Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SEDIMENTATION
According to Brown (1950), sedimentation is the separation of a suspension into a supernatant
clear fluid and a rather dense slurry containing a higher concentration of solid.
According to Perry (), sedimentation is the partial separation or concentration of suspended solid
particles from a liquid by gravity settling. This field may be divided into the functional operations of
thickening, whose purpose is to increase the concentration of suspended solids in a feed stream; and
clarification whose purpose is to remove a relatively small quantity of suspended particles and produce a
clear effluent.
Classification of Settleable Solids
There are different factors to be
consider
in
choosing
the
type
of
In this figure, it illustrates the relationship between solid concentration, interparticle cohesiveness
and the type of sedimentation that may exist. Totally discrete particles include many mineral particles, salt
crystals and similar substances that have little tendency to cohere. The flocculent particles generally
include those smaller than 20 micrometer, metal hydroxides, chemical precipitates and most organic
substances other than true colloids.
Sedimentation Tests
Short-Tube Method
This test is suitable in cases in which detention time does not change the degree of particle
flocculation and hence has no significant influence on particle-settling rates. It is also useful for
hydroseparator tests where the sedimentation device is to be used for classification.
Detention Test
This test utilizes a 1- to 4-L beaker or similar vessel. The sample is placed in the container,
flocculated by suitable means if required, and allowed to settle. Small samples for suspended-solids
analysis are withdrawn from a point approximately midway between liquid surface and settled solids
interface, taken with sufficient care that settled solids are not resuspended. Sampling times may be at
consecutively longer intervals, such as 5, 10, 20, 40, and 80 min.
From a simple batch sedimentation where suspended fine solids are placed in a graduated cylinder
allowing the contents to be undisturbed. The time rate of decrease in height of the visible interface
between s supernatant clear liquid and slurry containing the particles is the sedimentation rate. This small
scale experiment must be conducted at a uniform temperature to avoid movement of fluid or convection
due to density differences resulting from different temperatures. (Brown, 1950)
FACTORS AFFECTING SEDIMENTATION
Several factors affect the separation of settleable solids from water. Some of the more common
types of factors to consider are:
PARTICLE SIZE
The size and type of particles to be removed have a significant effect on the operation of the
sedimentation tank. Because of their density, sand or silt can be removed very easily. The velocity of the
water-flow channel can be slowed to less than one foot per second, and most of the gravel and grit will be
removed by simple gravitational forces. In contrast, colloidal material, small particles that stay in
suspension and make the water seem cloudy, will not settle until the material is coagulated and
flocculated by the addition of a chemical, such as an iron salt or aluminum sulfate. The shape of the
particle also affects its settling characteristics. A round particle, for example, will settle much more readily
than a particle that has ragged or irregular edges. All particles tend to have a slight electrical charge.
Particles with the same charge tend to repel each other. This repelling action keeps the particles from
congregating into flocs and settling.
WATER TEMPERATURE
Another factor to consider in the operation of a sedimentation basin is the temperature of the
water being treated. When the temperature decreases, the rate of settling becomes slower. The result is
that as the water cools, the detention time in the sedimentation tanks must increase. As the temperature
decreases, the operator must make changes to the coagulant dosage to compensate for the decreased
settling rate. In most cases temperature does not have a significant effect on treatment. A water treatment
plant has the highest flow demand in the summer when the temperatures are the highest and the settling
rates the best. When the water is colder, the flow in the plant is at its lowest and, in most cases; the
detention time in the plant is increased so the floc has time to settle out in the sedimentation basins.
CURRENTS
Basin inlets should be designed to minimize high flow velocities near the bottom of the tank. If
high flow velocities are allowed to enter the sludge zone, the sludge could be swept up and out of the
tank. Sludge is removed for further treatment from the sludge zone by scraper or vacuum devices which
move along the bottom.
Outlet Zone
The basin outlet zone or launder should provide a smooth transition from the sedimentation zone
to the outlet from the tank. This area of the tank also controls the depth of water in the basin. Weirs set at
the end of the tank control the overflow rate and prevent the solids from rising to the weirs and leaving the
tank before they settle out. The tank needs enough weir length to control the overflow rate, which should
not exceed 20,000 gallons per day per foot of weir.
SELECTION OF BASIN
There are many sedimentation basin shapes. They can be rectangular, circular, and square.
