Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O
A B S T R A C T
Article history:
Received 9 May 2015
Received in revised form 17 June 2015
Accepted 19 June 2015
Available online 29 June 2015
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the correlation between chronological age and the degree of
third molar mineralization by Demirjians developmental stages (Demirjian et al., 1973) using
panoramic radiography. From a total of 11.396 digital panoramic radiographs of patients from three oral
radiology private clinics from the northeast region of Brazil, obtained from January to June 2009, 2097
radiographic images from patients aged between 6 and 22 years were selected. The images were
analyzed individually by two obsevers using a 21-inch computer screen and Windows Picture and Fax
Viewer. Reliability was achieved by intra- and interobserver evaluation, using the Kappa test.
Chronological age, calcication stage, gender and third molar were interrelated using a multiple linear
regression model, considering age as a response variable. There was reliability with Demirjian et al.s
developmental stage assesment, displaying a signicant relationship between mineralization stages and
patients age (P < 0.05). There was no signicant difference between the average age and the calcication
stage taking gender and localization of the third molar into consideration. It is possible to estimate
chronological age based on Demirjians stage of a third molar, regardless of gender and location.
2015 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Age estimation by Teeth
Panoramic radiography
Third molar
1. Introduction
Forensic odontology has reliably been using third molar
mineralization to estimate chronological age as an auxiliary
parameter in the identication of corpses and human remains.
Furthermore, this process can be used as an additional tool to
distinguish between young people and adults for criminal purposes
[13]. Radiographic images are frequently used in the age estimation
process as an essential tool in human identication in forensics [4].
Teeth have specic characteristics consistent with the many
phases of human development [5]. Because they go through
different morphological stages, changes in mineralization of dental
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: caiorodriguesmd@gmail.com, caiorodriguesmd@icloud.com
(C.B.R.B. Soares).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.forsciint.2015.06.022
0379-0738/ 2015 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
14
15
Table 1
Kappa test conducted for the evaluation of intra- and interobserver agreement.
Teeth
Evaluators
18 (n = 2097)
28 (n = 2.097)
38 (n = 2097)
48 (n = 2097)
Kappa
Kappa
Kappa
Kappa
Intraobserver
1
2
0.75
0.82
67
59
0.70
0.82
71
60
0.80
0.75
61
66
0.77
0.85
64
55
Interobserver
0.73
0.065
0.70
0.071
0.78
0.064
0.83
0.058
Table 2
Results of adjustments using multiple linear regression models.
Arcade
Age (years)
Coefcient
Standard error
P valuea
Stage
Gender
Gender stage
Constant
1.13
0.24
0.04
9.73
0.04
0.25
0.05
0.18
<0.001
0.335
0.465
<0.001
1.061.20
0.25 to 0.73
0.06 to 0.13
9.3910.08
Stage
Gender
Gender stage
Constant
1.14
0.23
0.046
9.59
0.04
0.26
0.05
0.18
<0.001
0.363
0.378
0.000
1.071.21
0.27 to 0.74
0.06 to 0.15
9.239.56
Stage
Gender
Gender stage
Constant
1.12
0.04
0.10
9.87
0.04
0.25
0.05
0.18
<0.001
0.860
0.057
<0.001
1.051.19
0.44 to 0.53
0.003 to 0.20
9.5210.22
Stage
Gender
Gender stage
Constant
1.12
0.10
0.10
9.87
0.04
0.25
0.05
0.18
<0.001
0.694
0.064
0.000
1.051.19
0.37 to 0.58
0.01 to 0.19
9.5210.22
Student t test.
Table 3
Estimated average age and the respective 95% condence interval according to
gender and Demirjian stage in the upper arcade.
Table 4
Estimated average age and the respective 95% condence interval according to
gender and Demirjian stage in the lower arcade.
