Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NE UROSCIENCE
In the blink of an I
Douwe Draaisma is impressed by a study on the science behind maladies of the self.
3 2 | NAT U R E | VO L 5 2 4 | 6 AUG U S T 2 0 1 5
literature. Linking experiences with experiments, and individuals with numbers, Ananthaswamy bridges that gap convincingly.
Possibly the most harrowing malady of the
self is Cotards syndrome, in which a person,
often with severe depression, believes that he
or she has died. Ananthaswamy presents the
case of 48-year-old Graham. After a failed
attempt to electrocute himself, he became
convinced that he was brain dead. Scans
showed severe loss of activity in the frontal
and parietal regions of the brain structures
supporting the default mode network, which
allows one to remember and maintain the
feeling that there is an I that acts and experiences. Investigators speculated that antidepressants or depression could dampen
activity in these brain areas but held that neither hypothesis could explain the extent of
the lowered metabolism. Cotards syndrome
is philosophically unsettling, because it questions the axiomatic
certainty of the CarteNATURE.COM
sian I think, therefore For more on science
I am. Yet, Ananthas- in culture see:
wamy observes, there nature.com/
must still be an I that booksandarts
Books in brief
Katrina: After the Flood
Gary Rivlin Simon & Schuster (2015)
Ten years ago this month, New Orleans lay drowning, its levees
breached by the storm surge from Hurricane Katrina. One million
people were displaced and, despite federal preparedness exercises,
the administration responded sluggishly. Journalist Gary Rivlin
sweeps from street to boardroom in this history of the aftermath,
studded with figures such as polarizing New Orleans mayor Ray
Nagin and seething with egregious political failings that deepened
racial inequality during the citys recovery. As Rivlin sharply reminds,
overcoming disasters is very much an issue of governance.