Professional Documents
Culture Documents
APPELLANT
RESPONDENT
v.
BEFORE SUBMISSION TO
TABLE OF CONTENTS
S.No.
Headings
Page No.
1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Index of Authorities
List of Abbreviation
Questions Presented
Statement of Facts
Summary of Pleadings
Detailed Pleading
Prayer For Relief
3
4
5
6
7
8
13
INDEX OF AUTHORITIES
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
ABBREVIATION
FULL FORM
Honble
Honourable
3
QUESTIONS RAISED
ISSUE 1st
1. Whether the appellants were liable for the action of an Independent contractor?
4
ISSUE 2nd
2.
Whether the Appellant was liable for the damage under negligence?
ISSUE 3rd
3. Whether the appellant was liable under the principle of strict liability?
STATEMENTS OF FACTS
Appellant constructed a reservoir to supply water for his mill. Appellant employed independent contractors and
engineers to excavate and build the reservoir. While excavating, the Appellant contractors found several old
mine shafts which had been filled with soil. The shafts were actually connected to the defendants mines
5
SUMMARY OF PLEADINGS
1. Whether the appellants were liable for the action of an Independent contractor?
DETAILED PLEADINGS
1) Whether the appellant were liable for the action of an Independent contractor?
7
and
4 In the case of Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, AIR 2005 SC 3180,Ibid,quoting Ratanlal and
Dhirapal,Law of Torts,2002,441-42
5 In the cases of B.Govindarajulu v. M.L.A Govindaraja Mudaliar AIR 1966 Mad.332.also in the cases of Ramu Tularam
v Amichand 1968 ACJ 54 per Sharad Manohar,J.,Devinder Singh v. Mangal Singh,AIR 1981 P & H 53.
10
In the lights of facts stated and issues raised, authorities cited and arguments advanced, it is most humbly
prayed before this honorable House of Lords to adjudge and declare that:
1. The appellant is not liable for the act of independent contractor.
2. The act of the appellant will not incur any liability as no negligence was proved.
3. It does not come under the principle of strict liability.
And/or
Pass any other order that it deems fit in the interest of justice, equity and good conscience and for this the
appellant as in duty bound, shall humbly pray.
13