Rectangular Basins
Rectangular basins are commonly found in large-scale water treatment plants. Rectangular tanks
are popular as they tend to have:
High tolerance to shock overload
Predictable performance
Cost effectiveness due to lower construction cost
Lower maintenance
Minimal short circuiting
Gravity Settlers
According to Rousseau (1987), there are two types of sedimentation or settling. Type 1 settling
refers to the settling where interaction between particles are minimal. This is usually the case of settling
dilute slurries. All of the particles are to settle independently, knowing this and by acquiring additional data
like particle size distribution and rate of particle settling, a design of the settler can be made.
If the terminal velocity (U,) of the smallest particle to be separated is known or can be calculated,
then the overflow area (A1) can be calculated from the equation
The depth of the liquid should be great enough to avoid suspending effects of turbulent liquid
flow. Rousseau (1987) stated that the fluid velocity being about less than 20 times of the terminal velocity
will prevent the re-suspension of the particles. Since this is the case; for calculation purposes, Rousseau
(1987) indicated that the flow velocity should be 10 times of the terminal velocity of the particle resulting
for the flow area (AF)to be given as
Example
10 /tim particles of specific gravity = 3, the terminal velocity is 0.033 ft/s. To separate these
particles and all larger particles from a water stream of 100 ftVmin (833 gal/min), the basin dimensions
are calculated as follows:
In actual practice the effects of turbulence and other nonuniform flow characteristics would necessitate
making the basin at least 19 ft long. (Rousseau, 1987)
Another type of sedimentation; Type II sedimentation, is seen in thick and lumpy slurries where
the solid particles are settling as a mass. Because of this, systems are designed by controlling the
thickening capability of the basin along with sufficient overflow area in order to clarify the overflow of
liquid. Settlers of this type are referred to as thickeners. The construction of thickeners may be of a
rectangular basin but usually it is of circular cross-section. In the rectangular basin, solids are normally
removed by a traveling syphon that moves longitudinally back and forth along the basin. In the circular
design a raking mechanism is used to convey the settled solids slowly to the center of the basin where, as
with the rectangular basin, a syphon is used for their removal. (Rousseau, 1987)
The figure below depicts a circular thickener. The feed is introduced below the liquid surface and
above the sludge blanket. Density differences between the feed, clarified liquid, and settled solids cause
the feed to spread laterally or radially from the feed point, producing the effect of feeding the basin
uniformly across the area just above the sludge layer.
Solid-
Liquid Separation
Up
date,
to
there
are
already much inventions of equipment used to separate solids that are finely dispersed and divided within
a liquid. Given below is a table showing the different classification of mechanical processes employed in
solid-liquid separation. (Couper, Penney, Fair, & Walas, 2005)
Settling
Settling can be done letting the particles settle due to gravitational force of by employing
centrifugal force. Other means can also be used like flotation and magnetic separation. Sedimentation
behavior is important to be known in order to design the appropriate equipment. The figure below
illustrates typical sedimentation progress. (Couper et al., 2005)
According to Couper et al. (2005), it is more economical to concentrate dilute slurries when dealt
on a large scale basis. To make this happen, the slurries are made to undergo sedimentation with the use
of sedimentation tanks or thickeners within a prescribed period of time. Typical designs of thickeners are
shown next.
The
design employed
a large scale. The slurry is introduced at the top center via feed launder; the clear liquid overflows the top
edge in the overflow launder, whereas the solids settle out and are moved gradually towards the center
with slowly rotating rakes towards the discharge port at the bottom center. The concentrated slurry then is
suitable for filtration or other further processing. (Couper et al., 2005)
Another design of thickener is shown above. It is a deep cone thickener which was developed for
the National Coal Board in UK. The unit is about 10ft in diameter and the impellers have a rate of rotation
of 2rpm. Flow rate is about 70m 3 per sec with solids content of 6wt%. It can concentrate up to 25-35 wt%.
(Suarovsky, 1981).
Clarifiers are similar devices, primarily for recovering clear liquids from dilute suspensions. Sedimentation
rates can also be improved with the use of flocculating agents. Some of them are listed in the next page.
(Couper et al., 2005)
Rectangular basin
Depth: 7-16 ft
Width: 10-50 ft
Length: 4 width
Slope
of
bottom
toward
surface
dimensions,
Continuous sludge removal
ft/min
Detention time: 4-8 hours
volume
area,
and
of
the
sedimentation tank as
well as the weir length.
rate:
500-1,000
gal/day-ft2
We will determine
the
of
Calculations
Overview
least
two
tanks.
