You are on page 1of 2

22/12/2014

www.businessstandard.com/article/printerfriendlyversion?article_id=114122000669_1

Howtoavoiddoubletaxation
Twocasestudiesonhowonecanusetheexemptionmethodorthecreditroute
HomiMistryDecember20,2014LastUpdatedat22:06IST
Imaginethis.YouareanIndianworkingforoneoftheITmajorsand
havebeenrecentlytransferredtotheUK.
Sixmonthsintothejob,youaregrippedwithanigglingdoubt:Will
myincomebetaxedintheUKorIndia,orwillIbeaskedtopay
taxesinboththecountries?
Withtheincreasingmovementofemployeesacrosscountriesinthe
pastfewyears,it'sapertinentquestion.Employeesarerequiredto
abidebylawsofboththecountriestheirhomecountrybeingthe
residentcountryandsourcecountrywheretheincomearises.
Thiswouldresultinthesameincomebeingtaxedintwocountries.Toavoidthisdoubletaxation,Double
TaxAvoidanceAgreements('DTAA')havebeenenteredintobyvariouscountriestoavoidaperson
beingdoublytaxedinthesourcecountryandthecountryofresidence.
India,atpresent,hasenteredintoDTAAswithvariouscountries.Reliefofdoubletaxationisgenerally
availableundertwomethods:
A.ExemptionmethodUnderthismethod,eitherofthestatehasanexclusiverighttotaxtheincome
arisinginthesourcestate.
B.TaxcreditmethodUnderthismethod,foreigntaxcreditisgivenintheresidentstateinrespectoftax
paidinthesourcestateonthedoublytaxedincome.
InIndia,taxabilitydependsontheresidentialstatusandthesourceofincome.InIndiawhileaNon
Resident('NR')/NotOrdinarilyResident('NOR')istaxedontheIndiansourcedincome,aResidentand
OrdinarilyResident(ROR')istaxedonworldwideincome.Intheexamplegivenbelow,welookattwo
scenariosofdoubletaxationandhowthesamecanbeavoided.
AUKemployeeworkinginIndiaqualifyingtobeaRORduringFY20142015returnstohishome
countryonJuly31,2014
Inthepresentcase,sincetheemployeequalifiestobeanRORinIndia,hisworldwideincomewouldbe
subjecttotaxinIndia.Hence,thesalaryincomeearnedbyhimintheUKduringtheperiodAugust1,
2014toMarch31,2015wouldbesubjecttotaxinIndia.Further,undertheUKlaws,assuminghealso
qualifiestobearesidentoftheUKfromAugust1,2014,UKwouldalsotaxhissalaryincomefrom
August1,2014.
http://www.businessstandard.com/article/printerfriendlyversion?article_id=114122000669_1

1/2

22/12/2014

www.businessstandard.com/article/printerfriendlyversion?article_id=114122000669_1

However,aDTAAexistsbetweenIndiaandtheUKandtheemployeecanavailofthebenefitsofthe
DTAAtotheextentitismorebeneficialtohim.Typically,undertheDTAA,whereanindividualisa
residentofbothcountries,thetiebreakertestwouldhavetobeappliedtoascertainthecountryof
residenceaccordingtoDTAA.Underthetiebreakerclause,conditionssuchasexistenceofpermanent
home,closenessofeconomicandsocialtiesandthelikearefactorsindeterminingtheresidencyandthe
samehastobeexamined.Inthepresentcase,theindividualisdeputedfromtheUK.Assuminghis
residencytiebreakstotheUK,undertheIndiaUKDTAA,hewillbeexemptfromtaxinIndiaon
salaryearnedduringtheperiodAugust1,2014toMarch31,2015underArticle16oftheIndiaUK
DTAA.However,accordingtotheprovisionsoftheIndiataxlaw,aTaxResidencyCertificate(TRC)
wouldberequiredtobeobtainedfromtheUKauthoritiestoclaimtheexemptionalongwithForm10F
undertheIncometaxAct,1961(Act).
Inthisscenario,doubletaxisavoidedbyanexemptionmethod.
AnIndianemployeedeputedoutsideIndiaandprovidingservicesoutsideIndiaqualifyingtobean
RORinIndiaintheyearofdeputation(assumingheisdeputedtotheUKwitheffectfromJanuary1,
2015).
WhereanemployeeisdeputedtotheUKandqualifiestobeanRORintheyearofdeputation(i.e.
FY20142015),hewouldbetaxableonglobalincomeinIndiaincludingsalaryfortheperiodJanuary1,
2015toMarch31,2015.AssuminghequalifiesasresidentoftheUKwitheffectfromJanuary1,2015,
hewouldalsobetaxableinUKonsalaryincomeearnedintheUKfortheperiodJanuary1,2015to
March31,2015.NowassuminghisresidencytiebreakstoIndia,thenundertheIndiaUKDTAAhe
wouldbeeligibletoclaimcreditinIndiaoftaxespaidintheUKonsuchdoublytaxedincomein
accordancewiththeIndiaUKDTAA.
Inthiscase,doubletaxisavoidedbythecreditmethod.
Asitisevidentfromabove,whereyourincomeisderivedinonestateandyouareresidentofanother
state,doubletaxcanbeavoidedbyapplyingtheDTAA.However,wheredoubletaxisavoidedby
exemptionmethod,itisrelevanttoobtainTRCfromtheresidentcountry.Wheredoubletaxisavoided
byclaimingforeigntaxcredit,itisimperativethattheproofoftaxespaid(suchastaxreturn,tax
receipts,taxcertificates)intheothercountryismaintainedasevidence.Further,oneshouldbemindful
toexamineeachArticleoftherespectivecountryDTAAtoclaimanexemptionortakecredit.
ItwouldberelevanttonotethatevenintheabsenceofaDTAAenteredwiththatcountry,aresidentof
Indiacanclaimforeigntaxcreditunderthedomestictaxlawsinaccordancewithsection91oftheAct
subjecttoevidencebeingmaintained.
ThewriterispartnerwithDeloitteHaskins&SellsLLP

http://www.businessstandard.com/article/printerfriendlyversion?article_id=114122000669_1

2/2

You might also like