Professional Documents
Culture Documents
July, 2013
08
Contract No.:
Contractor Name:
Date of Report:
Document Title:
July, 2013
Authors Name:
USAID Pakistan
The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views
of the United States Agency for International Development, the United
States Government or Chemonics International Inc.
Page | 1
DATA PAGE
Name of Component:
Environment
Business Enabling
Page | 2
ABSTRACT
Thisreport presents the draft tourism policy for KP, identifying
key priorities of the provincial government for the next few
years to develop the tourism sector as the priority sector and
transform it into an engine of economic growth by making KP
a preferred tourist destination.
Page | 3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DATA PAGE....................................................................................II
ABSTRACT....................................................................................III
LIST OF FIGURES...........................................................................V
ABBREVIATION.............................................................................VI
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.................................................................VII
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.................................................................VIII
WHY INVEST IN TOURISM?..............................................................X
1. BACKGROUND AND CONTEXT......................................................1
2. KEY ISSUES/CHALLENGES FOR KP TOURISM SECTOR.....................3
2.1 CROSS-CUTTING ISSUES.........................................................................4
2.2 SECTOR-SPECIFIC ISSUES.......................................................................6
3. KPS TOURISM POLICY RATIONALE............................................9
4. POLICY OBJECTIVES AND STRATEGIC THRUST.............................11
4.1 BUILDING BLOCKS FOR TOURISM DEVELOPMENT.............................................11
4.2 POLICY OBJECTIVES AND EXPECTED IMPACT...................................................13
4.3 KEY STRATEGIC THRUST AREAS..................................................................14
5. IMPLEMENTATION PLAN............................................................21
6. MONITORING & EVALUATION.....................................................23
APPENDIX A - IMPLEMENTATION MATRIX.......................................27
APPENDIX B - LIST OF PERSONS CONSULTED.................................37
APPENDIX C - DOCUMENTS REVIEWED...........................................40
Page | 4
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Challenges Impeding Growth of Tourism Sector in KP.............3
Figure 2: Building Blocks of KP Tourism Policy......................................13
Figure 3: KP Tourism Policy 2013-18 Policy Objectives and Expected
Impact............................................................................................14
Figure 4: Key Strategic Thrust Areas KP Tourism Policy 2013-18.......15
Figure 5: Resource Mobilization Plan....................................................20
Figure 6: Implementation Plan..............................................................22
Page | 5
ABBREVIATION
ADP
BOS
Board of Statistics
C&W
DoT
DTS
EPA
EnvironmentalProtection Agency
GDP
IMF
KP
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
M&E
MIS
NAVTEC
P&D
PAITHOM
PHYDO
PIA
PKR
Pak Rupees
PPP
PTDC
TA
Technical Assistance
TCKP
TDC
TDCP
TDKP
TICs
Page | 6
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This draft tourism policy has been developed through support from
USAID and presents findings evolved out of extensive consultations
with stakeholders from public and private sectorsof KP from tourism
and other allied sectors. The document also extensively relies on the
vision document for tourism sector developed by USAID, besides an
extensive literature review of various relevant documents. The key
priorities of the policy have been finalized by developing a position
paper first and carefully deliberating on the key policy choices
available to the government. The complete list of documents consulted
is also appended at the end. A number of stakeholders have provided
useful comments to develop this draft policy. The list of all persons
consulted is also annexed at the end. The Firms team members,
especially the BEE and Tourism Specialists also gave extensive input to
the team of consultants.
Page | 7
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Pakistan in general and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) in particular, blessed
with immense tourism potential, have also been endeavoring to fully
capitalize on this potential despite the security challenges faced by the
country. While the province of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa has three fourth of
the countrys tourism assets, with sites representing archeological,
cultural, historical and religious significance and attractive natural and
scenic beauty, the province has also been facing severe conflict and
security challenges. This calls for a renewed effort on governments
part to come up with innovative solutions to promote tourism in the
province and facilitate investment in the sector.