2. Calculate
the
required
Weir loading: 15,000-20,000
surface area.
gal/day-ft
3. Calculate
required volume.
4. Calculate the tank depth.
5. Calculate the tank width and length.
the
6. Check flow through velocity. If velocity is too high, repeat calculations with more tanks.
7. Calculate the weir length
1. Divide the Flow
The flow should be divided into at least two tanks and the flow through each tank should be calculated
using the formula shown below:
Qc = Q / n
Where:
Qc = flow in one tank
Q = total flow
n = number of tanks
We will consider a treatment plant with a flow of 1.5 MGD. We will divide the flow into three tanks, so the
flow in one tank will be:
Qc = (1.5 MGD) / 3
Qc = 0.5 MGD
2. Surface Area
Next, the required tank surface area is calculated. We will base this surface area on an overflow
rate
of
500
gal/day-ft2 in
order
to
design
the
most
efficient
sedimentation
basin.
(Notice that we converted the flow from 0.5 MGD to 500,000 gal/day before beginning our calculations.)
3. Volume
The tank volume is calculated just as it was for flocculation basins and flash mix chambers, by
multiplying flow by detention time. The optimal detention time for sedimentation basins depends on
whether sludge removal is automatic or manual. When sludge removal is manual, detention time should
be 6 hours. We will consider a tank with automatic sludge removal, so the detention time should be 4
hours.
The volume of one of our tanks is calculated as follows:
V=Qt
V = (500,000 gal/day) (4 hr) (1 day/24 hr) (1 ft3/7.48 gal)
V = 11,141 ft3
(Notice the conversions between days and hours and between cubic feet and gallons.)
4. Depth
The tank's depth is calculated as follows:
d=V/A
Where:
d = depth, ft
V = volume, ft3
A = surface area, ft2
For our example, the depth is calculated to be:
d = (11,141 ft3) / (1,000 ft2)
d = 11.1 ft
The specifications note that the depth should be between 7 and 16 feet. Our calculated depth is within
the recommended range. If the depth was too great, we would begin our calculations again, using a
larger number of tanks. If the depth was too shallow, we would use a smaller number of tanks.
5. Width and Length
You will remember that the volume of a rectangular solid is calculated as follows:
V=LWd
Where:
V = volume
L = length
W = width
d = depth
For our tank, the length has been defined as follows:
L=4W
Combining these two formulas, we get the following formula used to calculate the width of our tank:
W = 15.8 ft
The length is calculated as:
L = 4 (15.8 ft)
L = 63.2 ft
Then the flow through velocity of the tank is calculated (with a conversion from gallons to cubic feet and
from days to minutes):
V = Qc / Ax
V = (0.0000928 ft3-day/gal-min) (500,000 gal/day) / (175.4 ft2)
V = 0.26 ft/min
The velocity for our example is less than 0.5 ft/min, so it is acceptable. As a result, we do not need to
repeat our calculations.
7. Weir Length
The final step is to calculate the required length of weir. We will assume a weir loading of 15,000
gal/day-ft and use the following equation to calculate the weir length:
Lw = Qc / W.L
Where:
Lw = weir length, ft
Qc = flow in one tank, gal/day
W.L. = weir loading, gal/day-ft
So, in our example, the weir length is calculated as follows:
Lw = (500,000 gal/day) / (15,000 gal/day-ft)
Lw = 33.3 ft
The weir length should be 33.3 ft.
SEDIMENTATION AS A PARTICLE SIZE MEASUREMENT
Sedimentation is one method of particle size measurement. In this method, the rate of
sedimentation of a sample of particles in a liquid is followed. The suspension is dilute and so the particles
are assumed to fall at their single particle terminal velocity in the liquid (usually water). Stokes law is
assumed to apply (Rep < 0.3) and so the method using water is suitable only for particles typically less
than 50 m in diameter. The rate of sedimentation of the particles is followed by plotting the suspension
density at a certain vertical position against time. The suspension density is directly related to the
cumulative undersize and the time is related to the particle diameter via the terminal velocity. This is
demonstrated in the following:
Based on the figure below, the suspension density is sampled at a vertical distance, h below the
surface of the suspension. The following assumptions are made:
than 50 mm).
Particles are assumed to accelerate rapidly to their terminal free fall velocity UT so that
the time for acceleration is negligible.
at the sampling point be C at time t after the start of settling. At time t all those particles travelling faster
than h=t will have fallen below the sampling point. The sample at time t will therefore consist only of
particles travelling a velocity h=t.
