Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 5
On the other hand, producing grades other than those initially considered is less economical or
even impossible. Generally speaking, the larger the PM production is, the more narrow is the
window of grades which can be produced on this machine. Hence, large and fast running
machines are usually "single-grade machines."
In order to avoid unfavorable interferences and in order to gain steady operation of certain
equipment or sub-processes, these units are, at least to some degree, de-coupled from each
other. This is usually achieved by buffers with sufficient capacity or by the possibility to switch or
to connect process streams differently. The higher the amount of storage or buffer capacity is, the
larger the variation may be, which can be leveled out. However, the smoothening effect of large
buffers on very low frequency variation can be limited. On a multigrade machine, the time needed
for changing grades should be short and the amount of broke produced during the grade change
should be small. Hence, stock chests should be relatively small and recirculations short. The total
production efficiency on a multigrade machine is usually lower than for especially designed
single-grade processes. Table 1 shows typical total efficiencies for modern paper mills; the
efficiency figure considers scheduled and unscheduled downtime and broke.
Table 1. Typical total efficiencies of modern paper machines.
Grade produced
Total efficiency
Newsprint
90%
Supercalendered paper
90%
Lightweight coated paper
82%
Woodfree paper
92%
Tissue paper
85%
Linerboard
85%
Folding boxboard
82%
The sub-processes of the stock and water systems of the paper machine are:
- Stock preparation
- Stock approach flow system
- White water and fiber recovery system
- Broke system.
Figures 1 and 2 show stock preparation and short circulation as blackbox models. For
process design as well as for troubleshooting in mill practice, it is useful to be aware of the
borders and interfaces between the sub-processes and operations, especially in complex and
sophisticated systems. Addressing the criteria, needs, and concerns for each process step
makes it evident as to whether all pieces are suitable to meet their particular goal. Designing the
processes accordingly will maximize profitability. Categorizing the activities and defining the
process steps is also known as system analysis. Possible bottlenecks in processes can be
identified. In an interconnected system, the entire system is only as good as its weakest part. In
this respect, malfunction or disturbances originating from auxiliary equipment, fittings, piping,
controls, etc., can spoil process performance significantly, even if the main equipment is well
chosen and, as such, operating perfectly. Separation of processes into functional units makes
complex and sophisticated systems more comprehensible and easier to understand, which
means a potential improvement in controllability, system stability, operation safety, etc. Clearly
structured processes also ease troubleshooting because reason and cause of problems can be
more quickly and easily separated and identified.
Figure 1. Stock preparation, system principle.
The number of used pulp components depends on their availability and on the product
properties desired. Accordingly, in stock preparation, the fiber furnish is determined by:
- Selection and proportion of the stock components
- Improvement and development of the fibers, i.e., beating.
Chapters 3 and 4 describe in detail the main operations like slushing, defibration, and refining
of pulp. The consumption of fresh water in stock preparation is very low if not zero. Fresh water is
used for the dilution of chemicals and eventually as supplement water in startup situations. In a
simple case, stock preparation consists of dilution of a single pulp component and mixing it with
recovered fiber and broke.
Figure 2 shows a typical short circulation as a blackbox model; the streams of air from
deaeration and filler are optional according to the paper produced. The "rejects" stream here also
includes the end-stage screen accept, if this is fed into the couch pit. The heating energy added
to the wire pit controls the process temperature; its application can be restricted to the startup
situation. All fluid streams vary purposely and arbitrarily in flow, concentration, the composition of
suspended and dissolved materials, and temperature to some extent. In this respect, the
component with the most impact on this system is the thick stock flow.
Figure 2. Short circulation, system principle.
The main operations in the approach flow system are:
- Dilution to headbox consistency
- Removal of product and production disturbing contaminants (solids and air)
- Conditioning with chemicals and additives
- Feeding the headbox
- Supply of additional water for PM cross-profile control in case of a headbox dilution system.
Figure 3 shows the approach flow system of a printing paper mill. The thick stock is pumped
from the machine chest (1) for dilution at the wire pit (2). After the thick stock pump a shut-off
valve, a magnetic flowmeter, and a connector for the consistency measurement are shown. Thus,
the basis weight is here controlled by the speed of the thick stock pump. At the stock mixing zone
of the wire pit (2), right before the stock fan pump (3), the additive dosage points are shown. The
stock fan pump (3) feeds the first stage cleaner banks (4), from where the accept flows to the
deaeration tank (5). The air from the stock deaeration tank (5) and the headbox dilution water
deaeration tank (not shown) passes through an on/off valve and the condenser to the first-stage
vacuum pump (6) followed by a water separator. On the small branch pointing to the right side,
the vacuum breaker valve is shown. The second stage vacuum pump followed by a water
separator is partly hidden. The stock flows from the deaeration tank (5) to the headbox fan pump
(7). There are connections shown for filler and additive dosage right before the fan pump (7).
There are two horizontally mounted pressure screens (8), which are equipped each with an
automatic shut-off valve on the feed side and a manual shut-off valve at the accept side. Reject
collection and treatment are not shown here. From the screens (8), the machine stock flows to
the headbox of the PM. Retention aid is dosed via a ring pipe header and several radial dosage
points (9).
Figure 3. Stock approach flow system of a fine paper machine (refer to text for itemization of
position numbers).
5.2.2 System stability
Production conditions and parameters can be quite different according to the wide range of
different paper and board grades. Papermaking succeeds even with highly loaded process water
in closed cycle, i.e., effluent-free, production. However, process conditions have to be stable to
reach the required product quality and a high production efficiency. Steadiness and uniformity of
flow are vital and are determined by the design as well as by the operation of the process.
Especially in modern operations with high-speed machines and with low fresh water
consumption, the physical system stability is as important as the chemical stability of the water
systems and the wet end. Attention is paid to the variation of several parameters, separately
acting or interacting with each other, when designing or improving the operation of the flow
approach system and the wet end. Problems can be caused by variation of:
- Flow speed
- Pressure (pulsation)
- Temperature
- Flow conditions and the degree of turbulence
- Consistency
- Furnish composition and its homogeneity including inorganic solids
- Specific surface of fibers, content of fines, freeness
- Charge content, cationic demand, pH
- Content and distribution of chemicals and additives
- Content and distribution of undesired substances and contaminants including air.
In the stock and water system of the PM, the importance of steadiness and uniformity of flow
increases when approaching the sheet forming. Unevenness in any flow can occur for each of
the above-mentioned parameters:
- In the cross-direction of the flow
- In the flow direction.
The latter means a time variation of the flow, which appears in:
- Short term: in frequencies > 1 Hz, or in wavelengths < 1 s
- Long term: in frequencies < 1 Hz, or in wavelengths > 1 s.
Additionally to these periodical (deterministic) variations, there are random (stochastic)
variations in the short term as well as in long term.
5.2.2.1 Grade changes
Contrary to the principle of steady operation are grade changes on the PM. Carrying out grade
changes has to be considered carefully when designing the approach flow system and the long
circulation of a paper or board machine to ensure stable operation over the entire product range.
This applies for so-called "single-grade" as well as for "multigrade" machines; on the single-grade
machine, the difference between the produced grades is small. The following points are important
on multigrade machines:
- Quick response upon changes to gain a short transition period when changing to another
grade. This means an improvement in production time efficiency and less broke. Large storage
capacity dampens the response.
- Adaptation without production disturbance. Machine runnability or production should not be
lower right after the grade change compared to steady-state operation.
- Fast leveling-out of variations, e.g., caused by instability in the wet end chemistry. Besides
the PM runnability, product quality also should not be on a lower level after the grade change
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 4
dilution water flow for the thick stock (Q0, c0) in the wire pit. Figure 4 b shows the dynamic
response for different retention values R, when starting the system in Fig. 4 a with clear water.
Consider that each stock fraction has a different retention value. The curves in Fig. 4 b could be,
for example, the retention curves for different Bauer McNett fractions of a certain stock
composition. Their different response causes variations in the basis weight as well as in the web
composition as a reaction to quality or quantity changes in the thick stock flow. An increase in
thick stock feed leads to a quicker change in the long fiber fraction of the web and to a slower
change in the fines and filler content. Vice versa, when decreasing the thick stock flow, fines and
fillers are over-represented in the web, due to the less retained material circulating1. This can
cause oscillation in the product properties, especially after grade changes, which can reduce the
total efficiency of the PM.
If a change between particular grades is not possible without major material losses or
process complications, emptying and washing of the system is necessary. In this case, the
production must be scheduled accordingly. Such washing periods are carried out, for example, in
colored paper production, where the dyestuff is changed grade by grade from light to dark
shades. After producing the darkest shade, the system is cleaned and production can be started
again with the lightest shade.
Figure 4. (a.) Short circulation model. (b.) Dynamic response for different retention values R as a
function of normalized time1.
5.2.2.2 Pressure variations and pulsation
Of the parameters possibly varying in short-term pressure variations or pulsation are the most
critical in the short circulation. High-speed, single-layer machines for printing paper production
are affected in particular. Changes in pressure alter the headbox pressure causing undesired
variations in the headbox lip flow and in the fiber orientation, etc. In the PM wet end, flow
variations are experienced as "barring." Pressure pulses can cause segregation of fibers, fines,
and fillers in the suspension, which cause small-scale stock concentration variations and, thus,
affect the formation of the sheet. Also fiber spinning, plugging of screens, and deposits can be
caused. These variations not only reduce the flow uniformity in the machine-direction, but also
make the control of the cross-direction profile more difficult. As a result, the runnability, thus the
production efficiency of the PM is reduced. Besides runnability, also the product quality can be
reduced and, in many cases, printability in particular.
Couching several plies like in board machines dampens significantly small-scale variation,
typically basis weight variations, which might be critical for a single-layered sheet.
Pulsation analysis
The stock approach system is a collection of elements that can
- create,
- transmit,
- dampen or amplify
pressure variations. The effect of these pulses can be studied from the basis weight variations,
either on-line or off-line. A more direct measurement of pulsation is possible by installing
pressure transducers at pipes or by taking vibration measurements with accelerometers outside
of pipes or machines. The occurring frequencies and amplitudes characterize the pulsation.
Usually, the higher the amplitude is, the greater is the disturbance. Signal analysis including the
Fast Fourier Transformation (FFT) is used to extract frequency components 2. Figure 5 shows the
typical frequency bands of sources in which the disturbances occur at the short circulation.
Figure 5. Frequency bands of hydraulic pulsation sources in the short circulation.
The detrimental effect of mechanical vibrations cannot be underestimated. Sufficient support
of pipes and solid foundations of machinery are important 3. Separate foundations and
substructure of the headbox and wire section reduce vibrations in the wet end. In the approach
flow system, a well-designed framework and proper mounting of the piping gives enough support
to avoid vibrations but allowing for thermal expansion.
Figure 7. Water Sankey diagram of supercalendered (SC) paper machine at design production.
Changes in the amount of stock circulating in the short circulation, i.e., by changes in the wire
retention, have an effect on the stock concentration in the headbox. This includes slow variations
in retention, which might be initiated by changes in the amount, size distribution, or charge of the
fillers and fines fraction, changes in the amount of dissolved and detrimental substances, or in
cationic charge demand, temperature, pH, etc.
5.2.2.4 Headbox approach flow stability
Pipe bends, joints, and installations cause pipe flow disturbances, which appear as turbulence
and vortices causing a head loss 4,5. Especially immediately before the headbox, secondary flows
or vortices have to be avoided as far as possible to ensure the most even flow conditions. The
number of bends in the pipe between the machine screen(s) and headbox should be as small as
possible, also for lessening the costs. Figure 3 shows one possible solution. The last bend before
the headbox has a radius of at least three times the pipe diameter. If that is not possible for some
reason, the pipe should be carried out as a so-called "hydraulic knee," where the pipe diameter is
reduced over the bend. This solution is usually more expensive; however, in any case, cavitation
and flow separation must be avoided. The bend is followed by a straight section of about five
times the pipe diameter right before the tapered inlet header of the headbox (if an attenuation unit
or other special headbox approach is not used)6. No control valves or other measuring devices
are installed in the headbox feed pipe. Properties of the headbox feed stock are measured after
the headbox at the recirculation line. See also the section about stock transport.