The tourism sector in KP has been facing a host of challenges that
have been impeding growth of the sector in KP. Some of these
challenges are cross-cutting, affecting the overall economy such as the
sluggish economic growth, unclear policy and institutional regime in
the wake of 18th constitutional amendment, poor law and order
situation and low public sector capacity to facilitate and regulate
private sector. On the other hand, there are also some serious sectorspecific issues affecting tourism sector such as limited availability of
information to monitor travel and tourism trends preventing planning;
low quality of workforce; low level of private investments; absence of
standards; poor infrastructure; limited and sub-optimal marketing
activities, etc.
Improving the tourism sector has been a priority for the Government of
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa to drive economic growth and make KP a
preferred tourism destination. While the government is committed to
create a robust facilitation and compliance tourism regime, built on
quality and image, the government also realizes that this is a long-term
goal and can only be achieved through a coherent well thought out
strategy. This tourism policy presents governments strategy to realize
this vision. This tourism policy envisionsto develop an internationally
competitive tourism sector to fully realize its diverse potential; making
tourism a leading economic sector for the province through publicprivate partnership. This vision would be realized through driving an
ambitious agenda for private-sector driven tourism development in the
province to propel economic growth and to make KP a preferred tourist
destination
The Government believes that through increased investments and by
ensuring a business and tourist friendly environment, the tourism
sector in the province can be strengthened, driving economic growth
as well as restoring peoples confidence in the region. A key in
Page | 8
Page | 9
Page | 10
Page | 2
Play the role of catalyst by providing level playing field for the
private sector
Page | 3
Cross-Cu ng
Issues
SectorSpecific
Issues
Low PrioritybyGovernment
Sluggish Economic Growth
Unclear Policyand Ins tu onal Regime
Poor Law and Order Situa on
Low Public Sector Capacity
Page | 4
Poor Law and Order Situation The armed conflict in KP has taken
its toll on the tourism sector and the security crisis in Swat and other
tourist areas in KP have created unprecedented damage. While the
situation has significantly improved in the last year, there is still a lot of
hesitation amongst tourists, especially the international visitors, to visit
tourism sites in KP. Furthermore, the heightened security situation has
also created procedural hassles in visa regimes, further discouraging
international tourists.
Page | 6
Followed by 2009 conflict, the 2010 flash floods and heavy torrential rains have
surpassed the physical destructions ever caused by all the disaster in Pakistan.
The catastrophe has impacted a wide population in Indus river basin starting from
North in Gilgit-Baltistan crossing KP, and Punjab and hitting down the Sindh
province. The unprecedented natural disaster has severely hit the human lives,
livestock, infrastructure, crops, and livelihoods in KP. The dynamics of this disaster
was such that life losses were less but the damage to public and community
infrastructure were beyond imagination.
According to the KP, Provincial Disaster Management Authority (PDMA) about
2000 km of major and link roads, 40 major bridges, 40 minor bridges, 150 health
facilities beside 158 buildings (including hotels, motels and restaurants) damaged
due to flood. The tourists destination of Swat and Chitral were declared among
worst and medium affected areas respectively. In Swat valley almost all the hotels
along the bank of river Swat were either partly damaged or completely wiped out.
At present USAID and World Bank are providing financial support through various
Page | 7
Page | 10
Page | 11
Page | 12
Page | 13
Page | 14
KP TourismPolicy
Robust Implementa on Plan
OrganicPlanning
Robust Compliance
StrongOwnership
Resource Mobiliza on
Public-Private Partnership
Clear Focus
Therefore the tourism policy addresses the wider issues related to the
tourism sector, ranging from regulatory and legal regime, workforce
development, infrastructure improvement, better service standards,
marketing and promotions, environmental and cultural conservation
and last but not the least a clear strategic thrust.
