You are on page 1of 92

ISSN 1018-5593

European Commission

ber information
REFERENCE MATERIALS

THE CERTIFICATION OF THE TOTAL CONTENTS


(MASS FRACTIONS) OF Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb
AND Zn AND THE AQUA REGIA SOLUBLE CONTENTS
(MASS FRACTIONS) OF Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni,
Pb AND Zn IN A SEWAGE SLUDGE
FROM INDUSTRIAL ORIGIN
CRM 146 R

Report
EUR 16892 EN

European Commission

ber information
REFERENCE MATERIALS

THE CERTIFICATION OF THE TOTAL CONTENTS


(MASS FRACTIONS) OF Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb
AND Zn AND THE AQUA REGIA SOLUBLE CONTENTS
(MASS FRACTIONS) OF Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni,
Pb AND Zn IN A SEWAGE SLUDGE
FROM INDUSTRIAL ORIGIN
CRM 146 R
Ph. QUEVAUVILLER('), H. MUNTAU(2), U. FORTUNATI^), K. VERCOUTEREf)
(') European Commission
Standards, Measurements and Testing Programme
B-Brussels
Belgium
(2) Joint Research Centre
European Commission
l-lspra
Italy
(3) Studio di Ingeneria Ambientale
l-Milan
Italy
C) Laboratory for Analytical Chemistry
University of Gent
B-Gent
Belgium
Directorate-General
Science, Research and Development

1996

EUR 16892 EN

EUROPEAN COMMISSION

LEGAL NOTICE
Neither the European Commission nor any person acting on
behalf of the Commission is responsible for the use which might be made of the
following information

Cataloguing data can be found at the end of this publication

Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, 1995


ISBN 92-827-7415-5
ECSC-EC-EAEC, Brussels Luxembourg, 1996.
Printed in Belgium

GLOSSARY OF ABBREVIATIONS
Throughout the report (including the annexes) the following abbreviations are used:
AR

Aqua regia soluble fraction

CV

Coefficient of variation

C VAAS

Cold vapour atomic absorption spectrometry

DPASV

Differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry

DPCSV

Differential pulse cathodic stripping voltammetry

EDXRF

Energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometry

ET AAS

Electrothermal atomic absorption spectrometry

FAAS

Flame atomic absorption spectrometry

ICPAES

Inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry

ICPMS

Inductively coupled plasma atomic mass spectrometry

ID ICPMS

Isotope dilution inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

IDMS

Isotope dilution mass spectrometry

INAA

Instrumental neutron activation analysis

MIBK

Methyl isobutylketone

NaDDTC

Sodium diethyldithiocarbamate

PTFE

Polytetrafluoroethylene

RNAA

Radiochemical neutron activation analysis

CONTENTS
Page
1.

Introduction

2.

Participating laboratories

3.

Preparation of the material

Homogeneity study

5.

Stability study

6.

Aqua regia soluble contents

10

7.

Analytical methods

11

8.

Technical and statistical discussion

9.

Certified values

54

10.

Informative values

55

11.

Instructions for users

57

ANNEX I

Tables of individual results and graphical presentations

61

1.

INTRODUCTION

The certified reference material described in this report is intended to replace the BCR CRM 146
sewage sludge from industrial origin (referred to as "original sludge CRM" in this report) of
which, due to its success in environmental and pollution control, the present supply is exhausted.
In view of the strong demand the Commission has decided to replace it. This sludge reference
material belongs to a set of 3 materials: BCR CRM 144 R sewage sludge from domestic origin,
BCR CRM 145 R sewage sludge from mixed origin and BCR 146 R sewage sludge from mainly
industrial origin, covering different concentrations of trace elements and different matrices.
These materials are intended mainly for the verification of accuracy in trace element
determinations of nutrititional or environmental importance in soils or other materials with
similar matrices.

Care was taken to find a material with a composition close to that of the original sludge CRM
but taking into account the evolution during the 10 years that separate their collection.

The

content of some trace elements is lower in the present material as a consequence of measures
taken to minimise environmental pollution by local and national authorities. The material will
therefore be more relevant to actual situations encountered in the laboratories.
As the information on the aqua regia soluble content of some elements was a very useful tool
for the users of the exhausted reference material, certification of this quantity was also decided
upon. The determination of this parameter is often requested to estimate the impact of sewage
sludge amending soils.

2.

PARTICIPATING LABORATORIES

2.1.

Preparation
European Commission, JRC-Environment Institute, Ispra

2.2.

Homogeneity study
GSF Forschungszentrum fr Umwelt und Gesundheit, Oberschleiheim

2.3.

DE

Stability study
ECN Energieonderzoekcentrum Nederland, Petten

2.4.

IT

NL

Analyses
Agricultural Research Centre of Finland, Jokionen

SF

Agriculture & Food Development Authority, Wexford

IE

Service Central d'Analyse, CNRS, Vernaison

FR

ECN Energieonderzoekcentrum Nederland, Petten

NL

Ecole Europenne des Hautes Etudes des Industries Chimiques,


Strasbourg, Lab. de Chimie Analytique

FR

GSF Forschungszentrum fr Umwelt und Gesundheit, Oberschleiheim

DE

INTRA, Station d'Agronomie, Villenave d'Ornon

FR

Institute for Soil Fertility, Haren

NL

Institut fr Analytische Chemie, Technische Universitt Wien

AT

IFA, Tulln

AT

Laboratorium voor Analytische Scheikunde, INW, Universiteit Gent

BE

Ris National Laboratory, Roskilde

DK

Universidad de Barcelona, Dept. de Qumica Analtica

ES

Universit di Pavia, Centro de Chimica Nuclearia

IT

3.

PREPARATION OF THE MATERIAL

A sewage sludge with an interesting high content of metals under regulation was collected in
Maison Lafitte in the region of Paris, (France). A preliminary analysis of the sludge revealed
that the heavy metal concentrations are lower than in the original sludge CRM thus reflecting
the present waste water conditions as a consequence of the pollution measures taken. The matrix
composition meets quite well that of the original sludge CRM considering the natural variability
of sludges.

A comparison of the composition of the 2 sludges is given in table 3.1; the

determinations of major components were performed by X-ray fluorescence spectrometry.


Table 3.1:

Comparison of the composition (expressed as mass fraction (g/kg) of the original


sludge CRM 146 with the sludge intended for replacement, BCR CRM 146 R
Material

BCR 146
BCR 146 R

Si0 2
228.0
221.5

MgO

A1203

Ti0 2

Fe^

p2o5

33
24

90
87

29.1
41.0

26.5
19.5

59.0
76.5

5.8
7.0

250 kg of sludge containing about 50 % of solid material was collected. The sludge was air
dried in thin layers and continuously moved and mixed to avoid fungi development.

The

material was passed through a 2 mm sieve discarding the fraction > 2 mm and eliminating
extraneous particles such as stones, roots, fragments of plastic and metal. The fraction < 2 mm
was divided into 10 batches of 10 kg which all underwent gamma irradiation at a dose of 25
KGy (sufficient to sterilise the material). The batches were pooled together for further processing
which consisted of crushing with a Retsch SR3 mill with an inner 0.75 mm sieve.
crushing, the material was further sieved mechanically to obtain the fraction <

After

90 . This

material was inserted in a rigid mixing drum with out-of axis-fins. The drum was kept rotating
for 170 hours at 40 rpm until a sufficiently homogeneous material with particle size <

90 m

was obtained; the optimal homogenization time was based on previous experience with this type
of material.

The final material was bottled in 50 g portions in clean brown glass bottles closed with a plastic
insert and screw cap; the bottling procedure was carried out in a stepwise manner: twenty bottles
were filled while the drum was stationary, then the drum was operated again for 3 minutes and
20 other bottles were filled; the operation was repeated until the whole material was bottled.
4.

HOMOGENEITY STUDY

Materials such as sewage sludges and soils consist of numerous solid phases, all of them
differing with respect to their morphological, physical and chemical properties. The geometrical
shape of the particles varies from fibres of a few diameter but several 100 in length,
over thin leaf-like particles (kaolinite, mica, etc.) to isometric compact particles such as rounded
silica grains and rhombohedric calcite cleavage particles with different mass densities.
Keeping in mind that all the different phases show distinct trace element concentrations,
sometimes differing over orders of magnitude, it is likely that any segregation of particles, for
example through vibrations during transport could lead to considerable inhomogeneities with
respect to the trace elements. Re-homogenisation prior to subsampling is therefore mandatory.
For more information the reader is referred to section 11 of this report: "Instructions for users".
A homogeneity study was performed for the elements Al, , Ba, Ca, Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Fe, K,
Mg, Mn, Mo, Ni, , Pb, S, Sn, Sr, V and Zn. This includes elements intended for certification
as well as some "key elements" that are specific for the phase distribution; e.g. is associated
with the phosphate phase, while Ni and Cr are determined to control possible contamination
which might have occurred during the processing of the soil. The chosen elements also cover
a large mass fraction range (from the lower mg/kg to several g/kg).

4.1.

Method

The within and between bottle homogeneity of the elements mentioned above was studied using
simultaneous ICPAES at different levels of sample intake, i.e. 50, 100 and 250 mg. After rehomogenisation, the material was digested using pressurised wet ashing with HN0 3 in quartz
vessels for 10 h at a temperature of 170 C for the 50 and 100 mg sample intake. Aqua regia
dissolution was used for the 250 mg sample intake, following the procedure described in section
6 of this report.
The within bottle homogeneity was studied by 10 replicate determinations on the content of one
randomly selected bottle whereas the between bottle homogeneity was determined by a single
determination in each of 10 different bottles. The CV of the final detection method could be
calculated on the basis of 10 replicates of one sample digest.
4.2.

Results

The CV's within and between bottles obtained for the different sample intakes and the CV of
the final detection method are summarised in table 4 . 1 .

Table 4.1:

Results for the within-and between-bottle homogeneity of BCR CRM 146 R at 50


and 100 mg levels of intake (total element contents)
Sample
mass

Element

CV (%)
between bottles*

CV (%)
within bottles**

CV (%)
method***

50 mg

Al

Ba
Ca
Cd
Co
Cr
Cu
Fe

Mg
Mn
Mo
Ni

Pb
S
Sr
V
Zn

2.6
2.7
2.9
2.4
2.7
4.8
3.4
2.7
3.9
2.5
2.4
2.3
2.3
3.6
4.3
2.6
1.6
2.1
3.1
2.8

2.7
3.7
1.6
1.7
1.8
3.0
3.0
2.4
4.2
1.5
1.0
1.3
2.9
3.8
3.3
1.9
1.2
1.5
1.9
1.3

3.0
1.0
0.4
1.0
0.8
2.0
0.9
0.7
2.5
1.6
0.5
0.5
2.0
2.1
1.4
1.3
0.5
0.4
0.5
1.7

100 mg

Al
B
Ba
Ca
Cd
Cr
Cu
Fe
K
Mg
Mn
Mo
Ni

Pb
S
Sr
V
Zn

3.0
6.5
1.6
3.4
1.8
2.0
1.9
4.3
1.7
1.3
1.7
5.3
3.0
3.1
1.7
1.4
1.7
1.6
1.8

2.6
9.2
1.9
4.5
2.0
2.3
2.1
3.8
1.7
1.7
1.7
4.7
2.7
2.3
2.3
1.8
1.6
1.7
1.8

3.0
1.0
0.4
1.0
0.8
0.9
0.7
2.5
1.6
0.5
0.5
2.0
2.1
1.4
1.3
0.5
0.4
0.5
1.7

Table 4.1:

Results for the within-and between-bottle homogeneity of BCR CRM 146 R at


250 level of intake (aqua regia soluble element contents)
Sample
mass

Element

CV (%)
between bottles*

CV (%)
within bottles**

CV (%)
method***

250 mg

Al

Ba
Ca
Cd
Co
Cr
Cu
Fe

4.6
7.7
3.2
0.9
3.0
4.8
2.5
2.0
0.5
5.3
1.9
1.5
4.7
5.9
1.4
2.4
2.0
2.5
1.4
3.7
2.1

3.6
5.2
4.2
1.4
2.6
2.6
3.8
1.5
3.9
5.5
1.9
2.1
4.1
4.6
2.2
3.1
1.9
2.3
1.7
4.1
2.1

3.0
1.0
0.4
1.0
0.8
2.0
0.9
0.7
2.5
1.6
0.5
0.5
2.0
2.1
1.4
1.3
0.5
1.8
0.4
0.5
1.7

Mg
Mn
Mo
Ni

Pb
S
Sn
Sr
V
Zn

*
***

single determination on the content of each of 10 bottles


10 replicate determinations on the content of one bottle
10 replicates on one digest solution

An approximation of the uncertainty on the CV's, (U), was calculated using the following
formula: U = CVfr/2n. Such a way of calculation leads to a symmetric uncertainty as can be
seen in the figures. An F test was applied on the CV's and revealed no systematic differences
between within and between bottle homogeneity even for sample intakes as low as 100 mg (for
total contents). The CRM is considered to be homogeneous at a minimum of 250 mg, and of
course at 3 g level (following the DIN standard).

