Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PEDAGOGY
KOSMAS LAPATAS
EEME, HEjMEC, IACOMP, ISME, ISPME, MPG, NAfME, WPTA
Contents
1. Introduction
2. Music Education Models
3. Music Education Overview
4. Music Education Methods
4.1 Dalcroze
4.2 Kodly
4.3 Orff
4.4 Suzuki
4.5 Gordon
4.6 Manhattanville
5. Standards and Assessment
6. Significance
7. Experiments
8. Advocacy
Dedication
This study is dedicated to the HELLO STAGE team, board and founders. Special thanks
to Bernhard Kerres, Nina K Lucas and Bettina Mehne for their faith on me within such as
very short time.
Acknowledgement
I would like to thank my old-time soulmate, friend for life and everlasting supporter
musician/psychologist Gianna Tzanoukaki, actress Maria Tzanoukaki and school master
Antonis Skellas for the faith and trust in me and my music education work. Special thanks
to my lifetime supporter, my Godmother Chris Tsettos.
1.
Introduction
Music education is a field of study associated with the teaching and learning of music. It
touches on all learning domains, including
The affective domain (the learner's willingness to receive, internalize, and share
what is learned), including music appreciation and sensitivity.
2.
During the past century, many distinctive approaches were developed for the teaching
of music, some of which have had widespread impact.
The Dalcroze method (eurhythmics) was developed in the early 20th century by
Swiss musician and educator mile Jaques-Dalcroze.
The Kodly Method emphasizes the benefits of physical instruction and response to
music.
The Orff Schulwerk "approach" to music education leads students to develop their
music abilities in a way that parallels the development of western music.
The Suzuki method creates the same environment for learning music that a person
has for learning their native language.
The Gordon Music Learning Theory provides the music teacher with a
comprehensive method for teaching musicianship through audiation, Gordon's
term for hearing music in the mind with understanding.
3.
Overview
In primary schools in European countries, children often learn to play instruments such
as keyboards or recorders, sing in small choirs, and learn about the elements of music
and history of music.
In countries such as India, the harmonium is used in schools, but instruments like
keyboards and violin are also common. Students are normally taught basics of Indian
Raga music.
In primary and secondary schools, students may often have the opportunity to perform
in some type of musical ensemble, such as a choir, orchestra, or school band: concert
band, marching band, or jazz band.
In some secondary schools, additional music classes may also be available. In junior high
school or its equivalent, music usually continues to be a required part of the curriculum.
At the university level, students in most arts and humanities programs receive academic
credit for music courses such as music history, typically of Western art music, or music
appreciation, which focuses on listening and learning about different musical styles.
In addition, most North American and European universities offer music ensembles such as choir, concert band, marching band, or orchestra - that are open to students from
various fields of study.
Most universities also offer degree programs in music education, certifying students as
primary and secondary music educators. Advanced degrees such as the D.M.A. or the
PhD can lead to university employment. These degrees are awarded upon completion of
music theory, music history, technique classes, and private instruction with a specific
instrument, ensemble participation, and in depth observations of experienced educators.
Music education departments in North American and European universities also support
interdisciplinary research in such areas as music psychology, music education
historiography, educational ethnomusicology, sociomusicology, and philosophy of
education.
The study of western art music is increasingly common in music education outside of
North America and Europe, including Asian nations such as South Korea, Japan, and
China. At the same time, Western universities and colleges are widening their curriculum
to include music of outside the Western art music canon, including music of West Africa,
of Indonesia (e.g. Gamelan music), Mexico (e.g., mariachi music, Zimbabwe (marimba
music), as well as popular music.
Music education also takes place in individualized, lifelong learning, and in community
contexts. Both amateur and professional musicians typically take music lessons, short
private sessions with an individual teacher.
4.
Improvisation, and
Eurhythmics.
According to the Dalcroze method, music is the fundamental language of the human
brain and therefore deeply connected to who we are. Eurhythmics classes are often
offered as an addition to general education programs, whether in preschools, grade
schools, or secondary schools. In this setting, the objectives of eurhythmics classes are to
introduce students with a variety of musical backgrounds to musical concepts through
movement without a specific performance-related goal.