Since C0 is representative of the suspension density for the whole population, then C represents
the suspension density for all particles which travel at a velocity h=t, and so C=C 0 is the mass fraction of
Particles smaller than x will travel slower than h=t and will still be in suspension at the sampling
point. Corresponding values of C=C 0 and x therefore give us the cumulative mass distribution. (Rhodes,
2008)
where
is the voidage or volume fraction occupied by the fluid. The effective viscosity of the suspension
The drag coefficient for a single particle in the Stokes law region was:
Substituting the effective viscosity and average density for the suspension, Stokes law becomes:
Where
and
Under terminal velocity conditions for a particle falling under gravity in a suspension, the force balance,
drag force
becomes
Stokes Law
Stokes law applies in Stokes law region with C D=24/Rep (drag coefficient), the single particle
terminal velocity is:
Where Qf and Qp are the respective volume flowrates of the fluid and particles which are assumed
constantly flowing within a vessel cross-sectional area A. Under isotropic conditions the flow areas
occupied by the fluid and particles are:
BATCH SETTLING
Batch settling involves no net flow through the vessel. The relationship of the terminal velocity of
the particle (UT) to its actual velocity (UP) and expressed as a volumetric solids settling flux (Ups) was
given as:
This was derived from the general relationship in the experiment results of Richardson and Zaki (1954)
where n is 4.65 for Rep<0.3 (under
suspension) for convenience. The figure below shows the interface between a suspension of
concentration C1 with particles settling at velocity Up1 and a suspension of concentration C2 with particles
settling at velocity Up2. (Rhodes, 2008)
With this, the interface falling velocity (Uint) can be expressed as:
Where UpC is also the particle volumetric flux (Ups). On a flux plot (a plot of Ups versus concentration)
a) The gradient of the curve at concentration C is the velocity of a layer of suspension of this
concentration.
b) The slope of a chord joining two points at concentrations C1 and C2 is the velocity of a discontinuity or
interface between suspensions of these concentrations.
Determination of interface and layer velocities from a batch flux plot (Rhodes, 2008)
Relationship Between the Height-Time Curve and the Flux Plot
By the analysis of a simple batch settling test we can obtain a height-time curve. And from that we
can derive a flux plot.
Referring to the curve we have the velocity of interface as the slope of the curve at time t which is also
equal to the velocity of the particles at the interface relative to the vessel wall (Up).
And for the relation of the suspension and planes or waves of higher concentration:
CONTINUOUS SETTLING
For a real thickener shown below:
Where: F, L, V are volume flows and CF, CL, and CV are concentrations. CT and CB are the
mean concentrations of bottom and top sections respectively.
PROBLEMS
1. A suspension in water of uniformly sized spheres of diameter 100 mm and density 1200 kg=m3
has a solids volume fraction of 0.2. The suspension settles to a bed of solids volume fraction 0.5.
(For water, density is 1000 kg=m3 and viscosity is 0.001 Pa s.) The single particle terminal
velocity of the spheres in water may be taken as 1:1mm=s.
Calculate:
(a) the velocity at which the clear water/suspension interface settles;
(b) the velocity at which the sediment/suspension interface rises.
3. A suspension in water of uniformly sized spheres of diameter 90 mm and density 1100 kg=m3
has a solids volume fraction of 0.2. The suspension settles to a bed of solids volume fraction 0.5.
(For water, density is 1000 kg=m3 and viscosity is 0:001 Pa s.) The single particle terminal
velocity of the spheres in water may be taken as 0:44mm=s.
Calculate:
(a) the velocity at which the clear water=suspension interface settles;
(b) the velocity at which the sediment=suspension interface rises.
4. The batch and continuous flux plots supplied in Figure below are for a thickener of area 200m2
handling a feed rate of 0:04m3=s and an underflow rate of 0:025m3=s.
(a) Using these plots, graphically determine the critical or limiting feed concentration for this thickener.
(b) Given that if the feed concentration is 0:18m3=m3, determine the solids concentrations in the
overflow, underflow, in the regions above and below the feed well.
(c) Under the same flow rate conditions in the same thickener, the feed concentration increases to 0.24.
Estimate the new solids concentration in the overflow and the underflow once steady state has been
reached.
Calculate:
(a) the velocity at which the clear water=suspension interface settles;
(b) the velocity at which the sediment/suspension interface rises.
