Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Comparative Review
A. ALTAMIRANO & A. BONDANI
Norwich Eaton S.A. de C.V., Mexico City, Mexico
D.F., Mexico
71
ADVERSE REACTIONS
T O FURAZOLIDONE AND
OTHER SELECTED DRUGS
Among 10,443 patients treated with furazolidone
who were cited in the 191 publications, 4760
(45.6%) were children ranging in age from a few
months to 15 years, and 1571 (15%) were adults.
The ages of the remaining 4112 patients (39.4%)
were not specified. Adverse reactions to the drug
were experienced by 8.3% (864) of the 10,443
patients. Some patients had more than 1 reaction;
the overall number of adverse reactions reported
was 1178.
Gastrointestinal reactions
By far the commonest adverse reactions to
furazolidone were gastrointestinal in nature-for
example, nausea and vomiting, nausea without
vomiting, abdominal pain, and diarrhea (Table
I). As shown in the table, the overall frequency
of gastrointestinal reactions in the total sample
was 8%. Such reactions were reported for 842 of
the 864 patients who experienced adverse reactions. Some of these patients had received doses
that were higher than the therapeutic doses of 5
to 7 mg/kg/day, and most of them had infectious
gastrointestinal diseases in which symptoms of
the disease could be difficult to distinguish from
an adverse reaction. Gastrointestinal intolerance
diminished if the drug was given with food.
The frequencies of gastrointestinal reactions
to furazolidone found in our survey compared
favorably with those reported for other drugs used
to treat gastrointestinal infections. The commonest gastrointestinal adverse reactions that
have been reported with chloramphenicol are
nausea and vomiting, diarrhea, anorexia, and
nausea without vomiting, with an overall occurrence of 10% (183,197). TMP-SMX has been
associated with nausea and vomiting, anorexia,
nausea without vomiting, abdominal pain, glossitis, stomatitis, and diarrhea at frequencies ranging from 3% to 26% (198-202). In two reports
the frequencies of adverse reactions to ampicillin,
including diarrhea, nausea, vomiting, and abdominal pain, ranged from 5% to 17%; pseudoTable I. Frequency of adverse gastrointestinalreactions
to furazolidone ( n = 10,443)'
Reaction
Nausea and vomiting
Nausea
Abdominal pain
Anorexia
Diarrhea
Heartburn
Regurgitation
Steatorrhea
No. of
reports
Frequency
443
165
126
56
35
13
2
1
1
842
4.24
1.58
1.21
0.54
0.34
0.12
0.02
0.01
0.01
8.06
(%I
=
number of patients treated with furszolidone in the literature reviewed.
72
No. of
reports
Frequency
75
31
24
3
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
140
0.72
0.30
0.23
0.03
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
1.34
(%I
Arthralgia
Backache
Itching
Serum sickness
Blurring of vision
Burning feeling in body
Deafness
Hypertonia
Impairment of vision
Angioneurotic edema
Total
No. of
reports
Frequency
35
7
3
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
0.34
0.07
0.03
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.56
1
1
59
73
("/.I
Dermatologic reactions
Dermatologic reactions are among the most
frequent adverse reactions associated with the
administration of drugs. Of these, exanthemas
(maculopapular, morbilliform, and erythematous
eruptions) are the commonest. However, their
frequency varies. One study reported that 2% to
3% of patients treated with any drug developed
such reactions (221); another reported that such
reactions occurred in 46% of 464 patients (222).
Because patients often receive several drugs
simultaneously, it can be difficult to attribute a
dermatologic reaction to a particular drug.
Adverse dermatologic reactions to furazolidone were observed in 56 of the 864 patients
who experienced adverse reactions-a frequency
of 0.54% in the total sample (Table IV). Skin
eruptions (40 reports) were commonest, followed
by pruritus (13 reports) and erythema multiforme
(3 reports).
