Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OFFICIAL
ACTION
J.
375
385
J.
AM . ACAD . CHILD AD OL ESC. PSY CHIATRY, 36:10 SUPPL EMENT, O C T OBER 1997
FORENSIC EVALUATION
inition of sexual abuse. It is important to consider developmental factors in assessing whether sexual behaviors
between two children are abusive or normative.
Psychological abuse occurs when a person conveys to a child
that he or she is worthless, flawed, unloved , unwanted, or
endangered. The perpetrator may spurn, terrorize, isolate, or
berate the child . Psychological abuse may also be caused by
repeatedly taking a child for unnecessary medical treatment.
When psychological abuse is severe, it is often accompanied
by neglect, physical abuse, and/or sexual abuse.
The maltreatment of children occurs in a wide range of
circumstances. It may have happened only once or twice, or it
may have constituted severe torture over a period of years. It
may have been perpetrated by parents or other family
members, by nonrelated caretakers, or by total strangers.
In American society there are wide variations in parenting
practices. These variations are partly determined by the cultural heritage and religious beliefs of the family. The cultural
context of the alleged act should be taken into consideration
when one is evaluating suspected neglect and abuse.
Brief History of Child Maltreatment
J.
AM. ACAD. CHILD ADO LE SC. PSYCHIATRY, 36:10 SUPPLEMENT, O CTOBER 1997
39$
405
FORENSIC EVALUATION
J.
AM. ACAD . CHILD ADOLESC. PSYCHIATRY, 36:10 SUP PL EMENT, OC TOB ER 1997
41$
several important tasks: finding out what happened, evaluating the child for emotional disorders, considering other
possible explanations for these disorders, being aware of
developmental issues, avoiding biasing the outcome with
one's own preconceptions, pursuing these objectives in a
sensitive manner and taking care not to retraurnatize the
child, being supportive to family members, and keeping an
accurate record that will be useful in future court
proceedings.
The Step-Wise Interview described by Yuille er al. (1993)
presents a systematic approach to achieve these goals. It is not
known scientifically or empirically whether the Step-Wise
Interview is preferable to other interview methods in eliciting
accurate reports. This method is presented here as an illustration, since individual evaluators may develop their own
ways to achieve the goals of the interview. The Step-Wise
Interview consists of the following components:
I. Rapport Building. During this time the interviewer
makes informal observations of the child's behavior, social
skills, and cognitive abilities.
2. Describing Two Specific Events. The interviewer asks
the child to describe two specific past experiences, such as a
birthday party or a school outing. In doing so, the interviewer
models the form of the interview for the child by asking nonleading, open-ended questions, a pattern that will hold
through the rest of the interview.
3. Telling the Truth. The interviewer establishes the need
to tell the truth, in a stepwise fashion. Start with asking
general questions and proceed, if necessary, to more specific
questions. Reach an agreement that in this interview only the
truth will be discussed, not "pretend" or imagination.
4. Introducing the Topic of Concern. Start with more
general questions, such as "Do you know why you are talking
with me today?" Proceed, if necessary, to more specific
questions, such as, "Has anything happened to you?" or "Has
anyone done something to you?" Drawings may be helpful in
initiating disclosure.That is, either the child or the interviewer
makes an outline of a person. Then the child is asked to add
and name each body part and describe its function. If sexual
abuse is suspected, when the genitals are described the interviewer could ask whether the child has seen or touched that
part on another person and who has seen or touched that part
on the child. If physical abuse is suspected, the interviewer
could ask whether particular parts have been hurt in some way.
5. Free Narrative. Once the topic of abuse has been
introduced, the interviewer encourages the child to describe
each event from the beginning without leaving out any
details. The child is allowed to proceed at his or her pace,
without correction or interruption. If abuse had occurred
over a period of time, the interviewer may ask for a
description of the general pattern and then for an account of
specific episodes.
425
FORENSIC EVALUATION
J.
435
closure. That is, children who were not abused and were subjected to repeated interrogations may develop sexual
symptoms that resemble the symptoms of children who were
actually abused.
False Statements and the Possible Explanations ofAbuse
Alkgations. Children may make falsestatements in psychiatric
evaluations. Sometimes they make false denials regarding
abuse (Sgroi, 1982; Sorenson and Snow, 1991; Summit,
1983). Children may make a false denial or recant a previous
disclosure for many reasons, including pressure from the
perpetrator or the family and fear of the judicial process. The
child may "forget" what happened, may minimize the abuse,
or may defend against bad feelings by empowering himself or
herself ("He used to touch me but I hit him and ran away.").
