Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Staffing
Factors affecting approaches to staffing
General staffing policy on key positions at headquarters
and subsidiaries
Constraints placed by host government
Beware..!!!!!!
What works at
home does not
necessarily
work abroad
A 4 day strike and pay rises of 10-15% were part of the cost
paid by a south Korean textile firm for an incident involving
one of the expatriate managers in its Vietnamese factory. A
Vietnamese worker was confronted by his south Korean
boss. Speaking in Korean, the manager yelled at him for
being in the wrong place in the factory. As he did not
understand her, the Vietnamese did not respond. The south
Korean manager kicked and slapped him as in south Korea
it is common for employers t0 scold or even beat employees
if they make a big mistake. Here though such behaviour
resulted in 10 of the Vietnamese co-workers retaliating in
kind. The manager was rushed to hospital and the workers
went on strike. The south Korean was subsequently
deported.
Approaches to staffing
Staff availability
Ethnocentric
Polycentric
Geocentric
Regiocentric
Ethnocentric
Strategic decisions are made at headquarters;
Limited subsidiary autonomy;
Key positions in domestic and foreign operations
are held by headquarters personnel;
PCNs manage subsidiaries.
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
To
ensure
new
subsidiary
complies
with overall corporate
objectives and policies
Has the required level
of competence
Assignments as control
Limits
the
promotion
opportunities of HCNs, leading
to reduced productivity and
increased turnover
Longer time for PCNs to adapt
to host countries, leading to
errors & poor decisions making
High cost
Polycentric
Each subsidiary is a distinct national entity with
some decision-making autonomy;
HCNs manage subsidiaries who are seldom
promoted to HQ positions;
PCNs rarely transferred to subsidiary positions.
Advantages:
Employment of HCNs eliminates language barriers,
avoids adaptation of PCNs, reduces the need for
cultural awareness training programs
Employment of HCNs allows a multinational company
to take a lower profile in sensitive political situations
Employment of HCNs is less expensive
Employment of HCNs gives continuity to the
management of foreign subsidiaries (lower turnover of
key managers)
Disadvantages:
Difficult to bridge the gap between HCN subsidiary
managers and PCN managers at headquarters
HCN managers have limited opportunities to gain
experience outside their own country
PCN managers have limited opportunities to gain
international experience
Resource allocation and strategic decision making will be
constrained when headquarter is filled only by PCNs who
have limited exposure to international assignment
14
Geocentric
A global approach - worldwide integration
View that each part of the organization makes a
unique contribution
Nationality is ignored in favor of ability
Best person for the job
Color of passport does not matter when it comes to
rewards, promotion and development
15
Advantages:
Disadvantage:
Regiocentric
Reflects a regional strategy and structure;
Regional autonomy in decision making;
Staff move within the designated region, rather
than globally;
They are not normally moved to the company
headquarters.
Advantages:
Allow interaction between
executives transferred to
regional headquarters from
subsidiaries in the region
and PCNs posted to the
regional headquarters
Provide some sensitivity to
local conditions
Help the firm to move from
a purely ethnocentric or
polycentric approach
Disadvantages:
Produce federalism at a
regional rather than a
country
basis
and
constrain the firm from
taking a global stance
Staffs
career
advancement still limited
to regional headquarters,
not the parent country
headquarters
Management development
Organizational development
Need for control, transfer of knowledge,
competence, procedures and practices into various
locations
Extended: up to 1 year
May involve
assignments
similar
activities
as
short-term
Traditional
Filling position,
management development
12-36 months
Family joins the assignee
Formal selection
Advantages
Good relation, constant
monitoring
Disadvantages
Dual career options,
expensive, less flexibility
Short term
Skill transfer / problem
solving
6-12 months
Unaccompanied by family
Informal, little bureaucracy
Advantages
Flexibility, cost effectiveness
Disadvantages
Poor relationship, side effects,
work permit issues
Non-standard Assignments
Commuter assignments weekly or bi-weekly basis
Rotational assignments short period followed by
break in home country, oil rigs
Contractual assignments - R & D
Virtual assignments manage from home,
international assignment, heavy reliance on
communication technologies, frequent visits to host
country but..
Contd
A Glamorous Life
International business travelers cite the positives as:
Excitement and thrills of conducting business deals
in foreign locations
Life style (top hotels, duty-free shopping, business
class travel)
General exotic nature
Contd
But a High Level of Stress!
HR departments
Key role: Managing all
high-grade management
positions worldwide
Decentralized HR
Companies
Small HR departments
corporate managers
Key activities:
international assignments
and performance
management globally,
identifying high-potential
staff
Influencing operating
units to support
international
assignments, supporting
decentralized HR
Transition HR
Companies
Medium-sized HR
departments
Key role: Management
divisional managers to
release key staff using
informal and subtle
methods, strategic staffing.
Source: Based on H. Scullion and K. Starkey, in Search of the Changing Role of the Corporate Human Resource Function in the International
Firms, International Journal of Human Resource Management, V 11, N 6 (2000) pp. 1061-1081.
HANK
OU