Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Grammar
Arif Saricoban & Esen Metin
arifs [at] hacettepe.edu.tr
Hacettepe University & Cankaya University (Ankara, Turkey)
Introduction
Grammar teaching has often been regarded as a structure based, formal activity. After the
integration of several sources and techniques, which are mainly based on communicative
activities, the teaching of grammar gained a new insight. In the teaching of grammar, techniqueresource combinations are often modified to structure-discourse match and if well developed,
they can be used effectively for all phases of a grammar lesson. In order to make a grammar
lesson effective, beneficial, and interesting a teacher should use some well-developed and
fascinating techniques in the classroom. In the present paper, the examples of such integrated
sources and techniques -the use of songs, verse, games, and problem solving activities- will be
clarified and several examples will be provided.
using traditional folk songs the base of the learners knowledge of the target culture can be
broadened. Correctly chosen, traditional folk songs have the dual motivating attack of pretty
tunes and interesting stories, plus for many students- the added ingredient of novelty (Hill,
1999:29). Most songs, especially folk songs, follow a regularly repeated verse form, with rhyme,
and have a series of other discourse features, which make them easy to follow.
In consequence, if selected properly and adopted carefully, a teacher should benefit from songs
in all phases of teaching grammar. Songs may both be used for the presentation or the practice
phase of the grammar lesson. They may encourage extensive and intensive listening, and inspire
creativity and use of imagination in a relaxed classroom atmosphere. While selecting a song the
teacher should take the age, interests of the learners and the language being used in the song into
consideration. To enhance learner commitment, it is also beneficial to allow learners to take part
in the selection of the songs.
Teaching Procedure
There are various ways of using songs in the classroom. The level of the students, the interests
and the age of the learners, the grammar point to be studied, and the song itself have determinant
roles on the procedure. Apart from them, it mainly depends on the creativity of the teacher.
For primary students, the best songs would be those that are either familiar to the children or
those, though maybe not familiar, which have an international nature, such as Old MacDonald.
Since there is not a strict teaching procedure, the teacher can mainly concentrate on what to teach
rather than on how to teach. For instance, while teaching them individual letter sounds or
spelling the words, the traditional camp song 'Bingo', or while teaching them counting 'Johnny
Works with One Hammer' will be useful. In order to make the songs more meaningful and more
enjoyable, motions can be added to the song which parallel the words of the song. Since most
children enjoy singing fun and nonsensical lyrics, using easy children songs will be useful.
Furthermore, choosing lively action songs through which they can dance or act while singing
will ensure a lively atmosphere.
For teenagers or adults in the intermediate or advanced level, it is better to use more meaningful
or popular songs, which not only review or introduce grammar points but also reflect cultural
aspects. At the primary level of singing the song, the prosodic features of the language is
emphasized. At the higher levels, where the practice of grammar points is at the foreground,
songs can be used with several techniques. Some examples of these techniques are:
Focus questions
True-false statements
Dictation
Discuss
Poems
Poems, like songs, contextualize a grammar lesson effectively. Since poetry is often spoken,
repeated, dealt with, and considered, it acts as an effective tool for practicing a specific
grammatical structure. Through repeating and considering the poem, the grammatical structures
become more deeply internalized. Thus, poetry not only provides a rewarding resource for
structured practice of grammar, but also a proper basis for review. If a poem that exemplifies a
particular structure is also a good poem, it engages the eye, the ear and the tongue
simultaneously while also stimulating and moving us; this polymorphic effect makes poetry
easier to memorize than other things for many students (Celce-Murcia and Hills, 1988:123).
Like songs, poems exaggerate the rhythmic nature of the language. Thus it is an important aspect
to be taught, since English is a syllable timed language with stressed syllables being spoken at
roughly equal time pauses, even in everyday speech. Similar to songs, poems have an enormous
linguistic value as they provide authenticity and cultural views. A poem's capacity to comfort the
reader or the listener also increases its effectiveness as a teaching resource. Once a poem or song
has been learned, they stay in the minds of the students for the rest of their lives, with all the
rhythms, grammatical features and vocabulary.