5.2.3 Stock and water balance
Determining the stock and water balance of the paper mill is the starting point for any new
process design as well as for an existing system analysis. The balances can vary substantially for
different situations, e.g., production of the lowest and the highest basis weight or in the case of
web breaks. An illustrative manner of representing balances is in the form of a Sankey-diagram
as shown in Figs. 6 and 7 for a supercalendered paper line in steady operation. Figure 6 shows
the flow of solids relative to the amount of paper at the reel, and Fig. 7 shows the specific water
flow for the same situation. Note that, for this grade, there is a large amount of solids in the short
circulation in this case, at a retention of 54%. For clarity reasons, the figure shows the cleaner
and screening system as one block each and the PM shower water system is very simplified.
Collected waters are of different quality, and they are not fed all together into the white water
(WW) tank, as shown in Figs. 6 and 7. Note also that the PM comprises a dilution water headbox.
Dilution at the second and third cleaner stages is done with wire water, which is shown by the
smaller of the two parallel streams between the blocks "wire pit and fan pump" and "cleaner
system" in Figs. 6 and 7. The paper mill surplus water is usually fed upstream, like in this case,
into the mechanical pulp production unit.
5.2.4 Multi-ply and multilayer systems
The number of separate stock approach flow systems increases according to the number of
different stock components used either in multi-ply or multilayer paper and board production.
Figures 8 through 10 show the block diagrams for a printing paper-producing machine, a
multilayer-producing PM like tissue or linerboard, and a multi-ply board or linerboard machine.
The multilayered sheet is produced from one multichannel headbox and one former; thus,
there is only one wire pit (see Fig. 9). The multichannel headbox combines two or three stock
flows into one jet leaving the headbox lip. This flow consists typically of two different furnishes,
which means in the case of a triple layered flow that one furnish is used for the middle layer
and the other one for the two outer layers. Both approach flow systems have to be dimensioned
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 7
according to the desired sheet structures and grades. The requirements on availability and
trouble-free operation of the stock approach flow systems are as high, if not even higher, as in
single systems because the failure of one approach flow system means that the entire paper
production fails.
Figure 8. Printing paper machine, block diagram.
On a multi-ply board machine, either on a multifourdrinier machine or on a multiple former
machine, the wire waters are collected separately and the water circuits are usually separated
(see Fig. 10). This is important, if the furnishes of the plies are of very different kinds, e.g., a
white top on a brown or gray mid or base layer. Investment costs are higher, due to the higher
degree of complexity of the entire stock approach flow system including separate blend and
machine chests for each ply or component. The larger amount of equipment also requires more
floor space, electric power, and instrumentation and control loops. The benefits of multi-ply
forming are7:
- Production can be possibly increased,
- Raw material costs can be optimized by using a cheaper furnish and still getting the same
strength or optical properties,
- Better quality white-lined grades can be produced with lower basis weight of white pulp
layer.
Figure 9. Multilayer headbox machine with two stock components, block diagram.
Figure 10. Two-ply machine, block diagram.
5.2.5 System cleanliness
Cleanliness refers to freedom from dirt and contaminants in the process and in the product.
Cleanliness refers also to absence or to a low level in dissolved and colloidal material
contamination, which can cause scale or dirt formed by precipitation, coagulation or biological
activity appearing as slime. Slime occurs as lumps or films causing product defects such as
holes, specs, and smell, as well as production problems by plugging and scaling. The latter leads
to micro-biologically induced corrosion and possibly to decreased heat transfer. Micro-organic
activity is unavoidable due to the large content of nutrients in paper mill waters and the usually
favorable temperature. Hence, control of biological activity is needed in order to protect the
production and the product from disturbing slime.
System cleanliness should be a concern everywhere in paper production. Cleanliness is
supported by correct process design. On the one hand, standing water or low flow speed, dead
ends, edges, corners, rough surfaces, and low-quality materials have to be avoided in piping and
machinery where material can accumulate and slime or scaling can build up. Note, for example,
that it is the first and not the last cleaner bank seen in feed flow direction in Fig. 3, which can be
disconnected, thereby ensuring full flow without dead ends in the distribution feed pipe. Figure 11
shows that a fine finish of the steel surface hampers the growth of microbes 8. This is important in
the stock approach system and nearer the headbox 6, especially at locations where the flow
velocity is not high, like in the deaeration tank. On the other hand, cleaning of equipment and
pipes has to be possible. This includes well-positioned wash fluid connectors and drainage
valves to empty pipes during shutdowns. The latter is essential for all thick stock pipes, which
should be inclined and equipped with a drain at the lowest and a vent at the highest point. Air
pockets are a prominent place for slime to build up, which then releases as lumps from time to
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 8
time. Avoiding the buildup of air pockets is important when positioning valves and selecting the
appropriate type of valve. At open surfaces, splashing should be avoided because air is
entrained and material builds up on surfaces above the waterline. This then accumulates, dries,
and eventually re-enters the process as detrimental chunks.
System washings have to be performed during planned maintenance shutdowns, which can
include pressure rinse, high-temperature treatment, and washing with chemicals according to
needs9. Timer-controlled washing systems and showers can be installed on equipment and
tanks, which are prone to build up dirt or chunks of dried stock. Finally, keeping floors and
machinery clean improves the mill operators' safety in general.
Figure 11. Microbe population on metal surfaces with different degree of finishing8.
i.e., the time until a reasonably homogenous mixture is reached. Therefore, agitation has to be
sufficient.
The blended pulp is pumped at a constant rate to the machine chest. The stock is diluted by
a small concentration decrement, typically about 0.2%0.3%. All connections to the blend and
machine chest are designed in such a way that the best possible mixing occurs and entrainment
of air is low, e.g., by avoiding splashing and large vortices in the vicinity of the open surface. In
some installations, additional equipment like refiner or thick-stock screens can be found at the
position between the blend chest and the machine chest. Constant consistency and steady
hydraulic load at this position ease the operation of such equipment. On the other hand, it has to
be considered that any extra equipment at this location requires extra maintenance or might
otherwise cause extra downtime, which decreases the total PM efficiency. Uneven operation,
e.g., by wear of refiner fittings or varying reject flow from the screen, can cause variations with
adverse effects on the performance of the stock approach flow system.
Figure 12 shows also how a sampling site can be integrated into the blending system.
Constant flow and the possibility to flush and to clean are important in order to collect
representative samples of the pulps for laboratory analysis. In addition, or instead of a station for
manual sampling, automated or robotized pulp analysis equipment can be also installed.
Figure 12. Stock blending and machine chest including sampling station, an example.
5.3.2 Stock dosage
The basis weight of the sheet is controlled by the amount of thick stock from the machine chest to
the PM. It is affected by the amount of filler added to the short circulation. For information on
basis weight control, refer to Volume 14: Process Control of this book series. Stock dosage or
metering is commonly carried out in either of the following two alternative ways:
- By a thick stock valve right before dilution at the wire pit
- By speed control of the thick stock feed pump.
In either case, the thick stock concentration is kept constant. Advantages of the
speed-controlled pump are a lower energy consumption, higher feed flow accuracy, and simpler
piping layout. The benefits are worth the effort, especially for machines producing a range of
grades with large variation in the basis weight. A stuff box is not recommended in modern paper
machines in either case because it is a source of slime problems.
If stock is metered by valve control, the basis weight valve is located directly before stock
dilution at the wire pit. The pipe at the location of the valve should point upward in order to avoid
the accumulation of air on the downstream side of the valve. Valve control can be also carried out
with two valves in parallel, i.e., with one valve for coarse metering and the other one for fine
control.
5.3.3 Stock dilution
5.3.3.1 Principle
In mill practice, reducing the stock consistency means the mixing of a high-consistency stream
with a low-consistency stream. Hence, consistency variations in the blended stream can be
caused by variations in the flow and in the consistency of either of the streams to be blended.
Consistency variations in the lean stream are usually not significant to the diluted stream, except
if the rate of dilution is high. The flows and the size of the mixing volume or the mixing zone
determine how much variation can be leveled out according to the amplitude and wavelength of
variation. For example, the machine chest is dimensioned according to this principle.
5.3.3.2 Mixing
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 10
Flow
velocity [m/s]
Thick stock
V1
2.0 0.5
Circulation
V2
1.5 0.5
Wire water
V3
1.0 0.5
Wire water
V4
0.080.15
If a low headbox consistency is required, a two-stage dilution system might be needed. In the
first stage, the stock is diluted to the cleaner feed consistency and, in the second stage, the
cleaner accept is diluted further to reach the desired headbox consistency after screening.
Hence, cleaner feed accept consistency and screen feed consistency are de-coupled. As an
advantage, the cleaner plant can be operated constantly at the optimal consistency, while the
headbox consistency may change according to the grade produced. Two-stage systems are
usually considered for multiple grade producing machines with stock cleaning, if the headbox
consistency is about 0.7% or lower. On the contrary, tissue paper machines without cleaners and
little product variations often have one-stage dilution, even though the consistency can be as low
as 0.15%. Similar to a multichannel headbox system with two approach flows, the wire pit also
has for a traditional two-stage dilution two separate dilution zones, which are usually located
opposite to each other. Another design consists of connected parallel wire water tanks each with
a dilution zone. Such a system of connected wire water tanks has been applied in, e.g., multiple
layer production with two-stage dilution. However, the two-stage dilution system operates only
then stable, if enough wire water is consumed at the second dilution stage.
5.3.3.4 Headbox dilution system
The aim of dilution at the headbox is to control the basis weight cross-profile at the PM (see
Chapter 6). The amount of dilution water ranges from a few percent of the headbox lip flow up to
over 20%. Basis weight control is more efficient the lower the solids content is of the dilution
water13. To ensure efficient control, a certain dilution flow is needed at all dilution positions all the
time. According to the design and recommendations by the headbox manufacturer, the amount of
required dilution water can be quite high, even if there is a high one-pass retention like on board
machines. In order to avoid an increase in hydraulic load on the saveall disc filter, the headbox
dilution water is usually taken directly from the wire pit. For products with characteristically low
retention, the required water for dilution has to be increased accordingly. The approach flow
system for the headbox dilution water consists of similar elements as the system for the diluted
stock main flow:
- A speed-controlled fan pump
- A fine screen
- Deaeration equipment similar to the stock system
- Overflow from the headbox dilution header, usually similar to the stock flow.
The dilution water is deaerated in a separate unit or in a separate compartment, which is
integrated into the stock deaeration tank. The same design criteria are applied as for the stock
approach flow system and its equipment concerning low pulsation and the proper design of
surfaces and materials.
5.3.3.5 Medium- and high-consistency stock dilution
In integrated mills, the prepared pulp is often collected from medium-consistency (MC) storage
towers, with a storage consistency of typically 8%12%. Dilution to a pumpable suspension takes
place in the bottom part of the storage tower by injecting dilution water, which is filtrate or white
water taken from the main header of the PM water system. Figure 15 shows a
medium-consistency storage tower. The dilution water is fed to the suction zone of the agitator or
injected along the propeller shaft directly into the zone of highest turbulence at the agitator 14. Its
amount is usually controlled by the diluted stock flow. The fine adjustment of the diluted stock
consistency is by injection of dilution water at the suction side of the pump according to the
consistency measurement, as shown in Fig. 15.
For long distance transport of pulp in high consistency of 20%50%, either lorries or belt/tube
conveyors are used. High-consistency pulp is transported over short distances by screw
conveyors. Stock from lorries is usually slushed in pulpers, while the use of a dilution screw is
possible for diluting the pulp, which is continuously fed by the conveyor. The pulp is diluted in the
screw to storage consistency and drops into a storage tower from where pulp proceeds as
described above.