In other studies the following frequencies were
reported for other drugs: TMP-SMX, 5.9%
(221,223); ampicillin, 5.2% (221,223); amoxicillin, 5.1% (224); gentamicin, 4.5% (224); sulfonamides, 1.7% (221); chloramphenicol, 0.6%
(221,223); and tetracycline, 0.4% (224). Metronidazole has also been associated with such reactions, but the frequency has not been determined
(212). One study found that quinacrine was
associated with yellow discoloration of the skin at
a frequency of 4% to 5% (210); two reports stated
that the drug was associated with exfoliative der-
reviewed. Cephalosporins and penicillins, including ampicillin, can cause anaphylaxis, and because
they are used extensively, they are responsible for
an incidence of reactions believed to be between
0.01% and 0.04% (219). Approximately 0.002%
of patients treated with these agents die of anaphylaxis (220). Sulfonamides and tetracycline
have also been associated with this adverse reaction (219). Although usually associated with parenteral administration of a drug, systemic
anaphylaxis also can occur after oral administration.
Serum sickness-a systemic allergic reaction
characterized by urticaria, angioedema, arthralgias with articular edema, fever, lymphadenopathy, and sometimes nephritis-is mediated by
IgG antibodies and usually appears a week or
more after treatment with the causative agent
has been discontinued (219). We found only two
reports of serum sickness after the use of fura- Table IV. Frequency of adverse dermatologic reactions
zolidone (184). The authors speculated that both to furazolidone (n = 10,443).
cases were related to tartrazine (yellow dye numNo. of
Frequency
ber 5 ) , formerly contained in tablets of the drug.
Reaction
reports
("/.I
Currently, furazolidone tablets manufactured in
Skin eruptions
40
0.38
the United States and in Latin America (under Pruritus
13
0.12
licensing of Norwich Eaton Pharmaceuticals, Erythema multiforme
3
0.03
56
0.54
Inc.) do not contain tartrazine. Both patients Total
were treated with corticosteroids, and neither
* n = The number of patients treated with furapatient had residual lesions. Serum sickness zolidone in the literature reviewed.
~~~~~~
~~~
74
aplastic anemia, chloramphenicol is the most frequently reported one (226); indeed, the most
important adverse reactions to chloramphenicol
involve the bone marrow. The incidence of aplastic anemia is low (1 in 21,000 to 1in 36,000 courses
of therapy) (226), but the fatality rate can be as
high as 70% (227). Other hematologic adverse
reactions that have been associated with chloramphenicol are hypoplastic anemia, bone marrow
inhibition, thrombocytopenia, and agranulocytosis (228).
One in 50,000 courses of treatment with quinacrine has been associated with aplastic anemia.
The risk of developing this condition after
exposure to quinacrine is reportedly 10 times
greater than it is without exposure (228). Other
blood dyscrasias associated with quinacrine are
hemolytic anemia and thrombocytopenia (225).
The hematologic reactions reported for TMPSMX include various types of anemia (e.g., aplastic, hemolytic, and macrocytic), coagulation disorders, granulocytopenia, sulfhemoglobinemia,
eosinophilia, thrombocytopenia, and leukopenia
(202,229,230). In one study the overall incidence
Hematologic reactions
In our review we found 38 reports of hema- of hematologic reactions to TMP-SMX was 15%
tologic abnormalities associated with furazo- (208). Adverse reactions to the sulfonamides are
lidone--0.36% of the total sample (Table V). similar to those observed with TMP-SMX (229).
Although no serious hematologic reactions
As Table V shows, leukopenia and changes in
hemoblobin were the two commonest reactions. have been recorded concerning metronidazole,
Most of the reactions listed were transient and significant neutropenia has been reported. Neuwithout clinical significance. No reports of bone trophil levels return to normal, however, when
marrow aplasia (aplastic anemia) were recorded. the course of treatment is completed (209). TetraOf all the drugs that may be responsible for cyclines have been associated with leukopenia,
hemolytic anemia, pancytopenia, and, in a few
cases, thrombocytopenia (225).
