Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contents
Acknowledgements 4
Introduction: What the future holds
11
18
Programme 19
Presentations 20
Acknowledgements
Together for Short Lives is grateful to all those who
contributed to The Future of Hospice Care: Implications for
the childrens hospice and palliative care sector event held on
2 July 2013 and who helped with the production of this report.
We are particularly grateful to Dr Heather Richardson, Laura
Hamblin and Steve Dewar from the Commission into the
Future of Hospice Care for their for their input, guidance and
support in developing and delivering the Together for Short
Lives event.
Thanks are also due to Roz Glover and Guy Privett for their
administration of the event.
Acknowledgements
Below is a full list of all the people who attended the event:
Emma Aspinall
Acorns Childrens Hospice Trust
Julie Atherton
Derian House Childrens Hospice
Professor Bryony Beresford
SPRU, University of York
Nick Borrill
Zoes Place Trust
Peter Branson
Forget Me Not Childrens Hospice
Dr Lynda Brook
Consultant in Paediatric Palliative
Medicine, Alder Hey
David Burland
Shooting Star CHASE
Richard Carling
Together for Short Lives
Dr Pat Carragher
Chair, APPM
Lizzie Chambers
Together for Short Lives
Elaine Conisbee
Shooting Star CHASE
Professor Sir Alan Craft
President, Together for Short Lives
Dr Finella Craig
Consultant Paediatric Palliative Care,
GOSH
Karen Dale
Julias House
Tracie Dempster
chYps from EllenorLions
Steve Dewar
Help the Hospices
Gill Dickson
Together for Short Lives
Wendy Dodds
Havens Hospices (Little Havens)
Susie Lapwood
Helen & Douglas House
Geoff Ellis
Rainbows Hospice for Children and
Young People
Peter Ellis
Richard House Childrens Hospice
Janet Ferguson
Eden House Childrens Hospice
Andy Fletcher
Together for Short Lives
Barbara Gelb
Together for Short Lives
Dot Gillespie
The Donna Louise Childrens
Hospice Trust
Ted Gladdish
Noahs Ark Childrens Hospice
Dr Richard Hain
Lead Clinician, Welsh PPM Network,
Childrens Hospital for Wales
Laura Hamblin
Project Manager to The Commission
into the Future of Hospice Care,
Help the Hospices
Anne Harris
Rainbow Trust Childrens Charity
Jane Houghton
Together for Short Lives
David Houston
Brian House Childrens Hospice
David Praill
Help the Hospices
Jennifer Provin
Iain Rennie Grove House Hospice Care
Tracy Rennie
East Anglias Childrens Hospices (EACH)
Dr Heather Richardson
National Clinical Lead at Help the
Hospices and Executive lead for
Commission
Claire Rintoul
Bluebell Wood Childrens Hospice
Jayne Saunders
Ty Hafan the family hospice for
young lives
David Savage
Helen & Douglas House
Steve Hoy
Demelza Hospice Care for Children
Ros Scott
Childrens Hospice Association
Scotland (CHAS)
Myra Johnson
Together for Short Lives
Liz Searle
Keech Hospice Care
Dr Victoria Lidstone
Consultant in Palliative Medicine and
All Wales Clinical Lead for Transition
in Palliative Care
Andy Smith
Havens Hospices (Little Havens)
Hugh Lowson
Chestnut Tree House
Carol Stone
chYps from EllenorLions
Tina McCrossan
Northern Ireland Childrens Hospice
David Strudley
Acorns Childrens Hospice Trust
Maria McGill
Childrens Hospice Association
Scotland (CHAS)
Jan Sutherland-Oakes
Claire House Childrens Hospice
Jennie McGivern
Alexander Devine Childrens
Hospice Service
Katrina McNamara
Together for Short Lives
Doug Morris
Parent Trustee of Together for Short Lives
Nuala OKane
The Donna Louise Childrens
Hospice Trust
Sheila OLeary
Martin House Childrens Hospice
Mike Palfreman
Haven House Childrens Hospice
David Pastor
Claire House Childrens Hospice
Linda Perry
Chestnut Tree House
Mark Smith
Naomi House and Jacksplace
Tom Tanner
Consultant
Sue Upton
The Js Hospice
Beth Ward
Demelza Hospice Care for Children
Jonathan Webber
Childrens Hospice South West
Jon Wheater
Richard House Childrens Hospice
David Widdas
Consultant Nurse Children with
Complex Needs, NHS Warwickshire
and NHS Coventry
Susan Wilson
Noahs Ark Childrens Hospice
Heather Wood
Rainbow Trust Childrens Charity
Acknowledgements
Introduction
What the future holds
Background
The Demos report Dying for Change1, commissioned by
Help the Hospices and published in 2012, highlighted that
hospices will need to adapt to meet the challenges and
opportunities facing them in the next 10-15 years. In order to
address the challenges highlighted by Dying for Change.