Poems may bring the use of creativity and the rhythm into the language classroom, though they
may also bring some difficulties. Poems are not constructed in a simple way and syntactically
they are at a higher level than prose, thus it might be very difficult for a foreign language learner
to comprehend them completely. As stated by Povey (cited in Celce-Murcia and Hills, 1988)
there are three main barriers for literature including poetry. They are linguistic, cultural, and
intellectual barriers. Linguistic difficulties are the problems caused by the syntax or the lexicon
of the poem. Cultural difficulties include imagery, tone, and allusion. At the intellectual level, the
students should be intellectual and mature enough to understand the theme of the poem. These
difficulties could be easily removed if the teacher provides a poem which is syntactically and
thematically appropriate to the level, age and the interests of the students. Thus, by removing or
minimizing the potential problems, poetry can provide an enormously rich, enjoyable and
authentic context for foreign language learners.
In the selection of a poem, the teacher should first consider the grammatical structure to be
presented, practiced, or reviewed, then the level and the age of the students, next the theme and
the length of the poem and its appropriateness to the classroom objectives. It is advisable to
select a poem from 20th century poets. As older poems often provide a more difficult lexicon and
syntax, and as they reflect some old-fashioned ideas, it is more convenient to use contemporary
poems than older ones. Poems, which reflect cultural themes, universal features, humanistic
values, or emotional aspects, will be more relevant to the foreign language learners. Finally,
through taking the classroom objectives into consideration, a teacher should effectively benefit
from poems as teaching aids.
Teaching Procedure
At the teaching stage of a poem, it is not advisable to talk about the meaning of the poem in
advance. Since they offer a reading and listening activity, poems could be presented through a
reading plan. At the pre-reading stage, students might be motivated through some enthusiastic
talks about poetry or the poet. Some necessary vocabulary can also be handled at this stage. At
the reading stage, in order to create images and stress the prosodic features, the teacher may want
the students to close their eyes while he/she is reading the poem. After the poem has been read at
least twice, it is better to elicit the primary responses of the students about the poem. Next, after
distributing the poem to students, students may be asked to read it either loudly or silently. In
order to practice the determined grammar point, students may be asked to paraphrase the poem.
Through transforming the verse into prose students get acquainted with the structure.
After easing the grammar and understanding the vocabulary, students get an idea about the theme
of the poem. Reading the paraphrased poem reinforces the grammatical structure under
consideration. Asking questions about context may follow the reading. Through asking Whquestions, providing additional information about the culture, and asking students to share their
experience with the subject matter, the cultural content of the poem becomes more real and vivid.
Words, pictures, and shared experiences can eliminate the gap that is created by different
cultures, as no one can deny that poems cannot always evoke the same sounds, sights, smells,
and associations for both native speakers and foreign language learners. After discussing the
surface content of the poem, students may again asked to close their eyes and visualize the poem
while listening to it.
As a follow-up activity a discussion may be held. After reviewing the plot of the poem and
providing adequate artful questions, the students will eventually discover the deeper meaning of
the poem. As being a facilitator, a teacher should always avoid telling the meaning. After each
student grasps his or her own meaning, it is proper to discuss the depth of the poem. In this
procedure, the teacher's aim is to support the students in their attempts to understand the poem
and make it relevant to their lives. Once they have understood it and perceived its relevance, they
will have no objection to practicing the poem or even memorizing it, for it will have become
special for them (Celce-Murcia and Hills, 1988:126). At the follow-up stage, providing the
determined structure, students may also be asked to write a poem about anything they want. In
such a procedure the four skills are effectively integrated to practice or present any grammar
point.
Since every class is different, teachers should creativity determine the teaching procedure. It is
not advisable to apply one procedure too strictly. A teacher should adopt the activities according
to the needs of the learners. However, it might not be very useful to use poems for young
students or for beginners. Instead of poems, using nursery rhymes or songs would be more
helpful since they provide more joyful and easier contexts. From pre-intermediate to advanced
levels, it is really beneficial to use either songs or poems. Several poems can be adopted from
contemporary poem books. The poems of the W.H. Auden, Robert Frost, Stanley Kunitz,
Delmore Schwartz, W.D. Snodgrass, Theodore Roethke, Gary Snyder, Richard Wilbur, and
Robert Lowell, etc. are suggested for the language teachers who want to use poems in their
grammar lessons.
The latest concern of the foreign language teachers is to make the students use the language
communicatively. After the realization of communicative competence , activities or techniques
that are task-oriented and that lead students to use the language creatively have gained
importance. Games and problem-solving activities, which are task-based and have a purpose
beyond the production of correct speech, are the examples of the most preferable communicative
activities. Such activities highlight not only the competence but also the performance of the
learner. Yet they are the indispensable parts of a grammar lesson, since they reinforce a formdiscourse match. In such activities the attention is on the discourse context.