For younger students, eurhythmics activities often imitate play. Games include musical
storytelling, which associates different types of music with corresponding movements of
the characters in a story. The youngest of students, who are typically experiencing their
first exposure to musical knowledge in a eurhythmics class, learn to correlate types of
notes with familiar movement; for example the quarter note is represented as a walking
note. As they progress, their musical vocabulary is expanded and reinforced through
movement.
While eurhythmics classes can be taught to general populations of students, they are also
effective when geared toward music schools, either preparing students to begin
instrumental studies or serving as a supplement to students who have already begun
musical performance.
Vocabulary
Eurhythmics classes for students in elementary school through college and beyond can
benefit from a rhythmic curriculum that explores rhythmic vocabulary. This vocabulary
can be introduced and utilized in a number of different ways, but the primary objective
of this component is to familiarize students with rhythmic possibilities and expand their
horizons. Activities such as rhythmic dictation, composition, and the performance of
rhythmic canons and polyrhythms can accommodate a wide range of meters and
vocabulary. In particular, vocabulary can be organized according to number of
subdivisions of the pulse.
Movement
A key component of a rhythmic education, movement provides another way of
reinforcing rhythmic concepts - kinesthetic learning serves as a supplement to visual and
aural learning. While the study of traditional classroom music theory reinforces concepts
visually and encourages students to develop aural skills, the study of eurhythmics
solidifies these concepts through movement. In younger students, the movement aspect
of a rhythmic curriculum also develops musculature and gross motor skills. Ideally, most
activities that are explored in eurhythmics classes should include some sort of kinesthetic
reinforcement.
Meter and Syncopation
Another element of a rhythmic curriculum is the exploration of meter and syncopation.
In particular, the study of meter should incorporate an organization of pulses and
subdivisions. This organization can be expressed in a meter chart, which can include
both equal-beat and unequal-beat meters.
Experiment
A group of 72 pre-school children were tested on their rhythmic ability; half of the
children had free-play (3540 min.) twice a week for a 10-week period while the other
half had rhythmic movement classes for the same amount of time. The group that had
classes (experimental group) did significantly better than the group that just had freeplay (control group). The experiment group scored four or more points better in every
area tested than the control group in the final test. This shows that eurhythmic classes
can benefit a childs sense of rhythm.
Kodly's primary goal was to instill a lifelong love of music in his students and felt that
it was the duty of the child's school to provide this vital element of education.
Most countries have used their own folk music traditions to construct their own
instruction sequence, but the United States primarily uses the Hungarian sequence.
Child-developmental approach
The Kodly Method uses a child-developmental approach to sequence, introducing skills
according to the capabilities of the child. New concepts are introduced beginning with
what is easiest for the child and progressing to the more difficult. Children are first
introduced to musical concepts through experiences such as listening, singing, or
movement. It is only after the child becomes familiar with a concept that he or she learns
how to notate it, similar to methods like Suzuki and Simply Music. Concepts are
constantly reviewed and reinforced through games, movement, songs, and exercises.
Rhythm syllables
The Kodly Method incorporates rhythm syllables similar to those created by nineteenthcentury French theoretician Emile-Joseph Chv. In this system, note values are assigned
specific syllables that express their durations.
These may be performed while listening to music or singing. Some singing exercises call
for the teacher to invent appropriate rhythmic movements to accompany the songs.
Movable-do solfege
The Kodly Method uses a system of movable-do solfege syllables, in which, during
sight-singing, scale degrees are sung using corresponding syllable names (do, re, mi, fa,
so, la, and ti). The syllables show function within the key and the relationships between
pitches, not absolute pitch. Kodly found movable-do solfege to be helpful in developing
a sense of tonal function, thus improving students sight-singing abilities. Kodly felt that
movable-do solfege should precede acquaintance with the staff, and developed a type of
shorthand using solfege initials with simplified rhythmic notation.
Hand signs
Hand signs, are performed during singing exercises to provide a visual aid. This
technique assigns to each scale degree a hand sign that shows its particular tonal function.