5.

STABILITY STUDY

The stability of the contents of some major and trace elements was tested to determine the
suitability of the chosen sludge as a candidate certified reference material.

Three series of

bottles were stored respectively at -20 C, +20 C and +40 C. The elements C, Cd, Cu, N,
Ni and Pb were determined at the beginning of the period and after 6 months. Analyses were
carried out in 6 fold.
5.1.

Methods

C and N were determined using an automatic C-N analyzer. After flash burning of 5 mg of
sample in a tin cup at 1800 to 2000 C the nitrogen oxides are reduced to nitrogen while the
carbon monoxide is oxidized to carbon dioxide.

They are separated by chromatography

(Poropax column) and are determined through thermal conductivity.


The stability of Cd, Cu, Ni and Pb was assessed with ICPAES. This method was applied after
digestion of the material in a PTFE-lined bomb at 190 C for 10 h with HN0 3 /HF/HC10 4
(5/3/0.25 ml).
5.2.

Results

Any change of results on element composition with time indicates instability, provided that a
good long-term analytical reproducibility has been achieved. At -20 C changes of any kind
proceed slowly, whereas at +40 C instability is more likely. Assuming that the samples stored
at -20 C in the dark are stable, these samples can serve as a comparator for the samples stored
at the other temperatures.
The results obtained for the stability study are given in table 5.1 as the relative variations
observed:
R, = /_20 . c
where (RJ is the ratio of the mean value of six measurements made at +20 C and +40 C
respectively, (X,), versus the mean of the determinations made at the same occasion of analysis
on samples stored at -20 C, (X.20c)

The uncertainty U t of the ratio Rt has been obtained from the coefficient of variation of each set
of measurements:
Ut = (CVt2 + CV. 20 . C 2 ) 1/2 . R,
where CV, and CV.20 c are the coefficients of variation of X, and X.20 c respectively.
In the case of ideal stability, R, should be 1.

In reality however there are some random

variations due to the uncertainty of the measurement. The value 1 is comprised between Rt U, and Rt + Ut in all cases except for Cd and for Cu and Ni at 40 C.
On the basis of these results, it was concluded that no instability could be detected.
Table 5.1:

Normalised results of the stability study of CRM 146 R after 6 months storage
at different temperatures (-20 C, +20 C and + 4 0 C).

Element

Time
(months)

+ 40 C/-20 C

+ 20 C/-20 C

Value of R,

u,

Value of R,

u,

0.997

0.007

0.989

0.010

Cd

1.060

0.058

1.099

0.038

Cu

0.991

0.012

0.987

0.010

0.992

0.011

0.993

0.011

Ni

1.016

0.024

1.029

0.026

Pb

1.021

0.048

1.014

0.047

The long term stability of this material is assumed to be very good, considering that the CRM
146 was stable over 10 years. The aqua-regia procedure dissolves all "mobile" and lithogenic
fractions which are assumed to remain constant and fairly stable over time.

6.

AQUA REGIA SOLUBLE CONTENTS

Many laboratories performing in agricultural analysis frequently determine the aqua regia soluble
fraction of certain elements instead of the total content. In many countries (D, NL, DK, F), the
determination of the aqua regia soluble part is requested by the national regulations. Therefore
it is also certified for the elements of interest.
For such certification purposes it is mandatory that the participants follow exactly the same
extraction procedure. The digestion method according to the German Norm (DIN 38414-S7)
was adopted as the common method for the certification campaign. The protocol is given below.
Weigh approximately 3 g of material in a round bottom flask. (The material should be
dried for 30 min at 105 C and, following cooling in a desiccator, weighed to the nearest
0.01 g.)
Add a little bidistilled water to obtain a slurry. Then mix with 21 ml of HCl (mass density
1.19) and 7 ml ofHN03 (mass density 1.40).
Add 10 ml of HNO3 (0.5 molli*) to the absorption vessel, connect the vessel to the reflux
condenser and place both on top of the reaction flask.
Allow to stand at room temperature for several hours (at least 12 h)
Heat until boiling and continue to boil gently under reflux for 2 h. (The condensation
zone should not rise above the lower third of the reflux condenser.)
Allow to cool slowly to room temperature.
Pass the content of the absorption vessel through the condenser tube into the reaction
vessel, rinse both with HN03 (0.5 molli*) and collect the HN03 in the reaction vessel.
Transfer the content of the reaction vessel quantitatively to a 100 ml graduated flask.
Rinse the reaction vessel with HN03 (0.5 molli*) and transfer as well. Fill the graduated
flask with bidistilled water up to the mark, close with stopper and shake.
After the undissolved content has settled, the supernatant solution shall be used for the
final determination of the elements.
If the undissolved components settle too slowly or unsatisfactorily, then centrifuge or
filter through a membrane filter with a pore size of 0.45 m after filling the graduated
flask up to the mark.
The reagents used should be of best purity. If necessary their purity should be checked
by performing a blank test. Glassware should be thoroughly cleaned before use with hot
HN03 (0.5 molli*) and then rinsed with bidistilled water. In this exercise the participants
were free in choosing of glassware for the digestion.
* 35 ml of HNO3 (mass density 1.4) diluted with bidistilled water to make 1 I.

10

The methods of final determination used were generally the same as those for the total contents.
The description of the methods and precautions to eliminate systematic errors can be found in
section 7 of this report. The tables 7.1 and 7.2 summarise the data for both total and aqua regia
determination.
7.

ANALYTICAL METHODS

Each laboratory which participated in the certification was requested to make a minimum of five
independent replicate determinations (from subsampling and weighing to the final determination).
This section summarises the main observations made in the analytical campaign and the methods
used for certification. The techniques used by the participating laboratories are summarised in
table 7.2 for both total and aqua regia determinations.
To obtain the accuracy and the reliability required for certification it is necessary to ensure that
no substantial systematic error is left undetected. This means that special attention was paid to
ascertain the accuracy of the results. To achieve this the following steps were taken :
1)

elimination of causes of systematic errors in the various steps of the analytical process.
Possible sources of error and measures taken to eliminate them were discussed in a
meeting with the participating laboratories and are shown in table 7.1. No systematic
difference between the different methods could be detected.

2)

The laboratories participating in the certification used at least the following quality
control steps:
a)

The determinations were performed with methods which were under statistical
control.

b)

Wherever possible, the performance of the method, as carried out by the


laboratory, was verified by analysing available reference materials.

11

Results of different methods as applied in different laboratories were compared for the detection
of methodological error sources. The technically accepted results (satisfying criteria 1 and 2)
are given in Annex I (tables a). No method bias was detected. As a conclusion one can say that
where the above requirements are met, the certified values are free of substantial systematic
error within the present state of the art.

12

Table 7.1:

Some possible sources of error and their elimination


Destructive methods

Analytical step

Systematic error by

Contribution

Elimination by

weighing

+ /-

calibrated balance

volumetric manipula
tion

+ /-

dilutions etc carried out with calibrated


glassware, temperature control

moisture

adsorption/desorption

+ /-

correction to dry mass according to


procedure in chapter 11

digestion/oxidation

incomplete

preparation

volatilisation

+ /-

adsorption/desorption

sample preparation/
clean u p /
preconcentration

adsorption/irreversible
precipitation
incomplete conversion

+ /-

reagent contamination
contamination by
tools/vials

contamination from lab


air

+ /-

calibration

13

participants used H F treatment with


acid digestion or alkaline fusion to
obtain complete digestion
for volatile elements e.g. Hg treatments
carried out in closed systems
acid washed containers of hard glass,
P T F E or H D P E prerinsed surfaces
pH-control and/or addition of complexing agents if necessary
excess of reagents; methods a priori
verified
reagents of appropriate purity; veri
fication with blank determinations
acid washing as appropriate; when
contents below 1 -g/g were determined:
steaming; verification with blank deter
minations
use of clean benches or clean rooms;
care in performing methods under cover
or in closed systems; verification with
blank determinations

different calibration methods were


chosen when possible: calibration
graphs, when necessary matrix mat
ched, and standard additions within the
limits of this method

Non destructive methods


Analytical step
irradiation

counting

Systematic error by

Contribution

self-shielding

Elimination by
contents are such that for the elements
investigated shielding does not occur

changes of flux

+ /-

flux monitors were added in the irradiation process

peak overlap intrinsic


irradiation; high background

+ /-

deconvolution; selection of proper


decay times; R N A A as an alternative

geometry

+ /-

calibrants and unknowns were both in


the same form e.g. solution or powder;
they were measured in identical vials at
the same distance of the detector etc

+ /-

the same remarks as for destructive


methods are valid; additional care was
given to the stability on irradiation of
the calibrant

calibration

14

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Cd

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

100

Pressurised digestion using HNO3 (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by H F (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H 3 B 0 4 (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd

ETAAS

100

As above
Calibrant: as above

ICPAES

100

As above
Calibrant: as above

I C P M S of Cd mass
111

60-80

High pressure ashing in quartz vessels with H N 0 3 (2


ml) and HC10 4 (0.3 ml) for 3 h at 280 C; treated
with H F and H N 0 3 i n Pt crucibles; residue taken up
in HCl (0.4 ml) and diluted with Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: as above

DPASV

500

Pressurised microwave digestion with H F (4 ml),


HNO3 (5 ml) and HCl (1 ml) for 30 min; addition of
H 3 B 0 4 (2 g); dilution with H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd in H N O , CO.5
m o l . l ' ) checked against Cd metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

500

Open digestion with H N 0 3 / H C 1 0 , / H F for 16 h at 20


C ; evporation to dryness at 170 C; repeated with
H F (5 ml); dissolution in HCl (10 ml)(6mol.l')
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd in HCl
checked against other calibrant solution

ETAAS

15

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Cd (ctd)

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

250

Digestion with aqua regia (1 ml) and H F (10 ml) for


12 h at 20 C; evaporation during 4 h at 100 C;
addition of aqua regia (10 ml) and heating in
microwave for 2 min at 180 W , 5 min at 600 W and
80 min at 510 W; addition of NH 2 OH.HCl (2.5 ml);
dilution with Milli-Q H 2 0 ; mixing with pentane
dione at p H 3 and extraction of Fe into CHC1 3 ;
addition of N a D D T C and extraction of Cd into
MIBK
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd in H N O ,

FAAS

180-300

Programmed dry ashing upto 450 C in Pt crucible;


followed by digestion with HF/HNOj/HClO., for 3 h
at room temperature and evaporation to dryness at
150 C; dissolution in H N 0 3 at 100 C for 15 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd in HCl

ICPMS of Cd mass
111

180-300

As above
Calibrant: as above

DPASV

1000

Addition of " 2 C d spike; digestion in PTFE lined


bomb with H N 0 3 / H F (10 ml/5 ml) for 2 d at 180
C; evaporation to dryness; further with
H N 0 3 / H C 1 0 4 (5 ml/2 ml); evaporation to dryness;
addition of HCl (10 ml)(2 mol.l' 1 ); anion exchange
procedure; elution with H N 0 3 (2 mol.l" 1 );
evaporation to dryness; addition of NH 3 buffer;
electrodeposition
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Cd
solutions; Cd metal (purity S 99.999 % ) ; natural
isotopie ratio

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Cd
masses 111, 112
and 114

13

i6

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Co

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

200

Open digestion in Pt crucibles with H F / H C 1 0 4 (10


ml/1 ml) for 3 h to dryness; residue taken up in HCl
(3 mol.l" 1 ); dilution with H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in H N O ,
checked against Co metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

80

Irradiation with thermal neutrons ( 4 x l 0 ' 3 c m ' 2 s ' ) for


5 h; decay time 2-3 weeks; transfer to un-irradiated
polyvial; counting for 4 h
Calibrant: Co metal (purity 99.98 %) in 10 % H N O ,

Gamma
spectrometry of
Co

500

Open digestion with HNCyHCIO,, / H F for 16 h at


20 C; evaporation to dryness at 170 C; repeated
with H F (5 ml); dissolution in HCl (10 ml)
(6 mol.l-')
Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in HCl
checked against other calibrant solution

ETAAS

100-150

Material pressed into pellet; irradiation with thermal


neutrons (1.8xl0' 2 cm" 2 s"') for 7 h; decay time 4
weeks; counting for 16 h
Calibrant: Co metal (purity > 99.99 %)(etched with
H N 0 3 ) in H N 0 3 ; as well as a commercial solution
of Co in H N 0 3

Gamma
spectrometry of
Co

180-300

Programmed dry ashing upto 450 C in Pt crucible;


followed by digestion with HF/HNC^/HCIO for 3 h
at room temperature and evaporation to dryness at
150 C; dissolution in H N 0 3 at 100 C for 15 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in HNO,

I C P M S of Co mass
59

200

Pressurised digestion with H N 0 3 / H F (3 ml/1 ml) for


2 h at 180 C
Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in HCl

ETAAS

11

17

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Co (ctd)

Sample mass
(mg)

700

Sample pretreatment

Final
determination

Irradiation with thermal neutrons (3xl0"cm"2s~') for


7 h; decay time 8 weeks; counting for 5 h
Calibrant: commercial solution of Co checked bv
titration

