Professional Documents
Culture Documents
322
322
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Republic vs. Sagun
power.
Same; Same; Same; If the citizenship of a person was subject to
challenge under the old charter, it remains subject to challenge
under the new charter even if the judicial challenge had not been
commenced before the effectivity of the new Constitution.Under
ArticleIV,Section1(4)ofthe1935Constitution,thecitizenshipofa
legitimate child born of a Filipino mother and an alien father
followedthecitizenshipofthefather,unless,uponreachingtheage
of majority, the child elected Philippine citizenship. The right to
electPhilippinecitizenshipwasrecognizedinthe1973Constitution
when it provided that [t]hose who elect Philippine citizenship
pursuanttotheprovisionsoftheConstitutionofnineteenhundred
and thirtyfive are citizens of the Philippines. Likewise, this
recognition by the 1973Constitution was carried over to the 1987
Constitution which states that [t]hose born before January 17,
1973 of Filipino mothers, who elect Philippine citizenship upon
reaching the age of majority are Philippine citizens. It should be
noted, however, that the 1973 and 1987 Constitutional provisions
ontheelectionofPhilippinecitizenshipshouldnotbeunderstoodas
having a curative effect on any irregularity in the acquisition of
citizenship for those covered by the 1935 Constitution. If the
citizenship of a person was subject to challenge under the old
charter,itremainssubjecttochallengeunderthenewchartereven
if the judicial challenge had not been commenced before the
effectivityofthenewConstitution.
Same; Same; Same; It is a settled rule that only legitimate
children follow the citizenship of the father and that illegitimate
children are under the parental authority of the mother and follow
her nationality.Being a legitimate child, respondents citizenship
followed that of her father who is Chinese, unless upon reaching
the age of majority, she elects Philippine citizenship. It is a settled
rulethatonlylegitimatechildrenfollowthecitizenshipofthefather
and that illegitimate children are under the parental authority of
the mother and follow her nationality. An illegitimate child of
Filipinaneednotperformanyacttoconferuponhimalltherights
and privileges attached to citizens of the Philippines; he
automatically becomes a citizen himself. But in the case of
respondent, for her to be considered a Filipino citizen, she must
havevalidlyelectedPhilippinecitizenshipuponreachingtheageof
majority.
323
VOL.666,FEBRUARY15,2012
323
324
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Republic vs. Sagun
VOL.666,FEBRUARY15,2012
325
_______________
1 Rollo, pp. 2732. Penned by Presiding Judge Fernando Vil
Pamintuan.
2Records,pp.14.
3Id.,atp.60.
4Id.,atp.7.
326
326
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Republic vs. Sagun
birthcertificatethatshehaselectedPhilippinecitizenship.
Consequently, she sought a judicial declaration of her
electionofPhilippinecitizenshipandprayedthattheLocal
Civil Registrar of Baguio City be ordered to annotate the
sameonherbirthcertificate.
In her petition, respondent averred that she was raised
as a Filipino, speaks Ilocano and Tagalog fluently and
attended local schools in Baguio City, including Holy
Family Academy and the Saint Louis University.
RespondentclaimedthatdespiteherpartChineseancestry,
she always thought of herself as a Filipino. She is a
registeredvoterofPrecinctNo.0419AofBarangayManuel
A.RoxasinBaguioCityandhadvotedinlocalandnational
elections as shown in the Voter Certification5 issued by
Atty.MaribelleUmingaoftheCommissiononElectionsof
BaguioCity.
Sheassertedthatbyvirtueofherpositiveacts,shehas
effectively elected Philippine citizenship and such fact
should be annotated on her record of birth so as to entitle
hertotheissuanceofaPhilippinepassport.
On August 7, 2007, the Office of the Solicitor General
(OSG)entereditsappearanceascounselfortheRepublicof
the Philippines and authorized the City Prosecutor of
Baguio City to appear in the above mentioned case.6
However,nocommentwasfiledbytheCityProsecutor.
Afterconductingahearing,thetrialcourtrenderedthe
assailedDecisiononApril3,2009grantingthepetitionand
declaring respondent a Filipino citizen. The fallo of the
decisionreads:
WHEREFORE, the instant petition is hereby GRANTED.
Petitioner Nora Fe Sagun y Chan is hereby DECLARED [a]
FILIPINOCITIZEN,havingchosenorelectedFilipinocitizenship.