Both games and problem-solving activities have a goal. Games are organized according to rules,
and they are enjoyable. Most games require choral responses or group works, whereas problemsolving activities (though they are structured) require individual response and creative solutions.
Games and problem-solving activities are generally used after the presentation, in the practice
part, because such communicative tasks can only be handled after mastering sufficient grammar
and lexical points.
Through well-planned games, learners can practice and internalize vocabulary, grammar and
structures extensively. Play and competition that are provided by games enhance the motivation
of the students. They also reduce the stress in the classroom. While playing games, the learners
attention is on the message, not on the language. In a way, students acquire language
unconsciously since their whole attention is engaged by the activity. By providing personal,
social, and cross-cultural issues to define, they sometimes simulate real life situations. Many
grammar games can be found in teaching grammar or course books.
There is a great overlap between games and problem solving activities. Though games generally
place an emphasis on competition and wining, they also require some type of problem-solving
activity. Like games, problem-solving activities have communicative purposes. Questions which
require students to use available evidence to reach a conclusion and the logic problems which
assist language learning by challenging students to demonstrate their understanding of English in
an interesting way are the types of problem-solving activities. In problem solving activities, the
problems are either based on real or imaginary situations. In the activities students are given a
real or an imagery situation, and they are expected to find solutions for the problems.
Games and problem solving activities can be used for all levels. By regarding the proficiency,
age and experience of the learners, appropriate activities might be applied successfully. It is also
important to design clear and easy directions for the games or the activities.
Through problem solving activities students utmost attention is to the detail and to the meaning.
The solution part of the problem can be used to generate any specific grammar point. In such
activities a teacher should act as a facilitator rather than a director. It is also possible to integrate
all skills in such activities. Reading or listening to a situation, a problem, or a question;
responding or commenting either through speaking or writing. It is also advisable to keep in
mind that such activities provide entertaining opportunities to practice thinking clearly while
focusing on the form unconsciously.
In sum, games and problem solving activities provide favorable usages for extended
communicative practice of grammar. They are both motivating and challenging. They encourage
students to interact and communicate. Through such activities students match the discourse with
the context of the game or the problem solving activity. So these activities create a meaningful
context for language use. The use of such activities both increases the cooperation and
competition in the classroom. Thus, potential classroom ideas come into being, and a successful,
joyful and enthusiastic learning is provided.
Conclusion
So far, the usage of songs, poems, games, and problem solving activities are clarified. The
advantages and some key points are explained. It is now more apparent that the teaching of
grammar can be supported effectively by using such resources. According to the needs analysis
of a classroom, several techniques can be integrated with such resources. Since teaching is a
developing art, which requires innovative and creative ideas to enrich its effectiveness, we must
not hesitate to use such resources in our classrooms. These resources can assist our teaching of
grammar while providing a relaxed atmosphere and motivated students. Such activities are
student centered, hence, by using them we give a chance to our students to express themselves,
enjoy themselves during learning, and use the reserves of their minds. As, it should be born in
mind that all these resources require the activation of both left and right hemispheres. Thus, we
let our students use their long-term memory and learn effectively during such activities. So there
is an undeniable fact that if our concern is to provide a successful and beneficial teaching, we
must not hesitate to use songs, poems, games, and problem solving activities, which bring the
structural, pragmatic, prosodic and communicative aspects of language together, in our language
classrooms.
Introduction
For the last two decades, EFL (English as a Foreign Language) methodology has been actively
considering the possibility of using music and songs in class The analyses of the recent EFL
literature on the problem in question (Graham, Murphey, Saricoban, Eken, Jedynak, etc.) makes
it possible to suggest that among the methodological purposes with which music, songs and
chants are used in class, it is possible to rank the following:
Practicing the rhythm, stress and the intonation patterns of the English language. (For
this, see the excellent works by Carolyn Graham).
Teaching grammar. In this respect songs are especially favored by teachers while
investigating the use of the tenses.
Teaching speaking. For this purpose, songs and mainly their lyrics are employed as a
stimulus for class discussions.
Developing writing skills. For this purpose a song can be used in a variety of ways--for
example, speculating what could happen to the characters in the future, writing a letter to
the main character, etc.
Theoretical Background
Though the list of publications devoted to the topic in question continues to grow yearly, and
though no one would doubt the potential of the songs and music as a springboard to students'
creativity, I think there are still several aspects in which music is overlooked in the classroom.
