You are on page 1of 18

25/03/2015

Breeding for carbohydrates

Luisa Trindade

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Plant components

Primary
metabolites

Carbohydrates

Lipids

Membranes
Oils, waxes

Proteins and free aminoacids


Secondary metabolites

Easily degradable sugars: starch, sucrose, fructans


Insoluble sugars: plant cell walls: (hemi) cellulose, pectin

Vitamins
Flavonoids / terpenoids

Water and minerals

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

25/03/2015

Program for today

Easily fermentable sugars:


Starch: potato
Sucrose: sugarbeet and sugarcane
Fructans: grasses

Plant cell walls


Maize as a model

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Starch

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

25/03/2015

Starch crops

The main sources of starch are Europe are:


Cereal crops
Rice
Maize
Wheat
Potato

The Netherlands is the largest


producer world wide
Potato is the major starch crop in The
Netherlands

...in other part of the world other crops are used: e.g
cassava, taro...
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Breeding targets in starch crops

Starch yield
Starch composition
Starch granule size
Starch properties

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

25/03/2015

Breeding for starch yield

What are the key factors behind starch yield?


1. Starch synthases expression play a (small) role depending on
the crop and growth conditions
Overexpression of glycogen
synthases in wheat lead to
increase in starch content:
in line 72 only at high
temperature
In line 79 at both high
and low temperature
In this approach the biosynthesis of starch is stimulated/induced
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Reference: Burrell. J Exp.Bot. 54(382): 451-456

Breeding for starch yield


2. Very recently reported: starch content is inversely correlated
with sugar content in potato:
High sugar content ->Low starch content
in the tuber

The sugars are probably originary from


starch.

This approach focuses on reduction of


starch degradation

What are the factors that influence starch


degradation?
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

25/03/2015

Breeding for starch yield

In approach 1 - target
genes in red

Synthases

In approach 2 target
genes in blue

Phosphorylation
Amylases
Debranching

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Reference: Schreiber et al. 2014. 4 (10): 1797-1811

Breeding for starch content in potato

What are potato characteristics:


Potato is a cross pollinator
Tetraploid (most varieties)
Highly heterozygous
Clonally propagated crop

Tools available
Genome sequence
Genetic maps of different diploid
populations and markers for
different traits

Starch content is correlated with


underwater weight
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

25/03/2015

Breeding for starch content in potato

Traditionally breeding for starch content targeted:


High yield of tubers
High underwater weight

Breeding methods
1. Crosses between diverse genotypes
2. Selection of genotypes with good performance (for both
yield and resistance to Phytophthora)

3. Different rounds of selection and generation of elite lines


4. Clonal propagation of elite genotypes

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Breeding for starch content in potato

Current/modern breeding for starch content targeted:


High yield of tubers
High underwater weight

Breeding methods: Marker assisted selection


1. Identification of genetic markers (QTLs) for the above traits

2. Identification of strong alleles


3. Introgression of the right alleles in elite lines

Future breeding: make use of diploid lines


Bioresource (PBR 31306)

25/03/2015

Starch quality

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Starch quality

Starch needs to be derivatized before it can be used for


different application
modified starch
pregelatinized
acid-thinned
oxidized

hydroxyalkyl ethers
esterified

monophosphates

treatment
(example)
heat/moisture
acid
hypochlorite

advantage

food use

non-food
use

cold-water soluble

pie fillings, instant products,


coatings
gums, jellies

oil-drilling,
mining

low hot paste


viscosity, high gel
viscosity
increased clarity,
reduced set-back

gravy, sauces
thickeners,
jellies

propylene
oxide
acetic
anhydride

increased clarity and


stability

salad dressings,
pie fillings

reduced set-back,
increased clarity,
forms films/fibres

instant foods,
frozen foods

phosphoric
acid

increased stability
to freeze/thaw
cycles
increased stability
to heat, pH, freeze
/thaw cycles
increased cold-water
solubility/dispersability, increased
binding to negatively
charged materials

frozen foods,
infant formulae

cross-linked

phosphorous
oxychloride

cationic starches

tertiary or
quaternary
amines

wide range of
canned and
frozen foods

textiles,
laundry
starch
paper, textiles, spray
starch,
adhesives
paper and
textile sizes
textiles,
paper,
packaging,
film
paper, textiles, metal
refining
paper, metal
sequestrants
paper, mining

