Professional Documents
Culture Documents
doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2011.03192.x
SUMMARY
Purpose: To evaluate long-term seizure outcome in children with epilepsy and a focal or hemispheric neuroimaging abnormality.
Methods: All children (<18 years and residing in Olmsted
County, Minnesota) with new-onset epilepsy diagnosed
between 1980 and 2004 and a single focal lesion on neuroimaging were identified by review of the Rochester Epidemiologic Project database. Outcomes were divided
into three categories: (1) seizure freedom for 1 or more
years at last follow-up, (2) ongoing seizures but not medically intractable epilepsy, and (3) medically intractable
epilepsy or undergoing epilepsy surgery. We also evaluated the proportion who achieved seizure control without
surgical intervention and whether lesion type predicted
intractability.
Key Findings: Of the 359 children with newly diagnosed
epilepsy, 37 (10%) had a focal or hemispheric lesion on
neuroimaging. Median age of diagnosis was 89 months
(25th percentile 26 months, 75th percentile 142 months)
and at follow-up was 137 months (25th percentile
95 months, 75th percentile 211 months). Eighty-three
percent of children with malformations of cortical
1522
1523
Outcome of Epilepsy in Childhood with Focal Lesion on Neuroimaging
selecting patients who have poorly controlled seizures (Semah & Ryvlin, 2005). No study has assessed long-term outcome in a population-based cohort of children documented
to have a focal lesion on neuroimaging at initial diagnosis of
epilepsy. One prospective study in patients seen at a single
epilepsy center examined the success of medical therapy
alone in patients with localization-related epilepsy and
found that the nature of lesion predicted control. The poorest
control was seen with mesial temporal sclerosis (42%) followed by malformations of cortical development (54%),
tumor (63%), infarct (67%), and vascular malformation
(78%) (Stephen et al., 2001). In another hospital-based
observational study of adults, Semah et al. (1998) also
found mesial temporal sclerosis to be a poor prognostic
factor.
The aim of this population-based, retrospective study was
to evaluate what proportion of children with epilepsy and a
potentially resectable lesion on neuroimaging (focal or
hemispheric) achieved seizure control without surgical
intervention and whether lesion type predicted intractability.
Methods
Case identification
Cases were ascertained by screening of the complete
diagnostic indexes of the Rochester Epidemiology Project.
These indexes include inpatient diagnoses, as well as diagnoses at the time of outpatient and emergency room visits at
all medical care facilities in Olmsted County, MN. All
charts were screened using a diagnostic rubric, which
included all seizure and convulsion diagnosis codes, and all
identified charts were reviewed by a pediatric epileptologist. We identified all children aged 1 month through
17 years with new-onset epilepsy diagnosed while residing
in Olmsted County, Minnesota, between 1980 and 2004.
Epilepsy was defined as a predisposition to unprovoked
seizures (Fisher et al., 2005). Most subjects had two or more
unprovoked seizures. However, patients with a single
unprovoked seizure who had evidence of an enduring alteration of the brain that increases the likelihood of further seizures (Fisher et al., 2005), and who were commenced on
antiepileptic drug treatment, were also included. An abnormal neurodevelopmental examination, focal abnormality on
brain imaging, initial presentation in status epilepticus, or
specific EEG findings (epileptiform discharge, intermittent
rhythmic focal delta activity) were considered indicative of
an enduring alteration of the brain that increases the likelihood of further seizures. Patients who were treated after a
single seizure, but who lacked any of the preceding features
were excluded. We included children who had two afebrile
seizures occurring within 24 h, as these children likely have
epilepsy (Camfield & Camfield, 2000). Children presenting
with acute symptomatic seizures alone (defined as seizures
in close temporal association with an acute neurologic
insult) were excluded. Similarly, children who had only
febrile seizures were excluded. Children with neonatal seizures were included only if their seizures recurred >28 days
after birth.
Classification of neuroimaging studies and patient
selection
Lesions detected on neuroimaging were categorized by
location (generalized, multifocal, hemispheric, frontal, temporal, parietal, and occipital) and presumed etiology (malformation of cortical development, mesial temporal lobe
sclerosis, tumors, vascular malformation, infarct, or other).
Neuroimaging reports for all cases were available, and
where possible, original neuroimaging studies were
reviewed by two epileptologists (EW and GC) for confirmation of lesion location and etiology. Only patients with single
focal or hemispheric lesion on neuroimaging [brain computed tomography (CT) or MRI] believed to be responsible
for their epilepsy were selected for study. Mesial temporal
lobe sclerosis was defined on the MRI as hippocampal formation atrophy and an increased mesial temporal T2-signal
intensity. Hippocampal formation atrophy is most obvious
using the T1-weighted gradient-echo image in the obliquecoronal plane. The high signal intensity alteration can be
identified using T2-weighted imaging or the fluid attenuated
inversion recovery (FLAIR) sequence in the oblique-coronal
plane (Cascino, 2008). Malformation of cortical development was defined on the MRI as focal cortical thickening,
blurring of the graywhite matter junction, and hyperintensity (on T2-weighted images) of subcortical white matter
tapering toward the ventricle (Colombo et al., 2003).