The child may deny the abuse because of fear of having done
something wrong ("I was afraid you wouldn't love me if you
knew what I did.").
Children may also make false allegations. Bernet (l993)
reviewed this topic and developed a differential diagnosis of
abuse allegations. Benedek and Scherky (l985), Everson and
Boat (l989), Gardner (l992, 1995), Goodwin et al. (l978,
1980), Quinn (l991), Schuman (l986, 1987), and Yates and
Musty (l988) have contributed to the literature on this issue.
The evaluation of these children is complex because there are
a number of distinct mental processes, both conscious and
unconscious, that may result in false allegations. Long before
the current interest in false allegations, Healy and Healy
(l915) described how some of the children they evaluated in
the first juvenile court clinic manifested pathological lying in
making allegations of abuse. Green (l986) described how a
delusional mother, who believed that her ex-husband had
been molesting their daughter, induced the girl to state that
the father had rubbed against her in bed. Clawar and Rivlin
(l991) presented many examples of "programming" of children, especiallyin custody disputes. In some cases inept interviewers, by repeatedly asking leading or suggestive questions,
have induced children to make false allegations of abuse.
Bernet (l993) described how children may knowingly lie
about abuse. Young children may tell "tall tales," and these
innocent lies may result in false allegations of abuse. Older
children may lie about abuse for revenge or for some personal
advantage. For example, an adolescent girl, who became
pregnant by her boyfriend, tried to accuse her stepfather of
molesting her. In some cases, multiple allegations of abuse
may have been generated through group contagion or
epidemic hysteria (Ceci and Bruck, 1995; Kenner, 1989).
Sexual abuse allegations that occur in the context of a child
custody dispute may be particularly complex. Faller (1991)
identified four scenarios that result in allegations during or
after divorce: abuse leading to divorce, abuse revealed during
the divorce, abuse precipitated by the divorce, and improbable allegations during custody and access disputes. In these
445
FORENSIC EVALUATION
455
465
FORENSIC EVALUATION
47S
485
FORENSIC EVALUATION
J.
495
50S
) . AM . ACAD. CHILD ADOLE SC . PSYC H IAT RY, 36:10 SUPPLEMENT, OC TOBER 1997
SIS
525
REFERENCES
Rq'nYnm mark~d with an tlJtniJk are particularly recommended.
Abright AR (1986) , Psychiatric aspects of sexual abuse. Bull Am Acad
Psychiatry Law 14:331-343
Adams JA. Harper K, Knudson S, RevillaJ (1994) . Examinat ion findings in
legally confirmed child sexual abuse: it's normal to be normal . Pediatrics
94:310-317
FORENSIC EVALUATION
J.
535
Am 3:645-661
Goodwin J, Caurhorne CG , Rada RT (1980). Cinderella syndrome: children
who simulate neglect. Am I Psychiatry 137:1223-1225
Goodwin J. Sahd D. Rada RT (1978) . Incest hoax: false accusations. false
denials. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Laio6:269-276
Green AH (1986) , True and false allegations of sexual abuse in child custody
disputes . I Am Acad Child Psychiatry 25:449-456
Green AH (1988). Overview of normal psychosexual development. In: Child
Psychiatry 29:955-957
Hibbard RA. Hartman GL (199 3), Components of child and parent
interviews in cases of alleged sexual abuse. Child AbuseN~gl 17:495-500
Horner TM, Guyer MJ. Kalter NM (l993a) , The biasesof child sexual abuse
experts: believing is seeing. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Laui 21:28 1- 292
Horner TM. Guyer MJ . Kalter NM (l993b) , Clinical expertise and the
assessment of child sexual abuse. I Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
32 :925-931
Hunter M (1990). Th~ StxuAUy AbustdMak. Lexington. MA: Lexington Books
Jampole L. Webc:r MK (1987). An assessment of the behavior of sexually
abused and nonsexually abused children with anatomically correct dolls.
Child Abuse N~gl 11 : 187-192
Jenkins PH . Howell RJ (1994) . Child sexual abuse examinations: proposed
guidelines for a standard of care. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law 22:5-17
545
Psychohist 19:191-214
Kempe CH, Helfer RE. eds (1972) . H~/ping tht Battered Child and His
Family. Philadelphia : Lippincott
'Kempe CH. Silverman FN . Steele BF, Droegmueller W. Silver H (1962).
The battered child syndrome. lAMA 181:17-24
Kempe RS, Kempe CH (1978), Child Abuse. Cambridge, MA: Harvard
University Press
"Kendall-Tackett KA, Williams LM, Pinkelhor 0 (1993) . Impact of sexual
abuse on children : a review and synthesis of recent emp irical studies.