18

Gamma
spectrometry of
Co

Series
in tables
Annex I
13

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Cr

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

100

Pressurised digestion using HNOj (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by HF (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H3BO (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr

ICPAES

500

Pressurised microwave digestion with HF (4 ml),


H N 0 3 (5 ml) and HCl (1 ml) for 30 min; addition of
H3BO (2 g); dilution with H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HNO,
checked against Cr crystallites (purity 99.998 %)

FAAS

80

Irradiation with thermal neutrons (4xl013cm"2s"') for


5 h; decay time 2-3 weeks; transfer to un-irradiated
polyvial; counting for 4 h
Calibrant: K,Cr,0, (purity 99.98 %) in ,; NIST
SRM 1362

Gamma
spectrometry of
5l
Cr

500

Open digestion with HN0 3 /HC10 4 /HF for 16 h at 20


C
C; evaporation to dryness at 170 C; repeated with
HF (5 ml); dissolution in HCl (10 ml)(6 mol.l 1 )
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HCl checked
against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

100

Material pressed into pellet; irradiation with thermal


neutrons (1.8xl0' 2 cm" 2 s') for 7 h; decay time 4
weeks; counting for 16 h
Calibrant: Cr metal in HCl (purity >99.99 %)
(etched with HCl (3 mol.l 1 )); verified against CRM
146

Gamma
spectrometry of
51
Cr

180-300

Programmed dry ashing upto 450 C in Pt crucible;


followed by digestion with HF/HNO,/HC10 4 for 3 h
at room temperature and evaporation to dryness at
150 C; dissolution in H N 0 3 at 100 C for 15 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HN0 3

ICPMS of Cr mass
52

19

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Cr (ctd)

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

200

Pressurised digestion with HNOj/HF (3 ml/1 ml) for


2 h at 180 C
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HCl

FAAS

11

1000

Addition of " Cr spike; digestion in P T F E lined


bomb with H N 0 3 / H F (10 ml/3 ml) for 3 d at 180
C; evaporation to dryness; further with
H F (5 ml); evaporation to dryness; dissolution in
HCl (10 ml)(6 mol.l"'); anion exchange procedure;
evaporation of the eluate; redissolution in acetic acid
(1 mol.l"'); oxidation with potassiumbromate; ion
exchange procedure
Calibrant: calibration of spike using 2 different Cr
solutions; Cr metal (purity 99.996 % ) ; etched with
H F before use

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of
masses 52, 53 and
54

13

700

Irradiation with thermal neutrons (3xlO u cm" 2 s"') for


7 h; decay time 8 weeks; counting for 5 h
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr verified bv
titration

Gamma
spectrometry of
5l
Cr

13

300

Open digestion with HNOj (5 ml) for 2 h at 80-100


C ; followed by aqua regia (6 ml) for 4 h at 100
C; addition of H 2 0 2 (4 ml) and left at room
temperature for 2-3 h; addition of H F (10 ml) and
left overnight; addition of H 2 S 0 4 (2 ml) and
evaporation to dryness at 200 C; addition of H N 0 3
and evaporation to dryness; taken up in H N 0 3 ;
filtered through Whatman filter
Calibrant: ICCr,0 7 (purity 99.98 %) in diluted
H N 0 3 ; NIST SRM 1362

FAAS

16

20

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Cu

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

100

Pressurised digestion using HNO, (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by HF (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H 3 B0 4 (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu

ICPAES

60-80

High pressure ashing in quartz vessels with H N 0 3 (2


ml) and HC104 (0.3 ml) for 3 h at 280 C; treated
with HF and HN0 3 in Pt crucibles; residue taken up
in HCl (0.4 ml) and diluted with Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: as above

DPASV

500

Pressurised microwave digestion with HF (4 ml),


H N 0 3 (5 ml) and HCl (1 ml) for 30 min; addition of
H 3 B0 4 (2 g); dilution with H 2 0
Calibrant: CuSO.5H 7 0 (purity > 99.5 %) checked
against Cu wire (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

500

Open digestion with HN0 3 /HC10 4 /HF for 16 h at


20 C; evaporation to dryness at 170 C; repeated
with HF (5 ml); dissolution in HCl (10 ml)
(6 mol.l 1 )
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu in HCl

ICPAES

180-300

Programmed dry ashing upto 450 C in Pt crucible;


followed by digestion with HF/HNC^/HCIO,, for 3 h
at room temperature and evaporation to dryness at
150 C; dissolution in H N 0 3 at 100 C for 15 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu in HNO,

ICPMS of Cu
masses 63 and 65

200

Material pressed into pellets; measured for 2000 s at


45 kV; 5 mA
Calibrant: addition of known amounts of pure metals
(Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) for calibration to 3
separate pellets; all elements added as acid solutions
of metals (purity >99.5 %)

EDXRF

10

21

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Cu (ctd)

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

200

Pressurised digestion with HNOj/HF (3 ml/1 ml) for


2 h at 180 C
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu in H N O ,

FAAS

11

500

Addition of " C u spike; digestion in P T F E lined


bomb with H N O j / H F (10 ml/5 ml) for 2 d at 180
C ; evaporation to dryness; addition of H F (5 ml);
evaporation to dryness; further with H N 0 3 / H C 1 0 4 (5
ml/2 ml); evaporation to dryness; uptake in HCl (0.2
mol.l" 1 ); separation by electrodeposition
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Cu
solutions; Cu metal (purity ^ 99.999 % ) ; metal was
etched before use; natural isotopie ratio

I D M S (thermal
ionisation) of Cu
masses 63 and 65

13

22

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Hg

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

100

Pressurised digestion using H N O , (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by H F (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H 3 B 0 4 (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0 ; addition of SnCl 2 ; addition of H N 0 3
Calibrant: commercial solution of Hg

CVAAS

100

Pressurised digestion using H N 0 3 (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by H F (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H 3 B 0 4 (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: as above

I C P M S of Hg
mass 202

200-400

Digestion with HNOj/HClO., (2 ml/4 ml) under


reflux; digestion at room temperature for 20 h and
heating for 1 h at 130 C ; filtration; dilution
Calibrant: commercial solution of H g in H N O ,

I C P M S of H g
masses 200, 201
and 202

500

Irradiation with thermal neutrons ( 3 x l 0 " c m " 2 s ' ) for


8 h; decay time 4 weeks; digestion with H N O , / H F
(7 ml/3 ml) in P T F E lined bomb for 2 d at 180 C;
addition of HCl (20 ml)(0.1 mol.l"'); adsorption on
ion exchange resin; counting for 15 h
Calibrant: commercial solution of H g

Gamma
spectrometry of

13

23

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Mn

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

100

Pressurised digestion using HNO, (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by HF (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H 3 B0 4 (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Mn

ICPAES

500

Pressurised microwave digestion with HF (4 ml),


H N 0 3 (5 ml) and HCl (1 ml) for 30 min; addition of
H 3 B0 4 (2 g); dilution with H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Mn in HNO,
checked against Mn metal (purity > 99.9 %)

FAAS

100

Irradiation with thermal neutrons (2xl0' 3 cm' 2 s') for


30 s; decay time 2-3 h; counting for 20 min
Calibrant: Mn metal (purity 99.98 %) in 10%
HN0 3 ; NIST SRM 3132

Gamma
spectrometry of
*Mn

500

Open digestion with HN0 3 /HC10 4 /HF for 16 h at


20 C; evaporation to dryness at 170 C C; repeated
with HF (5 ml); dissolution in HCl (10 ml)(6mol.l')
Calibrant: commercial solution of Mn in HCl
checked against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

100-150

Material pressed into pellet; irradiation with thermal


neutrons (2.6xl0' 2 cm" 2 s') for 5 min; decay time 2 h;
counting for 10 min
Calibrant: MnSO.H,0 (purity > 99.9 %) in -,;
verified against CRM 146

Gamma
spectrometry of
56
Mn

180-300

Programmed dry ashing upto 450 C in Pt crucible;


followed by digestion with HF/HNO,/HC10 4 for 3 h
at room temperature and evaporation to dryness at
150 C; dissolution in H N 0 3 at 100 C for 15 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Mn in HCl

ICPAES

24

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Mn (ctd)

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

200

Material pressed into pellets; measured for 2000 s at


45 kV; 5 mA
Calibrant: addition of known amounts of pure metals
(Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) for calibration to 3
separate pellets; all elements added as acid solutions
of metals (purity > 99.5 %)

EDXRF

10

200

Pressurised digestion with HN0 3 /HF (3 ml/1 ml) for


2 h at 180 C
Calibrant: commercial solution of Mn in HCl

FAAS

11

300

Irradiation with thermal neutrons (3xl0"cm" 2 s ') for


2 min; decay time 164 min; counting for 2 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Mn checked bv
titration

Gamma
spectrometry of
56
Mn

13

100-150

Irradiation with thermal neutrons (10' 3 cm" 2 s') for 60


s; decay time 300 s; counting for 300 s
Calibrant: KMn0 4 (purity > 99.99 %")

Gamma
spectrometry of
56
Mn

14

25

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Ni

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

100

Pressurised digestion using HN03 (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by HF (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H 3 B0 4 (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni

ICPAES

60-80

High pressure ashing in quartz vessels with H N 0 3 (2


ml) and HC10 4 (0.3 ml) for 3 h at 280 C; treated
with HF and H N 0 3 in Pt crucibles; residue taken up
in HCl (0.4 ml) and diluted with Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: as above

DPCSV

500

Pressurised micro wave digestion with HF (4 ml),


HNO-, (5 ml) and HCl (1 ml) for 30 min; addition of
H 3 B0 4 (2 g); dilution with H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni in HNO,
checked against Ni metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

500

Open digestion with HN0 3 /HC10 4 /HF for 16 h at 20


C; evaporation to dryness at 170 C; repeated with
HF (5 ml); dissolution in HCl (10 ml)(6 mol.l')
Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni in HCl checked
against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

180-300

Programmed dry ashing upto 450 C in Pt crucible;


followed by digestion with HF/HNOj/HClO,, for 3 h
at room temperature and evaporation to dryness at
150 C; dissolution in H N 0 3 at 100 C for 15 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni metal in HNO,

ICPAES

26

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Ni (ctd)

Sample mass
(mg)

1000

Sample pretreatment

Final
determination

Addition of e 2 Ni spike; digestion in P T F E lined


b o m b with HNO3/HF (10 m l / 5 ml) for 2 d at 180
C ; evaporation to dryness; further with
HNO3/HCIO4 (5 ml/2 ml); evaporation to dryness;
dissolution in HCl (6 mol.l" 1 ); anion exchange
procedure; evaporation of eluate; dissolution in H C l
(0.02 mol.l" 1 ); cation exchange procedure; elution
with HCl (2 mol.l"'); evaporation to dryness;
addition of N H 3 buffer; electrodeposition
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Ni
solutions; Ni metal (purity ^ 99.99 %) etched
before use; natural isotopie ratio

I D M S (thermal
ionisation) of Ni
masses 5 8 , 60 and
62

27

Series
in tables
Annex I
13

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Pb

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

100

Pressurised digestion using H N 0 3 (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by HF (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H 3 B0 4 (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb

ETAAS

100

As above
Calibrant: as above

ICPAES

100

As above
Calibrant: as above

ICPMS of Pb
mass 208

60-80

High pressure ashing in quartz vessels with H N 0 3 (2


ml) and HC10 4 (0.3 ml) for 3 h at 280 C; treated
with HF and H N 0 3 in Pt crucibles; residue taken up
in HCl (0.4 ml) and diluted with Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: as above

DPASV

500

Pressurised microwave digestion with 4 ml HF, 5 ml


H N 0 3 and 1 ml HCl for 30 min; addition of 2 g
H 3 B0 4 ; dilution with H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb in HNO, (0.5
mol.l"1) checked against Pb metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

500

Open digestion with HN0 3 /HC10 4 /HF for 16 h at 20


C; evaporation to dryness at 170 C; repeated with
HF (5 ml); dissolution in HCl (10 ml)(6 mol.l')
Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb in HN0 3
checked against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

180-300

Programmed dry ashing upto 450 C in Pt crucible;


followed by digestion with HF/HNO,/HC10 4 for 3 h
at room temperature and evaporation to dryness at
150 C; dissolution in H N 0 3 at 100 C for 15 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb in HNO,

ICPMS of Pb
masses 206, 207
and 208

28

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Pb (ctd)

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

180-300

As above
Calibrant: as above

DPASV

200

Material pressed in to pellets; measured for 2000 s


at 45 kV, 5 mA
Calibrant: addition of known amounts of pure metals
(Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) for calibration to 3
separate pellets; all elements added as acid solutions
of metals (purity > 99.5 %)

EDXRF

10

200

Pressurised digestion with HNO5/HF (3 ml/1 ml) for


2 h a t 180 C
Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb in HNO,

FAAS

11

200

Addition of 204Pb spike; digestion in PTFE lined


bomb with HNOj/HF (10 ml/5 ml) for 2 d at 180
C; evaporation to dryness; addition of HF (5 ml);
addition of HNO3/HCIO (5 ml/2 ml); fuming;
evaporation to dryness; dissolution in HBr
(1 mol.l"'); separation on anion exchange resin
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different
solutions; Pb metal (purity S 99.999 %); metal
etched before use

