Professional Documents
Culture Documents
198465
April 22, 2015
LITEX GLASS AND ALUMINUM SUPPLY AND/OR RONALD ONGSITCO vs. DOMINADOR B. SANCHEZ
Labor Law; Abandonment; To constitute abandonment, it is essential that an
employee failed to report for work without any valid and justifiable reason
and that he had a clear intention to sever the employment relationship by
some overt act. Mere failure to report for work after notice to return does
not constitute abandonment.
Same; Reinstatement; An illegally dismissed employee is entitled to
reinstatement as a matter of right but when an atmosphere of antipathy and
antagonism has already strained the relations between the employer and
employee, separation pay is to be awarded as reinstatement can no longer
be equitably effected.
DEL CASTILLO, J.:
FACTS: Dominador B. Sanchez (Sanchez) was employed as a driver and an
aluminum installer in companies owned and managed by Ronald Ong-Sitco
(Ong-Sitco), the last of which was with Glass and Aluminum Supply (Litex).
On December 23, 2008, Sanchez claimed that Ong-Sitco and his wife
scolded and threw offensive words and criticisms upon him. Then, he was
ordered to go on indefinite leave. Hence, Sanchez left the work premises
with the hope that the hostility between him and his employer would sooner
or later be settled.
Days after, Sanchez went back to discuss to Ong-Sitco his employment
status but the latter just ignored him. After two similar attempts from
Sanchez, Ong-Sitco still refused to entertain Sanchez. Thus, Sanchez filed a
case for illegal dismissal and non-payment of holiday pay, premium for
holiday pay, service incentive leave pay and attorney's fees against Litex
and Ong-Sitco.
Subsequent to the filing of the said complaint, Sanchez received two
memorandum-letters which contain notices to report for work and to
explain the following infractions: 1) going home early without justification
on December 3, 2008; 2) exhibiting erratic behavior and threatening to file
a case after being summoned to explain his unjustified leave; and, 3)