In our review we found four reports of hemoTable V. Frequency of adverse hematologic reactions
to furazolidone ( n = 10,443)*
lytic anemia associated with furazolidone in
deficient in glucose-6-phosphate
No. of
Frequency patients
dehydrogenase (69,127,134,153); the incidence
Reaction
reports
("/.I
of this reaction was 0.04%. Patients deficient in
Leukopenia
16
0.15
this enzyme who were treated with furazolidone
Changes in hemoglobin
9
0.09
did not always develop hemolytic anemia (or hepEosinophilia
6
0.06
Hemolytic anemia
4
0.04
atic abnormalities) (170,231, 232).
Anemia
Leukocytosis
Purpura
Total
1
1
1
38
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.36
Table VI. Frequencies of adverse cardiovascular, pulmonary, and oral/pharyngeal reactions to furazolidone
(n = 10,443)*
Reaction
Cardiovascular
Heart palpitations
Postural hypotension
Facial flushing
Tachycardia
Total
Pulmonary
Asthma
Acute pulmonary reaction
Total
Oral/pharyngeal
Coated or white,
fuzzy tongue
Dry mouth
Bitter taste in mouth
Cheiloses
Hyperemia, plus edema
of the tongue
Laryngitis
Total
No. of
reports
Frequency
4
4
0.04
0.04
0.02
2
12
0.02
0.11
0.06
0.05
0.11
11
2
2
1
1
1
1
8
(%)
0.02
0.02
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.01
0.08
75
76
Mortality
No deaths associated with adverse reactions
No. of
Frequency to furazolidone were reported in the literature
reviewed. This contrasted with reports about
Reaction
reports
(%I
other antimicrobial agents. For example, the
Hepatic
Committee on Safety of Medicines in Great Brit5
0.05
Jaundice
ain (247) stated that TMP-SMX was associated
Hepatic dysfunction
1
0.01
6
0.06
Total
with death in 85 patients, primarily after the
development of blood dyscrasias (50 reports) and
Renal
skin reactions (14 reports). Analysis of these
5
0.05
Abnormalities of urine
Oliguria or nephritis
1
0.01
reports showed that the death rate increased
Total
6
0.06
markedly with age. Ampicillin has been associ* n = The number of patients treated with fura- ated with death in 22 patients. Seven of the 22
zolidone in the literature reviewed.
reports involved colitis or pseudomembranous
colitis, and 4 involved skin reactions; the others
cited anaphylactic reactions, blood dyscrasias,
reported in connection with chloramphenicol, and superinfections (245,247).
Chloramphenicol has been associated with
quinacrine, and metronidazole (239,240).
Hypertensive episodes. Because furazolidone is deaths caused by aplastic anemia. The fatality
a monoamine oxidase (MAO) inhibitor in rate is higher when bone marrow aplasia is comhumans, it theoretically can precipitate a hyper- plete and those who recover have a high incitensive crisis if large doses of the drug are com- dence of acute leukemia (226,244). Several
bined with certain other M A 0 inhibitors or with authors (227,244) reported that neonates exposed
foods containing tyramine (241,242). If fura- to high doses of chloramphenicol may develop
zolidone is to be administered in larger-than- a severe reaction called 'gray syndrome', which
recommended doses or for longer than 5 days, results in the death of about 40% of affected
patients should be informed about the possibility patients. The aminoglycosides, including gentaof adverse reactions caused by MAO-inhibitor micin, have been associated with death resulting
drugs and certain foods.
from renal insufficiency and superinfections
Alteration of normal flora. According to the (244,245). Deaths secondary to sulfonamidearticles we reviewed (12,190,243), furazolidone induced skin eruptions (225) and to hepatic
does not alter normal flora. In contrast, ampicil- damage caused by tetracyclines (248) have also
lin, chloramphenicol, gentamicin, metronidazole, been reported.