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Pb
masses 204, 206,
207 and 208

13

29

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Zn

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

100

Pressurised digestion using HNOj (1 ml) for 10 h at


170 C followed by HF (0.5 ml) for 10 h at 170 C
and H 3 B0 4 (5 ml) for 10 h at 100 C; dilution with
Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn

ICPAES

60-80

High pressure ashing in quartz vessels with H N 0 3 (2


ml) and HCI0 4 (0.3 ml) for 3 h at 280 C; treated
with HF and H N 0 3 in Pt crucibles; residue taken up
in HCl (0.4 ml) and diluted with Milli-Q H 2 0
Calibrant: as above

DPASV

500

Pressurised microwave digestion with HF (4 ml),


H N 0 3 (5 ml) and HCl (1 ml) for 30 min; addition of
H3BO (2 g); dilution with H 2 0
Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn in HNO, (0.5
mol.l1) checked against Zn metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

80

Irradiation with thermal neutrons (4xl0' 3 cm' 2 s 1 ) for


5 h; decay time 2-3 weeks; transfer to un-irradiated
polyvial; counting for 4 h
Calibrant: Zn metal (purity 99.99%) in 1 mol.l"'
HN0 3 ; NIST SRM 728

Gamma
spectrometry of
"Zn

500

Open digestion with HN0 3 /HC10 4 /HF for 16 h at 20


C; evaporation to dryness at 170 C; repeated with
HF (5 ml); dissolution in HCl (10 ml)(6 mol.l"1)
Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn in HCl
checked against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

100

Material pressed into pellet; irradiation with thermal


neutrons (1.8xl0 12 c m ' V ) for 7 h; decay time 4
weeks; counting for 16 h
Calibrant: Zn metal (purity > 99.99 %). etched
with H N 0 3 (3 mol.l"'); verified against CRM 146

Gamma
spectrometry of
Zn

30

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Total Zn (ctd)

Sample mass
(mg)

Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

180-300

Programmed dry ahing up to 450 C in Pt crucible;


followed by digestion with HF/HNQ,/HC10 4 for 3 h
at room temperature and evaporation to dryness at
150 C; dissolution in H N 0 3 at 100 C for 15 min
Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn metal in HNO,

ICPMS of Zn
masses 64 and 66

200

Material pressed into pellets; measured for 2 000 s


at 45 kV, 5 mA
Calibrant: addition of known amounts of pure metals
(Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) for calibration to 3
separate pellets; all elements added as acid solutions
of metals (purity > 99.5 %)

EDXRF

10

200

Pressurised digestion with HNO3/HF (3 ml/1 ml) for


2 h at 180 C
Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn in HCl

FAAS

11

200

Addition of ^Zn spike; digestion in PTFE lined


bomb with H N Q / H F (10 ml/5 ml) for 2 d at 180
C; evaporation to dryness; addition of HF (5 ml);
evaporation to dryness; further with
HN0 3 /HC10 4 (5 ml/2 ml); evaporation; dissolution
in HCl (2 mol.l' 1 ); anion exchange procedure;
elution with HCl (0.1 mol.l"'); electrodeposition
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different
solutions; Zn metal (purity 99.99 %); etched before
use; natural isotopie ratio

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Zn
masses 64, 66 and
68

13

300

Open digestion with HNCX, (5 ml) for 2 h at 80-100


C; followed by aqua regia (6 ml) for 4 h at 100
C; addition of H 2 0 2 (4 ml) and left at room
temperature for 2-3 h; addition of HF (10 ml) and
left overnight; addition of H 2 S0 4 (2 ml) and
evaporation to dryness at 200 C; addition of H N 0 3
and evaporation to dryness; taken up in HN0 3 ;
filtered through Whatman filter
Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn verified against
Zn metal (purity > 99.99 %)

FAAS

16

31

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Cd
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd

ETAAS

Calibrant: as above

ICPAES

Calibrant: as above

ICPMS of Cd
mass 111

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd in HNO, (0.5


mol.l') checked against Cd metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd in HCl


checked against other calibrant solution

ETAAS

Ten fold dilution with H N 0 3 (0.14 mol.l"1); addition


of In as internal standard
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd in HNO,
verified against Cd metal in H N 0 3 (purity 99.95 %)

ICPMS of Cd
mass 111

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cd in HCl

ICPMS of Cd
masses 111, 112
and 114

Addition of " 2 Cd spike to extract; evaporation to


dryness; addition of HCl (10 ml)(2 mol.l' 1 ); anion
exchange procedure; elution with H N 0 3 (2 mol.l"');
evaporation to dryness; addition of NH 3 buffer;
electrodeposition
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Cd
solutions; Cd metal (purity 99.999 %), etched before
use

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Cd
masses 111, 112
and 114

13

32

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Co
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Co

ICPAES

Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in HNO,


checked against Co metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

Centrifugation to separate residue from extract;


residue dried for 18 h at 110 C until constant
weight; residue mixed and 0.8 g is irradiated with
thermal neutrons (4xl0 13 c m ' V ) for 5 h; decay time
2-3 weeks; transfer to un-irradiated polyvial;
counting for 12 h; aqua regia soluble content
calculated through difference
Calibrant: Co metal (purity 99.98 %i in 10 % HNO,

Gamma
spectrometry of
Co

Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in HCl


checked against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

Spiked on Whatman 41 filterpaper; irradiation with


thermal neutrons (1.8xl0 12 c m ' V ) for 7 h; decay
time 4 weeks; counting for 2 0 h
Calibrant: Co metal in H N 0 3 (purity 99.99 %)
(etched in HN0 3 ) as well as a commercial solution
of Co in H N 0 3

Gamma
spectrometry of
Co

5 ml of extract treated with HF (1 ml)(50 %) and


HNOj (5 ml)(14 mol.l' 1 ); heated at 70 C overnight
and evaporated to near dryness; residue taken up in
diluted HN0 3 ; addition of Ge as internal standard
Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in HNO,
checked against Co metal (purity 99.99 %) in H N 0 3

ICPMS of Co
mass 59

33

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Co (ctd)
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Sample pretreatment

Final
determination

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in H N 0 3

ICPMS of Co
mass 59

Calibrant: commercial solution of Co in HCl

ETAAS

11

34

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Cr
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr

ICPAES

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HNO,


checked against Cr crystallites (purity 99.998 %)

FAAS

Centrifugation to separate residue from extract;


residue dried for 18 h at 110 C until constant
weight; residue mixed and 0.8 g is irradiation with
thermal neutrons (4xl0 13 c m ' V ) for 5 h; decay time
2-3 weeks; transfer to un-irradiated polyvial;
counting for 12 h; aqua regia soluble content
calculated through difference
Calibrant: K 7 Cr,0 7 (purity 99.98 %) in ,: NIST
SRM 1362

Gamma
spectrometry of
51
Cr

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HCl checked


against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HNO,

ICPMS of Cr
mass 52

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HCl

FAAS

11

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cr in HCl checked


against CRM

FAAS

12

35

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Cr (ctd)
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Series
in tables
Annex I

Sample pretreatment

Final
determination

Addition of 53Cr spike to extract; evaporation to


dryness; dissolution in HCl (6 mol.l"1); anion
exchange procedure; evaporation of eluate;
dissolution in HOAc (1 mol.l' 1 ); oxidation of Cr(III)
to Cr(VI) with potassiumbromate; anion exchange
procedure
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Cr
solutions; Cr metal (purity 99.999 %); etched before
use with HCl

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Cr
masses 52, 53 and
54

13

Extraction carried out in closed teflon tubes with


aqua regia (10 ml) at room temperature for 12 h;
followed by heating for 3 h at 130 C; centrifugation
at 3000 rpm; filtered through Whatman No 54
Calibrant: K,Cr,0, (purity 99.98 %Y. NIST SRM
1362

FAAS

16

36

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Cu
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu

ICPAES

Calibrant: CuSO.5H,0 (puritv > 99.5 %Y. checked


against Cu wire (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu in HCl

ICPAES

5 ml of extract treated with H F (1 ml)(50 %) and


HNO3 (5 ml)(14 mol.l"1); heated at 70 C overnight
and evaporated to near dryness; residue taken up in
diluted H N 0 3 ; addition of Ge as internal standard
Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu in HNO ?
checked against Cu metal (purity 99.99 %) in H N 0 3

ICPMS of Cu
masses 63 and 65

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu in HNO,

ICPMS of Cu
masses and 65

Solution spiked on polypropylene film; measured for


2 000 s at 45 kV; 5 mA
Calibrant: addition of known amounts of pure metals
( Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) for calibration to 3
separate pellets; all elements added as acid solutions
of metals (purity > 99.5 %)

EDXRF

10

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu in H N 0 3

FAAS

11

Calibrant: commercial solution of Cu in HCl


checked against CRM

FAAS

12

37

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Cu (ctd)
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

DIN 38414-S7; addition of " C u spike to extract;


evaporation to dryness; dissolution in HCl (0.2
mol.l' 1 ); separation by electrodeposition
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Cu
solutions; Cu metal (purity 99.999 % ) ; etched before
use

38

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Cu
masses 63 and 65

Series
in tables
Annex I
13

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Hg
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Hg

CVAAS

Calibrant: as above

ICPMS of Hg
mass 202

Calibrant: commercial solution of Hg in H N 0 3


checked against Hg metal (purity 99.999 %)

CVAAS

Addition of SnCl; addition of HCl


Calibrant: commercial solution of Hg in HCl

CVAAS

5 fold dilution; addition of Tl as internal standard


Calibrant: addition of known amount of Isoflex
Hg(201) enriched standard

ID ICPMS of Hg
masses 202 and
201

39

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Mn
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of M n

ICPAES

Calibrant: commercial solution of M n in H N O ,


checked against M n metal (purity > 99.9 %)

FAAS

Centrifugation to separate residue from extract;


residue dried for 1 8 h a t l l O C until constant
weight; residue mixed and 0.1 g is irradiated with
thermal neutrons ( 2 x l 0 1 3 c m ' V ) for 30 sec; decay
time 2-3 h; counting for 20 min; aqua regia soluble
content calculated through difference
Calibrant: M n metal (purity 99.98 %) in 10 %
H N 0 3 ; N I S T S R M 3132

Gamma
spectrometry of
3<s
Mn

Calibrant: commercial solution of M n in HCl


checked against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

5 ml of extract treated with H F (1 ml)(50 %) and


H N 0 3 (5 ml)(14 m o l . l 1 ) ; heated at 70 C overnight
and evaporated to near dryness; residue taken up in
diluted H N 0 3 ; addition of G e as internal standard
Calibrant: commercial solution of M n in H N O ,
checked against M n powder (purity > 99 %) in
HNO3

I C P M S of M n
mass 5 5

Calibrant: commercial solution of M n in HCl

ICPAES

40

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble M n (ctd)
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Solution spiked on polypropylene film; measured for


2 000 s at 45 kV; 5 mA
Calibrant: addition of known amounts of pure metals
( Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) for calibration to 3
separate pellets; all elements added as acid solutions
of metals (purity > 99.5%)

EDXRF

10

Calibrant: commercial solution of Mn in HCl

FAAS

11

Calibrant: commercial solution of Mn in HCl


checked against CRM

FAAS

12

41

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Ni
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni

ICPAES

Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni in HNO,


checked against Ni metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni in HCl checked


against other standard solution

ICPAES

5 ml of extract treated with HF (1 ml)(50 %) and


HNOj (5 ml)(14 mol.l'); heated at 70 e C overnight
and evaporated to near dryness; residue taken up in
diluted H N 0 3 ; addition of Ge as internal standard
Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni in H N 0 3
checked against Ni metal (purity 99.99 %) in H N 0 3

ICPMS of Ni
masses 60 and 62

Addition of NH 2 OH.HCl before filling up to the


mark; mixing with pentane dione at pH 3 and
extraction of Fe into CHC13; addition of NaDDTC;
extraction into MIBK
Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni in H N 0 3

FAAS

Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni metal in H N 0 3

ICPAES

Calibrant: commercial solution of Ni in HCl checked


against CRM

FAAS

12

42

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Ni (ctd)
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Addition of "Ni spike to extract; evaporation to


dryness; dissolution in HCl (6 mol.l' 1 ); anion
exchange procedure; evaporation of eluate;
dissolution in HCl (0.02 mol.l' 1 ); cation exchange
procedure; elution with HCl (2 mol.l"'); evaporation
to dryness; electrodeposition from NH 3 buffer
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Ni
solutions; Ni metal (purity 99.99 %); etched before
use

43

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Ni
masses 58, 60 and
62

Series
in tables
Annex I
13

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Pb
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb

ETAAS

Calibrant: as above

ICPAES

Calibrant: as above

ICPMS of Pb
mass 208

Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb in HNO, (0.5


mol.l' 1 ) checked against Pb metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb in HNO,


checked against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

20 to 40 fold dilution; addition of as internal


standard
Calibrant: known amount of NIST SRM 983
standard (purity 99.9 %) enriched in Pb(206)

ID ICPMS of Pb
masses 208 and
206

Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb in HNCL,

ICPMS of Pb
masses 206, 207
and 208

Calibrant: commercial solution of Pb in HNOj


checked against CRM

FAAS

12

Addition of ^ P b spike to extract; evaporation to


dryness; dissolution in HBr (1 mol.l"'); anion
exchange procedure
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Pb
solutions; Pb metal (purity 99.999 %); etched before
use with HOAc

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Pb
masses 204, 206,
207 and 208

13

44

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Zn
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn

ICPAES

Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn in HNO, (0.5


mol.l') checked against Zn metal (purity 99.99 %)

FAAS

Centrifugation to separate residue from extract;


residue dried for 18 h at 110 C until constant
weight; residue mixed and 0.8 g is irradiated with
thermal neutrons (4xl0 1 3 c m ' V ) for 5 h; decay time
2-3 weeks; transfer to un-irradiated polyvial;
counting for 12 h; aqua regia soluble content
calculated through difference
Calibrant: Zn metal (purity 99.99 %) in 1 mol.l"1
H N 0 3 ; NIST SRM 728

Gamma
spectrometry of
"Zn

Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn in HCl


checked against other calibrant solution

ICPAES

5 ml of extract treated wii HF (1 ml)(50 %) and


HNOj (5 ml)(14 mol.l 1 ); heated at 70 C overnight
and evaporated to near dryness; residue taken up in
diluted H N 0 3 ; addition of Ge as internal standard
Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn in HNO,
checked against Zn metal (purity 99.99 %) in H N 0 3

ICPMS of Zn
masses 66 and 68

Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn metal in HNO,

ICPMS of Zn
masses 64 and 66

45

Table 7.2:

Summary of the methods and the sample masses used for CRM 146 R
Aqua regia soluble Zn (ctd)
(according to DIN 38414-S7)
Final
determination

Sample pretreatment

Series
in tables
Annex I

Solution spiked on polypropylene film; measured for


2 000 s at 45 kV; 5 mA
Calibrant: addition of known amounts of pure metals
( Cr, Cu, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn) for calibration to 3
separate pellets; all elements added as acid solutions
of metals (purity > 99.5 %)

EDXRF

10

Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn in HCl

FAAS

11

Calibrant: commercial solution of Zn in HCl


checked against CRM

FAAS

12

Addition of Z n spike to extract; evaporation to


dryness; dissolution in HCl (2 mol.l"1); anion
exchange procedure; elution with HCl (0.1 mol.l"1);
electrolytic deposition
Calibrant: calibration of spike with 2 different Zn
solutions; Zn metal (purity 99.999 %); etched before
use

IDMS (thermal
ionisation) of Zn
masses 64, 66 and
68

13

46

8.

TECHNICAL AND STATISTICAL DISCUSSION

All the results accepted for certification by the participating laboratories are given in the tables
1-18 in Annex I. Each set of results is identified by the code number of the laboratory.

The

details of the analytical methods used by each laboratory are given in the table 7.2 for both total
and aqua regia soluble fractions (section 7).
All the results were discussed at a technical evaluation meeting to confirm the performance of
the methods of analysis and their respective values.
All data accepted for certification were obtained from laboratories which had demonstrated good
analytical quality control and had fully implemented the analytical precautions outlined in section
7.
8.1.

Technical evaluation

Since the CRM is rich in silicates or alumino silicates to which some trace elements may be
bound, the application of an alkaline fusion or the use of H F in acid digestions is recommended
for the determination of the total contents of the elements.
Some remarks made for individual elements during the technical discussion are summarised
below as guidelines for the user.
Cobalt
Laboratory 2 determined Co by DPASV and came to the conclusion that it is not the most
appropriate technique for this element. The results were consequently withdrawn.
Nickel
Laboratories using INAA for the determination of Ni, via the 58Ni (n,p)
take into account the possible nuclear interference from
leading to an overestimation of the Ni content.

47

59

58

Co reaction, should

Co (n,2n) 58 Co, also yielding

58

Co, thus

Zinc
Laboratory 4 (INAA) was confident that it was possible to separate the 65Zn peak from a much
larger, possibly interfering, ^Sc peak in the INAA spectrum since the same results were
obtained with different deconvolution programs. Nevertheless, laboratories using INAA should
take into account the high Sc content.
8.2

General statistical discussion

For each set of results in the tables 1-18 of Annex I the mean value and the standard deviation
are calculated.
The sets of results have further been submitted to the following statistical tests:
Kolmogorov-Smirnov-Lilliefors tests to assess the conformity of the distributions of
individual results and of laboratory means to normal distributions;
Nalimov test to detect "outlying" values in the population of individual results and in
the population of laboratory means;
Bartlett test to assess the overall consistency of the variance values obtained in the
participating laboratories;
Cochran test to detect "outlying" values in the laboratory variances (s2);
One way analysis of variance (F-test) to compare and estimate the between- and the
within-laboratory components of the overall variance of all individual results.
For Cochran and Nalimov tests, a value is called an "outlier" when the hypothesis that it belongs
to the population of results considered can be rejected with a 0.01 risk of error. For a
"straggler", the risk lies between 0.01 and 0.05. The criterion was adopted that an "outlier" of
variance would be eliminated only if the standard error of the mean (sA/n) of the set exceeded
the standard deviation of the distribution of all laboratory means.
A summary of the statistical data, as obtained from computing, is given in the tables 8.1 and 8.2
respectively for total and aqua regia soluble contents. They are reported only for the certified
values (presented in the tables 9.1 and 9.2). The data are discussed in section 8.3.

48

The sets of results found acceptable on technical and statistical grounds are represented in the
form of "bar-charts" in the figures 1-18 of Annex I.

In the figures the length of a bar

corresponds to the 95 % confidence interval of the mean. The certified values were calculated
as the arithmetic means of the laboratory means (taking into account the number of sets accepted
for certification after both statistical and technical scrutiny); they are featured as vertical dotted
lines on the bar-graphs. The uncertainty is given by the half width of the 95 % confidence
interval of the mean of laboratory means.
8.3.

Statistical evaluation of the results

The within-laboratory standard deviation (S w ) and the between-laboratory standard deviation (SB)
as derived from one way analysis of variance (presented in tables 8.1 and 8.2) demonstrate that
the between-laboratory variation was the major source of variability (between results) in almost
all cases. For Co and Hg, S w was higher than SB which would indicate that the calculation of
the overall mean of the results should involve all individual values. As the differences between
the means (obtained by averaging the laboratory means or by averaging the individual values)
were only small, and for reasons of uniformity, it was decided to base the certification of these
elements on the laboratory means rather than on all individual results.
As in all cases the population of results accepted for certification had a normal distribution
(Kolmogorov-Smirnov-Lilliefors tests) and did not contain outlying mean values (Nalimov test),
the 95 % confidence interval of the means of the laboratory means was calculated.
The set of variances is often not homogeneous which is due to the fact that different methods
are used each having a different repeatability and reproducibility.

If one single method were

used then a homogeneous set of laboratory variances would be required. Consequently the S w
(within-laboratory standard deviation) calculated is not applicable to any particular method
because it is a composite value for all the methods used in this certification.

49

The variance proved to be homogeneous for Cu, Co(AR), Hg(AR), Pb(AR) and Zn(AR), not
homogeneous with 0.05 > > 0.01 for Cd, Cr(AR) and Ni(AR) and not homogeneous with
0.01 > for Co, Cr, Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb, Zn, Cd(AR), Cu(AR) and Mn(AR).
The sets of data of lab 16 (FAAS) for Cr, lab 10 (EDXRF) and lab 4 (INAA) for Mn and
Mn(AR), lab 2 (DPASV) for Pb and Zn as well as lab 2 (ICPAES) for Co(AR) were identified
as stragglers or outliers of variance (Cochran test).

Since they satisfied the criterion for

acceptance (section 8.2) they could be retained for calculation of the certified value. The sets
of results of lab 2 (ICPAES) for Cd, of lab 3 (FAAS) as well as lab 5 (ETAAS) for Cd(AR) and
the set of results of lab 7 (FAAS) for Ni(AR) had to be rejected because they did not satisfy the
same criterion.

50

Table 8.1:

Summary of statistical data for the total content of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni,
Pb and Zn in BCR CRM 146 R (expressed as mg/kg)

Elements

Cd

Co

Cr

Cu

Hg

Number of data sets

10

Number of accepted replicates

48

35

53

41

20

All data sets compatible two by

yes

yes

yes

yes

yes

no

no

no

no

no

no

no

yes

no

no

Mean of means

18.76015

7.39194

195.98800

837.85920

8.62150

sw
sb

0.46500

0.40326

8.97310

15.61579

0.34295

0.49469

0.22097

7.79842

16.55579

0.13405

yes

yes

yes

yes

no

about

no

no

yes

no

0.54735

0.28522

8.68012

18.09169

0.20370

yes

yes

yes

yes

yes

0.42073

0.26378

6.20943

15.12512

0.32412

two? (Scheff's multiple t-test)


Outlying data sets? (Dixon's test,
Nalimov t-test and Grubbs test)
Outlying variances? (Cochran
test)

Between data SD significant?


(Snedecor test)
Variances homogeneous?
SD of means
Data sets means normally
distributed? (KomogorovSmirnov-Lilliefors test)
95 % CI of the mean of means

51

Table 8.1:

continued

Mn

Ni

Pb

Zn

Number of data sets

10

11

11

Number of accepted replicates

54

31

59

58

All data sets compatible two by

yes

yes

yes

yes

no

no

no

yes

no

yes

323.44850

69.63490

608.71770

3061.3790

8.72792

2.77116

16.40069

58.90373

8.33227

3.61404

19.52996

83.98067

yes

yes

yes

yes

no

no

no

9.22985

3.82738

20.80651

yes

yes

yes

6.60269

4.01652

13.97809

Elements

two? (Scheff's multiple t-test)


Outlying data sets? (Dixon's test,
Nalimov t-test and Grubbs test)
Outlying variances? (Cochran
test)
Mean of means

sw
sb
Between data SD significant?
(Snedecor test)
Variances homogeneous?
SD of means
Data sets means normally

88.16988

distributed? (KomogorovSmirnov-Lilliefors test)


95 % CI of the mean of means

CI

Confidence interval

SD

Standard deviation

Sw

Within-laboratory standard deviation

Sb

Between-laboratory standard deviation

52

59.23364

Table 8.2:

Summary of statistical data for the aqua regia soluble content of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu,
Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn in BCR CRM 146 R (expressed as mg/kg)

Elements

Cd

Co

Cr

Cu

Hg

Number of data sets

Number of accepted replicates

31

41

47

46

25

All data sets compatible two by

yes

yes

yes

yes

yes

no

no

no

no

no

no

yes

no

no

no

Mean of means

18.44816

6.50139

173.74110

831.26760

8.39200

sw
s

0.27966

0.34673

3.91544

14.77243

0.19341

0.30620

0.32611

8.78213

19.26049

0.17617

yes

yes

yes

yes

yes

no

yes

about

no

yes

0.33224

0.36475

9.06246

20.53455

0.19625

yes

yes

yes

yes

yes

0.34866

0.30494

6.96608

15.78442

0.24368

two? (Scheff's multiple t-test)


Outlying data sets? (Dixon's test,
Nalimov t-test and Grubbs test)
Outlying variances? (Cochran
test)

Between data SD significant?


(Snedecor test)
Variances homogeneous?
SD of means
Data sets means normally
distributed? (KomogorovSmirnov-Lilliefors test)
95 % CI of the mean of means

53

Table 8.2:

continued

Mn

Ni

Pb

Zn

Number of data sets

10

Number of accepted replicates

45

35

46

51

All data sets compatible two by

yes

yes

yes

yes

no

no

no

no

yes

no

no

no

297.98330

65.01475

583.19360

3042.3490

8.65127

1.76719

9.65874

62.85468

10.70838

3.12949

21.41793

75.10096

yes

yes

yes

yes

no

about

yes

yes

11.38587

3.22774

22.04627

80.77613

yes

yes

yes

yes

8.75204

2.98516

16.94641

57.78418

Elements

two? (Scheff's multiple t-test)


Outlying data sets? (Dixon's test,
Nalimov t-test and Grubbs test)
Outlying variances? (Cochran
test)
Mean of means

sw
sb
Between data SD significant?
(Snedecor test)
Variances homogeneous?
SD of means
Data sets means normally
distributed? (KomogorovSmirnov-Lilliefors test)
95 % CI of the mean of means

CI

Confidence interval

SD

Standard deviation

Sw

Within-laboratory standard deviation

Sb

Between-laboratory standard deviation

54

9.

