Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 Shaun Tougher, The Eunuch in Byzantine History and Society (New York: Routledge,
2008), 42.
2 Mathew Kuefler, The Manly Eunuch: Masculinity, Gender Ambiguity, and Christian
Ideology in Late Antiquity (Chicago: 2001), 31-36, 61-69, 96-102, 245-282.
9 See, e.g. Eunapius frag. 64, 65. 1-7, Zosimus, New History 5.38-18, Marcellinus Comes,
Chronicle 396.
10 Ammianus, Res gestae 31.11.1; Eunapius, frag. 47;Zosimus, New History 4.22.
5
brambles roses spring up, and among the savage beasts some
are tamed.
13
15For depictions of Theodosius IIs heavy reliance on court eunuchs, and in particular,
the dominance of his spatharius Chrysaphius in internal and external politics and
Christological controversies, see e.g., Priscus, frag. 3, 11, 13, 15.2; Theodoret, Ep. 110;
Vita of Daniel the Stylite, 31; Marcellinus Comes, Chronicle s.a. 450; Malalas, Chronicle,
363, 368; Evagrius, HE 1.10, 2.2; Theophanes, A M 5738, 5740, 5943.
(Valentinian III)
Eunuchs took part in two of the fifth centuries most infamous
political assassinations. The first occurred in 454 when the
9
20 Jonathan Arnolds Theoderic and the Roman Imperial Restoration (Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 2014), 90.
11
21 A full account of this gendered propaganda is found in, Walter Kaegi, Procopius the Military Historian,
BF 15 (1990): 79-81; M.E. Stewart, Contests of Andreia in Procopius Gothic Wars, 4 (2014),
pp. 21-54.
12
22 See e.g., Edward Gibbon, The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (London: Penguin
Classics,1994),4.36; J.B. Bury, History of the Later Roman Empire from the Death of Theodosius I to the Death
of Justinian (London Macmillan, 1958), pp. 267-80; Lawrence Fauber, Narses the Hammer of the Goths (New
York: St. Martins Press, 1990), p. 135; John Martyn, The Eunuch Narses, in Text and Transmission in
Medieval Europe (Cambridge: Cambridge Scholarly Publishing, 2007), pp. 46-56.
23 Modern military historians, for example, have rated Narses as a better general than his rival Belisarius. See
e.g., Bevin Alexander, How Wars are Won: The 13 Rules of War from Ancient Greece to the War on Terror (New
York: Three Rivers Press, 2002), pp.49-52.
24 Procopius revealed that in 541, the Empress Theodora had sent Narses to assassinate the praetorian prefect
John the Cappadocian Procopius, Wars 1.25.24-30.
13
28
14
and
Agathias,
Ringroses
contention
that
however,
neither
undermine
historian
Kathryn
attributes
cannot fail to make its mark, no matter what obstacles are put
in its path, it seems clear that Agathias would have placed
Narses on or near the top of his ladder of human excellence. 33
Moreover, martial virtues had never centered solely on courage or physicality alone. In the
words of Agathias, Brains and not brawn represented the primary qualities of an effective
Roman general. Procopius too criticized generals for risking themselves fighting on the
frontline.34 These attitudes need not surprise. Byzantine military handbooks, in fact, preferred
it when military commanders avoided combat.35 Moreover, men with little or no military
background could lead Byzantine armies. The Italian senator Liberius, described by
Procopius as an old man and without experience in deeds of war, had for a timealbeit
ineffectually led Justinians Italian campaign.36
38 Shaun Tougher points out this possibility in his paper on Narses that he kindly allowed
me to see before publication.
39Procopius, Wars 6.30.1-5; Agathias, Histories 5.20.5. Historians continue to debate just
how viable a rival Belisarius was, see e.g. Henning Brm, Justinians Truimph und Belisars
Erniedrigung beriegungen zum Verhltnis Zwischen Reich,Chiron (2013): 63-91.
17
Somewhat
more
surprisingly,
non-Byzantine
40 Justinians predecessors Marcian (ruled 450-457), Leo I (ruled 457-474), Zeno (ruled
474-5, 476-91), Basiliscus (ruled 475/6), Justin I (ruled 518-27) all began their careers as
humble soldiers (the exception, Anastasius ruled 491-518, served as a palace official
before surprisingly being named emperor).
41 See e.g. John Malalas, Chronicle 484, 486, Evagrius, Ecclesiastical History 4.24, John
of Ephesus, Church History 3.1.39.
18
Heraclius
sent
the
Patrician
and
chamberlain
against
the
Lombards,
however,
stalled,
forcing
20
21
continued
until
the
thirteenth
century
to
wield
23
Thank you
Final slide
24
25