neomycin, the sulfonamides, tetracycline, and
TMP-SMX have been associated with superinfections secondary to their effect on normal
IMPLICATIONS
flora (204,244-246). Although the effects of antimicrobial and antiprotozoal drugs on the intes- As this review demonstrates, most of the adverse
tinal flora are not precisely characterized as reactions to furazolidone described in the 191
adverse reactions, these effects are of great publications were mild, and only in rare cases
importance because they can predispose the did they necessitate discontinuation of treatment.
microorganisms to develop resistance to anti- Because most of the frequencies reported for
microbials and to superinfection by resistant bac- other antimicrobials and antiprotozoal agents that
teria or fungi. Vaginal, oral, pharyngeal, and are often used to treat gastrointestinal infections
even systemic infections caused by opportunistic were obtained from published sources other than
organisms may follow the use of broad-spectrum the 191 dealing with furazolidone, it is difficult to
antimicrobials, mainly in individuals who already make direct comparisons. However, we believe
that the frequencies listed for the other drugs
have some predisposing condition.
reactions occur.
The expanding body of literature on adverse
drug reactions in recent years provides evidence
that, in many cases, physicians d o not sufficiently
weigh the risks inherent in administering a drug
against the benefits of its use, A more thorough
understanding of the risks associated with various
drugs should serve as a deterrent t o the prescription of powerful agents for minor conditions.
REFERENCES
1. Phillips KS, Hailey FJ. J Int Med Res 1986, 14,
19-29
2. Chamberlain RE. J Antimicrob Chemother 1976,
2, 325-336
3. Carlson JR, Thornston SA? DuPont HL, West
AH, Mathewson JJ. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 1983, 24, 509-513
4. Rabin HR, Lockerby DL. In: Bryan LE, ed. Antimicrobial drug resistance. Academic Press,
Orlando, Fla., 1984, 317-344
5. Griffin JP, Weber JC. Acute Poison Rev 1986, 5,
23-55
6. Ponce de Leon E. Antibiot Med Clin Ther 1957,
4, 816-818
7. Neter E. Proceedings of the International Colloquium on Resistant Infections, New York, November 20-21, 1958, 6-11
8. Rettig JH. AMA Annual Meeting, Atlantic City,
N.J., June 8-12, 1959
9. Galeota W, Moranville BA. Student Med 1959,7,
240-246
10. Desiderio VC, Beem JR. Proc SOCExp Biol Med
1959, 100, 343-346
11. Baddeley H, Baird T, Fletcher F. Med Press 1959,
26, 172-174
12. Massa A. Br Med J 1959, 2, 1063-1065
13. Massa A. Antiseptic 1959, 56, 905-910
14. Marvhall M, Rogers GS. Q Rev Pediatr 1959, 14,
172-175
15. Kobari I. Taiiri T, Suchi H. Jikken Chuyo 1959,
329, 197-19916. Turnbull TA. Med Proc S Afr 1959, 5,423-425
17. Ochiai K. Shinryo 1959, 12, 1212-1216
18. Bliuger AF, Giller SA, Shenigson BS. Med Parazit
(Moscow) 1960, 29, 646-647
19. Ochiai K, Kamidoko H, Yamanaka T. Jikken Chiryo 1960, 343, 256-259
20. Lippi M, Stocchi F. Rassegna Ital Gastroenterol
1960, 2, 3-16
21. Baldelli P. Policlinico 1960, 67, 368-374
22. Muhoz de Tor0 0. Prensa Med Argen 1960,47,
3274-3277
23. De Fiori T. Minerva. Pediatr 1960, 12, 1114-1117
24. Colombo ML. Minerva. Pediatr 1960, 12, 11101114
25. Toriano CA, Fernandez RF, Gomez RA. Prensa
Med Argen 1960, 47, 2746-2749
77
78
79
80