w i x i C j
Equation (3)
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment
075
a.
b.
c.
d.
Figure 2. Map Showing Straight line Distance and Slope of Evaluated Criteria for the Landfill Site
(a: straight line distance from properties to all points, b: straight line distance from water bodies to
all points, c: straight line distance from roads to all points, d: slope in degrees)
Standardisation of Criteria
Discussions
Figure 3 are map that shows all the criteria after they
were standardised by the assignment of fuzzy
membership based on an evaluation scale of 0 to 1.
Suitability Index
The Suitability Index (SI) of landfill for the study area is
shown in Figure 4. Suitability index values ranged from
0 to 1, with higher index values showing greater
suitability of land for siting a landfill. The index values
were reclassified into five levels of suitability ranging
from unsuitable to very highly suitable. Table 4 shows
these suitability classes as well as their corresponding
index values and total area.
Selection of Best Sites
Applying the constraint map together with a minimum
area of 20 ha, 4best sites were selected from the very
highly suitable class range. These potential sites
together with the constraints are shown in Figure 5.
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment
076
Figure 3.Maps showing suitability of evaluation (standardised) criteria for landfill site (a: distance to settlement;
b: distance to water bodies; c: distance to roads; d: slope)
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment
077
Area
Suitability Index
Class Name
0.00 - 0.10
Ha
Unsuitable
8748.36
40.23
0.10 - 0.20
Low Suitable
1430.46
6.58
0.20 - 0.5
Moderately Suitable
6882.75
31.65
0.50 - 0.65
Highly Suitable
4242.87
19.51
0.65 - 1.00
442.08
2.03
21746.52
100.00
TOTAL
Figure 5. Locations of Best Sites for Landfill Site in the Study Area
CONCLUSIONS
Siting of landfill site is multidisciplinary and a very
complex process, therefore careful consideration of all
factors ranging from environmental to economic is
required. This research has demonstrated the use of
multi-criteria evaluation (MCE) in GIS-Fuzzy Logic
environment for selecting of a landfill site in the
Sekondi-Takoradi Metropolis. The MCE was therefore
proven to be an effective and efficient method of siting
a landfill.
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment
REFERENCE
Ayat M (2006). The Networks of Collection and
Transfer Stations of Municipal Solid Waste
Management System, pp 1-137: University of Tehran.
Eastman JR (2009). Guide to GIS and Image
Processing, IDRISI Tiga(manual version 16). edn.
Clarke Lab: University of Clarke, Worcester, MA.
Erkut E, Moran SR (1991). Locating obnoxious facilities
in the public sector: An application of the hierarchy
process to municipal landfill siting decisions.
Socioecon. Plann. Sci. 25(2): 8-102.
Fei-Baffoe B, Nyankson AE, Gorkeh-Miah J (2014).
Municipal Solid Waste Management in SekondiTakoradi Metropolis, Ghana. Journal of Waste
Management 2014: 1-9.
Ghana Environmental Protection Agency (GEPA)
(2002). Landfill Guideline, p 73. Accra, Ghana.
Javaheri H, Jafarian MH, Rowshan GR, Khoshnam H
(2006). Site Selection of Municipal Solid Waste
Landfills Using Analytical Hierarchy Process Method
in
A
Geographical
Information
Technology
Environment
in
Giroft.
Iranian
Journal
of
Environmental Health Science and Engineering3(3):
177-184.
Jiang H, Eastman JR (2000). Application of fuzzy
measure in multi-criteria evaluation in GIS.
International Journal Geographical Information
Science 14(2): 173-184.
Karkazi A, T H, Mavropoulos A, Emmanouilidou B,
Ahmed E (2001). Landfill Siting Using GIS and Fuzzy
Logic
Kirkwood CW (1997). Strategic Decision Making:
Multiobjective Decision Analysis with spreadsheets.
edn. Duxbury Press: Belmont, CA.
Kreith F (1994). Handbook of Solid Waste
Management. edn. McGraw-Hill: New York, NY, USA.
Kumi-Baoteng B, Stemn E, Agyapong AE (2015). Effect
of Urban Growth on Urban Thermal Environment: A
Case Study of Sekondi-Takoradi Metropolis of Ghana
Journal of Environment and Earth Science 5(2): 3241.
Lin H, Kao J (1999). Enhanced Spatial Model for
Landfill Siting Analysis. Journal of Environmental
Engineering 125(9): 845-851.
Mahamid I, Thawab S (2010). Multi Criteria and Landfill
Site Selection Using GIS: A Case Study from
Palestine. The Open Environmental Engineering
Journal 2010 (3): 33-41.
Makhdum M (1993). Fundamentals of Land Use
Planning. edn. Tehran University Press: Tehran, Iran.
Malczewki J (1999). GIS and Multicriteria Decision
Analysis. edn. John Wiley and Sons, Inc: New York,
NY.
Malczewki J (2004). GIS-based land-use suitability
analysis: A critical overview. Progress Planning 62: 365.
078
Municipal solid waste landfill site selection in the Sekondi-Takoradi metropolis of Ghana using fuzzy logic in a GIS environment