Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cover photographs: (L) Structure S04-N7 Bowstring Bridge during construction, positioned on top of a reinforced earth approach
embankment prior to bridge slide to final position. (R) Removal of temporary excavation support after staged excavation and
replacement of soft ground at Bishop ODonnell-Seamus Quirke Road in Galway.
SYNOPSIS
By its nature, infrastructure construction in an urban context, particularly widening of an existing highway, can require significant
phasing and sequencing of temporary works in order to deliver the permanent solution within the constrained environment. Byrne
Looby Partners have worked on a variety of road schemes in Ireland including Phase I and II of the M50 Improvement Project and
Bishop ODonnell - Seamus Quirke Road, Galway. A variety of ground conditions were encountered on these schemes, in
conjunction with constraints such as traffic management, land acquisition, programme and restrictions imposed from adjacent
infrastructure resulted in the development of a number of temporary works systems in order to permit construction of the permanent
works solution.
On the M50 upgrade project, soil nailing was adopted as the temporary works solution at several slope locations permitting
excavations for the construction of new bridges and temporary excavations adjacent to live highways and the Royal Canal in the
vicinity of the improved M3 Interchange. At other locations, temporary excavations relied upon the undrained shear strength of the
Dublin glacial tills. Elsewhere the construction works relied upon temporary dewatering measures to facilitate the construction of the
permanent works.
Access to Monastery Road from the N7 required a new large bowstring arch bridge structure to be constructed. Due to extremely
limited working space the new bridge had to be launched across the N7 into position from a temporary reinforced soil approach
embankment. The bridge slide loading travelled across the reinforced soil earthworks imposing large transient loads as the bridge
structure was manoeuvred into place. A soil-structure interaction model was developed using PLAXIS to understand the influence of
the temporary loads on the reinforced soil / earth and predict the resulting ground movements and establish movement trigger levels.
During the bridge slide, movements were monitored and compared to the predicted displacements.
At Bishop ODonnell - Seamus Quirke Road in Galway excavation and replacement of soft ground deposits was required in a phased
solution adjacent live traffic. Temporary support was achieved using steel sheet piles which relied upon the support from the adjacent
filled / in situ ground sections. Complete excavation and replacement of up to 6.5m of soft ground was achieved.
1
INTRODUCTION
THE ROLE OF TEMPORARY
HIGHWAY UPGRADE SCHEMES
WORKS
IN
2.
reinforcement.
Retaining structures
1.
Interaction
2.
with
existing
structures
3.
4.
or
groundwater
on
CASE STUDY 1
M50 UPGRADE PPP CONTRACT 2, S17-N3
BRIDGE PIER 1 TEMPORARY CUT SLOPE AND
TEMPORARY SOIL NAILING
The 950m upgrade of the M50 motorway was
completed in September 2010 and brought about
significant improvements to the traffic condition around
the greater Dublin area. Contract 2 was delivered
through the M50 Upgrade PPP contract for the finance,
design, construction and maintenance of the motorway.
The NRA awarded the PPP contract to M50 Concession
Limited, a consortium currently comprising Spanish
infrastructure developers Global Via Inversiones, S.A.
(GVI), Sacyr Vallehermoso, S.A. and Irish firm P.J.
Hegarty & Sons Limited. The Contractor, M50 D&C
Limited, comprised FCC Construccin Ireland Limited,
Sacyr Ireland Limited and P.J. Hegarty & Sons Limited.
Atkins Consultant Engineers and Eptisa designed the
work on behalf of the Contractor, with Byrne Looby
Partners acting as the Designers Sub-consultant.
Roughan ODonovan Limited supervised the contract
on behalf of the NRA.
The works delivered as part of Contract 2 comprised the
following:
eastern extent.
For the majority of the pier base excavation, where the
formation level was proposed at 50.1m OD (plus an
allowance for blinding etc.), the proposed pier base
formation was above the level of the SAND and
GRAVEL stratum and groundwater level. In these
areas, 45 slopes, assuming undrained behaviour of the
Boulder Clay, were proposed.
For the remaining area of the pier base excavation,
where formation level was proposed at 48.8mOD, the
base of the excavation lay both below groundwater
level and the interface of the SAND and GRAVEL
strata. In this area, a temporary dewatering scheme was
required in order to ensure a dry excavation and to
maintain the stability of the 45 slopes over the duration
of the temporary works. A photograph of the temporary
slope is presented in Figure 4.
Furthermore, in the south-western corner of the
temporary excavation, over a length of 26.8m, there
was insufficient space between the excavation outline
CASE STUDY 2
M50
UPGRADE
CONTRACT
1,
S04-N7
MONASTERY ROAD BOWSTRING BRIDGE SLIDE
TEMPORARY
REINFORCED
EARTH
EMBANKMENT
The M50 Upgrade Contract 1 was delivered through a
Design & Build (D&B) contract by SIAC-Ferrovial
M50 Joint Venture, a partnership between SIAC
Construction Ltd. and the Spanish Construction
Company Ferrovial Agromn S.A. The Contractors
designer was a consulting engineering consortium of
Hyder Consulting Ltd, PH McCarthy & Partners and
Grontmij. Arup Consulting Engineers supervised the
contract on behalf of South Dublin County Council and
the NRA.
The works delivered under Contract 1 comprised the
following:
New
free-flowing
interchanges
were
constructed at Junction 7, (N4, Liffey Valley
Interchange) and Junction 9 (N7 Red Cow
Interchange) together with a significant
upgrade of Junction 10 (Ballymount).
GROUND CONDITIONS
4,267kN
589kN
30kN/m2 applied
implemented.