6. (a)Using the batch flux plot data given in Table below, graphically determine the limiting feed
concentration for a thickener of area 300m 3 handling a feed rate of 0.03m 3/s and with an
underflow rate of 0.015m3/s. Determine the underflow concentration and overflow concentration
under these conditions. Sketch a possible concentration profile in the thickener clearly indicating
the positions of the overflow launder, the feed well and the point of underflow withdrawal (neglect
the conical base of the thickener).
(b) Under the same flow conditions as above, the concentration in the feed increases to 110% of
the limiting value. Estimate the solids concentration in the overflow, in the underflow, in the
section of the thickener above the feed well and in the section below the feed well.
7. Consider the batch flux plot shown in below. Given that the final sediment concentration is 0.36
volume fraction:
(a) determine the range of initial suspension concentration over which a variable concentration zone is
formed under batch settling conditions;
(b) calculate and sketch the concentration profile after 40 min of the batch settling test with an initial
suspension concentration of 0.08 and an initial height of 100 cm;
(c) estimate the height of the final sediment and the time at which the test is complete.
8. Use the batch flux plot below to answer the following questions. (Note that the sediment concentration
is 0.44 volume fraction.)
(a) Determine the range of initial suspension concentration over which a variable concentration zone is
formed under batch settling conditions.
(b) For a batch settling test using a suspension with an initial concentration 0.18 volume fraction and initial
height 50 cm, determine the settling velocity of the interface between clear liquid and suspension of
concentration 0.18 volume fraction.
(c) Determine the position of this interface 20 min after the start of this test.
(d) Produce a sketch showing the concentration zones in the settling test 20 min after the start of this test.
SOLVED PROBLEMS
1
A heighttime curve for the sedimentation of a suspension, of initial suspension concentration 0.1,
a
b
c
vessel;
The final sedimentation concentration.
Given:
Reqd:
a
b
c
The velocity of the interface between clear liquid and suspension of concentration 0.1;
The velocity of the interface between clear liquid and a suspension of concentration 0.175;
The velocity at which a layer of concentration 0.175 propagates upwards from the base of the
vessel;
The final sedimentation concentration.
Soln:
Since the initial suspension concentration is 0.1, the velocity required in this question is the
velocity of the AB interface. This is given by the slope of the straight portion of the heighttime
curve.
We must first find the point on the curve corresponding to the point at which a suspension of
concentration 0.175 interfaces with the clear suspension.
curve corresponding to the time at which a suspension of concentration 0.175 interfaces with the
clear suspension (Figure 3W1.2). The coordinates of this point are t=26 s, h=15 cm. The velocity
of this interface is the slope of the curve at this point:
From the consideration above, after 26 s the layer of concentration 0.175 has just reached the
clear liquid interface and has travelled a distance of 15 cm from the base of the vessel in this
time.
For the concentration of the sediment, the value of h1 corresponding to the final sediment (h1s) is
found by drawing a tangent to the part of the curve corresponding to the final sediment and
projecting it to the h axis. In this case h1S=10 cm:
A suspension in water of uniformly sized sphere (diameter 150 m, density 1140 kg/m 3) has a
solids concentration of 25% by volume. The suspension settles to a bed of solids concentration of
a
b
Given:
uniformly sized sphere whose diameter is 150 m and with a density of 1140 kg/m 3
solids concentration of 25% by volume
a bed of solids concentration of 55% by volume
Reqd:
a
b
UpB;
Uint,BS
Soln:
a
Since CA=0,
UpB is the hindered settling velocity of particles relative to the vessel wall in batch settling
Assuming Stokes law applies, then n=4.65 and the single particle terminal velocity is
To check that the assumption of Stokes law is valid, we calculate the single particle Reynolds number:
which is less than the limiting value for Stokes law (0.3) and so the assumption is valid.
The voidage of the initial suspension, B = 1-CB = 0.75
The velocity of the interface between initial suspension (B) and sediment (S) is:
With CB = 0.25 and CS = 0.55 and since the velocity of the sediment, UpS is zero, we have:
And from part (a), we know that UpB = 0.45mm/s, and so Uint,BS = -0.375mm/s.
The negative sign signifies that the interface is moving upwards. So, the interface between initial
suspension and sediment is moving upwards at a velocity of 0.375mm/s. Ans: a) 0.45; b) -0.375
REFERENCES:
Brown, George G., et al. Unit Operations. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1971.
Foust, Alan S., et al. Principles of Unit Operations. 2nd ed. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.,
1980.
Geankoplis, C.J. Principles of Transport Processes and Separation Processes. 4th edition. New