The higher the transfer consistency is from integrated pulping to the paper machine system,
the better is the separation of the water circuits of the systems. Thus, the less detrimental
substances are carried over into PM water, when the white water exchange is made at highest
stock consistency.
Figure 15. Medium-consistency storage tower and stock dilution.
5.3.4 Cleaning and screening
Chapter 9 of Volume 5: Mechanical Pulping of this book series describes the principles of
cleaning and screening and related equipment. Depending on the stock components, pulp has
already been subjected to various classification processes like cleaning and screening upstream.
Hence, the amount of foreign material to be removed is small; thus, the reject stream should be
small. Therefore end-stage cleaners are of special design, and screens are often not discharging
reject continuously in an effort to reduce the loss of fibers. The main purpose of cleaning and
screening is to ensure clean stock by removing bundles, flakes, and occasional debris and
strings, which are partly created within the system; refer to the above section about system
cleanliness.
5.3.4.1 Hydrocyclone cleaning
Centrifugal cleaners are used to remove dense debris of fiber size or smaller from the diluted
stock within the short circulation15,16. This debris can be sand, grit, shives, pitch, or other dense
particles. Practically all low basis weight and printing paper machines have a multistage cleaner
cascade system, which can be attached to a deaeration tank.
In the hydrocyclone, the suspension path involves a double vortex with the suspension
spiraling downward at the outside and upward at the inside. At the beginning of the conical part of
the cyclone, the stream velocity undergoes a redistribution so that the tangential component of
velocity increases with decreasing radius. The spiral velocity in the cyclone might reach a value
several times the inlet velocity. The separation of accepted and rejected particles depends on the
velocity profile and the location of the layer of zero-vertical velocity. The smaller the main
diameter of the cyclone is, the more efficient is the separation of debris but the smaller is the
hydraulic capacity. At small diameter, the risk of plugging is higher. In the PM cleaner cascade,
however, plugging is a minor problem due to dilution after every stage and due to oversized
particle removal already performed during stock preparation by screening or high-density
cleaners.
No cutoff size or critical particle diameter exists for cyclone separation. Centrifugal and shear
forces determine the separation or fractionation1719. The flow pattern in the cyclone is very
complex, and the separation efficiency curve is unique for a given cleaner geometry. Figure 16
shows the flow pattern schematically. Hence, the debris removal efficiency must be determined
experimentally. The conical part of the cleaner can contain baffles and helical guides to modify or
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 13
direct the flow. These tend to increase the hydraulic capacity and to reduce the fiber reject rate
and pressure drop, but they also reduce the cleaning efficiency to some degree 15. The removal
of vapor and air from the cleaner can also stabilize cleaner flow. Air accumulates along the
longitudinal axis of the cleaner, thus in the core of the vortex. Besides the cleaner geometry and
design, particle separation is determined by the specific gravity difference between fluid and
particle, by the specific surface of the particle, by the stock viscosity, which varies with the stock
temperature and the air content, and by the velocity field in general. The operational cleaner
parameters are:
- Stock flow rate and feed pressure
- Ratio of underflow and overflow, i.e., the reject ratio
- Feed consistency
- Back pressure on the reject side.
Depending on these parameters and on the cleaner design, a certain pressure drop and
reject thickening occurs.
Figure 16. Flow pattern in the hydrocyclone (forward cleaner).
Hydrocyclones can remove heavy debris, if designed as forward cleaners, or light debris, as
reverse or through-flow cleaners. In the stock approach flow system of the PM, only forward
cleaners are used, of which up to seven stages are commonly connected in cascade fashion.
The overall debris removal efficiency is best in the cascade system. The higher the number of
stages, the higher is the debris concentration in the reject and the smaller the reject stream.
Mounting of PM cleaners is either linearly in banks or racks, or radially, e.g., in canisters, often
with the reject pipe at the center. Cleaners can operate in a horizontal as well as in a vertical
position. The advantage of a linear arrangement is good accessibility of individual cleaners for
service, while canisters usually require less floor space. Accept and reject lines are equipped with
pressure transmitters for monitoring the cleaner operation. The filler and abrasive pigment
content of the stock increases toward the higher stages of the cascade, which can cause
excessive wear and reduce the cleaner efficiency and ultimately cause the cleaner to burst. The
highest wear is at the narrow side of the cone, where flow velocity as well as consistency are
highest. Filtrate is often used instead of white water for dilution at later cleaner cascade stages to
improve cleaning efficiency and to reduce fiber loss.
End-stage cleaner rejects are usually rich in pigments or filler. Due to the separation principle
of cleaners, especially coarse filler particles and agglomerated pigments from coated broke are
rejected. It may prove to be feasible to recover these minerals by dispersion and to feed them
back to the PM. Thereby, the disposed amount of reject is reduced. In such a filler recovery
process, fractionation of the filler containing rejects takes place at first, possibly including coating
kitchen wash water. The fine fraction contains most of the filler, which is again classified
according to particle size. The coarse mineral particles are concentrated to 30%50% solids
content, treated by a disperser and looped back to previous classification. Undispersable, coarse
particles are classified along with the coarse fraction from fractionation and the reject from initial
classification. The accepts of both of these classification stages are recovered 20.
5.3.4.2 Screening
In nearly all papermaking operations, the installation of at least one pressure screen is mandatory
right before the headbox. Exceptions could be, for example, for the lowest quality level of bogus
board, or if using extremely long specialty fibers, which would become wrapped up in a screen.
The main functions particular to the PM screen are:
- Protecting the wet end from occasional coarse foreign material which could damage forming
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 14
Water temperature, surface tension, and pressure affect the adsorption and desorption of air,
the bubble stability, the ability of bubbles to coalesce, water viscosity, and thus the bubble
retention in the fluid phase25. Average bubble diameters usually range from 50 to 120 m. With
increased temperature, the amount of dispersed air and the air solubility in water decreases and
the weighted average of the bubble size decreases. On the other hand, air solubility in water
increases linearly with pressure according to Henry's law. With a pressure increase of about,
e.g., 400500 kPa after a fan pump or even higher after the headbox dilution water pump, most
of the dispersed air is dissolved. With the pressure decrease to ambient pressure at the headbox
lip, many small-sized bubbles are created by desorption. This redispersed air remains partly with
the drained water because small bubbles do not coalesce and, hence, are able to accumulate in
the short circulation25. Thus, the mean size of the bubbles is in the circulation water smaller than
at the point where air is mechanically entrained by splashing.
5.3.5.2 Effect of air on papermaking
Air in papermaking stock has adverse implications on the production process as well as on
product quality. The critical amount of air leading to noticeable problems depends on the type of
PM, the paper grade, and the kind of furnish being used26. Consider as an illustrative example a
headbox lip flow concentration of 1% by volume dispersed air for a PM without mechanical
deaeration and a headbox solids concentration of 0.7%27. In this case, the volume of dispersed
air is about as large as the volume of the solids. It is therefore well understandable that air in
stock reduces the production performance, e.g., by:
- Pumping efficiency decrease
- Screening efficiency decrease
- Reduction of drainage
- Foam problems at open surfaces, which can also cause accumulation of hydrophobic and
sticky material similar to froth flotation
- Increase in microbiological activity leading to slime problems
- Pressure and flow velocity variations due to air pockets within the system
- Instability and noise by cavitation.
Air in stock and water adversely affects the product quality 2830 in the form of:
- Pinholes and holes
- Spots, specks, and lumps in the paper, due to foam or accumulation at the surface of larger
air bubbles
- Decreased wet-web strength
- Decrease in smoothness and tensile strength due to deteriorated formation.
On the other hand, finely dispersed air bubbles can also improve formation in some cases 31.
A higher level of bulk due to the presence of small air bubbles can be a beneficial side effect.
In addition to paper quality improvement, the investment into a mechanical deaeration system
is often justified due to increases in:
- PM runnability and more stable production
- Possible speed increase of the PM
- Savings on defoaming agents
- Savings due to decreased energy losses in pumps.
5.3.5.3 Sources of air
From the hydrodynamics standpoint, dispersions of gas bubbles in liquids are basically unstable.
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 16
Forming bubbles means an expansion of the normal surface area of the liquid and, thus, requires
a work input. Dissolved substances can stabilize bubbles and retard their collapse. Bubbles can
also attach to hydrophobic sites in the stock or get trapped between fibers. Air is either brought
with the feed flows into the system, or it is brought in, either due to inherent process operation or
by action, which could be avoidable. For example, the splashing occurring in PM wire dewatering
is unavoidable. Possibly avoidable sources of air are:
- Air via incoming stock and water flows
- Splashing in open cleaner reject discharge
- Faulty operation of the deaeration unit, e.g., due to insufficient vacuum generation
- Liberation of gas by chemical reactions; e.g., acidic process water or acidic additives in
combination with calcium carbonate pigments cause a release of CO 2
- Leakage
- Biological activity.
As already mentioned above, pressure, temperature, and flow speed differences can desorb
dissolved air into dispersed air. The release of carbon dioxide from carbonate pigments in acidic
conditions causes distinct problems, due to the higher solubility of CO 2 compared to air, and due
to resistant scaling by calcium oxalate32.
5.3.5.4 Chemical deaeration
The principle of defoaming chemicals is to increase the rate of bubble coalescence. This means
that two colliding bubbles have a higher probability of joining and forming a bigger bubble in the
presence of a surface-active defoaming agent, commonly a product on mineral oil basis.
Defoaming agents usually affect to little extent, or not at all, the amount of dissolved gases in the
paper stock, which can be up to 2%3% by volume, even if the amount of dissolved air is low.
Hence, the ratio of dissolved gas to total gas is increased with the addition of a defoaming agent.
If a low level of dispersed air in stock is required, the exclusive use of defoaming chemicals
becomes expensive and thus the installation of a mecha-nical deaeration unit is feasible. The
addition of defoaming agents in large amounts often causes a decrease in system cleanliness,
deposition of dirt on fabrics and felts, a decrease in retention, or an increased need of retention
aids respectively. Over-dosage of some defoaming agents can even cause the reverse effect and
stabilize bubbles.
Defoaming chemicals are also used in combination with mechanical deaeration units for a
maximum in air removal. The mechanically deaerated stock is "hungry" and has a high capacity
to dissolve more gas into water27. Some types of defoaming agents can prevent the pulp
suspension from reabsorbing significant amounts of air when exposed to it after deaeration
treatment29.
5.3.5.5 Deaeration tanks
Deaeration tanks remove dissolved and dispersed air very efficiently. Air is desorbed above the
boiling point and effectively driven out, when creating a large fluid surface. The typical deaeration
tank is designed to treat the headbox stock or headbox dilution water by:
- Spraying
- Impingement
- Boiling.
With spraying and by impingement against the interior surface of the tank, a large fluid
surface is created and trapped or bound bubbles are released and removed. The air-containing
suspension enters upward into the deaeration tank from coaxially connected centrifugal cleaners
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 17
or feed nozzles through pipes in helical flow pattern. The helical flow causes the desired
spraying. The headbox circulation flow is usually fed back to the deaeration tank, but without
spraying. Boiling takes place at a vacuum, which is high enough so that no additional heating of
the suspension is required. The minimum required vacuum depends therefore on the feed
temperature. The system temperature is controlled by heat or steam injection into the wire pit. In
practice, the absolute pressure should be about 1 kPa lower than the boiling point at the given
temperature. To support the required amount of vacuum, the deaeration tank is placed in an
elevated location, and all flows from the unit are barometric drop-leg lines; this includes also the
reject lines, in case cleaners are directly connected to the deaeration. Likewise, the primary
cleaner feeding fan pump is provided by sufficient back-pressure. Besides deaeration, positive
side effects by tank deaeration are as follows:
- Constant weir overflow within the tank is maintained by controlling the fan pump speed.
