Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
4. Evidence must be substantial
5. Decision based on the evidence presented
6. Tribunal acts on its own independent consideration of the law
and facts
7. Parties should know that various issues involved and the
reason for the decision
Minimum Standard for Imposition of Disciplinary Actions in Schools
1. Students informed of the nature and cause of any accusation
2. Right to answer charged, with assistance of counsel if desired
3. Informed of evidence against them
4. Right to adduce evidence
5. Evidence duly considered by the investigating body
Void-for-Vagueness Doctrine
o A law is facially invalid if men of common intelligence must
necessarily guess at its meaning and differ as to its application
o Lacks sufficient standards
Overbreadth Doctrine
o A governmental purpose may not be achieved by means
which sweep unnecessarily broadly and thereby invade the
area of political freedoms
Quantum of Proof
o Administrative Proceedings : Substantial Evidence
o Probable Cause: Probability, not absolute and moral certainty
o Flight Rise: Clear and Convincing Evidence
Notice and Hearing (Requirements for Due Process)
o Quasi-judicial proceedings: Yes
o Executive or Legislative Functions: No
Requirements in Deportation Proceedings
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
3.
4.
5.
6.
Exclusionary Rule
o Any evidence obtained in violation of Section 2 or 3 of the
Constitution is inadmissible for any purpose in any proceeding
Types of Preliminary Investigation
1. Preliminary Investigation Proper
Made by fiscal, executive, to determine probable cause
to file a case
2. Preliminary Investigation to issue warrant
Made by judge, judicial, to determine probable cause to
issue a warrant
7.
Allowable Warrantless Searches
1. Incidental to a lawful arrest
Must be within the area
2. Moving Vehicle
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
Section 4 - Freedom speech, expression, press
Prior Restraint
Official government restrictions on the press or other forms of
expression in advance of actual publication or dissemination
Exceptions - Prior Restraint
Nation is at war
Obscene publications
Incitements to acts of violence
Overthrow by force of an orderly government
Types of Restrictions
1. Content neutral regulations
Concerned with the incidents of the speech
Subject to lesser but still heightened scrutiny
2. Content based restraint or censorship
Concerned with the subject matter of the utterance
More suspect because of judicial concern with
discrimination in the regulation of expression
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
Defamatory
Protected only if true and fair and maid with good faith
Libelous
Tends to injure a person in his reputation or brings him
to public contempt
Subsequent punishment
Public figure - actual malice should be proven
Private individual - case to case basis
Intrusions to privacy
Private individual - not permitted, complete protection
Public figure - permitted as long as the information is of
public character(open to scrutiny)
Actual Malice
"with knowledge that it is false or with reckless disregard of
whether it was false or not"
Motion Pictures, Television, Radio
"Censorship"
Must show proof of a clear and present danger
Three safeguards to protect against "undue inhibition of
protected expression"
1. The censors have the burden of proving that the speech
prevented is unprotected expression
2. Such acts require judicial determination for valid
determination
3. Such acts require prompt determination "within a
specified time period"
Freedom of Religion(to act), Assembly
May be curtailed upon a showing of a clear and present
danger
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
3. Whether the work, taken as a whole, lack s serious
literary, artistic, political, or scientific value
Section 5 - Non-establishment of Religion
Commercial Speech
The government has a greater right to regulate commercial
speech (commercial or economic) as against regulating noncommercial speech
Central Hudson test
1. Commercial speech must concern lawful activity and is
not misleading
2. There is a substantial government interest
3. The regulation directly advances the asserted
government interest
4. Whether it is not more extensive than necessary to
serve the interest
Banning signs altogether is content-based (if no alternatives
were provided)
Obscenity
Not protected
Basic guideline for the trier of fact
1. Whether the average person, applying contemporary
community standards would find the work, taken as a
whole, as appealing to the prurient interest
Applicable in the Philippines (but change "taken
as a whole" to "dominant theme of the material
taken as a whole")
2. Whether the work depicts or describes, in a patently
offensive way, sexual conduct specifically defined by the
applicable state law
Offensiveness is determined based on community
(not national) standards
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
Right to strike
Qualified by "in accordance with law"
Right to organize is broader
Ban on government employees
Statutory
May be lifted by a repealing statute
Section 9 - Eminent Domain
Eminent Domain
Sovereign power to appropriate public and private property of
all citizens within its territory for public use