4. Discussion
Quadrant
Demirjian
stage
Gender
Quadrant
Demirjian
stage
Female
Male
Gender
Female
Male
Average
95% CI*
Average
95% CI**
Average
95% CI
Average
95% CI**
Upper right
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
9.6
10.8
11.9
13.1
14.2
15.4
16.5
17.7
9.49.9
10.611.0
11.712.1
12.913.3
14.114.4
15.215.5
16.416.7
17.517.9
10.1
11.2
12.3
13.5
14.6
15.8
16.9
18.1
9.810.3
11.011.4
12.212.5
13.313.7
14.514.8
15.715.9
16.817.1
17.918.3
Lower right
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
9.7
10.8
12.0
13.2
14.3
15.5
16.7
17.8
9.49.9
10.611.1
11.812.2
13.013.3
14.214.5
15.315.7
16.516.8
17.618.0
10.2
11.3
12.5
13.7
14.8
16.0
17.2
18.3
9.910.4
11.111.6
12.312.7
13.513.8
14.715.0
15.916.2
17.017.3
18.218.5
Upper left
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
9.5
10.7
11.8
13.0
14.1
15.3
16.5
17.6
9.29.8
10.410.9
11.612.0
12.813.2
14.014.3
15.215.5
16.316.6
17.417.8
9.9
11.1
12.3
13.4
14.6
15.7
16.9
18.1
9.710.2
10.911.3
12.112.4
13.313.6
14.414.7
15.615.9
16.817.1
17.918.3
Lower left
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
9.7
10.8
12.0
13.2
14.3
15.5
16.7
17.9
9.49.9
10.611.1
11.812.2
13.013.3
14.214.5
15.415.7
16.516.9
17.618.1
10.1
11.3
12.5
13.6
14.8
16.0
17.2
18.3
9.910.4
11.111.5
12.312.7
13.513.8
14.714.9
15.816.1
17.017.3
18.118.5
*
Minimum-maximum age limit in years with condence interval of 95% for
males.
**
Minimum-maximum age limit in years with condence interval of 95% for
females.
*
Minimum-maximum age limit in years with condence interval of 95% for
males.
**
Minimum-maximum age limit in years with condence interval of 95% for
females.
16
25
Age (years)
20
15
10
5
A
D
E
Demirjian stage
Quadrant 1
Quadrant 3
Quadrant 2
Quadrant 4
Fig. 2. Correlation between Demirjian stage (x axis) and chronological age (y axis),
according to the quadrant where the third molar is located.
25
20
15
10
5
A
Demirjian stage
Male
Female
Fig. 3. Correlation between the Demirjian stage (x axis) and chronological age (y
axis) according to the patients gender.
5. Conclusion
There is reliability in Demirjian et al. [8] developmental stages
for the Brazilian population. Estimation of patients age according
to the mineralization stages of third molars is possible. There is no
difference between the average age and the calcication stage of
third molars from different locations and in both genders,
therefore it is possible to determine chronological age by the
development stage of just one third molar. For correct use of this
method in the Brazilian population, correction factors, such as
those presented in this study (regression equation), must be
applied.
References
[1] K.S. Dhanjal, M.K. Bhardwaj, H.M. Liversidge, Reproducibility of radiographic
stage assessment of third molars, Forensic Sci. Int. 159 (2009) S74S77.
17
[23] F.T. de Oliveira, A.L. Capelozza, J.R. Lauris, I.R. de Bullen, Mineralization of
mandibular third molars can estimate chronological ageBrazilian indices, Forensic Sci. Int. 219 (2012) 147150.
[24] E.R. Ferreira Junior, L.A.M. Santos-Pinto, R. Santos-Pinto, Estagio de mineralizacao dental: 1 Analise comparativa entre os sexos, Rev. Odontol. 22 (1993)
303313.
[25] W. Costa, Cronologia de mineralizacao do primeiro molar inferior permanente e
sua relacao com a idade cronologica em criancas da regiao de Belem-Para.