- Excellent ability to level out short-term stock consistency variations, especially if the flows
are connected obeying the multi-lag principle as shown in Fig. 13.
- Good mixing is obtained by the stock spraying.
- Upstream pressure pulses are well dampened.
The vacuum is generated by a one- or two-stage water ring pump system. Figure 3 shows a
two-stage system. The removed gases are cooled by cooling water in a pre-condenser, either by
direct contact or in a noncontact condenser. The more expensive and more cooling
water-consuming indirect condenser has the advantage that the cooling liquor does not get in
contact with the exhaust; thus, it cannot become contaminated. The use of a steam ejector to
discharge the deaeration tank receiver33 causes heat loss and loads the condenser thermally.
The use of a sufficiently large vacuum pump or two connected in series usually proves to be
more economical. Each vacuum pump is followed by a water separator. Condensed and
separated water is collected via drop-legs at the deaeration seal tank in the cellar and typically
added to the PM vacuum pump system. The removed air is exhausted via a silencer.
Two different deaeration and process design alternatives are commonly used:
- All cleaner stages are on the PM floor level and, thus, separated from the deaeration tank.
- One to three cleaner stages are connected directly to the deaeration tank. For mid-sized or
large PMs, the number of required cleaners is large; thus, the deaeration tank is extended by
wings to collect the cleaner accepts. This arrangement is called a "flying wing" system.
Table 3 shows the advantages of both alternatives. In several cases, the deaeration tank is
supplied with only the first stage cleaner accept. If also the second- and third-stage accepts are
fed into the deaeration receiver, the discharge is into the weir overflow, which means that the
third-stage accept is fed forward. The last stages are located on the PM floor level and connected
in cascade fashion.
High requirements for air-free headbox feed flow and operational constraints often make
deaeration necessary for the headbox dilution water also, if such a PM cross-direction control
system is applied. The deaeration of this dilution water can be either integrated into the stock
deaeration tank, or it can occur in a separate vessel. The combined stock and headbox dilution
water deaeration tank consists of two compartments located opposite to each other with facing
weirs discharging either into the same or into different overflow discharging pipes. The separate
headbox dilution water deaeration tank is connected to the vacuum pump system of the stock
deaeration. Principle and operation are similar to the stock deaeration system. The headbox
dilution header circulation can also be fed back to the dilution deaerator similarly to the headbox
stock circulation.
Table 3. Advantages of the two most common deaeration tank design solutions.
Deaeration tank with cleaners connected
High cleaner efficiency
Low pressure drop cleaners with low reject
thickening
Larger reject orifice diameter due to air core in
cleaner causing less plugging and less wear
More space on the machine floor level
Lower energy consumption
some of the process additives are added in order to support the functional paper chemicals
because the performance of the functional aid is measured only from that part, which remains
with the paper product35. The dosed chemical reacts with the dispersed fibers and pigments as
well as with the dissolved material and potentially with previously added chemicals circulating
with the process water. The less process water is discharged and, therefore, the higher the rate
of recirculation, the higher is the threat of unfavorable effects in the process caused by
accumulating substances. Hence, process chemicals should only be used when absolutely
necessary. Overdosing is to be avoided for cost reasons and because of unnecessary loading of
the process water. In mill practice, the addition of each wet end chemical should be checked on a
regular basis. Practice has shown that changes in the process or in its chemistry can make the
use of some chemicals obsolete, which should be consequently turned off. This tends to be
"forgotten" because their exact effect on the system is often unknown.
5.3.6.2 Dosage points
The right dosage point for a particular chemical can differ from system to system. At the dosage
point, there is often a trade-off between the best possible mixing with the targeted reaction
components and undesired reaction with other components or process disturbance. The flow
conditions and the flow speed difference at the dosage point have to be known to ensure proper
mixing with the stock or water stream. The order of addition of some additives matters, for
example, in a two-component retention system. Possible dosage sites are:
- In stock preparation, e.g., before or after refining
- To single stock components before blending
- At the blend chest, the machine chest, or in between
- Before the thick stock feed pump
- Before thick stock dilution
- At stock dilution, before the primary fan pump
- Before the headbox fan pump
- Before the machine screen
- Before the headbox
- To the wire pit.
5.3.6.3 Dosing
In the paper mill, dosage of chemicals means blending a stream of usually small volumetric flow
but high concentration with a large flow of stock water. In order to ensure good mixing with the
main stream, the additive is often diluted with water, which has to be in most cases of purified
fresh water quality. The chemical is dosed directly into the mixing zone or into the middle of the
stream. A multiple radial injector feed system is used typically for high-molecular retention
polymer or bentonite proportioning before the headbox (see Fig. 18). In this particular case,
mixing is supported by the turbulence created at the joint of the accepts of the two parallel
machine screens. The location between the PM screens and headbox can also be seen in Fig. 3.
The multiple injection ensures better distribution of the chemical component compared to a single
nozzle; this is needed, if consecutive mixing with high shear forces is to be avoided.
Figure 18. Bentonite dosage at the headbox feed pipe after pressure screens.
5.3.6.4 Measurements
Various sensors and measuring devices are installed for control and to supply the operators with
necessary information. Besides the basic process parameters like flow, consistency,
temperature, and pressure, other data more specific to the papermaking process can be
obtained, as shown in Table 4. Reliable metering and measuring is most important for good
control of stock operations and high process performance.
Table 4. Parameters for wet end chemistry monitoring and control36.
Important parameters:
Temperature
pH
Conductivity
Consistency
Freeness, fines, and filler content
Flow
At a given speed, each pump has a characteristic curve H P(Q). Also the system response is
described by a characteristic curve HS(Q), which consists of a static part and an operational part
according to factors such as the downstream load characteristics, pipe friction, and valve
performance. Typically, the head changes as a square of the flow rate. The operating point of the
pump is determined by the point, where the characteristic curve of the pump H P(Q) meets the
characteristic curve of the system HS(Q). In process design, the desired pump capacity is usually
given and the required pumping head is calculated. The flow through the system can be altered,
by the following means:
- Speed control of the pump, which changes the characteristic curve H P(Q)
- Control by a throttling valve, which creates additional system friction and thus changes the
characteristic curve HS(Q)
- Control by bypass circulation
- Irreversible, mechanical reduction of the impeller diameter by rotary cut, or replacement by
an impeller of a different size.
Speed control is often feasible for larger pumps operating at variant conditions because of the
energy savings compared to throttling valve control, which has the lowest investment cost. The
more throttling there is, the higher are the losses and the less economic is the type of flow control
compared to pump speed control. Throttling losses are however less if the characteristic curve of
the pump HP(Q) is flat, which means a moderate decrease in head, H, with increased flow, Q.
Furthermore, the type of solids and the ions contained in the fluid determine the material
requirements for the impeller and the pump casting in order to avoid erosion and corrosion during
long-term operation. Stock pumps are especially designed to avoid plugging and fiber spinning
as well as excessive wear. The air content of the fluid also has to be considered because air
accumulates around the rotation axis on the suction side of the impeller and lowers the
characteristic curve of the pump and reduces pumping efficiency.
The largest pumps in the paper mill are the fan pumps feeding the first cleaner stage and the
headbox. Especially the headbox pump has to operate at lowest possible pulsation, which is
achieved by design and manufacturing precision, for example, by a staggered position of vanes
between the two suction sides. The characteristic curve of the headbox pump H P(Q) should be
steep in order to keep the transformation of pressure variations into flow variations as low as
possible12.
the required product quality or due to other reason. Depending on the paper grade and the
degree of processing, the broke might be pulped and used at another time or elsewhere.
However, when this broke leaves the mill, it becomes per definition "recovered paper" or
secondary fibers.
One way to classify broke handling together with other processes connected to the PM is to
consider it as a system of its own. Another way is to consider the broke system as part of stock
preparation because the same operations of slushing and defibration are performed. Finally,
broke handling means that fibers are recovered for use on the PM. However, the broke system
should not be integrated into the fiber recovery or saveall operation because it can lead to system
instability. During steady operation of the PM, a steady flow of white water with constant solids
content is handled in the saveall, while broke occurs at an inconstant rate. The broke system
should therefore be decoupled from the white water treatment. Also the use of broke as
sweetener of the disc filter is not favorable. The broke thickener filtrate, however, is normally fed
into the fiber recovery, while the dilution water to the broke pulpers is taken from the white water
or clear water tower, hence, from water after fiber recovery.
5.4.2 Broke system requirements
Uniform and good stock quality is the main requirement to a properly operating broke system. If
breaks are long-lasting or occur repeatedly, the amount of broke in the stock has to be increased.
Poor performance of the broke system due to malfunctions or faulty design can cause further
breaks, which in turn raises pressure to increase the proportion of broke in the stock. Hence,
proper design and sufficient storage capacity of the broke system are essential. The total broke
storage capacity is commonly equivalent to 24 hours of net production, depending on the paper
grade; complex machines with coating stations require large broke storages like an on-line
lightweight-coated (LWC) paper machine.
Broke handling is determined by the following functional steps:
- Broke transport
- Pulping
- Storage
- Cleaning and homogenizing
- Dosage.
The capacity of all machine pulpers and equipment of the broke system has to be sufficient to
handle the amount of paper produced at maximum gross production. On the other end, the broke
system also has to function properly from the broke storage tower to broke dosage, if no breaks
occur over a long period of production. In this case, the broke consists only of trims and slab-offs
and eventually occurring broke from rejected rolls, which accounts together for only a few percent
of the maximum capacity. Therefore, broke can be circulated to assure proper functioning of the
broke screens and deflakers.
On multigrade machines, grade changes can create a special problem if furnishes of two
grades are not compatible. A running grade change in such a situation is not possible, but a
time-consuming cleanup of the system is necessary. Therefore, it is not usually feasible to use a
large single broke storage tower on a multigrade machine. At the next grade change, the stored
broke might not be suitable for the new grade and would have to be discarded. For this reason,
wet broke is used immediately. At least on small machines, dry broke can be stored and added
together with other raw material components at the beginning of the stock system. The flexibility
required by a multigrade machine is achieved by sacrificing the stability of the system, especially
during web breaks. During a web break, the proportion of broke in the stock pumped to the PM
increases, which can easily cause new breaks. This is one reason among several others causing
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 24
usually a lower operation speed of a multigrade machine than the speed of a single-grade
machine operating under similar conditions.
5.4.3 Broke handling
5.4.3.1 Transport and auxiliary equipment
The location and the number of broke pulpers is chosen for each machine as a compromise
between the minimum transport effort of broke and the cost for installation and operation. Right
after a break begins, the web is cut at the next pulper before the break location to avoid
accumulation of broke in the cellar or on a conveyor. Showers spray some of the pulper dilution
water in order to ensure proper transport of the web into the pulper. Broke pulpers are equipped
with an exhaust fan to avoid moisture entering the machine hall and to ensure the paper web
feed into the pulper. Loose bits of dry broke are transported under the PM drying section on
demand by conveyor belts of full machine-width to the pulpers. Older and slower running
machines may lack such conveyor systems; thus, broke is collected in the cellar and fed into
pulpers manually. Winder trims are often carried through a pneumatic system over longer
distances to a dry-broke pulper or to a separate trim-pulper. The conveying air is separated in a
cyclone separator, which can be integrated into the trim-pulper. Spray showers are installed,
which might also be used to de-dust exhaust from certain dust removal sites, like the slitting
stations. Especially for wide machines, a continuously operating trim pulper with a single bottom
rotor is usually more practical than running a pulper of machine-width, e.g., the winder pulper,
continuously. Rejected rolls are either fed into the PM dry-end pulper, into some other finishing
room pulper, or into a separate broke roll pulper with a single bottom rotor. The rejected rolls are
opened by a guillotine cutter, which can be equipped with two conveyor belts, one on each side
of the cutter. Large rolls are moved back and forth for cutting into small segments, which are
repulped bit by bit to avoid upsetting the broke system.