Over the next five years, the policy is expected to achieve this task
through strong public-private partnership, improved institutional
capacity, adequate resources and a coherent set of interventions in
short, medium and long terms. In particular, the policy will address
institutional issues that have traditionally impeded tourism
development in the province; capitalize on previous work done through
various policies and strategies developed over the last few years;
create an enabling environment; and bring about a paradigm shift in
governments role by making it a facilitator and a regulator, rather
than an implementer.
The key objectives of the tourism policy include:
1
Establish Khyber Pakhtunkhwa as a preferred
tourist destination, nationally in the short-tomediumtermand globallyin thelongterm.
5
Figure 3: KP Tourism Policy 2013-18 Policy Objectives and Expected
Impact
assurance; institutional and regulatory reforms; marketing and imagebuilding; workforce development; and resource mobilization.
Tourismand Allied
Infrastructure
Development
Resource
Mobiliza on
QualityAssurance
KP TourismPolicy
Workforce
Development
Marke ngand
Image-Building
Page | 19
The Tourist Guides Act would be revised in line with the above
statutes, besides introducing effective enforcement provisions.
Page | 20
F) Resource Mobilization
The implementation of this tourism policy would be reliant on
availability of adequate resources. The government realizes this need
Page | 21
Page | 22
Cost Cu ng
and Efficiency
Improvements
Protec ng
Public
Funding
through ADP
Thresholds
$
Private
Investment
through PPP
Revenue
Generated
from
Tourists
User Charges
Page | 23
Donor
Funding
5. IMPLEMENTATION PLAN
Tourism Development Committee The Government of KP would
formulate a high level Tourism Development Committee to spearhead
the implementation of this policy. The high profile committee would
generate enough momentum to provide strategic guidance on the
policy. DOT would act as the secretariat of the Tourism Development
Committee (TDC).
Role of DoTDoT is mandated by the Government of KP to drive the
tourism development agenda in the province and would support TDC
for this purpose. At present the DoT has weak institutional capacity
with limited resources. In order to implement this ambitious tourism
policy, the government would revitalize DoT to drive the reform agenda
and take a central role in building capacity of other organizations such
as TCKP, PAITHM, etc. and galvanize support and resources from
donors and other partners.
Capacity Development of DoTDoT is in need of some serious capacity
development support. For this purpose, the requirements will be
assessed and will be consolidated into a PC-I for seeking funding from
the government. DoT will then be staffed and resourced as per these
requirements.
TourismReform Leaders - In order to create a broad-based ownership of
the tourism policy, DTC will also nominate a Tourism Reform Leader for
each of the six strategic thrust areas. These leaders would be
provincial legislators and would ensure removing any hurdles in
reforms implementation and would advise DTC in devising appropriate
strategies to address key challenges.
Detailed Resourcing Plan - Once DoT is fully staffed and resourced, it
would also develop a detailed resource plan to fully implement the
tourism policy, in line with the broader plan given above.
Implementation Plan Sign-of - Although this implementation plan sets
up the broader framework for the tourism policy implementation and a
more detailed strategic area-wise implementation plan is also annexed
at this document, there is a need to further refine this plan. DoT will
therefore develop a detailed implementation plan for the Tourism
Policy. Based on this implementation plan, the responsibilities of each
organization/partner would be clearly delineated and signed off with
DTC with clear timelines.
TA Mobilization Plan -DoT will also develop a Technical Assistance
Mobilization
Plan.