Dissertacao (Mestrado em Radiologia Odontologica), Faculdade de Odontologia
de Piracicaba - FOP, Piracicaba, 1999.
[26] R.A. Nicodemo, L.C. Moraes, F.E. Medici, Tabela cronologica da mineralizacao dos
dentes permanentes entre brasileiros, Rev Fac Odental Sao Jose Compos 3 (1974)
5556.
[27] J.B.S. Nascimento Neto, Estudo da calcicacao dentaria em criancas da regiao
metropolitana do Recife., Tese (doutorado em Radiologia Odontologica), Faculdade de Odontologia de Piracicaba, Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Piracicaba, 2005.
[28] S.R.P. Silva, P.R.A. Nouer, I.U. Garbui, S.A. Ramalho, Denicao da epoca para incio
do tratamento ortodontico (The time for the beginning of orthodontic treatment),
Rev. Gaucha Odontol. 53 (2005) 273276.
[29] B. Rai, J. Kaur, H. Jafarzadeh, Dental age estimation from the developmental stage
of the third molars in Iranian population, J. Forensic Leg. Med. 17 (2010) 309311.
[30] G. Li, J. Ren, S. Zhao, Y. Liu, N. Li, W. Wu, S. Yuan, H. Wang, Dental age estimation
from the developmental stage of the third molars in western Chinese population,
Forensic Sci. Int. 219 (2012) 158164.
[31] Y.H. Jung, B.H. Cho, Radiographic evaluation of third molar development in 6- to
24-year-olds, Imaging Sci. Dent. 44 (2014) 185191.
[32] A.M.M. de Araujo, M.L.A. Pontual, K.P. Franca, R.V. Beltrao, A.A. Pontual, Association between mineralization of third molars and chronological age in a Brazilian
sample, Rev. Odonto Cienc 25 (2010) 391394.
[33] K. Cantekin, A.E. Sekerci, S.K. Buyuk, Dental computed tomographic imaging as
age estimation: morphological analysis of the third molar of a group of Turkish
population, Am. J. Forensic Med. Pathol. 34 (2013) 357362.
[34] J. Costa, J. Montero, S. Serrano, A. Albaladejo, A. Lopez-Valverde, I. Bica, Accuracy
in the legal age estimation according to the third molars mineralization among
Mexicans and Columbians, Aten. Primaria 46 (Suppl. 5) (2014) 165175.
[35] B. Rai, J. Kaur, H. Jafarzadeh, Dental age estimation from the developmental stage
of the third molars in Iranian population, J. Forensic Leg Med. 17 (August (6))
(2010) 309311.
[36] L. Ciapparelli, The chronology of dental development and age assessment, in: D.H.
Clark (Ed.), Practical Forensic Odontology, Wright Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 1992, pp. 2242.
[37] K.M.K. Masthan, Age and Sex. Textbook of Forensic Odontology, Jaypee Brothers
Medical Publishers, New Delhi, 2009, pp. 5965.
[39] T.T. Lopez, C.P. Arruda, M. Rocha, A.S. Rosin, E. Michel-Crosato, M.G. Biazevic,
Estimating ages by third molars: stages of development in Brazilian young adults,
J. Forensic Leg. Med. 20 (2013) 412418.
[40] Y. Sisman, T. Uysal, F. Yagmur, S.I. Ramoglu, Third-molar development in relation
to chronologic age in Turkish children and young adults, Angle Orthodontist 77
(2007) 10401045.
[41] M.V. Bolanos, H. Moussa, M.C. Manrique, M.J. Bolanos, Radiographic evaluation of
third molar development in Spanish children and young people, Forensic Sci. Int.
133 (2003) 212219.
[42] A. Schmeling, W. Reisinger, G. Geserick, A. Olze, Age estimation of unaccompanied
minors. Part I. General considerations, Forensic Sci Int. 159 (May (Suppl. 1))
(2006) S61S64.