Psychol Bull 113:164-180
Kenner WD (1989) . The sex abuse controver sy (letter). I Am Acad Child
FORENSIC EVALUATION
Chicago, IL 60604)
'Ney T, ed (1995), Trur and FalsrAlkgations ofChild SexualAbus: Assessment
and Case Management. New York: Brunner/Maze!.
Nurcombe B (1986), The child as witness: competency and credibility.] Am
Acad Child Psychiatry 25:473-480
"Nurcombe B, Parrlerr D] (1994), Child Mental Health and the Law. New
York: Free Press
Nurcombe B, Untitzer U (1991), The ritual abuse of children: clinical
features and diagnostic reasoning. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry
30:272-276
Olafson E, Corwin DL, Summit RC (1993), Modern history of child sexual
abuse awareness: cycles of discovery and suppression. Child Abuse Nrgl
17:7-24
Pelton L, ed (1981), The Social Context of Child Abus and Neglect. New
York: Human Sciences Press
Quinn KM (1986), Competency to be a witness: a major child forensic issue.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law 14:311-321
J.
Ross DF, Toglia MP. Ceci S], eds (1987), Childrens Eynoitness Memory. New
York: Springer-Verlag
Ross DF, Toglia MP. Ceci S], eds (1989), Perspectives on Childrens Testimony.
New York: Springer-Verlag
Rush F (1980), The Best Krpt S(C1rt: SexualAbus of Children. New York:
McGraw Hill
Schetky DH, Benedek EP. eds (1985), Emerging Issues in Child Psychiatry
and the Law. New York: Brunner/Mazel
Schetky DH, Benedek EP.eds (1992), Clinical Handbook ofChild Psychiatry
and the Law. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins
"Scherky DH, Green AM (1988), Child Sexual Abuse: A Handbookfor Health
Carr and Lrgal Proftssionals. New York: Brunner/Maze!
Schmitt B, ed (1978), The Child Protection ,"am Handbook. New York:
Garland STPM Press
Schmitt B (1987), The child with nonaccidental trauma. In: The Battered
Child, 4th ed, Helfer RE, Kempe CH, eds. Chicago: University of
Chicago Press
Schuman DC (1986), Falseaccusations of physical and sexual abuse. BullAm
Acad Psychiatry Law 14:5-21
Bebau 17:399-421
Sorenson T, Snow B (1991), How children tell: the process of disclosure in
child sexual abuse. Child ~/fim 70:3-15
State v Michaels (1994), 136 N] 299
Steller M (1989), Recent developments in statement analysis. In: Crrdibility
Assessment, Yuille], ed. Dordrecht, Netherlands: Kluwer
Summit RC (1983), The child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome.
Child Abuse N(gl 7: 177-193
Tardieu A (1860), Etude medico-legale sur les serviceser mauvais traitments
exercessur des enfants. Ann Hyg Publ M(d Leg 13:361-398
Tardieu A (1868), Etud Medico-Legale sur L'infanticiek. Paris
Terr LC (1989), Resolved:child sex abuse is overdiagnosed.] Am Acad Child
Adolesc Psychiatry 28:788-797
Terr LC (1990), Too Scared to Cry: Psychic Trauma in Childhood. New York:
Harper & Row
Terr LC (1991), Childhood traumas: an outline and overview. Am J
Psychiatry 148:10-20
Thompson RA (1994), Social support and the prevention of child
maltreatment. In: Protecting Children from Abuse and Neglect, Melton
GB, Barry FD, eds. New York: Guilford
Tobey A, Goodman G (1992), Children's eyewitness memory: effects of
participation and forensic context. Child Abus NrgI16:779-796
US Department of Health and Human Services, National Center on Child
Abuse and Neglect (1995), Child Maltreatment 1993: Reports from the
States to th( National Center on Child Abus and Neglea. Washington,
DC: US Government Printing Office
Walker L, ed (1988), Handbook on Sexual Abuse ofChildren: Assessment and
Treatment Issues. New York: Springer
Walker LEA (1990), Psychological assessment of sexually abused children
for legal evaluation and expert witness testimony. Prof Psychol Res Prac
21:344-353
Wasserman S, Rosenfeld A (1985), Decision-making in child abuse and
neglect. Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law 13:259-271
Waterman ], Lusk R (1993), Psychological testing in evaluation of child
sexual abuse. Child Abus Nrg117: 145-159
Weissman HN (1991), Forensic psychological examination of the child
witness in cases of alleged sexual abuse. Am] Orthopsychiatry 61:48-58
555
Law 16:269-278
AccusationJ 2:7-14
565