Capacity
gaps
in
each
participating
organization/partner would be addressed through TA support provided
by DoT and international donors. International donor programs within
Page | 24
Page | 25
IMPLEMENTATIONFRAMEWORK
KHYBERPAKHTUNKHWATOURISM POLICY2013-18
Donor Coordina on
TourismDevelopment
Commi ee (TDC)
DoT
Technical Support /
Financing
PPP Arrangements
Governance
Governance
ReformChampions
Governance
ReformChampions
TourismReform
ReformChampions
Leaders
Coordina on
Financing
TA
M&E
Donors
Donors
QualityServices
Private Sector
PrivateSector
Service Providers
Service Providers
Tourists
Figure 6: Implementation Plan
Page | 26
meet
periodically
with
implementing
agencies/departments/partners to assess progress towards policy
objectives;
conduct field monitoring missions to gauge achievements and
constraints;
identify any lessons or good practices;
reflect on how well policy implementation is improving the
quality of tourism assets and services;
Page | 27
Page | 28
M&E
Component
Responsibility
Timefram
e
DTC (Through
DoT Support)
Q4 2013
M&E Unit/DoT
Q1 2014
DoT/TCKP
Q1 2014
Q1 2014
Monitoring
Committees
Q1 2013
M&E Unit @
DoT/ TCKP
All Partners
All Qs
All Qs
Activity
Monitoring
Establishment of MIS
Q4 2014
Annual Monitoring Report
Q4 2015
Q4 2016
Reviews / Assessments
Evaluations
Q4 2017
End Term Completion Report
Q4 2018
Baseline Evaluation
Q4 2013
Mid-Term Evaluation
Q2 2016
End-Term Evaluation
Q1 2019
M&E Unit @
DoT/ TCKP and
Other
Agencies/Partne
rs
DoT
Q1 2021
Impact Assessment
Page | 29
Studies
Page | 30
St
Q4
Q4
C) Nominate a Tourism Reform Leader for each of the six strategic thrust areas. These leaders
would be senior provincial legislators.
Q1
D) Complete the Resource Plan that will detail the resource requirements for delivering the cross
cutting policy reform measures, including governments resources, donor support, private
investment, etc.
Q1
II. DoT to develop a detailed implementation plan for the KP Tourism Policy 2013-2018. Based
implementation plan, the responsibilities of each partner would be clearly delineated and sig
timelines.
A) Development of detailed implementation plan.
Q4
B) Development of detailed responsibility matrix and sub-matrices for each participating partner.
Q4
Q1
Q4
Q4
Q4
Q1
IV. Communication Plan DoTwill drive a comprehensive communication plan addressing the
needs of the KP Tourism Policy 2013-2018
A) Comprehensive stakeholder mapping exercise, including both internal and external
stakeholders
Page | 31
Q4
B) Identifying communication needs for each stakeholder group (including whether its one-way or
two-way communication)
Q4
Q1
Q1
Q4
Q4
Q1
Q1
Q1
Page | 32
Future
I. Tourism and
Allied
Infrastructure
Development
1) Tourist Asset
Mapping
Interventions
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
Expected
Outcomes
DoT
Short term
A) Better stock of
existing facilities and
prospective sites
TCKP
B) Improved planning
C) Study Roll-Out
2) Rehabilitation
of Tourism
Facilities
DoT
TCKP
PPP Unit &
P&D
Short to
Medium
Term
Page | 33
A) Better tourist
facilities
B) Increased tourist
traffic
C) Investment in
tourism sector
Future
Interventions
3) New Tourist
Facilities
Development
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
Expected
Outcomes
DoT/TCKP
Medium to
Long Term
A) A) Better tourist
facilities
B) Increased tourist
traffic
C) Project Preparation
C) Investment in
tourism sector
PPP Unit
4) Allied
Infrastructure
Development/Im
provement
Planning and
Development
Medium to
Long Term
C&W
Department
Support by
DoT
D) Project Execution
D) Development of
new tourist localities
E) Economic growth
and income
generation
A) Better access to
tourist facilities
B) Increased tourist
traffic
C) Greater interest to
invest in sector
D) Higher investment
5) Existing
Leases/Public
Tourist Resorts
DoT
Short to
Medium
Page | 34
A) Better
management of
Future
Interventions
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
Expected
Outcomes
TCKP
Term
existing facilities
C) Transaction Execution
B) Better returns
D) Regulation of Contract
C) Incentives for
private sector to
invest
PPP Unit
D) More competition
and value for money
6) Improve
Electricity Supply
Energy and
Power
Department
Medium to
Long Term
PHYDO
7) Better Tourist
Facilitation
Services
DoT
DTS
Communicati
on &Works
Department
A) Tourist satisfaction
increased
B) Greater
investment
Short to
Medium
Term
C) Increased tourist
traffic
A) Tourist satisfaction
increased
B) Greater
investment
Page | 35
C) Increased tourist
traffic
Future
Interventions
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
Expected
Outcomes
1) Baseline
Assessment of
Quality and
Standards
BOS
Short Term
A) ToRs development
A) Improved planning
B) Mobilizing TA
B) Better quality
services and
improved tourist
satisfaction
C) Execution of study
D) Results presentation and decision
making by TDC
2)
VoluntaryService
Quality Codes
DoT
DTS
Short to
Medium
Term
3) Compliance
Regime
Implementation
DoT
DTS
Short to
Medium
Term
Page | 36
C) Increase in tourist
traffic
D) Greater
investment
Future
Interventions
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
Expected
Outcomes
DoT
DTS
Medium to
Long Term
5) International
Certifications
DoT
DTS
Medium to
Long Term
III.