First, songs, especially chants, are very popular with teachers whose target audience are young
learners, while adult learners are less often exposed to songs. Secondly, though a song is an
inseparable unity of the music and its lyrics, it is the musical part that is constantly overlooked
and ignored.
My own teaching shows that songs can be effectively used in an intermediate class for the
purpose of teaching speaking to prospective EFL teachers. The main reasons for this are as
follows:
As a cultural phenomenon, songs can introduce students to the musical and cultural
patterns typical for the target language community.
Songs belong to a synthetic genre, which includes both lyrics, and music and these two
constituents may be used as a good incentive for speaking English in class.
Prospective teachers of English, in order to be able to use effectively songs in their own
teaching in future, should themselves be exposed to them in the context of a teacher
training program.
The question that any teacher who is willing to use music in class has to wrestle with is
'what kind of music and what particular songs should we choose from the "ocean" of
today's music?' A quick glance at the musical picture of modern society shows how
picturesque and colorful it is. When I use musical material in class for the first time, I
always choose the songs I know and love myself. This enables me to be more
emotionally persuasive as I expose my students to the songs and their interpretation of
them. Later, while encouraging students to choose the songs for discussions, I ask them to
follow the following criteria (though they are not free from being subjective):
o The song must be an example of a particular musical trend.
o There shouldn't be any form of violence in it.
o The song should contain a certain artistic image.
I have been incorporating songs into teaching EFL to prospective teachers of English for more
than 10 years and I have to admit with a certain degree of surprise and content, that the songs by
the "Beatles," though composed more than thirty years ago, generally appeal to the tastes of 1925 year-olds since they deal with such eternal problems as love, commitment and
parents/children relationships. One must also not forget to mention that the words are very
intelligible and easy to distinguish. They are deservedly considered to be classics of pop music,
from which different musical trends sprang up.
In my view, the main purpose of using songs in an advanced class should be for the development
of the students speaking skills and the promotion of their cultural competence. The model of
speech development through songs was worked out with the tasks mentioned above in mind.
This model should be comprised of three stages - preparatory, forming and developing - each of
them having its own logistics.
Preparatory
o Introductory talk: Micro-texts about different musical trends and history of the
Beatles
o Activities aimed at vocabulary development
Forming
o Listening and discussing songs; 7-step sequence:
1. Pre-listening tasks.
2. Listening to the song.
3. Answers to the pre-listening tasks.
4. Post-listening tasks.
5. Presentation of the text of the song. (Optional)
6. Second listening.
7. Song discussion.
Developing
o Discussing different problematic issues and music genres
o Tasks for using songs in English language teaching.
The aim of the first stage is to form lexical subskills of monological speech and to develop the
speech content. For this purpose students are encouraged to read texts, containing information
about different musical trends as well as musical reviews about various groups and singers, to
fulfill pre-reading and post-reading tasks. As an example may serve the pre-reading and post
reading activities that follow.
Rank the musical trends you like most in the decreasing order. Compare your list with the
one by your fellow student.
Read the beginning of the essays on different musical trends and match them with the
trend they refer to: Classical, Country, Electronica, Folk, Hip Hop/Rap, Pop, Rhythm and
Blues.
For the full texts of the essays visit the Art and Culture magazine (Music section) at
http://www.artandculture.com
It is at this stage that students do the activities aimed at vocabulary development, which also
create the basis for song interpretation at the next forming stages. Below follow some examples
of activities of this type.
a. Accompaniment
b. Song cycle
c. Motif/motive
d. Ballad
e. Bridge
5. Individual song on an album;(vb) to record a song.
f. Air
g. Oldie
h. Bubblegum
i. A cappella
j. Solo
9. Pop song from early ears.
k. Cut
10. (Slang) light, trendy, innocuous pop music.
l. Hook
11. Singing without instrumental backing.
m. Lip-sync (vb)
Music is an extremely powerful art. It may evoke a strong emotional response. Listen to
the song (choose any song you like ) and determine the mood the song evokes as well as
the feelings it arouses. Useful vocabulary: quiet, peaceful, active, buoyant, calm, restful,
happy, dreamy, mysterious, self-pitying, intimate, sad, somber, festive, joyful, etc.)
Music gives rise to our imagination and feelings. Bring to class several instrumental
pieces of different genres of your preference. Play them and compare the associations
caused by them among your fellow students. You may use the following phrases:
o It reminds me of ...
o It depicts the picture of ...
o While listening I can easily imagine ...