CERTD7D2D VALUES

The certified values for the total contents and the aqua regia soluble fraction (both expressed
as the mass fractions based on dry mass (see chapter 11)) are presented in tables 9 . 1 . and 9.2
respectively. The certified value is the unweighted mean of accepted sets of results. The
half width of the 95 % confidence interval of the mean is used as the estimate of the
uncertainty.
Table 9 . 1 :

Certified total mass fractions of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb and Zn in
BCR CRM 146 R (expressed as mg/kg)

Element

Certified
value

Uncertainty

Number of accepted
results (p)

Treatment in Tables
of Annex I

Cd
Co
Cr
Cu
Hg
Mn
Ni
Pb
Zn

18.8
7.39
196
838
8.62
324
69.7
609
3061

0.5
0.27
7
16
0.33
7
4.0
14
59

9
7
10
8
4
10
6
11
11

la
2a
3a
4a
5a
6a
7a
8a
9a

Table 9.2:

Certified a q u a regia soluble mass fractions of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni,
Pb and Zn in BCR CRM 146 R (expressed as mg/kg)

Element

Certified
value

Uncertainty

Number of accepted
results (p)

Treatment in Tables
of Annex I

Cd
Co
Cr
Cu

18.5
6.50
174
831
8.39
298
65.0
583
3043

0.4
0.31
7
16
0.25
9
3.0
17
58

6
8
9
9
5
9
7
9
10

10a
11a
12a
13a
14a
15a
16a
17a
18a

Hg

Mn
Ni
Pb

Zn

55

10.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION

During the course of the certification exercise some laboratories individually determined
other elements.

These results are given in table 10.1 as additional information.

emphasised that these values are not certified.


Table 10.1:

Informative values for BCR CRM 146 R (total element contents)


Element

Al(g/kg)
As (mg/kg)
Ba (mg/kg)
Br
Ca
Cl
Fe

(mg/kg)
(g/kg)
(mg/kg)
(g/kg)

I (mg/kg)
K (g/kg)
La (mg/kg)
Mg (g/kg)
Na (g/kg)
P (g/kg)
S (g/kg)
Sb (mg/kg)
Sn (mg/kg)
Sr (mg/kg)
Ti (mg/kg)
Th (mg/kg)
Tl (Mg/kg)
U (mg/kg)
V (mg/kg)
W (mg/kg)

Mean value
25.13
6.30
786
683.6
7.36
154.6
371.0
17.7
14.38
2.57
5.66
4.82
19.8
10.46
1.915
1.692
25.6
10.62
18.8
13.7
95.8
1179
2771
4.25
578
2.22
42.7
5.13

S.D.*
1.37
1.01
19
57.2
0.66
5.9
29.28
0.5
0.37
0.30
1.7
0.3
0.83
0.25
0.2
0.03
1.7
0.22
0.4
0.23
2.2
43
85
0.17
9
0.037
1.7
0.18

56

Techniques used
ICPAES
INAA
ICPAES
INAA
INAA
ICPAES
INAA
ICPAES
INAA
INAA
ICPAES
INAA
INAA
ICPAES
ICPAES
INAA
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPMS
INAA
ICPMS
ICPAES
ICPAES
INAA
ICPMS
INAA
ICPAES
INAA

It is

Table 10.2:

Informative values for BCR CRM 146 R (aqua-regia soluble contents)


Element

Al (g/kg)
(mg/kg)
Ba (mg/kg)
Ca (g/kg)
Fe (g/kg)
(mg/kg)
Mg (g/kg)
Na (mg/kg)
P (g/kg)
S (g/kg)
Sb (mg/kg)
Sn (mg/kg)
Sr (mg/kg)
Ti (mg/kg)
Tl (Mg/kg)
V (mg/kg)

p:
*:

Mean value
17.45
92.1
632
148.3
15.82
1825
8.87
555
28.0
8.80
12.0
81.6
1131
124
514
33.3

S.D.*

0.22
5.5
5
1.1
0.14
36
0.04
14
0.3
0.05
0.2
1.0
7
13
4
2.4

sets of results (mean value of at least 4 replicates)


S.D. is calculated for the individual results

57

Techniques used
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPMS
ICPMS
ICPAES
ICPAES
ICPMS
ICPAES

11.

INSTRUCTIONS FOR USERS

The following notes are a guide to the user of this reference material for the determination
of trace elements in sewage sludge from industrial origin.
PLEASE CONSULT THESE NOTES PRIOR TO OPENING THE BOTTLE.
The sample consists of approximately 50 g of sewage sludge (particle size < 90 ) in a
brown glass bottle provided with PTFE ball for re-homogenisation and closed with a
polyethylene insert and a screw cap.
The material should be used as it is from the bottle. However, upon mailing or storage, the
sample may partly segregate as pointed out in section 4 of this report. This is due to the fact
that the sample contains particles of different size and relative density.

Therefore re-

homogenisation before subsampling is mandatory. This can be done by manual shaking for
at least 5 minutes. The minimum intake is 50 mg.
The closed bottles may be kept in a dry and cool atmosphere. Once opened, the bottles
should be stored closed in a dry desiccator; direct prolonged exposure to sunlight should be
avoided.
The correction to dry mass must be determined on a separate portion taken at the same time
of the analysis from the same bottle.

It can be done by drying in an oven at 105 C until

constant mass is attained (successive weighings should not differ by more than 0.2 g).
In selecting a method of sample treatment, the user should take into account that part of some
elements present may be bound to the inorganic part of the matrix which might be difficult
to dissolve.

Therefore these elements are not completely soluble in oxidizing acids.

Treatment with HF is recommended for the determination of total contents.


For the digestion method used for the determination of the aqua regia soluble part, the reader
is referred to the section 6 of this report. The results in this report are expressed in dry mass
on a mass per mass basis which is different from the way to express results as indicated by
the norm.

58

This reference material is intended to verify the performance of a method and not to
calibrate the method. The more the concentrations and the matrices of sample and chosen
reference materials are similar, the more it is likely that errors can be detected.
When using the reference material for checking an analytical procedure or the performance
of the method, the user can refer to the results of this certification campaign after having
ascertained that the repeatability of his method is satisfactory.

59

The user may assess the bias of his results from the difference between the certified value
() and the mean value of his replicate measurements (x). The criterion for acceptance is
given in ISO-guide 33 (1988) as follows:
-a2 - 2a L < X-/X < a, + 2a L
in which ax and a2 are adjustment values, chosen by the user according to economic or
technical limitations or stipulations, and aL is the long term within laboratory standard
deviation of the user's method (e.g. as reflected on a SHEW ART Quality Control Chart).
Although these materials are not intended for use as a calibrant, they can be used for further
assessment of the calibration. In such a case, the value to be used for each quantity is the
certified mean value with the uncertainty at the 95 % confidence level.

60

ANNEX I
TABLES OF INDIVIDUAL RESULTS AND
GRAPHICAL PRESENTATIONS

61

Cadmium in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 1
DATA SET

NUM

REPLICATES.

MEAN

ST.DEV

02 ETAAS

18.1000

17.7000

19.4000

17.3000

17.6000

18.0200

.8228

05 ETAAS

17.4700

18.5600

18.2000

18.2100

18.2600

18.1400

.4026

03 FAAS

18.7700

18.5200

18.7800

19.0300

18.4400

18.7080

.2345

07 FAAS

19.7000

20.0000

19.8000

20.0000

19.8000

19.8600

.1342

02 ICPAES

17.7000

18.9000

16.8000

19.5000

16.2000

17.8200

1.3846

02 ICPMS

18.4000

18.5000

18.8000

18.8000

18.9000

18.6800

.2168

09 ICPMS

19.3000
19.0000

18.6000

18.5000

18.8000

18.6000
18.8000

.3033

13 IDMS

19.4000
19.3000

19.5000

18.9000

18.7000

18.9000

19.1167

.3251

02 DPASV

18.5000

19.7000

19.7000

18.9000

18.2000

19.0000

.6856

09 DPASV

18.4000
18.9000

18.0000

18.6000

17.8000

19.4000

18.5167

.5879

Figure 1
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
16.000
+ ..

17.000
... +

18.000
+

19.000
+

20.000
+ ....

02 ETAAS
05 ETAAS
03 FAAS
<..*..>

07 FAAS
02 ICPMS

<...*.

09 ICPMS
<

13 IDMS

02 DPASV
09 DPASV
MEANS'

-M

63

>

>

Cobalt in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 2
MEAN

ST.DEV

05 ETAAS

7.06000

6.82500

7.29800

7.14100

7.20400

7.10560

.17942

11 ETAAS

7.21000

7.18000

8.15000

6.64000

7.49000

7.33400

.55021

03 FAAS

7.16000

7.17000

7.39000

7.39000

5.92000

7.00600

.61744

09 ICPMS

7.36000

8.50000

8.30000

7.70000

7.10000

7.79200

.59860

04 INAA

7.59000

7.48000

7.36000

7.46000

7.55000

7.48800

.08871

06 INAA

7.20000

7.30000

7.20000

7.50000

7.50000

7.34000

.15166

13 INAA

7.52000

7.49000

7.66000

7.81000

7.91000

7.67800

.18158

Figure 2
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
5.500
05 ETAAS

6.500

7.500

<

>

11 ETAAS
03 FAAS
09 ICPMS
04 INAA
06 INAA

<--.*.

13 INAA
MEANS!

64

8.500

Chromium in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 3
NUM

t EPLICATES

03 FAAS

191.900

188.800

194.900

184.300

11 FAAS

196.400

183.300

166.700

207.000
170.000

201.000

02 ICPAES

194.000

05 ICPAES

MEAN

ST.DEV

206.500

193.280

8.367

169.400

176.300

178.420

11.941

201.000

165.000

174.000

186.333

18.608

197.000

219.000

196.000

201.500

11.733

191.000

187.000

193.300

200.000

197.500

193.760

5.159

195.000
197.000

195.000

195.000

201.000

194.000

196.167

2.563

197.800
198.000

199.900

200.500

199.800

196.000

198.667

1.701

04 INAA

204.900

204.900

200.800

197.900

203.100

202.320

2.990

06 INAA

193.000

197.000

203.000

203.000

207.000

200.600

5.550

214.000
209.000

214.000

199.000

207.000

210.000

208.833

5.565

A "A SET

16 FAAS

09 ICPMS
13 IDMS

13 INAA

Figure 3
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
160.0

180.0

200.0

03 FAAS
11 FAAS
16 FAAS
02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
09 ICPMS
13 IDMS
04 INAA

<-*>
<..*--->

06 INAA
13 INAA
MEANS|

65

220.0

Copper in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 4
NUM

DATA SET

REPLICATES..

MEAN

ST.DEV

03 FAAS

800.400

807.600

807.600

773.600

821.200

802.080

17.610

11 FAAS

824.800

827.400

823.200

815.900

816.900

821.640

5.025

02 ICPAES

866.000

843.000

823.000

828.000

853.000

842.600

17.700

05 ICPAES

858.900

849.300

868.200

847.800

849.200

854.680

8.759

09 ICPMS

826.000

844.000

842.000

858.000

875.000

849.000

18.439

13 IDMS

828.000

839.400

826.400

838.700

834.100

833.320

5.973

02 DPASV

839.000

887.000

842.000

843.000

851.000

852.400

19.844

847.330
845.460

872.920

835.250

816.660

865.300

847.153

20.335

10 EDXRF

Figure 4
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
780.0
03 FAAS

800.0

820.0

840.0

<-

11 FAAS
02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
09 ICPMS
13 IDMS
02 DPASV
10 EDXRF
MEANS

66

860.0

880.0

Mercury in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 5
MEAN

ST.DEV

8.22000

8.57200

.24994

8.73000

8.19000

8.42600

.26463

8.45000

8.53000

8.56000

8.90800

.57941

8.61000

8.58000

8.50000

8.58000

.04743

DATA SET

NUM

02 CVAAS

8.67000

8.59000

8.90000

8.48000

02 ICPMS

8.32000

8.69000

8.20000

09 ICPMS

9.21000

9.79000

13 RNAA

8.62000

8.59000

REPLICATES..

Figure 5
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
8.000

8.400

8.800

9.200

02 CVAAS
02 ICPMS
09 ICPMS
13 RNAA
MEANS

67

9.600

Manganese in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 6
MEAN

ST.DEV

326.100

329.700

3.988

315.800

313.700

318.320

3.757

316.000

313.000

316.000

315.800

2.168

325.900

323.700

327.400

328.000

326.160

1.671

326.000
315.000

326.000

323.000

316.000

315.000

320.167

5.419

341.100

348.500

318.400

330.300

318.600

331.380

13.422

329.000
315.000

325.000

328.000

316.000

313.000

321.000

7.127

340.000
332.000

329.000

337.000

339.000

338.000

335.833

4.355

316.400

307.300

300.000

304.700

296.300

304.940

7.681

303.060
348.040

320.360

338.950

324.310

352.390

331.185

18.706

NUM

REPLICATES

03 FAAS

329.700

326.800

329.700

336.200

11 FAAS

322.100

322.100

317.900

02 ICPAES

319.000

315.000

05 ICPAES

325.800

DATA SET

09 ICPAES
04 INAA
06 INAA
13 INAA
14 INAA
10 EDXRF

Figure 6
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
280.0

300.0
... +

320.0
+

03 FAAS

<-__*

11 FAAS

<

02 ICPAES

<--->

>

>

05 ICPAES
09 ICPAES
04 INAA
06 INAA
13 INAA
14 INAA
10 EDXRF
MEANS!

<

340.0
..+ ..