Institutional
and
Regulatory
Reforms
1) Revisions on
Existing Laws
DoT
Law
Department
Short to
Medium
Term
Page | 37
Future
Interventions
2) Promulgation
of New Laws
(PPP Law)
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
Expected
Outcomes
P&D
Short to
Medium
Term
A) Private sector
interest
Finance
Department
B) Approval by legislature
C) Institutional arrangements
B) Investment in
sector
C) Risk reduction
through PPPs
D) Improved services
3) Capacity
Development of
DoT
DoT
Short Term
4)
Operationalizing
Statutory
Committees
DoT
Short Term
DTS
A) Agreement on membership of
committees
B) Notifications
C) Periodic meetings of the committees
5) Establishment
of Tourism
Development
Committee
Cabinet
DoT
Short Term
Page | 38
A) Better resourced
department
B) Improved sector
management
A) Broader
stakeholder decisionmaking
B) Greater ownership
A) Momentum for
reform
B) Top level
ownership
Future
Interventions
6) Capacity
Development of
Board of
Statistics
IV. Marketing
and Image
Building
1) Marketing and
Image-Building
Strategy
Development
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
Expected
Outcomes
BoS
Short to
Medium
Term
A) Better information
collection
P&D
DoT
DoT
TCKP
B) Mobilizing TA
C) Roll-out
Short to
Medium
Term
Improved image
B) Mobilizing TA
KP, becoming
preferred destination
C) Execution of study
DoT
TCKP
Short to
Medium
Term
A) ToRs development
B) Mobilizing TA
C) Strategy development
D) Results presentation and decision
making by TDC
E) Social media tools and platform
development
3) International
Fairs and
DoT
Short to
Medium
C) Impact
assessment more
objective
A) ToRs development
B) Improved planning
Page | 39
Future
Interventions
Exhibitions
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
TCKP
Term
Expected
Outcomes
V. Workforce
Development
4) Joint
Marketing
Campaigns with
Private Sector
TCKP
Short to
Medium
Term
5) Collaboration
with Railways
and PIA and
Pakistani
embassies and
other govt.