Help the Hospices established the Commission into the
Future of Hospice Care to enable a deeper exploration with
the sector of these issues with a view to enabling hospices to
be better equipped to address these challenges within their
own organisations.
The Commission into the Future of Hospice Care seeks to
create lively debate and critical consideration of the options
facing hospices.
Opportunities exist across the UK to improve the experience
of people who are approaching the end of their life, and that
of their families and carers.
Help the Hospices believes that hospices have a significant
role to play. We have established the Commission so that
hospices are informed about the opportunities available to
them to make this difference in the future.
The Commission is also considering how hospices need to
develop over the next three to five years to be prepared for
the challenges facing them in the future. It is acknowledged
that there is no single optimum model for hospices, so a
menu of options will be offered instead.
You can find out more about the Commission and its work
by visiting www.helpthehospices.org.uk/our-services/
commission/.
1. www.demos.co.uk/publications/dyingforchange
Introduction
Introduction
Section One
Morning plenary sessions
Dr Heather Richardson
National Clinical Lead at Help the Hospices and
Executive lead for the Commission into the Future of Hospice Care
Technology
We would be crazy not to recognise that what we do in
social and practical care could be done by other means.
The sector needs to embrace technology, for example
telemedicine and robotics over the next decade.
Financial
The health sector as a whole is already feeling the pinch
from a reduction in statutory funding. Many hospices are
struggling to come to terms with significant cuts in this most
important funding stream and are already doing a good job of
maximising what they get from engaging with communities.
2. www.skillsforhealth.org.uk/component/docman/doc_view/
327-sfh-full-uk-sector-skills-assessment-2011.html
Section One
Coordinated care
Key actions
Hospices must think hard about how they care for more
people with the same or fewer resources and do so by
thinking creatively and differently.
Section One
Dr Richard Hain
Lead Clinician, Welsh Paediatric Palliative Medicine Network,
Childrens Hospital, Wales
Specialisation
Providers of paediatric palliative care need to have a broader
understanding of what specialisation really means in the
context of childrens palliative care. It is about having the right
breadth as well as depth in specialist skills. Providers need
to be able to deliver a wide ranging set of services across
their multi-disciplinary team as well as providing access to
consultant level medical expertise.
All the levels of medical expertise need to be available to all
children because they will use a range of services differently
and at different times over the course of their illness, from
the generalist support of a GP; care from a paediatrician or
a paediatrician with a special interest in palliative care; all
the way to a specialist palliative care consultant. The ideal
scenario is to have the full range of services and access to a
high level of expertise.
Services
The report by Fraser and colleagues published in 20113
found that for every 100,000 children that attended hospital,
400 had potentially life-limiting conditions. This challenges
the myth that life-limiting conditions are extremely rare
amongst children. It was argued that given this new evidence
of much higher prevalence levels, that paediatric palliative
care consultants should be in proportion with the number of
adult palliative care consultants. The actual number of adult
palliative care consultants is 434, while there are just 15
paediatric palliative care consultants.
There are only 15 paediatric palliative care consultants.
Thats the same as the number of adult consultants
working in Dorset.