+ ..

>

68

360.0

Nickel in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 7
NUM

SET

REPLICATES..

MEAN

ST.DEV

03 FAAS

63.9000

63.7000

63.9000

64.5000

64.5000

64.1000

.3742

02 ICPAES

74.2000

73.8000

73.5000

75.6000

74.0000

74.2200

.8136

05 ICPAES

64.1200

66.3600

64.5500

74.6400

71.1700

68.1680

4.5728

70.3000
74.5000

72.1000

70.5000

76.3000

73.0000

72.7833

2.3327

13 IDMS

66.1600

66.5600

66.4100

67.3900

69.0700

67.1180

1.1848

02 DPCSV

73.7000

67.1000

77.7000

69.4000

69.2000

71.4200

4.2517

09 ICPAES

Figure 7
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
60.0

64.0

68.0

72.0
.. + ..

03 FAAS

<-*->

02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
09 ICPAES
13 IDMS
02 DPCSV
MEANS

69

76.0
.. + ..

..+ . .

Lead in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 8
MEAN

ST.DEV

02 ETAAS

630.000

634.000

619.000

613.000

609.000

621.000

10.747

03 FAAS

579.800

578.300

578.300

585.500

574.100

579.200

4.113

11 FAAS

586.500

618.000

625.300

595.000

606.400

606.240

15.950

02 ICPAES

640.000

638.000

610.000

655.000

656.000

639.800

18.606

05 ICPAES

601.200

604.300

591.300

593.400

600.200

598.080

5.495

02 ICPMS

635.000

618.000

626.000

619.000

613.000

622.200

8.526

584.000
573.000

570.000

607.000

580.000

574.000

581.333

13.560

613.000
608.600

614.800

606.300

608.600

604.100

609.233

4.023

686.000

632.000

614.000

595.000

630.000

631.400

33.953

586.000
566.000

618.000

576.000

563.000

599.000

584.667

21.030

658.490
615.300

627.520

611.910

608.180

615.050

622.742

18.680

09 ICPMS
13 IDMS
02 DPASV
09 DPASV
10 EDXRF

Figure 8
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
540.0

.+

580.0
+

620.0
+

02 ETAAS
03 FAAS

<--*->

11 FAAS
02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES

<---->

02 ICPMS
09 ICPMS
13 IDMS
02 DPASV
09 DPASV
10 EDXRF
MEANS

>

70

+.

660.0

Zinc in CRM 146 R - total mass fraction (mg/kg)


Table 9
DATA SET

ST.DEV

NUM

REPLICATES

03 FAAS

3036.00

3003.00

3106.00

3133.00

3106.00

3076.80

54.71

11 FAAS

3192.00

3187.00

3173.00

3228.00

3211.00

3198.20

21.51

3008.00
3005.00

2962.00

2874.00

2882.00

2951.00

2947.00

58.10

02 ICPAES

3024.00

3058.00

2966.00

2968.00

3044.00

3012.00

42.83

05 ICPAES

3049.00

3028.00

3068.00

3095.00

3138.00

3075.60

42.72

09 ICPMS

3083.00

3037.00

3089.00

3075.00

3065.00

3069.80

20.43

3210.00
3047.00

3016.00

3181.00

3158.00

3169.00

3130.17

78.98

02 DPASV

3360.00

3140.00

3270.00

3100.00

3030.00

3180.00

133.23

04 INAA

2927.00

2966.00

2940.00

2887.00

2889.00

2921.80

33.91

06 INAA

2969.00

3019.00

3035.00

2939.00

3005.00

2993.40

38.97

3069.93
3078.69

3108.53

3067.11

3029.66

3068.47

3070.40

25.29

16 FAAS

13 IDMS

10 EDXRF

Figure 9
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI

2800.0
+ ..

2900.0
.. + ..

3000.0

3100.0
.. + ..

03 FAAS
11 FAAS
16 FAAS
02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES

09 ICPHS
13 IDMS
02 DPASV
04 INAA
06 INAA

->

10 EDXRF
MEANS

--M--

71

.+

3200.0
+ ....

3300.0

Cadmium in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 10
MEAN

ST.DEV

18.8000

18.6600

.2408

19.8500

20.6300

18.9860

1.3287

19.7000

17.8700

17.8700

18.4680

.8424

18.4000

18.3000

18.6000

19.3000

18.5400

.4615

18.7000

18.3000

19.1000

19.1000

18.4000

18.7200

.3768

17.9160

18.0460

18.5610

18.2270

18.1780

18.1856

.2423

17.9000

18.0000

17.8000

17.9000

17.9000

17.9000

.0707

18.8000
18.6000

18.7000

18.8000

18.6000

18.6000

18.6833

.0983

REPLICATES..

DATA SET

NUM

02 ETAAS

18.4000

18.6000

19.0000

18.5000

05 ETAAS

17.5600

17.7400

19.1500

03 FAAS

19.0000

17.9000

02 ICPAES

18.1000

02 ICPMS

06 ICPMS
09 ICPMS
13 IDMS

Figure 10
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI

17.800

18.200

18.600
.. + ..

02 ETAAS
02 ICPAES
02 ICPMS
00 ICPMS
09 ICPMS
13 IDMS
MEANS!

72

19.000
.. +

Cobalt in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 11
MEAN

ST.DEV

5.80000

6.14000

.24083

7.07000

6.66000

6.85200

.18006

6.70000

6.60000

7.10000

6.46000

.68044

6.17400

5.60800

5.95100

6.50800

6.07720

.33001

6.57550

6.71630

6.37520

6.47100

6.22880

6.47336

.18635

7.56000

7.37000

6.57000

7.35000

7.08000

7.18600

.38449

6.52500

6.42900

6.16100

6.27900

6.30200

6.33920

.14084

6.90000
6.00000

6.60000

6.40000

6.30000

6.70000

6.48333

.31885

DATA SET

NUM

11 ETAAS

6.40000

6.20000

6.30000

6.00000

03 FAAS

6.67000

6.93000

6.93000

02 ICPAES

6.60000

5.30000

05 ICPAES

6.14500

06 ICPMS

09 ICPMS
04 INAA
06 INAA

REPLICATES..

Figure 11
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
5.000

7.000

6.000

11 ETAAS
03 FAAS

8.000
...+

+ ...

<

02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
06 ICPMS
09 ICPMS
04 INAA
06 INAA
MEANS!

73

>

Chromium in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 12
NUM

DATA SET

REPLICATES..

MEAN

ST.DEV

03 FAAS

173.300

170.000

163.300

170.000

170.000

169.320

3.656

11 FAAS

168.600

168.600

167.800

170.500

170.400

169.180

1.205

12 FAAS

190.154

188.928

190.931

193.263

193.482

191.352

1.980

173.000
164.000

163.000

172.000

166.000

163.000

166.833

4.535

16 FAAS

02

ICPAES

179.000

174.000

184.000

172.000

189.000

179.600

7.021

05

ICPAES

172.200

172.000

175.500

179.000

182.200

176.180

4.415

09

ICPMS

163.000

157.000

159.000

156.000

162.000

159.400

3.050

179.100
174.900

176.100

179.500

177.900

175.900

177.233

1.875

178.920

178.990

172.610

169.000

173.340

174.572

4.325

13 IDMS

04

INAA

Figure 12
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
150.0

160.0

170.0

180.0
,..+

+.

190.0
...+...

03 FAAS
11 FAAS
12 FAAS

<-.* >

16 FAAS
02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
09 ICPMS
13 IDMS

<-.*_->

04 INAA
MEANS!

74

Copper in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 13
DATA SET

NUM

REPLICATES..

MEAN

ST.DEV

03 FAAS

784.000

789.200

779.300

810.000

800.000

792.500

12.449

11 FAAS

802.200

804.400

807.300

811.100

805.700

806.140

3.343

12 FAAS

849.258

839.042

846.639

844.719

850.477

846.027

4.503

02 ICPAES

829.000

837.000

831.000

858.000

862.000

843.400

15.502

05 ICPAES

845.300

846.900

848.300

844.000

841.600

845.220

2.594

06 ICPMS

855.680

893.600

852.760

838.160

832.950

854.630

23.794

09 ICPMS

857.000

823.000

830.000

815.000

876.000

840.200

25.489

815.000
826.100

823.400

828.500

827.300

825.500
824.300

4.871

832.810

836.800

844.170

834.210

796.970

828.992

18.429

13 IDMS
10 EDXRF

Figure 13
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
760.0

.+

800.0
+ ...

840.0

03 FAAS
11 FAAS

<-_*_.>

12 FAAS
02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
06 ICPMS
09 ICPMS
13 IDMS

<-*-->!

10 EDXRF
MEANS;

75

880.0

Mercury in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 14
MEAN

ST.DEV

8.28000

8.10800

.19942

8.35000

8.68000

8.50000

.25583

8.52300

8.58200

8.53600

8.63420

.12907

8.36000

8.47000

8.48000

8.09000

8.38000

.17103

8.11000

8.56300

8.50300

8.27200

8.33780

.18947

DAI A SET

NUM

02 CVAAS

8.02000

7.80000

8.19000

8.25000

03 CVAAS

8.12000

8.65000

8.70000

05 CVAAS

8.70300

8.82700

02 ICPMS

8.50000

06 ID ICPMS

8.24100

REPLICATES...

Figure 14
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
7.800

8.000
... +

8.200
+

02 CVAAS

8.400
+

<
<

02 ICPMS

<

06 ID ICPMS

*
>

*
<

8.800
... +

*--

05 CVAAS

MEANS!

+ .. .. + ..

>

03 CVAAS

8.600

>
M

>

76

>

Manganese in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 15
NUM

REPLICATES

03 FAAS

290.000

284.700

289.000

287.300

11 FAAS

282.700

282.800

286.500

12 FAAS

307.785

307.363

02 ICPAES

294.000

05 ICPAES

09 ICPAES

DATA SET

MEAN

ST.DEV

285.700

287.340

2.207

282.800

280.500

283.060

2.159

307.143

308.564

308.287

307.828

.600

287.000

284.000

290.000

280.000

287.000

5.385

296.500

298.600

303.900

305.700

308.500

302.640

4.983

296.000

289.000

290.000

290.000

289.000

290.800

2.950

06 ICPMS

306.180

302.780

302.520

305.000

298.460

302.988

2.958

04 INAA

319.400

321.650

289.530

299.230

286.810

303.324

16.386

10 EDXRF

302.170

311.390

347.110

305.340

318.340

316.870

17.998

Figure 15
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI

270.0
+

.+

290.0
+

310.0
+

03 FAAS
11 FAAS

<-..->

12 FAAS
02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
09 ICPAES
06 ICPMS

<-_.*_->
<__-*-._>

04 INAA
10 EDXRF
MEANS!

77

330.0
+ ..

Nickel in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 16
DATA SET

NUM

REPLICATES...

MEAN

ST.DEV

03 FAAS

63.6000

65.1000

62.0000

57.9000

59.5000

61.6200

2.9372

0 7 FAAS

78.4000

63.2000

75.6000

58.8000

59.9000

67.1800

9.1631

12 FAAS

65.5710

64.6900

64.4260

65.0860

64.9250

64.9396

.4320

02 ICPAES

71.6000

71.4000

72.0000

66.9000

73.0000

70.9800

2.3626

05

ICPAES

63.5700

63.9300

65.1000

65.9200

66.3100

64.9660

1.1996

0 9 ICPAES

61.5000

61.7000

59.8000

60.5000

62.8000

61.2600

1.1546

06 ICPMS

67.5780

67.3830

67.1960

64.6880

63.8430

66.1376

1.7402

13 IDMS

64.4000

64.4000

66.5000

64.0000

66.7000

65.2000

1.2903

Figure 16
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
54.0

58.0

62.0
.. + ..

66.0

03 FAAS
12 FAAS

02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
09 ICPAES
06 ICPMS
13 IDMS
MEANS

78

70.0

74.0

Lead in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 17
MEAN

ST.DEV

611.000

621.400

15.093

536.700

545.300

542.940

11.050

560.400

569.150

568.787

567.549

4.095

587.000

597.000

619.000

597.000

597.000

13.491

569.600

570.600

580.400

586.900

579.600

577.420

7.266

585.000

613.000

596.000

590.000

602.000

597.200

10.895

09 ICPMS

587.000

585.000

567.000

585.000

569.000

578.600

9.737

06 ID ICPMS

578.650

576.210

576.830

580.450

565.360

575.500

5.906

595.600
586.700

590.800

593.200

592.100

588.400

591.133

3.237

DATA SET

NUM

REPLICATES

02 ETAAS

634.000

600.000

632.000

630.000

03 FAAS

561.300

536.700

534.700

12 FAAS

568.567

570.840

02 ICPAES

585.000

05 ICPAES

02 ICPMS

13 IMDS

Figure 17
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI

500.0

580.0

540.0

...+

02 ETAAS
03 FAAS
12 FAAS

<--*->

02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES

<-..*-

02 ICPMS
09 ICPMS

<

*.