_______________
5Id.,atp.8.
6Id.,atp.28.
327
VOL.666,FEBRUARY15,2012
327
ITISSOORDERED.7
328
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Republic vs. Sagun
teredwiththelocalcivilregistryandannotatedonherbirth
certificate, then she does not have to resort to court
proceedings.
Petitioner further argues that even assuming that
respondents action is sanctioned, the trial court erred in
finding respondent as having duly elected Philippine
citizenship since her purported election was not in
accordance with the procedure prescribed by law and was
not made within a reasonable time. Petitioner points out
thatwhilerespondentexecutedanoathofallegiancebefore
a notary public, there was no affidavit of her election of
Philippine citizenship. Additionally, her oath of allegiance
whichwasnotregisteredwiththenearestlocalcivilregistry
wasexecutedwhenshewasalready33yearsoldor12years
after she reached the age of majority. Accordingly, it was
madebeyondtheperiodallowedbylaw.
In
her
Comment,9
respondent
avers
that
VOL.666,FEBRUARY15,2012
329
ThisCourtbelievesthatpetitionerwasabletofullysubstantiate
her petition regarding her election of Filipino citizenship, and the
LocalCivilRegistrarofBaguioCityshouldbeorderedtoanno
_______________
11Sarsaba v. Vda. de Te, G.R. No. 175910, July 30, 2009, 594 SCRA 410,
420.
330
330
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Republic vs. Sagun
Forsure,thisCourthasconsistentlyruledthatthereis
no proceeding established by law, or the Rules for the
judicial declaration of the citizenship of an individual.13
Thereisnospecificlegislationauthorizingtheinstitutionof
ajudicialproceedingtodeclarethatagivenpersonispartof
our citizenry.14 This was our ruling in Yung Uan Chu v.
Republic15 citing the early case of Tan v. Republic of the
Philippines,16whereweclearly stated:
Under our laws, there can be no action or proceeding for the
judicial declaration of the citizenship of an individual. Courts of
justiceexistforsettlementofjusticiablecontroversies,whichimplya
givenright,legallydemandableandenforceable,anactoromission
violativeofsaidright,andaremedy,grantedorsanctionedbylaw,
for said breach of right. As an incident only of the adjudication of
therightsofthepartiestoacontroversy,thecourtmaypassupon,
and
_______________
12Rollo,pp.3132.
13Yung Uan Chu v. Republic,No.L34973,April14,1988,159SCRA593,
597;Board of Commissioners v. Domingo,No.L21274,July31,1963,8SCRA
661,664.
14Id.,atp.598;Tan v. Republic of the Philippines,107Phil.632,634(1960).
15Id.,atp.597.
16Supranote14atp.633;Republic v. Maddela,Nos.L21664andL21665,
March28,1969,27SCRA702,705.
331
VOL.666,FEBRUARY15,2012
331
UnderArticleIV,Section1(4)ofthe1935 Constitution,
the citizenship of a legitimate child born of a Filipino
mother and an alien father followed the citizenship of the
father,unless,uponreachingtheageofmajority,thechild
electedPhilippinecitizenship.TherighttoelectPhilippine
citizenshipwasrecognizedinthe1973Constitutionwhenit
provided that [t]hose who elect Philippine citizenship
pursuant to the provisions of the Constitution of nineteen
hundred and thirtyfive are citizens of the Philippines.17
Likewise, this recognition by the 1973 Constitution was
carried over to the 1987 Constitution which states that
[t]hosebornbeforeJanuary
_______________
17Sec.1(3),Art.III,1973Constitution.
332
332
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Republic vs. Sagun
VOL.666,FEBRUARY15,2012
333
334
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Republic vs. Sagun
_______________
27 Re: Application For Admission to the Philippine Bar. Vicente D.
Ching, supra note 19 at p. 9; Ma v. Fernandez, Jr., supra note 23 at p.
578.
335
VOL.666,FEBRUARY15,2012
335
Castro,
336
SUPREMECOURTREPORTSANNOTATED
Republic vs. Sagun
DepartureofrespondentrecognizedasaFilipinocitizen
andwhointendstoreturnheredidnotrenderhisrevoked
application for citizenship moot. (Gonzalez vs. Pennisi, 614
SCRA292[2010])
o0o