5.4.3.2 Pulpers
Old and very slowly running PMs might have no broke pulper or just one located beside the
machine. Also for a modern tissue machine with a Yankee dryer and especially with one wire/one
felt design, one broke pulper at the dry end is sufficient. In contrast, for large board machines and
modern high-speed machines for graphic paper production, the number of broke pulpers can be
large. A couch pit, press, and dry end pulper are needed at least. The total number of pulpers
depends on the paper grade and particular process. For example, a modern uncoated wood-free
paper machine could have the following pulpers:
- Couch pit
- Press pulper(s)
- Size-press pulper
- Calender pulper
- Reel pulper
- Winder pulper
- Winder trim pulper
- Finishing room pulper
- Finishing room trim pulper
- Broke roll pulper.
The broke pulpers under the PM are dimensioned according to the PM width. The
construction is either concrete or steel. On wide machines, usually two rotors are located next to
each other at the long side of the pulper. The direction of rotation is opposite, so that the web is
pulled into the vat. The pulped stock leaves the vat through a screen plate behind the rotor. Also
cross-shaft agitated pulpers are used with several impellers on the shaft. There, the discharge is
from the short side of the pulper. Figure 19 shows the principle of a discontinuously operating
one-pump broke pulping system. In the case of a break, the pulper is started and dilution water is
added immediately. This is commonly initiated by break automatics. The pulping consistency
ranges usually between 3% and 6%. The pulped broke is pumped into the couch pit, which
operates continuously. Two pumps with different capacity discharge the couch pit and possibly
other pulpers with continuous broke feed like, e.g., trims. During normal running condition, the
smaller pump runs and the level is controlled similarly to that shown in Fig. 19. In a break
situation, the level rises quickly and the larger pump starts. In case trims at the PM dry end are
not pulped in a separate trim pulper, the receiving broke pulper is also equipped with a two-pump
system. Finally, finishing room broke pulping can operate in some cases at high consistency in a
separate system.
Figure 19. Broke pulping system.
Coated broke is not fed to the couch pit, but collected separately. The pigments of the coating
color appear in coated broke like filler. In order to control the amount of coated broke, thus the
amount of pigment added to the paper stock, collection, thickening, and storage are separated
from the uncoated broke system. The separate system has its own broke storage, while cleaning
and other broke treatment can be together.
Wet-strength broke requires sometimes chemicals and elevated temperature by the addition
of steam in order to reduce pulping time. Steam or chemicals are added to pulpers, in particular,
to finishing room or broke roll pulpers in order to slush broke, which has been dry for some time.
5.4.3.3 Slushed broke-handling system
The degree of sophistication of a broke system can vary from plain recirculation of pulped broke
to the blend chest without any treatment up to complex systems with multiple cleaning stages.
The following equipment can be part of a broke-handling system:
- Broke storage tower
- Broke thickener
- Pressure screen, possibly in multiple stages
- High-density cleaner
- Open screen, like vibrating screen or scalping screen
- Deflaker.
Broke storage towers are usually operated in combination with a thickener, e.g., a gravity
decker or sometimes inclined screens. The thickener increases the consistency of the stored
pulp, and water can be moved back to the clear water system. Consistency fluctuations are
thereby reduced. The thickened pulp is collected in a chest, from where part of the broke is
circulated to the tower. In a few special cases of dyed paper, broke bleaching chemicals are
added to the broke storage. If the saveall is employed also as a broke thickener, which is
sometimes done for wire pit trims, the saveall is loaded with fines. Especially at PM web breaks,
variations in the saveall operation affect the white water system and possibly thereby cause
system instability. A clear separation between broke handling and the white water system is
preferred. For coated paper production, double broke lines are used for thickening and storage,
one for uncoated broke and one for coated broke.
The degree of sophistication of broke cleaning systems is determined by the demands in
quality and in quality constancy of the stock. For example, a high-speed PM for graphical paper
production can have multiple-stage pressure screening. To reduce fiber losses, the end-stage
screen is often operated with sequential flushing. Also open screening devices, of which the
vibrating screen is most common, have been used at the last stage. However, modern broke
cleaning systems are operated at the same consistency as the entire broke system, i.e.,
2.5%3.5%. High-density cleaners can be installed to remove, e.g., sand and other heavy dirt.
Coated and uncoated broke are often treated together in a single system, in order to operate the
pressure screens under desirably constant load. Thus, the proportioning of coated and uncoated
broke is done at the broke screening chest.
More efficient than the removal of dirt from the stock is to avoid contamination by dirt entering
the broke pulpers. The way broke is collected and transported (see above) affects its dirt content.
The cleanliness of areas where broke falls onto the ground determines the dirt entry into the
stock system.
The deflaker (see Chapter 3) creates high hydraulic forces when passing the stock through
the gaps between static and rotating plates, which are either perforated or equipped with bars.
Flocks, flakes, and fiber bundles are sheared due to high acceleration and deceleration of the
stock and by impact of surfaces. The content of flakes in broke is usually high due to the short
dwelling and repulping time. Deflakers are needed in particular for coated broke and wet-strength
paper broke. Possible arrangements for deflakers are:
- Deflaking of whole broke before dosage
- Deflaking of first-stage screen reject only
- Deflaking of coated or dry broke only
- No deflaking.
If needed, deflakers are connected in parallel. In special cases or for certain specialty papers,
broke handling arrangements can be different.
5.4.4 Broke dosage
Broke is usually added to the stock at the blend chest. It should be considered that the
composition and the quality of broke might be different from the fresh furnish components. Broke
contains fillers and other dispersed and dissolved material according to the additives and
materials applied to the stock or to the paper surface in the PM. Fluctuations in the broke dosage,
especially those of coated broke, can disturb or even upset the wet end chemistry. Consider, for
example, a sudden increase of broke added to the furnish, which causes an increase in fine and
filler material resulting in an increased cationic demand. In consequence, wire retention drops
which affects production and the demand for retention aids.
Quality variations can also originate from changes in the proportion of wet and dry broke. In
some cases, separate storage systems for wet and dry broke are applied. This might be
considered in particular for an integrated mill using never-dried chemical pulp or for specialty
papers. The fiber properties and the needed amount of drying energy change at most when
chemical pulp fibers are dried for the first time.
In multi-ply board production or at multilayer headboxes, broke can be exclusively dosed to
certain layers or plies of the sheet, e.g., in order to hide dirt or specks in the middle layer.
5.4.5 Coated broke systems
In particular applications, like special coating colors with high binder content and for high-end
demands, a disperser or a kneader can be installed to crush coat particles. Platelets or grainy,
insufficiently broken-up coat particles can cause problems in forming and streaks especially in
low-weight coat application. The coarse particles are also entering the cleaner system of the
stock approach system and cause an increased loss of pigments, if they are not recovered from
the cleaner rejects. A dewatering press is usually required because the disperser or kneader runs
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 27
at a consistency of 30% or higher. Recycling the press filtrate back to coated broke pulping ends
up in a separate water circulation, which reduces the amount of detrimental substances passed
to the PM. Treatment of this circulating water by, e.g., dissolved air flotation (DAF) can also
reduce the amount of hydrophobic substances ("white pitch") significantly.
The disc filter is a unit where multiple discs rotate in a vat. Each of the 30 or more discs consists
of several segments covered with fine wire and rotates over the stationary filtration zones, as
shown in Fig. 20. During filtration, a fiber mat builds up with the aid of pre-coating pulp, the
so-called "sweetener," which is added to the white water feed flow. The thicker and denser this
filter cake becomes during vacuum filtration, the less solids are passed through. Hence, the
filtrate consistency is getting lower, until the filtration process is interrupted, when the filter mat
emerges from the filled vat. The filtrate of the different phases is therefore collected separately as
richer cloudy filtrate, leaner clear filtrate, and the optionally leanest super-clear filtrate. Table 5
shows the typical filtrate properties41. The disc segments of the same radial shaft position
discharge into the same discharge channel in the shaft, i.e., the channel to which these segments
are firmly connected. The different filtrate qualities are collected at one end of the shaft, where
the pipes or drop legs to the filtrate tanks are attached. The split ratio of the 23 filtrates is either
adjustable by altering the access to the shaft channels of the disc filter, or it is determined by a
fixed design of the rotary filtrate valve at the shaft. Cloudy filtrate is discharged under
atmospheric conditions via a free-fall pipe. Clear filtrate and super-clear filtrate are collected in
two separate drop legs, each discharging the filtrates into a seal chamber in the filtrate tanks (see
Fig. 21). The height difference between disc filter center-shaft and the level in the filtrate tank is
78 m for creating the required vacuum generated by the virtue of a sufficient velocity in the drop
legs. Vacuum can be also generated by a vacuum pump, especially if a high dryness of the filter
cake is desired. The filter cake maintains the vacuum in the super-clear filtrate line, even at the
end of filtration when it emerges above the waterline. After that, vacuum is released from the mat,
which is then removed from the wire by the knock-off shower or by an air jet. Another shower
keeps the trough clean from bits of discharged pulp. An oscillating shower cleans the filter cloth.
The water from this shower enters into the cloudy filtrate tank, or it is collected separately in a
discharge channel according to the design of the disc filter (see Fig. 20). All filter shower waters
are usually taken directly from the clear filtrate tank. The cloudy filtrate is often circulated as
shown in Fig. 21.
Table 5. Typical filtrate properties41.
Property
White water
Cloudy filtrate
Clear filtrate
Consistency,
mg/L
Consistency
variation, mg/L
Particle size
index
Pigment to fiber
ratio
3 500
2 500
1
<<1
400
200
23
1
50
30
4
5
Super-clear
filtrate
5
10
5
10
clear and super-clear filtrate is gained. The rotational speed of the disc filter determines the time
given to the fibers to build up a mat. The typical speed in the range of 0.2 to 1.5 rpm can be
controlled by the level signal of the filter vat. Another mode of operation is to run with a selected
speed and to maintain the vat level with cloudy filtrate circulation, as shown in Fig. 21. Variations
in the following feed flow parameters cause changes in the filter mat properties and, hence,
fluctuation in the hydraulic capacity and the quality of the filtrates:
- Fines and filler content
- Feed flow
- Freeness
- Type and properties of the sweetener.
If there is for example a jump in freeness, the level in the disc filter vat can drop even at low
disc speed. In such a case, the hydraulic load can be increased by adding white water from the
header to the cloudy filtrate circulation loop, as shown in Fig. 21. The sweetener is dosed at a
certain ratio to the white water flow to the saveall. The dilution of the recovered solids at the
discharge screw of the disc filter is proportional to the amount of sweetener supplied. Further on,
an exhaust can be connected to the filter hood, especially if the white water temperature is high.
Instead of vacuum-driven filtration, pressure can be applied to increase the filtration rate by
an increased pressure difference. Air is blown from the filtration tank into the disc filter to create a
certain pressure under the hood. If no drop legs are needed, it is not necessary to install the
pressure disc filter at an elevated location. Pressure disc filters are used, e.g., in mechanical
pulping, where the water temperature might be high. In the PM water system, low-pressure disc
filters are sometimes used to post-treat the saveall clear filtrate to produce a super-clear filtrate
for PM showers and similar purposes.
The paper mill discharge point is at the clear filtrate tank where water leaves the system; this
is the point where the paper mill effluent occurs regularly. This effluent stream is flow-controlled,
for example, according to the level in the filtrate tower. This surplus water is fed upstream into the
water system of the pulping or the recycled fiber processing plant. If no such integrated operation
exists, the surplus filtrate is let into the sewer.