The signs are made in front of the body, with do falling about at waist level and la at eye
level. Their distance in space corresponds with the size of the interval they represent. The
hand signs were featured in the 1977 film, Close Encounters of the Third Kind.
Studies have shown that the Kodly Method improves intonation, rhythm skills, music
literacy, and the ability to sing in increasingly complex parts. Outside of music, it has
been shown to improve perceptual functioning, concept formation, motor skills, and
performance in other academic areas such as reading and math.
Orff considers the whole body a percussive instrument and students are led to develop
their music abilities in a way that parallels the development of western music. The
approach fosters student self-discovery, encourages improvisation, and discourages
adult pressures and mechanical drill.
Students of the Orff Approach sing, play instruments, and dance alone as well as in
groups. Songs are usually short, contain ostinatos, are within singing range, can be
manipulated to be played in a round or ABA form. Music can also be anything from
nursery rhymes to songs that are invented by the children themselves.
Main Characteristics
The music is largely modal, beginning with pentatonic scales. The drone is quickly
established as the ground bass that supports most melodies and melodic ostinati
add energy and colour.
Ionian mode. Note, this is not major scale, as the drone bass enforces a nonfunctional harmony. Parallel thirds and sixths (paraphony) are used as well as
triads.
Dorian, Aeolian and Phrygian modes with similar shifting drones and triads
When interesting original music has been generated by the groups or individual child a
desire to record it may arise. Thus, the desire to develop musical skills emerges by itself
and the child may be intrinsically propelled to learn formal music.
The primary method for achieving this is centered around creating the same environment
for learning music that a person has for learning their native language. This 'ideal'
environment includes love, high-quality examples, praise, rote training and repetition,
and a time-table set by the student's developmental readiness for learning a particular
technique.
The central belief of Suzuki, based on his language acquisition theories, is that all people
can (and will) learn from their environment. The essential components of his method
spring from the desire to create the "right environment" for learning music (he believed
that this positive environment would also help to foster excellent character in every
student).
Emphasis on playing from a very young age, typically starting formal instruction
between the ages of three and five years old and sometimes beginning as early as
age two.
Using well trained teachers, preferably also trained in using the Suzuki materials
and philosophy.
Memorization of all solo repertoire is expected, even after a student begins to use
sheet music as a tool to learn new pieces. This is related to this focus on music as
separate from notation.
Music theory and note reading are left to the teacher. The Suzuki method doesn't
include a formal plan or prescribe specific materials for introducing music theory
& reading into the curriculum.
Retaining and reviewing every piece of music ever learned is required. This is
intended to raise technical and musical ability.
Frequent public performance makes performing feel like a natural and enjoyable
part of being a musician.
Suzuki Institutes were established to encourage a musical community, train teachers, and
provide a place where master teachers' ideas can easily be spread to the whole
community of Suzuki students, teachers, & parents. These music festivals include teacher
training courses; concerts; discussion sessions; seminars; and various 'enrichment' classes
in different musical styles, instruments.
The skills and content sequences within the Audiation theory help music teachers
establish sequential curricular objectives in accord with their own teaching styles and
beliefs. There also is a Learning Theory for Newborns and Young Children. The term
audiation is relatively new, having been coined recently by Edwin E. Gordon. The general
idea, however, is not new at all. To audiate means to think music in the mind. Good
musicians of all cultures have audiated since the dawn of music.
The power of Gordons word is that it provides a well-defined way to think about
essential cognitive musical processes, thereby clarifying the steps teachers should take to
help students fully comprehend music.
MLT is specifically concerned with developing the ability to audiate the tonal and rhythm
content of music.
First, the rhythmic and tonal realms constitute a very large portion of what makes
music.
Further, the great depth and complexity of tonal and rhythm content necessitates
a careful focus on sequence.
MLTs emphasis on tonal and rhythm is not meant to suggest that musical elements such
as timbre, phrasing, expression and style are unimportant. The traditional model serves
well for teaching these nonsyntactical musical elements, for which sequence is less
important than it is for tonal and rhythm elements. A teacher who implements MLT for
teaching tonal and rhythm skills is likely to approach the other musical elements in much
the same way as any other capable music teacher.
