Antitrust Case Chart

Morgan Fall 2006

Page 1 of 6

Horizontal Arrangements

First Period
1890 1914
Price
Fixing

TransMissouri
(1897)
Addyston
Pipe
(1898)

Second Period
1915 1939
Rule of
Reason
-

Market
Division

Group
Boycotts

Chicago Bd.
of Trade
(1918)
American
Lumber
(1921)
Standard Oil
(Indiana)
(1931)
(patent pool)
Trenton
Potteries
(1927) (per
se)
Appalachian
Coals (1933)

Third Period
1940 1973
Per Se
-

Eastern
Lumber
Dealers
(1914)

US Steel
(1920)

Addyston
Pipe
(1898)

Standard
Oil NJ
(1911)
Terminal
RR (1912)

Monopol
ization

SoconyVacuum (1940)
Container
Corp. (1969)

Modern Period
1973 Present

Timken Roller
Bearing (1951)
Topco (1972)

Fashion
Originators
(1941)
Radiant
Burners (1941)
Klors v.
BroadwayHale (1969)
(vertical group
boycott)
Topco (1972)
ALCOA (1945)
Griffith (1948)
United Shoe
(1953)
EI DuPont
(1965)
Lorain
Journal (1951)
(unilateral
refusal to deal)
Utah Pie
(1967)
(predatory
pricing)

Goldfarb v. VA
State Bar
(1975)
Natl Society
of Engineers
(1978)
BMI (1979)
Catalano v.
Target Sales
(1980)
NCAA (1984)
Texaco v.
Fauad (2006)
(joint-venture)
Polk Bros.
(1985)
Jay Palmer v.
BRG (1990)
NW Stationers
(1985)
Rothery v. Atlas
Van Lines
(1986)

Aspen Skiing
(1985)
(unilateral
refusal to deal)
Verizon v.
Trinko (2004)
(unilateral
refusal to deal)
Matsushita v.
Zenith (1986)
(predatory
pricing)
AA Poultry
(1989)
(predatory
pricing)
Brooke Group
v. B&W (1993)
(predatory

Attempt
to
Monopol
ize
Merger

Swift & Co.

(1905)

Northern
Securities
(1904)

Antitrust Case Chart

Morgan Fall 2006
Page 2 of 6
pricing)
- Le Pages v.
3M (2003)
(predatory
conduct)
- Confederated
Tribes v.
Weyerhaeuser
(2005)
(predatory
buying)
- Microsoft
(2001)
(predatory
conduct)
- Spectrum
Sports v.
McQuillan (US
1993)
-

Brown Shoe
(1962)
Philadelphia
National Bank
(1963)
Vons Grocery
(1966)
Penn-Olin
(1964) (joint
venture)
El Paso Gas
(1964)
Continental
Can (1964)
Proctor &
Gamble (1967)
(conglomerate)
Falstaff
Brewing
(1973)

General
Dynamics
(1974)
Kraft (1995)
FTC v. Staples
(1997)
FTC v. Heinz
(2001)

Antitrust Case Chart

Morgan Fall 2006
Page 3 of 6

Vertical Arrangements

First Period
1890 1914
Resale
Price
Maintena
nce

Dr. Miles
(1911)
(minimum)
Colgate
(1919)

Second Period
1915 1939
Rule of
Reason
-

General
Electric
(1926)
(patent)

Third Period
1940 1973
Per Se
-

Territoria
l
Allocatio
n

Vertical
Integrati
on
(Merger)
Exclusiv
e
Dealing
(Require
ments
Contract
s)
Tying

Parke-Davis
(1960)
Simpson v.
Union Oil
(1964)
General
Motors (1966)
Albrecht v.
Herald (1968)
(overruled by
State Oil v.
Khan 1997)
White Motor
(1963)
(remands case
to see what
impact of the
restraints would
be on
competition)
Schwinn
(1967)
(overruled by
GTE Sylvania
in 1977)
Albrecht v.
Herald (1968)
Columbia Steel
(1948)

Modern Period
1973 Present
-

Monsanto v.
Spray-Rite
(1984)
Business
Electronics v.
Sharp (1988)
State Oil v.
Kahn (1997)

GTE Sylvania
(1977)

Jefferson
Parish
Hospital
(1984)
Kodak v. ITS
(1992)
Illinois Tool v.
Independent
Ink (2006)

Tampa Electric
(1961)
Standard Oil
(CA) (1949)

Intl Salt
(1947)
Times
Picayune
(1953)
Northern
Pacific RR
(1958)
Loews (1962)

Fortner (1969)
(but on
remand, found
not to be
illegal)

Tying in Franchise
- Carvel (1964)
- Chicken
Delight (1971)
- McDonalds
(1980)

Antitrust Case Chart

Morgan Fall 2006
Page 4 of 6
- Microsoft
(1998)
(Background
Case)

Antitrust Case Chart

Morgan Fall 2006
Page 5 of 6

Jurisdictional / Procedural Issues

First Period
1890 1914
Interstat
e
Commer
ce
Foreign
Commer
ce

Second Period
1915 1939
Rule of
Reason

Third Period
1940 1973
Per Se

Modern Period
1973 Present

EC Knight
(1895)

Summit
Health (1991)

American
Banana
(1909)

Harford Fire
Insurance
(1993)
HoffmanLaRoche v.
Empagram
(2004)
Brunswick v.
Pueblo Bowl
(1977)
ARCO (1990)
Verizon v.
Trinko (2004)
Cargill v.
Monofort
(1986)
Goldfarb v.
VA State Bar
(1975)
Cal. v. Mical
(1980)
Southern
Motor
Carriers
(1985)
Twombly v.
Bell Atlantic
(2005) (plus
factors)
California
Dentist (1999)
(quick look)
Matsushita
(1986)
(summary
judgment)
Professional
Real Estate v.
Columbia
Picture (1993)
mere sham)
EBay v.
MercExchan
ge (2006)
(injunction)

Private
Litigant
Standing
(Antitrus
t Injury)

Keogh v.
Chicago &
NW RR
(1922) (no
standing)

State
Action

Parker v.
Brown (1943)

Standard
of Proof

Remedy

Standard
Oil NJ
(1911)
(Dissolutio

ALCOA (1945)
(no divestiture)
United Shoe
(1953)

Antitrust Case Chart

Morgan Fall 2006
Page 6 of 6
-

n)
Terminal
RR (1912)
(Essential
Facility)

(divestiture)