5.5.1.2 Sweetener
The fiber content of the white water entering the filter vat is increased by adding pulp, the
so-called "sweetener," or precoating pulp. The vat concentration is in a similar range as known
for PM headboxes. Sweetener is needed to form a sufficient fiber mat. The function of the filter
fabric is to support this filter cake, which acts as the filter medium. In cake filtration, the fineness
of the fabric has rather little significance on the filtrate quality, if chosen within a range of
reasonable mesh size. The sweetener acts as filter medium; hence, its quality determines:
- Filtrate quality
- Constant and high filtration rates to reach the desired filtrate quality
- Reliable filter cake discharge.
Sweetener fibers are not circulating in the saveall system; thus, sweetener fibers are always
used once and then blended with the PM stock. The fines content of the sweetener pulp is
preferably low and constant. Thus, long-fiber chemical softwood pulp is the best possible
sweetener. The following are less preferable sweeteners in descending order: TMP, GW, mixed
recovered paper stock, and broke42. The sweetener stock is taken from the stock feed header to
the blend chest (see also Fig. 12). The recovered fibers are fed back to the blend chest. Due to
the increased fines content, the recovered stock should not be forwarded into the broke system in
order to avoid fluctuation of fines content entering stock blending.
In addition to the sweetener, the filtration result can be influenced by the dosage of charged
polymers as flocculating agent. If no optimal sweetener is available for example, in paper
production with 100% recycled fiber furnish, addition of a chemical aid can benefit the filtrate
quality. Polymer addition reduces the amount of required filter area; hence, it might be a suitable
approach in de-bottlenecking a disc filter.
5.5.1.3 Drum filter
A drum filter is a filter fabric-covered drum rotating in a vat with filtration toward the inside of the
drum, i.e., similar to the disc filter. Filtration can be supported by vacuum created in drop legs,
similar to the disc filter. Drum filters with a low-pressure differential are either gravity deckers or
valveless drum filters. Gravity deckers are the most simple drum filters, where filtration is driven
by the head difference between the vat level and the filtrate level inside the drum. The
low-pressure difference causes a gentle flow through the filter medium, which results in a fairly
good filtrate quality. A valveless drum filter contains tubes inside the drum, which are arranged in
a helical pattern. One end of the tubes is connected to a longitudinal channel under the drum
surface, and the other opening is inside the drum. As the longitudinal chamber emerges from the
stock, the open end of the connected tube is still immersed in the filtrate inside the drum, which
creates a siphon for vacuum40.
Drum filters can be used for high freeness long fiber pulp, which quickly builds up thick pulp
mats and which does not discharge cleanly from disc filter elements 43. However, for most
applications, the hydraulic capacity of drum filters is too low and only one filtrate quality is
produced. This usually makes them unsuitable for a saveall application. Drum filters are often
used as simple but reliable thickeners, e.g., in the broke-handling system.
5.5.1.4 Other filters
- Special pressure filters or some bag filters are used for post-treatment of clear or
super-clear filtrate for some shower applications.
- Sludge and wet rejects can be dewatered by gravity tables and screw or wire filter presses.
For low-quality board grades, fiber-containing sludge or even effluent treatment sludge can be
returned into the papermaking process. The same applies for the pressate, which may be
returned into the process water system. In various instances, some rejects sludge from flotation
and from other locations in the integrated mill are dewatered and treated together. In such a
case, water should not be returned to the process without advanced treatment.
- Sand filters are often used in fresh water preparation. Sand filtration has been applied in the
special case of total effluent-free paper production to post-treat process water 44. Also if effluent
from the effluent treatment plant is recycled, it can be sand filtered before reintroduction into the
paper mill process. In some devices, flotation and sand filtration are combined into one unit. Sand
filters are periodically cleaned by backwashing.
- Classifying filters are dicussed below.
5.5.2 Flotation
Dissolved air flotation (DAF) units are used in the paper mill to clarify fresh water, process water,
or effluent. Due to the size of the created air bubbles, DAF is also called microflotation. Unlike the
other water clarification techniques, the physical treatment is usually preceded by addition of
chemicals, which can also reduce the amount of dissolved organic substances in process water
to some degree. The removal of colloidal material by DAF is typically in a range of 10%40% if
chemicals for precipitation and fixing are added. Inorganic salts, similar to the other techniques
discussed in this section, are not reduced. Usually, DAF does well in removing hydrophobic
particles and colloids, which are prone to form stickies and pitch 45. In a process with little effluent
discharge, colloidal and potentially sticky material accumulates, especially when recycled fiber
furnish is used or coated broke occurs. In these cases, DAF improves process water and thus
the PM runnability efficiently. The brightness of graphical paper made from recycled fiber furnish
is improved when applying DAF to grayed process water filtrates. In these cases, the flotation
sludge must be discarded and not reintroduced into the process.
The removal of dispersed microscopic and fine material is also very good. According to the
solids content of the feed flow and the type and amounts of chemical aids dosed, the removal
efficiency is usually between 85% and 98%. Typically, a coagulation aid, fixative, or alternatively
bentonite is added at first. The dosage point is at the suction side of the feed pump or at another
location with high turbulence to ensure good mixing. Then, a long-chained polymer is added to
the feed flow via a chemical injector to flocculate suspended solids. Right after this, the
microscopic air bubbles are introduced, which make the created flocs buoyant (see Fig. 22).
Figure 22. Dissolved air flotation unit for process water treatment.
The air bubbles are created according to Henry's law when releasing pressure from water
saturated by dissolved air. The over-saturation with dissolved air by the sudden pressure
decrease is the so-called "soda-bottle effect." The generation of large amounts of microscopic
bubbles is crucial for the operation of DAF.
Air is dissolved into water at the air saturation reactor, where water is mixed at high
turbulence with compressed air at an absolute pressure usually of 500700 kPa. The reactor can
contain turbulence-creating and flow-guiding elements; also two-stage systems are available. Air
is supplied by a separate compressor system or from the mill's compressed air network, if the
supplied pressure is sufficient. Either cleared water or feed water is delivered to the air saturation
reactor by the booster pump. There are three system modes for flow through the reactor:
- Partial flow mode
- Full flow mode
- Recycle flow mode.
In recycle flow mode, a part of the clear water is used for aeration and mixed with the feed
flow. Figure 22 displays this most commonly used mode in operation while the valve for partial
flow operation is closed. In recycle flow mode, the hydraulic load is increased by about the
amount of circulating water and the flotation unit has to be dimensioned accordingly. In partial
flow mode, part of the feed passes the aeration system. In full flow mode, all feed water has to
pass aeration and the reactor as well as the compressed air system has to be increased in size
accordingly. The advantages of recycling vs. partial flow mode are:
- Slightly lower chemicals consumption because the effect of the fixative may be reduced for
the partial flow passing the air saturation system
- No plugging and less dirt accumulation in the air saturation system
The pressure of the aerated water is released by a decompression valve or by a turbine right
before mixing with the feed stream (see Fig. 22). Pressure can also be released at
decompression nozzles feeding the air-saturated stream into the feed pipe. The microbubbles are
created immediately at the pressure drop and attach to the fibers and flocs to create buoyant
sludge forming a blanket at the surface of the flotation tank. The bubble size is typically 40100
m. Heavy particles are removed from the bottom of the flotation tank, typically via a
discontinuously operating trash trap. The flow conditions inside the flotation tank are important for
the separation performance. In round tanks, the surface is large and the radial flow velocity
toward the clear water side is low. In rectangular tanks, parallel guiding plates installed inside the
tank control the flow profile and the bubble rise. Particularly in older devices, the feed and the
aerated stream are fed separately to the flotation tank.
The floatage is removed by one or by a combination of the following devices:
- Scoop or skimmer
- Scraper or sometimes a blower
- Flow over a weir.
The solids content of the sludge depends on various parameters, which determine, e.g., the
floc size and density. When treating PM white water and filtrates, the solids content of the
flotation sludge is typically in a range of 3%5%. Similarly to the saveall principle, the recovered
solids can be returned to the process; otherwise the sludge is disposed. In the latter case, the
sludge is either dewatered and post-treated, e.g., together with other mill sludges and wet rejects,
or it is pumped into an effluent treatment plant. In some instances, the solids content of the
flotation sludge is controlled by the speed of the scoop or scraper.
Finally, by applying special measurements to determine, for example, charge or turbidity, the
chemicals dosage and the operation and efficiency of the DAF unit can be controlled and
improved.
5.5.3 Classification
Screening or fractionation of white water in order to recover fibers and fines is not feasible due to
the large flow to be treated and due to relatively high demands in fines recovery.
Inclined screens, i.e., curved or bow screens, which are sometimes called scalping screens,
are used for various applications including fiber recovery, thickening, or protecting downstream
operations from fibers or debris. Inclined screens have no moving parts, except an oscillating
cleaning shower, which removes plugging material and which prevents buildup and blinding by
slime or scaling. Washing is often realized by backspraying, flushing nozzles, or by a combination
of both. Screen plate design and slot size depend on the application. Inclined screens require a
constant feed flow, which can also be pressurized, and have a limited hydraulic capacity.
Microscreens and shower water screens are used to post-treat clear and super-clear disc
filtrate for mid- and high-pressure shower applications. Microscreens are sometimes called
"polishing filters." In contrast to drum or disc filters, the type of medium determines the separation
of the solid and the filtrate phases, although the design of the screen can be rather similar to
filtration.
If contaminated white water is fed to a microscreen, inclined screens are often installed
upsteam to retain coarse particles from entering in order to avoid damage of the filter medium.
Even at a low solids concentration, as low as 0.001%, long fibers can be still present in the
filtrate44, which can plug needle jets or high-pressure spray showers. Showers particularly
sensitive to coarse particles are therefore protected by a screen, which in this respect is called a
"police filter."
Membrane filtration, in particular ultra- and nano-filtration, is discussed in the section about
advanced water treatment.
5.5.4 Sedimentation
Settling chests and hopper-bottomed tanks were commonly used before saveall equipment like
disc filters was introduced. The clarification of PM white water by sedimentation has several
disadvantages, which make its application as process water purification unit unpractical. Some of
these disadvantages are:
- Long retention time
- Low concentration of recovered fibers
added during startups and web breaks compared to normal PM operation. This can cause
process instability. Fresh water can be adjusted in temperature and pH, but the content of
suspended and dissolved solids is different. This can imbalance wet end chemistry; variations
imposed on the effluent treatment plant are often increased. The fresh water to supplement
lacking process water is heated to the process water temperature and added to the process at
one location only, i.e., the white water tank. This location is processwise distant from the
headbox; thus, a possible impact on the wet end chemistry is attenuated. Similarly, consistency
variations in the dilution water header are avoided.
A supply tower for mechanically and/or chemically pretreated fresh water is useful, for
example, if varying amounts of fresh water are needed in the cold season of the year. In this
case, fresh water circulates from the tower through a heating loop utilizing recovered heat from
the PM hood exhaust or from the mechanical pulping heat recovery system, if available.
Otherwise, steam is injected. For many grades, the optimum stock temperature is found within a
range of 46C to 54C (115F to 130F)47. Higher temperatures of up to over 60C (140F) limit
microbiological growth significantly, while fungal growth stops already when exceeding 50C
(122F)48.
5.6.2 Fresh water use
As shown in Table 6, the specific fresh water consumption of modern mills is in a range of 220
L/kg paper49,50 with the exception of technical or specialty paper mills which might consume up
to 100 L/kg or more. In older mills, the fresh water consumption can be higher due to suboptimal
process design. Table 6 shows average consumption figures in 1971 51 to indicate the progress in
the reduction of fresh water consumption. The large reduction in the last decades was possible
due to the introduction of saveall equipment, the installation of sufficient process water storage,
the use of more efficient machinery, the separation of streams of different water quality, and an
all-over improved process design.
Table 6. Typical specific fresh water consumption of modern paper mills in comparison to
the situation in 197151.