Over the duration of the bridge slide, on the Hexlok
wall forming the southern face of the south approach
embankment, the range of observed lateral movement
CASE STUDY 3
BISHOP ODONNELLSEAMUS QUIRKE ROAD
WIDENING SCHEME TEMPORARY SUPPORT
FOR SOFT GROUND EXCAVATE AND REPLACE
Bishop ODonnell Road / Seamus Quirke Road is part
of regional route R338, which links the R336 and the
Western Distributor Road the main approach roads to
Galway from the suburban and coastal areas west of the
city and the N6 across the Quincentenial Bridge. The
road passes through the largely residential areas of
Rahoon, Shantalla and Westside, which have grown
significantly in recent years. The area also supports
shopping, commercial and social services and sporting
facilities, all of which access Seamus Quirke Road
directly or indirectly.
In accordance with the Galway County Borough
Development Plan 1999, the following provisions were
set out as part of the Seamus Quirke Road Widening
Scheme:
GROUND CONDITIONS
The area at the Bishop ODonnell Road-Rahoon Road
Junction had been characterised by substantial depths of
soft ground. Substantial historical settlements have been
noted in the area as shown in Figure 13. As a result of
this, the area was investigated with geophysics using
MASW and seismic refraction methods. The
interpretation (refer Figure 14) indicated that, locally,
substantial deposits of overburden material were
prevalent in depths of between 6-7m. These geological
features were identified as ancient infilled river
channels.
The overburden material itself comprised up to 2m of
made ground generally composed of clayey gravelly
SAND with many cobbles and boulders and road
construction materials. This overlay a relatively thin
layer of very soft organic fibrous PEAT which in turn
overlay 3-4m of very soft creamy / grey shelly MARL.
The depth at which the CPT probe refused correlated
well with the interpreted bedrock level of the
geophysics. Bedrock in this area was proven to
comprise very strong pink / white fine-grained
GRANDIORITE.
The prevalence of MARL across the area is not
uncommon in Galway. The deposit is characteristic of a
lake or water-filled channel depositional environment
known as an aquatic / limnic environment. Its
distinctive colour is derived from the nature of the
depositional waters which were highly basic (containing
calcium and magnesium).
cu =
qC v
NK
where:
N K = 13 +
5 .5
I P (2)
50
CURRENT BEST
GEOTECHNICAL
TEMPORARY
DISCUSSION
PRACTICE IN
DESIGN
OF
WORKS
-
10
The
foundation
soils
beneath
strengthened
11
CONCLUDING REMARKS
Upgrade
of
existing
highway
networks
present
adopted
in
the
12
REFERENCES
Bowles, J.E. (1997) Foundation Analysis and Design
Fifth Edition. McGraw-Hill
BS8006:1995 Code of Practice for Strengthened /
Reinforced Soils
BS8006-1:2011 Code of Practice for Strengthened /
Reinforced Soils and Other Fills British Standards
Institute
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The authors would like to acknowledge M50 D&C,
Siac-Ferrovial and Coffey Construction Ltd. for their
kind permission to publish the data contained within the
case studies of this paper. The views expressed in this
paper are the sole views of the authors and do not
represent the views of any third parties.
The authors gratefully acknowledge the assistance and
support given by many colleagues at Byrne Looby
Partners both during the projects and in the production
of this paper.
13
Figure 1 - Location plan for S17-N3 Bridge Pier 1 adjacent to the Royal Canal
14
STRATUM
MADE GROUND/BOULDER CLAY
(Drained Behaviour)
MADE GROUND/BOULDER CLAY
(Undrained Behaviour)
(kN/m3)
()
20
34
c/cu
Avg D10
(kN/m2) (mm)
k
(m/s)
0
0.02
4 x 10-6
20
cu = 75
20
35
0.2
4 x 10-4
17
cu = 10
1 x 10-8
LIMESTONE
21
35
500
1 x 10-7
15
Figure 5 - Section through proposed temporary soil nailed slope adjacent to the Royal Canal
16
Figure 6 - Elevation on proposed temporary soil nailed slope adjacent to the Royal Canal
Figure 7 - Photograph of as-constructed soil nail stabilised steepened embankment prior to casting of
Pier 1 base
17
M1 Lateral
0.008
M1 Vertical
0.007
M3 Lateral
0.006
M3 Vertical
0.005
Amber Trigger Limit
M5 Lateral
0.004
M5 Vertical
Movement (m)
0.003
0.002
0.001
0.000
-0.001
-0.002
-0.003
-0.004
Amber Trigger Limit
-0.005
-0.006
-0.007
-0.008
-0.009
-0.010
13/08/09
14/08/09
15/08/09
16/08/09
17/08/09
18/08/09
19/08/09
20/08/09
21/08/09
22/08/09
23/08/09
24/08/09
25/08/09
26/08/09
27/08/09
28/08/09
Date
Upper Design
Level - P1
52
Lower Design
Level - P1
Upper Design
Level - P2
Lower Design
Level - P2
Piezometer 1
51
Recovery from
instrument installation
Piezometer 2
P1 pumping trial
P1 recovery after
pumping trial
50
49
25/07/2009
01/08/2009
08/08/2009
15/08/2009
22/08/2009
29/08/2009
Date
18
19
20
21
R338 Seamus
Quirke Road
R338 Bishop
ODonnell Road
Figure 12 - Location map showing the position of Bishop ODonnell Road-Rahoon Road Junction
22
Observed wall
settlement / distortion
Figure 13 - Settlement of wall in the vicinity of Bishop O'Donnell Road-Rahoon Road Junction prior to improvement works
23
24
Figure 15 - Cone penetration results for the area around Bishop O'Donnell Road-Rahoon Road Junction
25
Figure 16 - Temporary sheet pile solution for excavate-and-replace at Bishop O'Donnell Road-Rahoon Road Junction
26
Figure 17 - Output from FREW (SLS) for temporary sheet pile wall
27