Dharaidhar Jha Dated 01" August, 2015 T, ¢ $ ‘The Chaiman, iar State @ar Council, Gar Council Chavwan, Patna-400 001. ‘ Ref: Your invitation for participating in the farewell party on 01.08.2015 the honour of Hon'ble Shiri > (ie RRA es at SRI op wear G8 fcharerd Paka, ' This has a reference to your invitation to me under reference. Let me thank, SFitst the Bihar State Bar Council and your Rind self for extending the invitation to me. However, at the same time, I regret my inability to participate in the party for ‘various reasons, some which areas follows ou, being the leader of the Bar of the State, are aware of the written Rule for conducting the business of the High Court as also of the Subordinate Courts. The Rules pertaining to the administrative set up of the Subordinate Courts have in its centre the Judge In-charge. Sfiri L. Narasimha Reddy acting against the writen Rules which have been. formulated by the Full Court of the Patna High Court, arbitrarily and in-an authoritarian manzer abolished the post of the Judge In-charge from all judgeships and has appointed « Clerkin the Civil Courts as the Drawing and Disbursing Officer which is contrary to the written Rules. ‘Not onky thattheatonal policy on creation of any coltt anyutiere in tle terntory of India was oraited Keeping on vew the Supreme Court decision in AIT Infia judges “Asscation and. the reconmendevions of te Shetty Commission. s per the policy “ction no court could 6 created or established unless complete inftstructure 0 llaseets of running a court wes created bythe State Government. Te eration of the infastructure also takes inte account the appropriate and dignified sitting space ‘forthe advocates Besides the minima spat of fourroom quart for he judge of any rank, You must be aware ta Shi Rey acting. as the Chisf Justice of the at High Court threw tose polices ond decisions of the Supreme Court 0 the win and has in an arbitrary and anastforiaran manner created Sub-Ceisionat CCousswithout there being any infrastructure set up for te same and Iam sure You mewn that Primary Heath Cents, Kean Bhawans, Godowns fave een used toes Subdivisions Courts in alvost a Subdivisions where the Cvatory oF the Pimery rm tig Chambers forthe Presiding Officers of the Cour. Instead of at last four room qustterrehichi must als0 provide ax appropriate space for official residence, dingy aap eset jul officer whic isin ute Era of the ecngnized ners, principles polices adopted by the Chief Justices Conference and alco decided by the Infrastructure Committee of this High Court. Shri Reddy eld video conference with ad'aistice Judges and you may be surprise to Rnow that fe insisted upon. ther to Kirebouses to sit Judges and establish the Courts. Some of us ofways seconded. fim nsf show of syeopfancy. ‘Sirs Ryily di not fave enyimerst-though he ostensibhy intcated as if he ‘ven concerned to decentrlize the subordinate judiciary-to cater to the needs of the oor people as regards providing jstse to them Stiri Reddy was so impatient in thee matters that he had placed anagenca in te lst Full Court meeting in order toa cating Family Courts i the Sub-divsina! Headquarters By vesting powers of the ‘Family Court into a Magutrate or a Mansi, Te moto of Shiri Ryddy was not £0 provdejustice tote needy people hes mere interested in seeing fis mame wanton onaplague t0 be put up asthe mark.of narguration of a particular Sub-divisional cour, His Gefiavior was never like a Judge rather he Behaved as a politician. ‘ot only the abr, we orgarzeé te Centenary Celibrations ofthe Patne Sfgh Court on acing 10 years of is etbhiment. You wil be suprised’ t0 row thas 1 was the Claiman of one of the Committees, ie, te @andal and Occortion Committee andas soon ase ad drawn a mimute direing invitation of ovations from interested persons (partes by pointing out the rele of the High Gout im tie above ebalf, we were rot allowed to fold anotier sting of the Committee and Shri Reddy did everyifing himcelf and no one fnows what was the 0 fad epproved and ordered for the Aylerabad. It is not required to be pointel out to a person of your expe waiting that Gigger functiv od buen Feld in Patna by the High cour and no requirement of anything wns fail by ringing anyling from outside Guta or Bihar. We was sve tongued Gecaue he was unfairandnst fonest ‘is unfairness cou 6 appreciated fron one fact. Let your Kindelf go inside the Clif Justices Cour Roo to find tat the pointed photograph of Late Hfon'sle gusti Laxyni Kant Sha and other Judges whick were Rung up in that Court Room stend now remaved by Siri Reddy. You maybe eware that photegraphs are ung up inCourt Rooms ony when there fad been a lection of tha High Cour. Shri Reddy autedagainse the decision of the High Cort and in te most demeaning fashion only because fie was rioving under some caste conserations of kis under the advise of some of ts.J hye you since the 19% of Agus, 2003 when I joined the judgeship of aotas as the District Judge. ad te epponurity of working with you with close coaperation and: understanding. ‘We may come and so, institution fas to remain anit has to be respected. Institutional noms are the only guiding light under which a Judge has to act. A Judge is atvays subordinate to the Rubs. Dut Shri Rely fad no respect forthe Rules and he was acting as if he wes « ‘Moghal Guadshah’ who fiad been posted as the Chief usice of Patna High Court. This was the reason that he smasted the whole administration not onty of the High Court but of the sub-ordinate judiciary abo. With the advent of Shri Reddy as the Chief Justice of this great institution, adninistration suffered with steep escalation in cormiption aff around. ‘The State | “Ber Councit might have seogh pay ote Ki, But waste that at its ll advocates fad absuntal themselves from cour work. recent, Comeption and " ‘ramp. instead of decrying it or adding to bring these things the public vie wicitate persons who breed them by = indulyng ir tens Dow then we 6+ ai te ighethe menace? SS) ‘Trust, you will appreciate my pind of view and the facts which Ihave placed Sefore your Tre my opin, Shri Rody id not deserve mey participation in the feewell party which has ben organized fy youand the State Bar Cosncit ‘Thanking you again : males 4.) Q>) 57