Derivatization implies:
Use of chemicals
Energy
Reduces the quality of
starch
Improvement of starch in
plant has many
advantages:
Environmental impact
Improve quality of
starch
More economical

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

25/03/2015

Starch granule composition

Amylose: 20-30%
Mw. 5105 to 106

Amylopectin: 70-80%
Mw. 107 to 108

Proteins
Lipids
Phosphate

Contaminating
substances

Possibly starch modifications

Amylose and amylopectin ratio


Size of the granules
Length of the amylopectin chains
Phosphate content
Protein and lipids content
Expression of heterologous proteins:
New polymers
New linkages

25/03/2015

Potato amylose free starch

What happens when you remove amylose?


Interesting breeding target!!

Bakery creams ( 20% expensive alginates)


Fruit filling (shiny texture)

Powdered soups, sauces & processed


meat products (salt stability)

Noodles
(hydration at lower
temperatures)

Snacks ( crispness)

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Breeding for amylose-free potato

How do you identify amylose


free lines?

Based on phenotype
Wild type

Amylose-free

Iodine staining

Based on genotype
Search for lines where
GBSS has been mutated

Induce mutations in GBSS


(Tilling)
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

25/03/2015

Breeding for amylose-free potato

Breeding strategy: mutation breeding (non-GM)


As potato is a highly heterozygous and tetraploid crop it is
difficult to combine all the desired traits in one genotype

One tool is to do the first breeding steps in diploid (or even


monoploids) to generate a line homozygous for non-functional
GBSS

Introduce the non-functional GBSS in an elite line (this can


take many years!)

A GM approach is much faster and effective in this case

Amflora
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Attempts to breed for high-amylose


starch in potato

Advantages of high amylose


starches:

Form strong gels


Applications in jelly-gum
candies and coating of
deep-fried foods

No 100% amylose potato


could be achieved
Probably lethal

Large impact on tuber yield


Bioresource (PBR 31306)

10

25/03/2015

Starch phosphate content

Where is P in starch?
Amylopectin: C3 and C6 positions

What is the effect of P on starch prop.?


Higher phosphate content
High swelling power
Increased solubility
Resistance starch effective in lowering glycemic index

Low phosphate content


Higher digestibility
Low viscosity
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Breeding for phosphate content

The genes involved in phosphorylation of starch are


known: GWD (glucan-water dikinase), PWD
(phophoglucan water dikinase)

Phosphatases are known: sex4 (starch excess)


Phosphate content is not only important for starch
properties but for survival of plant:

Paradox:
P is needed for starch for degradation in the plant
P is reducing digestibility of starch in humans

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

11

25/03/2015

Breeding for phosphate content

Breeding approach: Reverse genetics (candidate gene)


Breeding strategy:
1. Alleles of GWD, PWD and SEX4 have been identified in a wide
collection of potato genotypes

2. These same genotypes have been characterized for P content


3. Alleles correlating with high or low P content have been
identified

4. Epistatic effects of starch phosphorylation are being analysed


(specially effect of reduced P on yield)

5. Positive and strong alleles will be introgressed in potato elite


lines
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Tailoring of potato starch (GM)


CBM25
Streptococcus downei
Mutansucrase gtfi

L. mesenteroides
Dextransucrase
dsrs

A. thaliana
Water dikinase

E. coli
Branching
enzyme (GlgB)

L. mesenteroides
Alternansucrase asr

Human - Laforin
Bacterial Glucansucrases

Expression of different heterologous proteins lead to changes in


starch granule morphology and properties of starch
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

12

25/03/2015

Sugarbeet

Crop characteristics:
Cross pollinator
Most commonly diploid and tetraploid
Originally self-incompatible
Root has high sucrose (sugar) content