Section One
10
Section Two
Panel discussion: Are we ready
for the future? A response from
childrens hospice services
Chaired by: Steve Dewar
Consultant, Commission into the
Future of Hospice Care
The panelists
Nuala OKane
CEO, The Donna Louise Childrens Hospice Trust
Tracy Rennie
Director of Care, East Anglias Childrens Hospices (EACH)
David Pastor
CEO, Claire House Childrens Hospice
Peter Ellis
CEO, Richard House Childrens Hospice
The panel members were presented with a series of questions
about the sectors preparedness for the challenges it faces,
the models of care required and how those can be provided
into the future. This account provides a brief summary of the
discussion and responses from the four panelists.
Nuala OKane
CEO, The Donna Louise Childrens Hospice Trust
...often heard phrases like thats not what we do here,
or thats not what we do best, should be banned as they
mire the sector in feet of clay.
The childrens hospice sector is more than ready for change
and for providing more services for more children, young
people and families. The sector has done nothing but change
to meet the needs of families for 20 years, broadening criteria
and age ranges. However, the sector shouldnt disregard
the fact that some of the changes could be very challenging
and might meet opposition from within, from people who
want stability and find change uncomfortable. Staff must be
imbued with a positive attitude and preparedness for change.
Childrens hospices need to challenge themselves all the
time, questioning their models and their effectiveness and,
crucially, how they can reach the population who are not
currently using hospice services.
The Future of Hospice Care
Tracy Rennie
Director of Care, East Anglias Childrens
Hospices (EACH)
Hospices should resist all temptation to compromise
on quality.
Future services and funding for these services should be
based on the childs and familys needs rather than bed
occupancy. Robust evidence is required to establish the level
of need to inform the right services to meet this need.
We need a flexible model of care to meet need. For example,
the one-to-one model of care is non-negotiable for many
children with complex needs. Others may need two-to-one
or in some cases three-to-one depending on the complexity
of care required by some children and young people with lifelimiting or life-threatening conditions.
Childrens hospices should be proud of the quality of care
they provide and can demonstrate their value by showing
that their service is markedly different to that provided by
generalist services. While private providers may be able to
undercut childrens hospices, they may not be equipped
to provide the specialist care required and there are known
examples of them coming to hospices for help, six months
into a contract.
Section Two
11
David Pastor
CEO, Claire House Childrens Hospice
Go out and find the children not currently accessing
hospice services.
Childrens hospice services now need to make a paradigm
shift in their approach to the development of their services,
and address four key challenges:
To populate their organisations with staff who can deal with
change.
To sweat their assets to make the maximum difference to
children and their families.
To go out and find the children not currently accessing
hospice services.
To stop providing services where they are not working, and
develop services to replace them, rather than constantly
building new layers on existing services.
Peter Ellis
CEO, Richard House Childrens Hospice
There is no room for complacency in the sector.
Although childrens hospices remain high profile, they are
very expensive, reach only 16% of the children and young
people patient population and only give them a small
fragment of support throughout their lives.
There are three possible solutions for responding to the
changing needs of children and families:
1. Childrens hospice services cannot meet the challenges
on their own and must work together and with other
partners, establishing networks which can provide
learning and development resources for other
professionals to tap into, as well as a 24 hour advice
service. To do this, childrens hospices will need to
develop expertise, sustainable approaches, make staff
more resilient and recalibrate resources.
Section Two
12
Section Three
Afternoon plenary sessions
Preparing for the future
Robin Knowles CBE QC
Chairman of Together for Short Lives
and member of Commission
Steve Dewar
Consultant, Help the Hospices
Section Three
13
Section Three
14
Section Four
Priorities for childrens hospices
and palliative care services
Delegates were asked to contribute their ideas via their iPads
on how best hospices could prepare for the future and meet
the opportunities and challenges presented by the changing
needs of children, young people and families. Delegates
worked in small groups to respond to speakers main points
and to identify key issues that now need to be addressed by
the childrens hospice and palliative care sector.
Section Four
15
2. Workforce development
Section Four
16
Section Four
17
Conclusions and
next steps
A key message from the event is that there is a responsibility
for all those within the childrens hospice and palliative care
sector to seize the opportunity to look ahead and consider
how we can ensure that the sector is equipped to develop
and deliver the best possible care and support to children,
young people and families within services that are fit for the
future. Leaders, strategists and those with a governance
role must lead the way in their respective organisations by
stimulating debate at every level in order to explore the best
way of being prepared for the future delivery of services.