You may often hear somebody saying I like the voice of this singer." Describe the voices
of the singers you know, using the words given below.
o Deep, gentle, soft, fresh, clear, lyrical, expressive, nasal, guttural, hollow,
resonant, gruff, harsh, raucous, husky, mellow, metallic properly/not properly
placed.
It is possible to define the rhythm of a song in different words. Study the list of adjectives
below and use them in the sentences of your own while speaking about the songs you
prefer to listen to.
o Assured, distinct, crisp, regular, irregular, dense, scattered, impatient, regular
dance, abrupt, jaunty.
o Models:
Bring in class several songs you like and describe their vocal part with the help of the
useful vocabulary given below.
The second stage is aimed at formation of speaking skills while interpreting and discussing the
songs under consideration, with the 7-step sequence being used. (See the model above.)
As an example, let us consider the tasks fulfilled while working with the song "Yesterday."
Pre-listening questions: Who is on lead vocal and what instruments accompany him?
Post-listening questions:
What is it about the song that makes it sound like it comes from another time?
Listen to the song again. How would you describe the interaction between the singer's voice and
instruments in the song?
The song "Yesterday" is the most covered rock 'n' roll song of all time. More than 2.500
artisits (Frank Sinatra, Ray Charles among them) covered it. Listen to the recorded
version of the song "Yesterday" by Ray Charles. What differences in the manner of
singing and in the song over all can you point out? Which singer is more dramatic?
Choose a song you like most of all. Design your own activities for the 7-step sequence
(see above). Bring the song in class and encourage your fellow students to interpret and
discuss its lyrics, musical part and the artistic image created in the song.
The aim of the third stage of the presented model is to further develop speaking skills on the
topic 'Music" and to prepare students for using songs in the EFL classroom. At this stage students
are involved in less teacher controlled activities, such as: discussions, simulations and role-plays.
The examples of the questions for discussion as well as simulations might serve the following:
Should a teacher know and understand pop music in order to be able to discuss it with the
pupils; helping them to differentiate between original and well-written music from
second-rated ones of newly formed groups?
The task "Support or challenge the following statements" also serves the purpose of preparing
students for discussion about the modern perspectives of development in music:
Nowadays, young people prefer only that kind of music to which they can dance or just
talk to friends. It should be simple, cheerful and up-to-date.
The pop music rhythms may be new and vigorous, but they lack variety: it's the same
monotonous beat again and again. The tunes are mostly primitive and as easily forgotten
as picked up.
Todays pop music is at a crossroads. New and interesting composers and soloists have
appeared. Established styles have been replaced by new ones. Some groups are trying to
achieve alloys of different styles.
The concluding lesson on the topic may go in the form of a panel talk where students present
their points of view on trends in modern music, supporting their presentation by musical pieces
related to the discussion.
Since the ability of using the songs and music in class is an important constituent of the wouldbe teachers preparation, the third phase should also include training, so that prospective teachers
of English could have the knowledge and skill to do the following:
Critically evaluate songs with the purpose of including them in class activities.
To develop the skills mentioned above, it is possible to encourage the students to fulfill the
following tasks:
Study the song lyrics by your favorite group. Select those ones you believe would be
effective for language teaching while discussing the topics Friendship, Parents and
Children, Love in Song lyrics and Poetry.
Collect interesting stories about music and musicians. Explain why these texts may be
effective tools for language instruction; work out pre-reading and post-reading activities.
Select five pieces of music that belong to different musical genres; etc.
Listen to the song and think of the questions you could ask your pupils to help them
understand the song.
Conclusion
Concluding, I would like to mention that the system of activities presented above has the
character of a training model, which may be creatively extrapolated to different musical genres be that jazz, classic music, country music or any other.
References
Eken, D. K. 1996 Ideas for using pop songs in the English language classroom. In
English Teaching Forum, 34, 1, 46-47.
Jedynak, M. 2000 Using Music in the Classroom. In English Teaching Forum, 38, 4,
pp.30-32
Saricoban, A. & Metin, E. (October 2000). Songs, Verse and Games for Teaching
Grammar, The Internet TESL Journal, Vol. VI, No. 10, October 2000
http://iteslj.org/Techniques/Saricoban-Songs.html
The Internet TESL Journal, Vol. IX, No. 3, March 2003
http://iteslj.org/
http://iteslj.org/Techniques/Orlova-Songs.html