Paper grade
Newsprint
Wood-free fine
paper
Supercalendered
(SC) paper
Lightweight
coated (LWC)
paper
Tissue
Liner and fluting
Multiply board
Today
L/kg
515
510
1015
1020
515
210
815
Today
gal/lb
0.61.8
0.61.2
1.21.8
1.22.4
0.61.8
0.251.2
11.8
1971a
L/kg
85
180
120b
290
4085
130
1971a
gal/lb
10
22
14b
35
510
16
a Mills in Sweden
b "Magazine paper" 51
The driving forces to reduce the fresh water consumption are:
- Legislation and permissions in respect to either the fresh water consumption or the effluent
discharge
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 35
- Cost:
- Fresh water and its treatment- Effluent treatment and possibly effluent discharge cost- Material
savings: fibers, fines, and filler- Energy savings
- Fresh water availability
- Higher process stability, if fresh water reduction means a reduction in process water
supplement.
A mill is called closed if no process water is discharged. Due to process inherent evaporation,
mainly in the drying section of the PM, and due to the discharge of water contained in cleaning
and screening rejects, a certain input of fresh water is always needed. This amount is smaller the
more water enters with moist raw materials, pigment slurry, chemicals, etc., cf. Fig. 23. If a rather
dry raw material like recycled fiber is used, then the specific fresh water consumption is about 2
L/kg in a closed mill operation. In this case, the amount of water evaporated at the PM drying
section is about 50% of the fresh water intake. Effluent-free papermaking is possible, but the
system stability and PM runnability are likely reduced and quality problems can occur if process
design and internal water purification are inadequate. Fresh water is used for selected shower
applications at the PM, and no fresh water is consumed to supplement process water.
Table 7 shows the shower water need of a wide PM52. Fresh water can be replaced by
cleaned process water, if the content of suspended solids is sufficiently low, and if detrimental
substances do not deposit or precipitate, which can plug the orifices of showers, cf. Table 853.
High-pressure showers are operated with fresh water for that reason. Fresh water is also used at
other locations, where dissolved organic and inorganic compounds can cause problems or where
scaling is harmful. As already mentioned, up to 10%15% of fresh water is needed for
preparation and dilution of chemicals.
Table 7. Shower water demand of a modern 9-m-wide paper machine 52.
Wire section
Warm fresh water
300 kPa
3 500 kPa
Post-treated clear filtrate
300 kPa
1 200 kPa
Press section
Warm fresh water
300 kPa
3 500 kPa
Post-treated clear filtrate
300 kPa
In total, of which:
Washing and lubrication
High-pressure showers
In total, of which:
Former and roll showers
Trim knock-off and edge
showers
Knock-off
Trim squirt, roll edge
moistening
In total, of which:
Washing and lubrication
High-pressure showers
In total, of which:
Internal roll washing
100200 ppm
200500 ppm
> 500 ppm
Usable in 3 mm orifice
Brush type shower recommended
Purgable shower recommended
information. The effect of salts in the process water can be monitored on-line by measuring the
conductivity of the fluid. Specific metal cations and some anions are usually determined in the
laboratory; only a few are measured on-line, for example, calcium, aluminum, and silicate. See
also Table 4.
5.6.2.2 Accumulation mechanisms
Continuous feed or generation of a substance within a process with internal circulation causes
this substance to accumulate. This means that the concentration in the circulation loop increases
reaching levels the higher the less effluent is discharged, which is sometimes described by the
(misleading) term "degree of closure"57. Each organic and inorganic dissolved compound
eventually reaches equilibrium. The equilibrium appears earlier and a lower concentration level is
reached if part of the substance is consumed in chemical reactions by a phase change like
precipitation, by flocculation, by microbiological degradation, or in some other way. The particular
equilibrium of each substance is determined by the process conditions, which can be monitored
by measuring, for example temperature, pH, and charge density. If a substance is not consumed,
a higher level of concentration is reached, which is governed by the streams discharged from the
process.
In order to show trends and possible levels of accumulation, so-called "enrichment" or
"accumulation" curves are plotted, which are often based on short circulation balance
calculations. For example, the term "enrichment factor" has been defined as the ratio of the
headbox concentration of a given substance at a certain degree of white water recycling to that at
zero-recycling58. To study the accumulation of detrimental or other substances, the simple short
circulation model has to be extended to the entire mill water system, as shown below in Fig. 26.
In order to gain a better understanding of mill water systems, it can be useful to incorporate
adsorption parameters into model calculations to study, e.g., wire retention or the concentration
of chemical aids59, or pursuit accumulation mechanisms by dynamic simulation 60. Table 10
summarizes the disadvantages of decreased fresh water use.
Table 10. Disadvantages of decreased fresh water consumption 61.
Increase in suspended
Increase in dissolved
Increase in temperature
solids
material
Blocking of showers
Scale deposits
Sizing problems
Increase of fines and change Alteration of wet end
Reduction in vacuum pump
in retention
chemistry
capacity
Spots and dirt in the product
Increase of biological activity
Increase of biological activity
Deposit formation
Deposit formation
(at low temperature)
Abrasion
Corrosion
Reduction of wire life
Color, smell
The PM headbox should always be the reference point for evaluating changes in water
quality and in the load by detrimental substances 62. The following points have relevance in
respect to accumulation of detrimental substances and system stability:
- Correct choice of source for water to discharge from the mill as effluent
- Correct selection of water to be treated by advanced purification
- Suitable application of the purified water in the process.
While savealls improve process water reuse, advanced water purification techniques are
needed just as well in order to remove dissolved material, if the fresh water consumption and the
discharge of effluent should be reduced further.
5.6.2.3 Vertically integrated mills
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 38
Many paper mills are connected to a pulp plant, producing chemical or mecha--nical pulp or
processing recovered paper. The interface to the paper mill is usually a medium- or sometimes a
high-consistency storage, from where the pulp is picked up by dilution water from the paper mill.
The reduction in fresh water consumption in an existing process has to be accompanied by
two means in order to keep the load of detrimental substances low in the headbox. On one hand,
the increase of the transfer consistency at the interface between pulping and paper mill
decreases the carryover of detrimental substances that are created in pulping and bleaching. On
the other hand, fresh water is used in high-pressure showers and other selected locations at the
PM and if needed for preparation and dilution of chemicals. Further on, effluent is not discharged
from the PM system, but surplus PM filtrate is added to the white water system in the pulping
plant. Figure 25 shows this principle. The separation of the pulping and paper mill water systems
leads to a higher dissolved matter concentration in the upstream water loops, from where all
effluent of the integrated mill is discharged.
Figure 25. Vertically integrated mill water household, system principle.
Designing the integrated mill water system according to this counter-current flow principle, or
as a cascade of mill water loops, results in:
- Decreased load of detrimental substances in the PM water
- Reduced effluent flow and lower fresh water demand
- Possibly improved efficiency in pulping, e.g., in deinking63.
The separation of the water systems is enhanced further, when introducing a "washing" loop
by installing a second dewatering press at the interface between pulping and the PM. This is
particularly useful to reduce detrimental substances caused by the high alkalinity in peroxide
bleaching of deinked or mechanical pulp, which is often carried out as a final step before
transferring the pulp to the PM. In addition to organic dissolved and colloidal material, supporting
chemicals like sodium silicate used in deinking and in peroxide bleaching also can be
detrimental. After the bleaching tower, pulp is diluted to a lower consistency and pumped to a
second dewatering press prior to the pulp storage. The pressate is fed upstream. Figure 26
shows the lower level in detrimental substances at the headbox of the two-press system against
the effluent discharge from the integrated mill. For comparison, a situation without press
dewatering is also shown, assuming a 12% solids content after thickening compared to 35% after
press dewatering. The specific load of detrimental substances is plotted relative to the
concentration at the kink point of the two-press curve. At this point, the amount of surplus PM
filtrate meets exactly the amount of dilution water required to reach the desired consistencies at
bleaching and pulp storage towers. Reducing further the amount of the fresh water added to the
paper mill would create a lack of PM filtrate in this particular example; hence, it would require
supplement by highly contaminated pulping filtrate. Figure 26 shows clearly that this must not be
done in mill practice without applying advanced water purification treatment to this recycle water.
On the other hand, applying advanced treatment to this stream is most feasible, when closing the
water system of the integrated mill62.
Figure 26. Accumulation of detrimental substances in the PM headbox water at reduced effluent
discharge for an integrated paper mill with different degrees of process water separation.
5.6.2.4 Horizontally integrated mills
Horizontal integration here means parallel paper production lines. Even if parallel paper
machines were identical, or if the same product is produced on both lines, the amount of
dissolved organic and inorganic substances can vary significantly. In most cases, it is feasible to
separate the water systems of neighboring machines, especially if the fresh water consumption is
low or different for both lines. This requires separated stock preparation, wet broke systems,
savealls, and process water storage for each line. Hence, the independent and trouble-free
operation of either line is guaranteed regardless to whether changes occur on the other line,
either in wet end chemistry, in production state, or due to grade change. A case in which
collected mill effluent is re-introduced as process water requires sufficient treatment by advanced
water purification.
5.6.3 Advanced water purification techniques
Advanced water purification techniques are applied to paper mill process water in order to reduce
the amount of dissolved and colloidal substances circulating in the process. Advanced
techniques might become feasible or necessary when reducing the fresh water consumption
below a certain level as described above. Investment and operational costs of advanced
equipment are reduced by the savings from decreased flows through fresh and wastewater
treatment.
From the many known techniques for advanced water purification, the following have been
successfully applied to paper mill process water in industrial scale:
- Biological treatment
- Membrane filtration
- Evaporation.
The selection of the suitable technique is determined by parameters similar to those for
choosing equipment to remove suspended solids, namely:
- Desired quality of purified water
- Cost:
- Investment cost- Operational cost- Spare parts and replacement media; maintenance
- Energy demand, power, and steam consumption
- Reliability, availability, and responsiveness
- Properties and reachable concentration of concentrate
- Required feed flow properties and pre-treatment
- Uniformity requirements on the flow rate and properties of the feed
- Floor space.
The reject stream from advanced treatment consists either of a concentrate with increased
viscosity or of sludge. Required post-treatment of this reject stream and costs resulting from it are
often crucial for the feasibility of a certain technique. Possible further uses or treatments of the
concentrate or sludge are:
- Drying and/or combustion
- Trading or use elsewhere
- Disposal, if allowed
- Treatment in the wastewater treatment plant
- Re-use within the process.
The most frequently applied method for fluid concentrate handling is combustion 64.
5.6.3.1 Membrane filtration
Membrane filtration is used in the paper industry to purify process water or to recover valuable
material like pigments or latex from coating kitchen effluents. The membrane works as a
molecular screen; thus, the properties of the membrane determine the quality of the cleaned
stream. Table 11 shows classification of membrane filtration according to the particle cut-off size
in separation. The separation sizes and operating pressures in Table 11 are guideline figures.
Table 11. Membrane filtration techniques.
Method
Separation size
Operating pressure Membrane type
Reverse osmosis
Non-porous
< 1.5 nm
36 MPa
(RO)
Micro-porous
0.5 nm7 nm
14 MPa
Nano-filtration (NF)
Micro-porous
3 nm0.1 m
0.21 MPa
Ultra-filtration (UF)
Porous
50 nm5 m
0.10.4 MPa
Microfiltration (MF)
Membranes can be shaped in various module types such as tubes, plates or frames, hollow
fibers, monoliths, or spiral wound. Membrane material can also be charged when applied to UF
or RO. The cross-flow principle is generally applied to paper mill process water to avoid
excessive fouling. Membrane fouling means a decrease in flux due to adsorption, blockage of
pores, or deposition on the membrane surface by gel or layer formation. Periodical or continuous
cleaning is necessary. Good pretreatment of the feed, like microfiltration, is required. NF and
especially RO usually post-treat ultra-filtrate. Despite pretreatment and cleaning, membranes
have to be replaced every 15 years. The specific energy consumption is 0.55 kWh/m3(65). The
filtrate quality as well as the flux depend on the type of membrane used and on the feed. The
reduction in COD depends on the contributing amount of large molecules and colloids. The COD
reduction from PM filtrates by UF is usually in the range of 20%40%66,67, but by NF possibly up
to 90%68. NF or RO reduces the content of ions to some degree.