The themes that have emerged from this event will be critical
within the overall engagement of Together for Short Lives
with the childrens hospice and wider palliative care sector in
the forthcoming period. In the first instance, various events
have already been organised including for example the
leaders of care event in September 2013, the Hospice Chief
Executives meeting in October 2013, the medical models
event in November, the Leaders of Voluntary Sector in early
2014 and the Together for Short Lives UK wide 20:20 Vision
conference in March 2014.
18
Programme
The Future of Hospice Care: Implications for the childrens hospice
and palliative care sector, 2 July 2013
10.00 to 10.05 Welcome and introduction to the event
Barbara Gelb
10.05 to 10.35
Coffee
11.35 to 12.10
A response from childrens hospices: How ready are we for this future?
A panel discussion
Steve Dewer with Nuala OKane, David Pastor, Tracy Rennie and Peter Ellis
Lunch
13.30 to 13.45
Programme
19
Presentations
Presentation 1:
A glimpse of the future: making positive choices
Dr Heather Richardson
21
Presentation 2:
Numbers, needs and preferences: a childrens palliative care perspective
Dr Richard Hain
27
Presentation 3:
Some principles: Offered to help guide a journey into a complex future
Steve Dewar 41
Presentations
20
A glimpse of the
future: making positive
choices
Overview
The changing context in which we are
working
Some issues to which we must attend
Opportunities to take control of the
future
Technological advancements
Genetic/medical advancements
The economic context in which we
are working
Increasing competition
Societal shifts
Policy priorities
TFSL event June 2013
Presentations
21
Elderly people
Chronic illness
Cormorbidities including
dementia
People living alone
Access to informal carers
Technological
advances
Presentations
22
Increasing competition
Societal shifts
choice and control
Presentations
23
Presentations
24
Presentations
25
Thank you
Presentations
26
Introduction
Introduction
Specialisation: experts and expertise
Services: evidence and equity
Scepticism: objections and oppositions
Conclusions
Specialisation:
experts and expertise
Specialised must refer to the range of
relevant skills as well as their extent
Presentations
27
Extent of
specialist
expertise
Ideal
expertise
Adequate
Inadequate
expertise
Range of services
Inadequate
range
Ideal
range
Adequate
Ideal
expertise
D
Inadequate
range
Ideal
range
Adequate
Inadequate
expertise
The Future of Hospice Care
Presentations
28
Ideal
expertise
D
Inadequate
range
Ideal
range
Adequate
Inadequate
expertise
Ideal
expertise
D
A
C
Inadequate
range
Adequate
Ideal
range
Inadequate
expertise
Specialisation:
experts and expertise
Specialised must refer to the range of
relevant skills as well as their extent
All levels of specialisation need to be
available to all children with LLC
Presentations
29
Cons
PPM
Paed
WSI
Paed
GP
Course of illness
Cons
PPM
Paed
WSI
Paed
GP
Course of illness
Cons
PPM
Paed
WSI
Paed
GP
Course of illness
Presentations
30
Cons
PPM
Paed
WSI
Paed
GP
Course of illness
Cons
PPM
Paed
WSI
Paed
GP
Course of illness
Cons
PPM
Paed
WSI
Paed
GP
Course of illness
Presentations
31
Specialisation:
experts and expertise
Specialised must refer to the range of
relevant skills as well as their extent
All levels of specialisation need to be
available to all children with LLC
Services:
evidence and equity
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England)
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
4343
(=1:100,000)
64
(=0.05:100,000)
Presentations
32
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England)
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
4343
(=1:100,000)
64
(=0.05:100,000)
1 Fraser et al 2012
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England)
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
4343
(=1:100,000)
64
(=0.05:100,000)
1 Fraser et al 2012
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England) 2
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
4343
(=1:100,000)
64
(=0.05:100,000)
1 Fraser et al 2012
2 Census data 2001, 2011
Presentations
33
Services:
evidence and equity
It seems that the ratio of paediatric to
adult consultants in SPC should be
roughly the same as the ratio of
children to adults
that is, about 1:4
Presentations
34
Presentations
35
Presentations
36
Presentations
37
Services:
evidence and equity
Proportion of children with LLC is same
as proportion of adults with cancer
Compared with adults, dying children:
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England) 2
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
64
(=0.05:100,000)
1 Fraser et al 2012
2 Census data 2001, 2011
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England) 2
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
434
(=1:100,000) 3
64
(=0.05:100,000)
1 Fraser et al 2012
2 Census data 2001, 2011
3 NCPC Specialist Palliative Care Workforce Survey 2010
Presentations
38
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England) 2
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
434
(=1:100,000) 3
120 ?