Chart review and data analysis
Medical records of selected cases were reviewed to determine outcome with or without epilepsy surgery at last follow-up. Outcomes in each of the etiologic categories were
stratified into three groups: (1) seizure freedom for 1 year
at final follow-up (on or off antiepileptic medications), (2)
ongoing seizures but not medically intractable, and (3) medically intractable epilepsy or undergoing epilepsy surgery.
Medically intractable epilepsy was defined as having
seizures more frequently than every 6 months during the
year prior to final follow-up, and failing two or more antiepileptic drugs for lack of efficacy.
All data entry and statistical analysis was performed
using PASW Statistics 18.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL,
U.S.A.). Correlations were examined using the Fishers
exact test (two sided table). p-Values <0.05 were considered
statistically significant.
This study was approved by the institutional review board
of Mayo Clinic, Rochester.
Results
Three hundred fifty-nine children were newly diagnosed
with epilepsy between 1980 and 2004 while residing in
Epilepsia, 52(8):15221526, 2011
doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2011.03192.x
1524
R. Dhamija et al.
Olmsted County. The mode of onset and etiologies of
seizures in this population has been previously reported
(Wirrell et al., 2011). All children except three were seen on
at least one occasion by a child neurologist who confirmed
the diagnosis of epilepsy. Of the remaining three, two were
diagnosed with epilepsy by a general neurologist and one by
a pediatrician. Prophylactic antiepileptic drug therapy was
commenced in 339 patients, whereas 20 were never treated.
Forty-nine were started on medication after their first
afebrile seizure, and of these, 34 had subsequent seizures
despite medication. Fifteen had only a single seizure, but
had one or more features predicting higher rate of recurrence (specified in Methods) and were commenced on
antiepileptic drug therapy without recurrence.
MRI became available in our center in 1984. Prior to
that, neuroimaging was performed with CT scanning,
which arguably could have missed important epileptogenic
lesions such as mesial temporal sclerosis or certain malformations of cortical development. Over the period of our
study, use of MRI in our entire cohort of new-onset pediatric epilepsy increased, being done in 17 (38%) of 45
patients diagnosed from 19801984, 33 of (53%) 62 diagnosed from 19851989, 47 (67%) of 70 diagnosed from
19901994, 73 (82%) of 89 diagnosed from 19951999,
and 77 (83%) of 93 diagnosed from 20002004 (p < 0.01).
Overall, in our cohort of 359 cases of new-onset pediatric
epilepsy, neuroimaging was performed in 329 (92%) cases,
247 of whom had MRI, and 82 of whom had CT only. Of
those who had MRI, 40 had generalized or multifocal
abnormalities and 36 had either focal or hemispheric
abnormalities. Of those who had CT scans only, 14 had
generalized or multifocal abnormalities and only 1 had a
focal or hemispheric abnormality. In summary, 37 (10%)
were found to have a focal or hemispheric lesion on
neuroimaging responsible for their epilepsy.
Our cohort included 25 male and 12 female patients.
Median age of diagnosis was 89 months (25th percentile
26 months, 75th percentile 142 months) and at follow-up
was 137 months (25th percentile 95 months, 75th percentile
211 months). The clinical details of the patients at presentation and last follow-up are listed in Table 1.
Original imaging studies were reviewed in all but four
cases, as they were no longer available. Etiologies on imaging included encephalomalacia (n = 12), malformations of
cortical development (n = 6), mesial temporal sclerosis
(n = 9), vascular malformations (n = 6) [cavernous hemangioma (n = 2), arteriovenous malformation (n = 2), thrombosed arterial aneurysm (n = 1), Sturge-Weber syndrome
(n = 1)], tumor (n = 2) [ganglioglioma (n = 1), fibrillary
astrocytoma (n = 1)], and other (n = 2) [hypothalamic hamartoma (n = 1), calcified granuloma (n = 1)]. Table 2
summarizes the epilepsy course of patients with each presumed etiology.