MLT classroom
An MLT classroom looks like any other music class. The crucial difference is that the time
spent in tonal and rhythm pattern instruction develops essential audiation skills that are
otherwise likely to be left to chance. Students who have engaged in learning sequence
activities are able to bring greater aural comprehension and more skills to the music
literature they study during classroom activities.
Rather than imparting factual knowledge, this method centers around the student, who
learns through investigation, experimentation, and discovery. The teacher gives a group
of students a specific problem to solve together and allows freedom to create, perform,
improvise, conduct, research, and investigate different facets of music in a spiral
curriculum.
musical behaviors in students. MMCP does not focus on imparting factual music
knowledge. Rather, learning and acquisition of musical information are the byproduct of
the doing in performing and creating the music.
The four behavioral objectives closely aligned with the MMCP process of learning are:
Attitudinal Students excited about their own creative musical potential and their
aesthetic sensitivity to music.
Concepts & Skills - Going through the task-oriented process of deciding how to
create music using concepts from all styles and periods.
Music of Today - Students should understand and create the music of their
contemporary environment.
The MMCP uses a spiral curriculum that sequentially introduces new concepts in actionoriented cycles that are developmentally appropriate.
Critical Evaluation - Students may have an oral discussion after the performance
to discuss and evaluate themselves. They may also record the performance for
critical analysis at a later time.
The teacher's role in this sequence is the creator of the musical problem yet an
unobtrusive observer. Students should view the teacher as a resource rather than an
evaluator.
5.
NAME
The National Association for Music Education, created nine voluntary content standards,
called the National Standards for Music Education. These standards call for:
6.
It has been argued that studying music enhances academic achievement. The research
was brought to the attention with the assertion that listening to Mozart improved spatial
reasoning skills. This led to countless attempts to recreate the study, debunk the results,
and expand upon them. While listening to Mozart may temporarily enhance a student's
spatial-temporal abilities, learning to play an instrument holds much more promise as an
avenue to improve student performance and achievement.
According to the Florida Music Educators Association, Music and the Fine Arts have
been a significant portion of every cultures educational system for more than 3,000
years. The human brain has been shown to be hard-wired for music; there is a
biological basis for music being an important part of human experience.
Music and the Arts surround daily life in our present day culture. Most present day
artists, architects, and musicians acquired their interests during public school Fine Arts
classes. Education without the Fine Arts is fundamentally impoverished and
subsequently leads to an impoverished society.
William Earhart, former president of the Music Educators National Conference, said that
Music enhances knowledge in the areas of mathematics, science, geography, history,
foreign language, physical education, and vocational training."
Music not only inspires creativity and performance, but academic performance over all
is seriously impacted. A research study produced by the Harris Poll has shown that 9 out
of 10 individuals with post graduate degrees participated in music education.
The National Report of SAT test takers study indicated students with music performance
experience scored higher on SAT: 57 points higher on verbal and 41 points higher on
math.
Schools that have high academic performance are spending 20 to 30% of their budget
in the arts with emphasis on music education. Comprehensive music education
programs average $187 per pupil, according to a 2011 study funded by the national
Association of Music Merchants (NAMM) Foundation.
Music education also increases one's success in society. The Texas Commission on
Drugs and Alcohol Abuse Report noted that students who participated in band or
orchestra reported the lowest lifetime and current use of all substances including alcohol,
tobacco, and illicit drugs.
Playing music increases overall brain activity. In experiments done at the University of
Wisconsin students with piano or keyboard experience performed 34% higher on tests
that measure spatial-temporal lobe activity, which is the part of the brain that is used
when doing mathematics, science, and engineering.
7.
Experiments
Music aids in text recall. Wallace conducted a series of experiments by setting text to a
melody.
One experiment created a three verse song with a non-repetitive melody; each verse
had different music.
A second experiment created a three verse song with a repetitive melody; each verse
had exactly the same music.