organizations
TCKP
Short to
Medium
Term
1) Capacity
Development of
PAITHM and
Other Training
Institutes
DoT
Short to
Medium
Term
2) Curriculum
Needs
Assessment and
Improvement
Plan
DoT
Railways
PIA
Foreign
Ministry
TCKP
B) Mobilizing TA
C) Roll-out
Short to
Medium
Term
A) ToRs development
B) Mobilizing TA
C) Study execution
D) Results presentation and decision
Page | 40
A) Better quality
workforce
B) Higher retention
C) Lower turnover
D) Greater tourist
satisfaction
E) Increase in
investment
Future
Interventions
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
Expected
Outcomes
making by TDC
3) Tourism Sector
Workforce
Assessment
Survey
DoT
BOS
Short to
Medium
Term
A) ToRs development
B) Mobilizing TA
C) Study execution
D) Results presentation and decision
making by TDC
VI. Resource
Mobilization
4) MoU and
Collaboration
with
International
Centers of
Excellence
DoT
1) Annual
Development
Fund Ceiling
TDC
TCKP
Medium to
Long Term
P&D
Short to
Medium
Term
DoT
A) Increase in
resource availability
B) Sub-statutory notifications
B) Greater private
investment
2) PPP Project
PPP Unit/P&D
Medium to
Page | 41
C) Better tourist
services
Future
Interventions
Pipeline
Responsibili
ty
Timefram
e
TCKP and
DoT
Long Term
TCKP
PPP Unit
Medium to
Long Term
4) Donors
Conference
DoT/TCKP/P&
D
Short Term
5) Efficiency
Improvement
Plan
DoT/DTS/TCK
P
Finance
Department
Short to
Medium
Term
Page | 42
Expected
Outcomes
Page | 43
Shah,
Administrative
Secretary,
Tourism
8. Mr. Hayat Ali Shah, GM, Special Projects, TDKP & TCKP
9. Mr. Muhammad Ali Sayed, GM Events & TICs, TCKP
10.
11.
Mr. Iftikhar, Deputy Secretary, Tourism Promotion, Bahrain,
Swat
12.
13.
14.
Page | 44
6. Mr. Hurmat Khan, In-Charge, Pak Austrian Institute for Tourism &
Hotel Management (PAITHOM), Golibagh, Swat
7. Mr. Javaid Iqbal, Regional Director, NAVTEC, KP
8. Mr. Sajad Ali Shah, Director, NAVTEC, KP
9. Mr. Bashir Khan, Additional Secretary Development, Finance
Department, KP
10.
Shahab Ali Shah, Chief
Development Department, KP
Economist,
Planning
and
11.
MianAsim Ismail, Chief Economic Analysis Section, Public
Policy and Social Reform Unit, Planning and Development
Department, KP
12.
Mr. JafferKohistani, Manager, Patriata chairlift/cable car,
TDCP, Murree, Punjab
FGD participants, mainly from the private sector:
13.
Mr. Zahoor Durrani, Vice President PATO for KP, MD Sehrai
Travel
14.
Said Nawab, President Tourism Promotion Association,
Madyan, Swat
15.
16.
BakhatBuland Khan, Sr. Vice President Hotel Association,
Bahrain, Swat
17.
Mr. Rasool
Association
Khan,
18.
Mr.
WaliRehman,
Association
General
Vice
Secretary,
president,
IslampuraKhadi
IslampuraKhadi
19.
Seth Matiullah, President, Tourism Promotion Association,
Kaghan
20.
Mr. Nawazish Khan, Sr. Vice President, Tourism Promotion
Association, Kaghan
21.
Mr. Asad Shah, Managing Partner, Nature Tourism Services,
& Executive Member, PATO, Abbottabad
22.
Col. Khalid Mahmood, Principal, Tourism Training Institute,
Abbottabad
23.
Mr. Hukum
Nathiagali
24.
Dad,
Vice
President,
Hotel
Association,
Page | 45
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
Muhammad Humayun, Manager Holiday Hotel, Madyan,
Swat
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
Amir
Association
Rasheed,
Finance
Secretary,
IslampuraKhadi
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
Mr. Arif Swati, Managing Partner, Nature Tourism Services,
Abbottabad
47.
Mr. Asif Javed, CEO, Tourism Training Institute (NITHHMS),
Abbottabad
48.
49.
Engr. Mohsin Khan, Marketing Director, Hotel Demanchi,
Naran
50.
51.
Mr. Noor Hussain Shah, Hotel construction contractor,
Nathiagali
52.
Page | 46
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
Page | 47
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
Final Report
a. Technical Vol.1: Medium Term Marketing Strategy
b. Technical Vol.2:
Considerations
Physical
Planning
&
Environmental
Page | 48