Of the six patients with malformations of cortical
development, 5 (83%) were either medically intractable or
Epilepsia, 52(8):15221526, 2011
doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1167.2011.03192.x
1525
Outcome of Epilepsy in Childhood with Focal Lesion on Neuroimaging
Table 2. Detailed description of epilepsy course in different etiologies
Etiology
Epilepsy course
Median follow-up (months)
25th percentile, 75th percentile
Median age at diagnosis (months)
25th percentile, 75th percentile
Surgical treatment
Seizure-free
Intractable
Median follow-up (months)
Medical treatment alone
Seizure-free
Intractable
Median follow-up (months)
MCD
n=6
MTS
n=9
131
(86, 177)
35
(<1, 150)
4/6 (67)
2/4 (50)
2/4 (50)
131
2/6 (29)
1/2 (50)
1/2 (50)
165
234
(133, 260)
115
(67, 173)
5/9 (56)
4/5 (0)
0
260
4/9 (44)
3/4 (75)
1/4 (25)
135
Encephalomalacia
n = 12
150
(85, 189)
85
(31, 121)
3/12 (25)
2/3 (67)
1/3 (33%)
191
9/12 (75)
7/9 (77)
1/9
149
Tumor
n=2
108
51
2/2 (100)
1/2 (50)
1/2 (50)
Vascular malformation
n=6
129
(69, 176)
134
(5, 191)
3/6 (50)
2/3 (67)
1/3 (33%)
122
3/6 (50)
1/3 (33)
0
135
surgery. Compared to the other etiologies, encephalomalacia was significantly less likely to correlate with this outcome (p < 0.012).
Discussion
In our population-based cohort of new-onset pediatric
epilepsy, 10% had a focal neuroimaging abnormality that
was felt to be responsible for their epilepsy. Encephalomalacia was the most common abnormality (32%), followed by
mesial temporal sclerosis (24%), malformation of cortical
development (16%), vascular malformations (16%), and
tumor (5%). In previous surgical series of children with epilepsy, malformations of cortical development have been
found to be the most common cause of medically intractable
focal onset epilepsy (Lerner et al., 2009). The difference
likely relates to our methodology. We identified a population-based cohort of newly diagnosed children with epilepsy, then selected for study both medically and surgically
treated patients with lesional neuroimaging. Of this cohort,
we found that the presence of encephalomalacia has the
most favorable outcome and predicts the least likelihood of
being intractable or undergoing surgery.
Previous studies have reported that mesial temporal sclerosis is associated with a high likelihood of intractable epilepsy (Semah & Ryvlin, 2005). Surprisingly, in our cohort,
one third of patients with this etiology were seizure-free at
final follow-up with medical treatment alone after prolonged follow-up. Similar to prior reports, we found that
surgical outcome is favorable with this etiology, with 80%
achieving seizure-freedom (Shaefi & Harkness, 2003;
Wieser et al., 2003; Mihara et al., 2004; Nakase et al.,
2007; Smyth et al., 2007; Spencer & Huh, 2008).
Surgical outcomes are typically less favorable for malformations of cortical development, with reported rates of seizure freedom of 49%, 44%, and 33%, respectively, at 1, 2,
1526
R. Dhamija et al.
is small sample size. Such size limits our ability to detect
statistically significant difference in the outcome of children
among the different etiologies.
We conclude that although finding a focal lesion on neuroimaging in a child with newly diagnosed epilepsy portends a higher risk of medical intractability, outcome is not
always bleak. Medical management alone was associated
with seizure freedom in nearly one third of cases, particularly if the etiology is encephalomalacia. Larger populationbased studies are needed to confirm whether lesion etiology
predicts outcome.
Disclosure
Dr. E. Wirrell serves on the Editorial Boards for Epilepsia, Canadian
Journal of Neurological Sciences, and Journal of Child Neurology. Dr. G.
CascinoResearch Grant: Neuro Pace, Inc. (coinvestigator); Honoraria:
American Academy of Neurology; Research Grant: National Institutes of
Health R01NS053998 (principal investigator); Associate Editor: Neurology
(published by the American Academy of Neurology). The remaining
authors have no relevant relationships to disclose.
We confirm that we have read the Journals position on issues involved in
ethical publication and affirm that this report is consistent with those guidelines.
References
Berg AT, Shinnar S, Levy SR, Testa FM, Smith-Rapaport S, Beckerman B.
(2001) Early development of intractable epilepsy in children: a prospective study. Neurology 56:14451452.
Camfield P, Camfield C. (2000) Epilepsy can be diagnosed when the first
two seizures occur on the same day. Epilepsia 41:12301233.
Camfield C, Camfield P, Gordon K, Smith B, Dooley J. (1993) Outcome of
childhood epilepsy: a population-based study with a simple predictive
scoring system for those treated with medication. J Pediatr 122:861
868.
Cascino GD. (2008) Neuroimaging in epilepsy: diagnostic strategies in
partial epilepsy. Semin Neurol 28:523532.
Colombo N, Tassi L, Galli C. (2003) Neuroimaging of focal cortical dysplasia. Am J Neuroradiol 24:724733.