06 ID ICPMS
13 IM0S
MEANS;

79

620.0

+ ...

.+

660.0
+

Zinc in CRM 146 R - aqua regia soluble fraction (mg/kg)


Table 18
NUM

DATA SET

REPLICATES...

MEAN

ST.DEV

03 FAAS

2940.00

2940.00

3067.00

2967.00

2980.00

2978.80

52.28

11 FAAS

2985.00

2980.00

3001.00

3067.00

3106.00

3027.80

55.87

12 FAAS

3012.03

3091.12

3151.26

3282.30

3138.02

3134.95

98.76

02 ICPAES

3042.00

3101.00

3078.00

3137.00

3066.00

3084.80

36.12

05 ICPAES

3020.00

3031.00

3070.00

3080.00

3090.00

3058.20

30.92

06 ICPMS

3052.70

3121.20

3089.90

3045.90

3040.40

3070.02

34.55

09 1CPMS

3010.00

2914.00

2902.00

3142.00

3088.00

3011.20

105-33

3004.00
3091.00

3127.00

3097.00

2983.00

3126.00

3071.33

62.40

04 INAA

2872.60

2906.20

2880.60

2818.00

2813.70

2858.22

40.65

10 EDXRF

3097.25

3144.57

3229.18

3092.02

3077.85

3128.17

61.78

13 IDMS

Figure 18
BAR-GRAPHS FOR LABORATORY MEANS AND 95% CI
2750.0

2850.0

2950.0

3050.0

03 FAAS
11 FAAS
12 FAAS
02 ICPAES
05 ICPAES
06 ICPMS
09 ICPMS
13 IDMS
04 INAA
10 EDXRF
MEANS;

80

3150.0
...+

+.

3250.0
... +

European Commission
EUR 16892

The certification of the total contents (mass fractions) of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Pb
and Zn and the aqua regia soluble contents (mass tractions) of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn,
Ni, Pb and Zn in a sewage sludge from industrial origin - CRM 146 R

Ph. Quevauviller, H. Muntau, U. Fortunati and K. Vercoutere


Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities
1996 87 pp, num. tab., fig. - 21.0x29.7 cm
BCR information series
ISBN 92-827-7415-5

This report describes the preparation as well as the homogeneity and stability studies, of a sewage sludge
reference material intended to replace the exhausted BCR CRM 146 sewage sludge from industrial origin. It
also summarises the analytical work for the certification of the total contents and the aqua regia soluble contents
(expressed as mg/kg on a dry mass basis) of some elements. The report contains all the results and a
description of the methods used to certify the total contents of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb, and Zn, as
well as the aqua regia soluble contents of Cd, Co, Cr, Cu, Hg, Mn, Ni, Pb, and Zn.
PLEASE CONSULT T H E INSTRUCTIONS FOR USERS PRIOR TO OPENING A
BOTTLE OF REFERENCE MATERIAL

Venta Salg Verkauf Sales Vente Vendita Verkoop Venda Myynti Frsljning
BELGIQUE/BELGI

IRELAND

NORGE

ISRAEL

M o n i t e u r belge/
B e l g i s c h Staatsblad
Rue de Louvain 42/Leuvenseweg 42
B1000 Bruxelles/B1000 Brussel
Tl. (02) 512 00 26
Fax (02) 511 01 84

Government Supplies A g e n c y
45 Harcourt Road
Dublin 2
Tel. ( 1 ) 6 6 13 111
Fax ( 1 ) 4 7 52 760

NIC Info a/s


Boks 6512 Etterstad
0606 Oslo
Tel (22) 57 33 34
Fax (22) 68 19 01

Roy International
17, Shimon Hatarssi Street
P.O B. 13056
61130 Tel Aviv
Tel. (3) 546 14 23
Fax (3) 546 14 42

J e a n De L a n n o y
Avenue du Roi 202/Koningslaan 202
B1060 Bruxelles/B1060 Brussel
Tl. (02) 538 51 69
Fax (02) 538 08 4I
Autres distributeurs/
Overige verkooppunten:
Librairie e u r o p e n n e /
Europese b o e k h a n d e l
Rue de la Loi 244AVetslraat 244
B1040 Bruxelles/B1040 Brussel
Tl. (02)231 04 35
Fax (02) 735 08 60

ITALIA

SCHWEIZ/SUISSE/SVIZZERA

Licosa SpA
Via Duca di Calabria 1/1
Casella postale 552
150125 Firenze
Tel. (055)64 54 15
Fax 64 12 57

OS EC
Stampfenbachstrae 85
CH8035 Zrich
Tel. (01)365 54 49
Fax (01) 365 54 11

Messageries du livre
5, rue Raifteisen
L2411 Luxembourg
Tl. 40 10 20
Fax 49 06 61

D o c u m e n t delivery:
NEDERLAND
SOU Servicecentrum Uitgeverijen
Postbus 20014
2500 EA 'sGravenhage
Tel. (070) 37 89 880
Fax (070) 37 89 783
OSTERREICH

DANMARK
J . H. Schultz I n f o r m a t i o n A/S
Hersledvang 1012
DK2620 Albertslund

Til. 43 63 23 00
Fax (Sales) 43 63 19 69
Fax (Managemeni) 43 63 19 49

Manz'sche Verlags
und U n i v e r s i t t s b u c h h a n d l u n g
Kohlmarkt 16
A1014 Wien
Tel. (1) 531 610
Fax (1) 531 61181
Document delivery:

DEUTSCHLAND
B u n d e s a n z e i g e r Verlag
Postfach 10 05 34
D50445 Kln
Tel (02 2 1 ) 2 0 290
Fax (02 2 1 ) 2 02 92 78
GREECE/
G.C. E l e f t h e r o u d a k i s SA
International Bookstore
Nikis Street 4
GR10563 Aihens
Tel. (01) 322 63 23
Fax 323 98 21
ESPANA
MundiPrensa L i b r o s . SA
Castell, 37
E28001 Madrid
Tel. (91) 431 33
431 32
435 36
F a x ( 9 1 ) 5 7 5 39

99 (Libros)
22 (Suscripciones)
37 (Direccin)
98

Boletin Oficial del Estado


Trafalgar, 2729
E28071 Madrid
Tel. (91) 538 22 95
Fax (91) 538 23 49
Sucursal:
Librera I n t e r n a c i o n a l AEDOS
Consejo de Cenlo. 391
E08009 Barcelona
Tel (93) 488 34 92
Fax (93) 487 76 59
Librera de la Generalitt
de Catalunya
Rambla deis Esludis. 118 (Palau Moja)
E08002 Barcelona
Tel. (93) 302 68 35
Tel. (93) 302 64 62
F a x ( 9 3 ) 3 0 2 12 99

Wirtschafts kammer
Wiedner Hauptstrae
A1045 Wien
Tel (0222) 501054356
Fax(0222)50206297
PORTUGAL
Imprensa Nacional Casa da Moeda, EP
Rua Marqus S da Bandeira, 16A
P1099 Lisboa Codex
Tel (01)353 03 99
Fax (01)353 02 94/384 01 32
Distribuidora de L i v r o s
Bertrand, Ld."
Grupo Bertrand, SA

26. rue Dcsaix


F75727 Paris Cedex 15
Tl. (1) 40 58 01/31
Fax (1) 40 58 77 00

Europress Klassica BK Ltd


66, bd Vitosha
BG1463 Sofia
Tel/Fax (2) 52 74 75
CESKREPUBLIKA
NIS CR
Havelkova 22
CZ130 0 0 P r a h a 3
Tel/Fax (2) 24 22 94 33

Mediatrade
Hatza 1
HR4100 Zagreb
Tel./Fax(041)43 03 92
MAGYARORSZAG
EuroInfoService
Europa Hz
Margitszigel
H1138 Budapest
Tel/Fax (1) 111 60 6 1 . (1) 111 62 16

ul. Krucza 38/42


PL00512 Warszawa
Tel. (2)621 99 93. 628 28 82
International Fax&Phone (039) 12 00 77
ROMANIA

RUSSIA

SLOVAKIA

Akateeminen Kirjakauppa
Akademiska Bokhandeln
Pohjoisesplanadi 39 / Norra esplanaden 39
P L / P B 128
FIN00101 Helsinki / Helsinglors
Tel 90) 121 4322
Fax (90) 121 44 35

Slovak Technical
Library
Nm. slobody 19
SLO812 23 Bratislava
Tel. (7) 52 204 52
Fax (7) 52 957 85

UNITED KINGDOM
HMSO Books (Agency section)
HMSO Publications Ceir
51 Nine Elms Lane
London SWS 5DR
Tel. (0171)873 9090
Fax (0171)873 8463

Skoldvorduslig, 2
IS101 Reykiavik
Tel. 551 56 50
Fax 552 55 60

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA/


CANADA

4611 F Assembly Drive


Lanham, MD 207064391
Tel. Toll Free (800) 274 48 I
Fax (301) 459 00 56

Subscriptions only
Uniquement a b o n n e m e n t s
Renouf P u b l i s h i n g Co. Ltd
1294 Algoma Road
Ottawa, Ontario K1B 3W8
Tel. (613) 741 43 33
F a x ( 6 1 3 ) 7 4 1 54 39
AUSTRALIA
Hunter Publications
58A Gipps Streel
Collingwood
Victoria 3066
Tel. (3)9417 53 61
Fax (3) 9419 71 54
JAPAN
Procurement Services Int. (PSIJ apan)
Kyoku Dome Postal Code 102
Tokyo Kojimachi Post Office
Tel. (03)32 34 69 21
Fax (03) 32 34 69 15
Subagent:
Kinokuniya C o m p a n y Ltd
J o u r n a l Department
PO Box 55 Chitse
Tokyo 156
Tel. (03)34 390124
SOUTH and EAST ASIA
Legal Library Services Ltd

CYPRUS
Cyprus Chamber of C o m m e r c e
and Industry
Chamber Building
38 Grivas Dhigenis Ave
3 Deligiorgis Streel
PO Box 1455
Nicosia

Orchard
PO Box 0523
Singapore 9123
Tol. 243 24 98
Fax 243 24 79
SOUTH AFRICA

Tel (2) 44 95 00. 46 23 12

Sarto

Fax (2) 36 10 44

5lh Floor. Export House


Cnr Maude & Wesl Streets
Sandlon 2146
Tel. (01 1) 8833737
Fax (011) 8836569

MALIA
Miller Distributors L t d
PO Box 25
Malta International Airoon LOA 05 Malta
Tel. 66 44 88
Fax 67 67 99

ICELAND
BOKABUD
LARUSAR BLNDAL

41 Sherif SI.
Cairo
Tel/Fax (2) 393 97 32

Euromedia
65. Strada Donisie Lucu
RO70184 Bucuresli
Tel/Fax 131 29 646

SUOMI/FINLAND

BTJ AB
Traktorvgen 11
Box 200
S221 00 Lund
Tel. (046) 18 00 00
Fax (046) 18 01 25

Middle East O b s e r v e r

POLSKA
Business Foundation

CC EC
9.60teliya Oktyabrya Avenue
117312 Moscow
Tel/Fax (095) 135 52 27

SVERIGE

EGYPT/
MIDDLE EAST

UNIPUB
HRVATSKA

Rua das Terras dos Vales. 4A


Apartado 37
P2700 Amadora Codex
Tel. (01) 49 59 050
Fax 49 60 255

FRANCE
J o u r n a l officiel
Service des p u b l i c a t i o n s
des Communauts europennes

PO Box 19502
Jerusalem
Tel. (2) 27 16 34
Fax (2) 27 12 19

BALGARIJA
GRANDDUCHE DE LUXEMBOURG

Credoc
Rue de la Montagne 34/Bergstraat 34
Bote 11/Bus 11
B1000 Bruxelles/B1000 Brussel
Tl. (02)511 69 41
Fax (02)513 31 95

Subagent for the Palestinian Authority:


INDEX Information Services

ANDERE LANDER
OTHER COUNTRIES
AUTRES PAYS

TURKIYE

Office des p u b l i c a t i o n s officielles


des C o m m u n a u t s e u r o p e n n e s

Pres AS
Dunya Inlotel
TR 80050 TnelIstanbul
Tel (1) 251 91 90/251 96 96
Fax (I) 251 91 97

2, rue Mercier
L2985 Luxembourg
Tel 29 291
Telex PUBOF LU 1324 b
Fax 48 85 73. 48 68 17

NOTICE TO THE READER


All scientific and technical reports published by the European Commission are announced
in the monthly periodical 'euro abstracts'. For subscription (1 year: ECU 63) please write
to the address below.

o
en
co
CD

ro
m
O

-l

ISBN S - f l 2 7 - ? m S - S
* **
*

"

* op *

OFFICE FOR OFFICIAL PUBLICATIONS


OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES
L2985 Luxembourg

9"789282"774151

You might also like