Traditionally executive in nature but requires legislation
before it may be used
May be conferred upon municipal governments and
other LGUs
Plenary in nature
Elements of the exercise of the power of eminent domain
1. Taking
2. Public use
3. Just compensation
Requisites of Taking
1. Entrance
2. Entrance not just for a momentary period
3. Entry under warrant or color of legal authority
4. Property must be devoted to public use or otherwise
informally appropriated or injuriously affected
5. Utilization of property in a way that ousts original owner to
deprive him of all benefits of the property
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
Public Use
As broad as "public welfare"
Determination of genuine necessity - justiciable question
Exception: when power is exercised by the legislature political question
Just Compensation
Just and complete equivalent of the loss which the owner of
the thing expropriated has to suffer by reason of the
expropriation
Payment that matches the "market value"
Market value - price fixed by buyer and seller in the
open market
If determined by a government agency - subject to judicial
review
Judicial Review
Adequacy of the compensation
Necessity of taking
"Public use" character
Requisites of Expropriation by a Municipal Government
Public use
Just compensation
Valid offer
Done on the strength of a legislative act of the LGU
(ordinance)
Section 10 - Non-impairment clause
To fall within the guarantee:
Impairment must be substantial
Changes the terms of a legal contract (e.g. new conditions)
Out-of-court identification
General rule: no need for counsel
Exception: when custodial investigation has already began
Totality of circumstances test to determine validity of out-of-court
identification
1. Witness' opportunity to view the criminal at the time of the
crime
2. Witness' degree of attention
3. Accuracy of any prior description
4. Level of certainty of witness in identification
5. Length of time between commission of the crime and
identification
6. Suggestiveness of the identification procedure
Waiver of Right
Presumption: no waiver
Requirement: done voluntarily, knowingly, intelligently, and in
writing and in the presence of counsel
Right deemed waived if there was failure to raise objection at
the earliest time possible (during trial)
Section 13 - Bail
Right to bail
Means of immediately obtaining liberty
Enables accused to prepare defense
Purpose: guarantee appearance during trial
Not available when(must concur):
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
1. Accused is charged with an offense punishable by reclusion
perpetua
2. Evidence against him is strong
Some guidelines:
Not absolute (e.g. Military personnel may not be granted bail)
Should not be excessive
Available in extradition proceedings
May be waived: accused agrees to remain in legal custody
during pendency of his case
Section 14 - Rights of the Accused
Rights under this provision
1. Due process of law
2. Presumption of innocence
3. To be heard
4. To be informed of the nature and cause of accusation
5. Speedy, impartial, and public trial
6. Meet witnesses face to face
7. Compulsory process to (a) secure attendance of witnesses and
(b) produce evidence
Trial by publicity
Presumption of impartiality - judge
To warrant prejudicial publicity:
Allegation and proof that judges have been duly
influenced
Right to be heard:
The one hearing must be
Fair
Impartial
The one being hear
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
4. No similar evidence could be obtained
Trial in absentia
Requisites
Accused has been arraigned
Notice of trial was duly served to him
Failure to appear is unjustified
Section 16 - Speedy disposition of cases
This provision covers the periods before, during, and after trial
Section 14 covers just the trial
Speedy
Relative and flexible, judged on a case to case basis
Factors to be balanced to decide whether or not there has
been a violation of this right
Length of delay
Reason for the delay
Assertion of the right or failure to assert it
Prejudice caused by the delay
Proper remedy: MANDAMUS
Section 17 - Right against Self Incrimination
Taking the witness stand:
Criminal case
Accused may not be compelled (exception: congress'
queries in aid of legislation)
Any other case
May be compelled (exception: when a penalty is
involved - partakes of a criminal nature)
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
3.
Waiver of right
When a person voluntarily answers a question, there is a
deemed waiver of right
Debt covered
Ex contractu (coming from a contract)
Ex delicto (coming from a crime) not covered
Heinous crimes
Grievous, odius, and hateful offenses and which, by reason of
their inherent of manifest wickedness, viciousness, atrocity,
and perversity are repugnant and outrageous to the common
standards and norms of decency and morality in a just,
civilized and ordered society
Requisites for the Congress to validly restore the death penalty:
1.
2.
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
Article V - Suffrage
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
Efficient production
More equitable distribution of land
Just share of other or seasonal farm workers
CROMBONDS 2011-2012
Quality Education
Right to quality education is not absolute
Subject to regulation to safeguard the public