Another experiment studied text recall without music. The repetitive music
produced the highest amount of text recall; therefore, music serves as a mnemonic
device.
It is important to note that "While studies show positive influences in other academic
areas, music and the Fine Arts are an academic discipline that are, as the other
academics, an independent way of learning and knowing."
Citing many of the statistics above passed a resolution declaring that: Music education
enhances intellectual development and enriches the academic environment for
children of all ages; and Music educators greatly contribute to the artistic, intellectual
and social development of children and play a key role in helping children to succeed in
school.
Unfortunately, music in our schools are being cut at a drastic rate due to budget cuts
being forced upon the schools. Dr. Patricia Powers states, It is not unusual to see
program cuts in the area of music and arts when economic issues surface. It is indeed
unfortunate to lose support in this area especially since music and the art programs
contribute to society in many positive ways.
Music makes students more successful in school. Skills learned through the discipline
of music, transfer to study skills, communication skills, and cognitive skills useful in
every part of the school curriculum. It also makes students become successful when
participating to ensembles. This helps students learn to work effectively in the school
environment and cuts down on resorting to violent or inappropriate behavior.
Music also has found to help students with developing intelligence. Studies have
found that some measure of a childs intelligence is indeed increased with music
instruction.
Behavioral studies and groundbreaking neurological research that show how music
study can actively contribute to brain development. Researchers at the University of
Montreal used various brain imaging techniques to investigate brain activity during
musical tasks and found that sight-reading musical scores and playing music both
activate regions in all four of the cortexs lobes; and that parts of the cerebellum are also
activated during those tasks.
Other studies show that music also helps with reasoning. Music makes students better
learners and better thinkers.
8.
Music advocacy
In some communities music is provided little support as an academic subject area, and
music teachers feel that they must actively seek greater public endorsement for music
education as a legitimate subject of study. This perceived need to change public opinion
has resulted in the development of a variety of approaches commonly called "music
advocacy". Music advocacy comes in many forms, some of which are based upon
legitimate scholarly arguments and scientific findings, while other examples rely on
unconvincing data and remain rather controversial.
Most recent high-profile music advocacy projects include the "Mozart Effect", the
National Anthem Project, and the movement in World Music Pedagogy which seeks out
means of equitable pedagogy across students regardless of their race, ethnicity, or
socioeconomic circumstance.
Even though the Mozart Effect is controversial, the proof shows reliability. The study
includes two tested groups: a group of students with and another without music
education. When this test was given to three-year-olds their temporal test improved by
35% over those with no music; this lasted for several days.
Many contemporary music scholars assert that music advocacy will only be truly
effective when based on empirically sound arguments that transcend political
motivations and personal agendas. Yet a gap remains between the discourse of music
education philosophy and the actual practices of music teachers and music organization
executives.
Author links
Official Site: klapatas.weebly.com
Hello Stage: hellostage.com/klapatas
About.me: about.me/klapatas
Academia: independent.academia.edu/klapatas
Bandcamp: klapatas.bandcamp.com
Classical Artists: classical-artists.com/users/profile.php?a=00002551
Classical Music Education: classicalmusiceducation.blogspot.gr
Classical Music for Children: classicalmusicforchildren.blogspot.gr
Classical Place: classicalplace.com/klapatas.html
Facebook: facebook.com/klapatas
GoGetFunding: gogetfunding.com/support-music-education
Google+: plus.google.com/+KosmasLapatas
Instagram: instagram.com/klapatas
KLmastering: klmastering.weebly.com
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/klapatas
Music Pedagogy: klapatas.wordpress.com
Musical Chairs: musicalchairs.info/musician-cv?id=4646
ONErpm: onerpm.com/klapatas
Patreon: patreon.com/klapatas
PFTI: pianistsfromtheinside.wordpress.com
Pinterest: pinterest.com/klapatas
Reddit: reddit.com/user/klapatas
Tumblr: klapatas.tumblr.com
Twitter: twitter.com/klapatas
Vkontakte: vk.com/klapatas
YouTube: youtube.com/ApolloPlayers/videos