(=1:100,000)
1 Fraser et al 2012
2 Census data 2001, 2011
3 NCPC Specialist Palliative Care Workforce Survey 2010
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England) 2
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
434
(=1:100,000) 3
60 ?
(=0.6:100,000)
1 Fraser et al 2012
2 Census data 2001, 2011
3 NCPC Specialist Palliative Care Workforce Survey 2010
Services:
evidence and equity
Adults
Children
Prevalence of LLC
(England)
400/100,000
(cancer)
400/100,000
(all LLC)1
Population (England) 2
42.0 million
11.7 million
No. of PM consultants
in 2010 (England)
434
(=1:100,000) 3
6
(=0.05:100,000) 4
1 Fraser et al 2012
2 Census data 2001, 2011
3 NCPC Specialist Palliative Care Workforce Survey 2010
4 Brit Soc Paed Pall Med Manpower Database 2006
Presentations
39
Services:
evidence and equity
The Future:
Challenges in Paediatric SPC
Understanding specialisation:
Conclusion
In 2013, we are a very long way
from being able to offer children
the same access to best quality
specialist palliative care
that adults can already expect.
Presentations
40
Some principles:
Offered to help guide a journey into a
complex future
Steve Dewar
Commission Support Team
My Stance
I have listened to the wider hospice sector
and heard the common dilemmas and
challenges.
My aim is to bring that narrative in the hope
that it strikes a chord and brings some
insight
The Context
As the complexity and the scale and scope
of need increases we need to question the
aspirations drawn from our values.
If we cant do everything then the question
becomes one of working to establish our
best contribution to enable the system wide
response that we know is valued.
Presentations
41
An Observation
Im struck by the range of services on offer:
the extraordinary ability at your best to
combine specialist and generalist care; to
offer personal and family support.
A Different Culture
This means becoming the best partner and
collaborator living with the discomfort and
the sometimes uncertain business of
negotiation with others.
My Offer
I offer six operating principles identified by
adult hospices as a starting point.
I offer four domains of uncertainty that
start to map out the challenges for a new
era of strategic leadership.
Presentations
42
Being a point
of
navigational
support
Managing
death and
dying
Providing
support
across the
family
Establishing
clear ambition
and role
across the
system of care
Managing
transition
Presentations
43
Establishing sustainable
funding
Cross hospice
partnerships to
liberate cost
effectiveness at
scale
Preparing
options that
can attract
social
investment and
or use of
personal
budgets
Negotiating
and
establishing a
sustainable
business
model for care
Considering
partnerships
with statutory
or private
providers
Negotiating
new outcome
based contracts
for system
wide
contribution
Exploring social
enterprise
models of
development
Building credible
engagement
Collecting
and sharing
data to
illustrate
expertise and
value
Demonstrating
flexibility in
the face of
local
accessibility
and quality
Becoming a
good partner
and
collaborator
across the
system
Developing a
collective and
authentic voice
that reinforces
local
discussions
Ensuring story
of future
responsibility
for users,
supporters,
staff and
trustees
Demonstrate
benchmarking
to illustrate the
effective use
of resources
Enabling staff
and volunteers
to work across
a dispersed
system of care.
Investing in
system wide staff
development and
system wide data
to support best
care
Establishing
clear systems
of
organisational
support
Identifying and
growing a
confident and
skilled workforce
that meets
contribution
Enabling clear
sense of
direction for
trustees,
supporters,
partners..
Presentations
44