5.6.3.2 Evaporation
Evaporation is the most effective technique to concentrate all nonvolatile substances for removal
from the process. The quality of the condensate is equivalent to fresh water quality or better 69.
For paper mill process water, multi-effect (ME) and mechanical vapor recompression (MVR)
evaporation are used at mill scale, both employing falling film technology and vacuum
evaporation7072. The feed water is usually pretreated by filtration and/or dissolved air flotation.
In the ME cascade, the evaporated vapor is used as heating steam in the next lower pressure
effect. The vapor from the final effect is condensed by water cooling. Waste heat in form of
secondary or low-pressure steam is used for heating. According to the number of effects and the
amount of heating, a final contaminant concentration of 50% or higher is achieved. In MVR, a fan
or compressor to be used as the heating medium recompresses the vapor. No steam or cooling
water is required. By using polymeric film as heat-exchanging material, a large heating surface is
provided at low investment cost and relatively low power requirements. For the latter, the specific
energy consumption is 810 kWh/m3(70), and the concentrate flow is about 10% of the feed flow.
Post-treatment of the MVR condensate by ME evaporation or direct steam concentration is
needed to reach a higher concentration level.
The COD removal efficiency by evaporation is about 95%, and the removal of electrolytes is
even better. The removal of organic material can be improved by stripping volatile organic
compounds at the evaporator and by treating the foul condensate, e.g., in an anaerobic
reactor71. Evaporation of volatile low-molecular organic acids can be reduced by increasing the
pH.
5.6.3.3 Biological in-process treatment
Paper process water is loaded with non-toxic substances, the majority of which are
carbohydrates. It is therefore well suited for biological degradation. The type of treatment
required does not differ appreciably from that used for ordinary paper mill effluent treatment.
Contrary to wastewater treatment, the biological treatment becomes part of the manufacturing
process, which requires the process design optimized for reliability and responsiveness.
Especially for mills without effluent discharge, anaerobic treatment is feasible to degrade the
highly concentrated dissolved organic substances in the process water. To avoid dissipation of
anaerobic conditions into the paper production process, an aeration tank follows the anaerobic
reactor. The water cleaned in a clarification tank after aeration can be purified further by sand
filtration or directly by membrane filtration. Biological water treatment is not efficient to remove
colored substances from water, especially from mechanical pulping filtrates. An integrated
post-treatment by membrane filtration73 can be useful to remove color and to detain
microorganisms from entering into the paper process if required74. Sludge can be recycled back
into the process as furnish used in brown or gray liner and board production 75,76.
Compared to the other techniques, biological treatment does not require prior solids removal.
Anaerobic micro-organisms are sensitive against unsuitable temperature and pH, as well as
against major variations in nutrition feed. The advantages compared to aerobic cultures are a
higher degradation efficiency of organic material if fed at high concentration, about ten times
lower generation of sludge, and possible energy recovery from produced biogas. The reduction in
BOD, especially in a combined aerobic and anaerobic system, is naturally high, typically up to
95%99%. Depending on the amount of biodegradable material contributing to the COD, a
reduction of 90% in COD is also reachable. Precipitation occurring in biological treatment
reduces the content of dissolved inorganic material like calcium and sulfate to some extent.
The removal of the blend and machine chests from the mill layout requires a constant level in
all stock proportioning chests and consistence constancy. This can be achieved by stock
circulation between the proportioning chest and the dilution zone of the pulp storage tower 79.
Operation without wire pit and short circulation with a centrifugal deaeration pump showed on a
pilot machine an about 10 times improved stabilization time and 24 times faster basis weight
adjustment on a grade change82.
Examples of stock and water systems of modern machines producing different paper and
board grades are given in Chapter 1.
References
1. Norman, B., "The water and fiber flow system in the paper and board mill," EUCEPA 1990
Print, Paper and Board Products for Printing in the Nineties Conference Proceedings, EUCEPA,
Paris, p. 217.
2. Seifert, P., Tappi 63(10):135 (1980).
3. Perrault, J., Tappi J. 67(7):62 (1984).
4. Kershaw, T.N., "Basic wet end hydraulics," TAPPI 1985 Wet End Operations Seminar Notes,
TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 5.
5. Boyce, M.P., in Perry's Chemical Engineers' Handbook (Perry, R. H. and Green, D. W. Eds.)
7th edn., McGraw-Hill, New York, 1997, Chap. 10.
6. Reijonen, Y., "Optimising the short circulation," EUCEPA 1988 XXIII Conference Proceedings,
vol. 1, EUCEPA, Paris, p. 11.
7. Seppl, S.I., "Driving forces to multiply forming," 1987, New available techniques and current
trends, part I, SPCI, Stockholm, p. 171.
8. Kieling, H., Das Papier 41(7):370 (1987).
9. Guillory, K., Tappi J. 81(9):81 (1998).
10. Reed, C.S., Tappi J. 78(7):241 (1995).
11. Cutshall, K.A., Ilott, G.E., Brooks, B.W., Pulp Paper Can. 80(6):T193 (1979).
12. Stadelmann, J., Wochenbl. Papierfabr. 116(21):902 (1988).
13. Nyberg, P. and Malashenko, A., Pulp Paper Can. 99(1):T5 (1998).
14. T oukonummi, O., Paperi Puu 80(6):430 (1998).
15. Bliss, T., "Centrifugal cleaning in the stock preparation system," TAPPI 1996 Stock
Preparation Short Course Notes, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 195.
16. Moore, S.J., "The practical aspects of cleaner system diagnosis for optimum performance,"
TAPPI 1986 Papermakers Conference Proceedings, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 295.
17. Wood, J.R. and Karnis, A., Pulp Paper Can. 80(4):T116 (1979).
18. Rehmat, T. and Branion, R., "Fibre fractionation in hydrocyclones," CPPA 1995 81st Annual
Meeting Notes, Technical Section, CPPA, Vol. B, Montral, p. B105.
19. Sevilla, E.M. and Branion, R.M.R., J. Pulp Paper Sci. 23(2):J85 (1997).
20. Vikio, P.A., "Recovering fiber and filler from mineral loaded paper mill rejects," TAPPI 1997
Engineering and Papermakers Conference Proceedings, Book II, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 639.
21. Johnson, M., "The headbox approach system," TAPPI 1991 Papermakers Conference
Proceedings, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 515.
22. Bliss, T., "Screening in the stock preparation system," TAPPI 1996 TAPPI Stock Preparation
Short Course Notes, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 171.
23. Fredriksson, B., Hmlinen, T., Koikkalainen, J., Paperi Puu 79(1):30 (1997).
24. Kervin, D. and Coffey, C.A., "Thick stock screening for fine debris removal," TAPPI 1997
Engineering and Papermakers Conference Proceedings, Book II, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 653.
25. Isler, W. and Widmer, F., Das Papier 32(11):473 (1978).
26. Pietikinen, T., Tappi J. 75(11):185 (1992).
27. Matula, J.P., "Deaeration and the Approach System," TAPPI 1996 Stock Preparation Short
Course Notes, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 212.
28. May, O.W. and Buckman, S.J., Tappi 58(2):90 (1975).
29. Lorz, R.H., Pulp Paper Can. 88(10):T361 (1987).
30. Ajersch, M., Pelton, R., Towers, M., Loewen, S., J.Pulp Paper Sci. 18(4):J121 (1992).
31. Karras, M. and Springer, A., Tappi J. 72(2):155 (1989).
32. Rauch, R., Hofer, H.-H., Sangl, R., Weigl, J., Wochenbl. Papierfabr. 125(17):794 (1997).
33. Steward, J., Pulp and Paper 55(3):170 (1981).
34. May, O.W., Tappi J. 74(7):67 (1991).
35. Roberts, J.C., Paper Chemistry, 2nd edn., Blackie Academic and Professional, London, 1996.
36. Korpi, T., Paperivalmistusprosessin kemian peruskoulutus, KCL, Espoo, 1997.
37. Moller, K., Duffy, G.G., Titchener, A.L., Appita 26(4):278 (1973).
38. Duffy, G.G., Appita 42(5):358 (1989).
39. TAPPI TIS 0410-15 "Optimum consistency for pumping pulp," TAPPI PRESS (1993).
40. Doucette, J.A., "White water and savealls," TAPPI 1996 Stock Preparation Short Course
Notes, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 269.
41. Pelki, A., "Kuiduntalteenotto paperikoneen 0-vedest," 1995 Paperitehdaspivt, Ahlstrom
Machinery, Savonlinna, Paper No. 9.
42. Pelki, A., "Fiber recovery from paper machine white water," 1997 Paperitehdaspivt,
Ahlstrom Machinery, Savonlinna.
43. Perrault, R.R., Tappi J. 76(12):189 (1993).
44. Diedrich, K., Hamm, U., Knelissen, J.H., Das Papier 51(6A):V153 (1997).
45. Strau, J. and Gromann, H., Wochenbl. Papierfabr. 125(9):468 (1997).
46. Mardon, J., O'Blenes, G., Robertson, A.G.,Tkacz, A., Pulp Paper Can. 99(5):35 (1998).
47. Panchapakesan, B., "Closed white water system designs," TAPPI 1993 Papermakers
Conference Proceedings, TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, p. 219.
48. Hoekstra, P.M., in Chemical Processing Aids in Papermaking: A Practical Guide, (K.J. Hipolit,
Ed.), TAPPI PRESS, Atlanta, 1992, pp. 126.
49. Terho, J., Pulp Paper Eur. 3(3):25 (1998).
50. Myren, B., Water Sci. Tech. 29(5-6):1 (1994).
51. Franzn, T., Heinegard, C., Martin-Lf, S., Sremark, C., Wahren, D., "Establishment of a
closed system for the paper making process," EUCEPA 1973 XV Conference Proceedings,
Papermaking Part 1, Stock Preparation and Wet End - Page 44
Chapter
75. Gttsching, L., "Completely closed water system a German case study," 1997 Johan
Gullichsen Colloquium, PI, Helsinki, p. 101.
76. Pichon, M., Nivelon, S., Charlet, P., "Paper mill whitewater deconcentration to move towards
complete closure of circuits," TAPPI 1996 Minimum Effluent Mill Symposium Notes, TAPPI
PRESS, Atlanta, p. 206.
77. Meinander, P.O., Paper Tech. 36(4):26 (1993).
78. Meinander, P.O., Pulp Paper Eur. 3(1):13 (1998).
79. Pekkarinen, T. and Kaunonen, A., "New Approach to Wet End Management," XI Valmet
Paper Technology Days 1998 Proceedings, Valmet Inc., Jyvskyl, p. 25.
80. Matula, J. P., Paperi Puu 82(3):174(2000).
81. Kaunonen, A., "Runnability and quality improvement through consistency measurement and
control," 1996 Valmet Paper Machine Days Proceedings, Valmet Inc., Jyvskyl, 7 pp.
82. Nyknen, R., "Technological and Economic Potential of the POM Concept," Master's Thesis,
Helsinki Univ. of Technology, Espoo, 1998.
Figure 3. Stock approach flow system of a fine paper machine (refer to text
for itemization of position numbers).
Figure 4. (a.) Short circulation model. (b.) Dynamic response for different
retention values R as a function of normalized time1.
Figure 12. Stock blending and machine chest including sampling station, an
example.
Figure 18. Bentonite dosage at the headbox feed pipe after pressure
screens.
Figure 22. Dissolved air flotation unit for process water treatment.
Figure 24. Working cycle for segregated and optimized internal mill water
use.