Dlugos DJ, Sammel MD, Strom BL, Farrar JT. (2001) Response to first
drug trial predicts outcome in childhood temporal lobe epilepsy.
Neurology 57:22592264.
Fisher RS, Van Emde Boas W, Blume W, Elger C, Genton P, Lee P, Engel J
Jr. (2005) Epileptic seizures and epilepsy: definitions proposed by the
International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) and the International
Bureau for Epilepsy (IBE). Epilepsia 46:470472.
Goyal M, Bangert BA, Lewin JS, Cohen ML, Robinson S. (2004) Highresolution MRI enhances identification of lesions amenable to surgical
therapy in children with intractable epilepsy. Epilepsia 45:954959.
Hauser WA, Rich SS, Lee JR, Annegers JF, Anderson VE. (1998) Risk of
recurrent seizures after two unprovoked seizures. N Engl J Med
338:429434.
Kwan P, Brodie MJ. (2000) Early identification of refractory epilepsy.
N Engl J Med, 342:314319.
Lerner JT, Salamon N, Hauptman JS, Velasco TR, Hemb M, Wu JY,
Sankar R, Donald Shields W, Engel J Jr, Fried I, Cepeda C, Andre VM,
Levine MS, Miyata H, Yong WH, Vinters HV, Mathern GW. (2009)
Assessment and surgical outcomes for mild type I and severe type II
cortical dysplasia: a critical review and the UCLA experience.
Epilepsia 50:13101335.
Mihara T, Matsuda K, Tottori T, Otsubo T, Baba K, Nishibayashi H, Inoue
Y, Yagi K. (2004) Long-term seizure outcome following resective
surgery at National Epilepsy Center in Shizuoka, Japan. Psychiatry Clin
Neurosci 58:S22S25.
Nakase H, Tamura K, Kim YJ, Hirabayashi H, Sakaki T, Hoshida T. (2007)
Long-term follow-up outcome after surgical treatment for lesional
temporal lobe epilepsy. Neurol Res 29:588593.
Phi JH, Cho BK, Wang KC, Lee JY, Hwang YS, Kim KJ, Chae JH, Kim IO,
Park SH, Kim SK. (2010) Longitudinal analyses of the surgical
outcomes of pediatric epilepsy patients with focal cortical dysplasia.
J Neurosurg Pediatr 6:4956.
Roper SN. (2009) Surgical treatment of the extratemporal epilepsies.
Epilepsia 50(Suppl. 8):6974.
Semah F, Ryvlin P. (2005) Can we predict refractory epilepsy at the time of
diagnosis? Epileptic Disord 7(Suppl. 1):S10S13.
Semah F, Picot MC, Adam C, Broglin D, Arzimanoglou A, Bazin B, Cavalcanti D, Baulac M. (1998) Is the underlying cause of epilepsy a major
prognostic factor for recurrence? Neurology 51:12561262.
Shaefi S, Harkness W. (2003) Current status of surgery in the management
of epilepsy. Epilepsia 44(Suppl. 1):4347.
Sisodiya SM. (2000) Surgery for malformations of cortical development
causing epilepsy. Brain 123(Pt 6):10751091.
Smyth MD, Limbrick DD Jr, Ojemann JG, Zempel J, Robinson S, Obrien
DF, Saneto RP, Goyal M, Appleton RE, Mangano FT, Park TS. (2007)
Outcome following surgery for temporal lobe epilepsy with hippocampal involvement in preadolescent children: emphasis on mesial
temporal sclerosis. J Neurosurg 106:205210.
Spencer S, Huh L. (2008) Outcomes of epilepsy surgery in adults and children. Lancet Neurol 7:525537.
Stephen LJ, Kwan P, Brodie MJ. (2001) Does the cause of localisationrelated epilepsy influence the response to antiepileptic drug treatment?
Epilepsia 42:357362.
Von Oertzen J, Urbach H, Jungbluth S, Kurthen M, Reuber M, Fernandez
G, Elger CE. (2002) Standard magnetic resonance imaging is inadequate for patients with refractory focal epilepsy. J Neurol Neurosurg
Psychiatry 73:643647.
Wieser HG, Ortega M, Friedman A, Yonekawa Y. (2003) Long-term
seizure outcomes following amygdalohippocampectomy. J Neurosurg
98:751763.
Wirrell EC, Grossardt BR, Wong-Kisiel LC, Nickels KC. (2011) Incidence
and classification of new-onset epilepsy and epilepsy syndromes in
Olmsted County, Minnesota from 19802004: a population-based
stduy. Epilepsy Res 95:110118.
Woermann FG, Vollmar C. (2009) Clinical MRI in children and adults with
focal epilepsy: a critical review. Epilepsy Behav 15:4049.