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Sugar content in sugar beet

History:
Modern sugarbeets are originated from selections made in the
middle of the 18th century from fodderbeets grown in then
German Silesia

Breeding of sugarbeet was intensified during the blockade of


shipments of cane sugar to Europe by the British during the
Napoleonic wars

The sugar extraction process developed in the 19th century has


created a market for sugarbeet and thus breeding of this crop
enforced

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

13

25/03/2015

Breeding sugarbeet

Breeding of the first varieties of sugar beet ware done by


mass selection

These varieties were followed by better ones produced

by anisoploid (triploid) synthetic varieties resulting from


crossing diploid and tetraploid lines
Diploid male sterile x tetraploid pollinators

Current sugarbeet varieties are diploid hybrids


1. Making diploid inbred parents containing the required traits
(sugar content, resistance to pathogens, and sugar quality)

2. making hybrid seeds


Synthetic: refers to varieties that result from crossing of multiple (>2) parents

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Breeding sugarbeet

Breeding targets:
Total root yield
Sucrose yield
More recently breeding
for sugar quality has
become a target.

Current yield in The Netherlands:


Average root yield ~ 60 tons/ha
Average sugar yield ~ 10 tons/ha (16%)

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

14

25/03/2015

Sugarcane

Perennial grass

Genetics: 2n=80 chromosomes

Breeding is a great challenge!!

Comprises 6 species but Saccharum


officinarum is the major contributor of
high sucrose in modern varieties

Contains a lot of duplications and


unpaired chromosomes

Breeding targets:

Sugar yield!
Ratooning performance, resistance to
pathogens, low fibre, cane yield.

Further reading: Jackson. 2005. 92: 277290

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Breeding sugarcane

Breeding of sugarcane happen in three phases:


1. Crossing and selecting among S. officinarum clones: these
varieties had high sugar content and low fibre content, but
they were susceptible to diseases and lacked vigour

2. Development of interspecific hybrids between S. officinarum


and other species (mostly S. spontaneum): these were
vigorous and with good ratooning performance but they had
lower sucrose levels. By backcrossing the hybrids with S.
officinarum rubust high-sugar-high-yielding varieties were
generated: wonder cane (ancestry of all modern varieties)

3. Exploitation of interspecific hybrids from phase 2 by recurrent


selection

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

15

25/03/2015

Breeding sugarcane

Most modern varieties are made from a small number


of original progenitors

Narrow genetic basis of sugarcane breeding programs

Limited possibilities for introgression or improvement


of new traits

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Breeding sugarcane

Sugar yield/ha has increased


But...that was not to increase
in sugar content but due to
improvements in total
biomass yield

Future:
Increase genetic basis in
breeding programs

Developing genetic markers


for different positive and
negative traits
Bioresource (PBR 31306)

16

25/03/2015

Fructans in plants

Fructans are the major form of storage carbohydrates in grasses:

Are important to sustain regrowth of the plant after defoliation


Nutritive value of feed
When extracted can be used as sweeteners as humans are not
able to degrade fructans

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

Breeding fructans in wheat

Genetic markers (QTLs) for fructan yield in wheat grain have been
(recently) identified

Breeding strategy: Marker


Assisted Selection (MAS)

Identify the genes underneath


these QTLs would create tools
for breeding in other crops

Bioresource (PBR 31306)

17

25/03/2015

Summary

Starch, sucrose and fructans are the main storage forms of easily
degradable sugars and they are specific to each crop.

Each crops has different characteristics and different


genetic/breeding tools are available this determines breeding
strategy

Breeding for sugar/starch content is often indirect. The real target is


crop yield

Starch biosynthetic pathway is well characterized and starch quality


has been mainly tackled using candidate gene approaches both GM
and non-GM.

Breeding of polyploids (potato and sugarcane) is much more difficult


than diploids species

One (future) line of potato breeding is through diploids


Bioresource (PBR 31306)

18

You might also like