You are on page 1of 4

75762 Federal Register / Vol. 70, No.

244 / Wednesday, December 21, 2005 / Proposed Rules

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY REG–104385–01). The public hearing the actual tax expense is added to a
will be held in the IRS Auditorium, reserve (the accumulated deferred
Internal Revenue Service Internal Revenue Building, 1111 federal income tax reserve, or ADFIT).
Constitution Avenue, NW., Washington, The difference between ratemaking tax
26 CFR Part 1 DC. expense and actual tax expense is not
[REG–104385–01] FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: permanent and reverses in the later
Concerning the proposed regulations, years of the asset’s life when the
RIN 1545–AY75 ratemaking depreciation method
David Selig, at (202) 622–3040;
concerning submissions of comments, provides larger depreciation deductions
Application of Normalization
the hearing, or to be placed on the and lower tax expense than the
Accounting Rules to Balances of
building access list to attend the accelerated method used in computing
Excess Deferred Income Taxes and
hearing, Treena Garrett, at (202) 622– actual tax expense.
Accumulated Deferred Investment Tax
Credits of Public Utilities Whose 7190 (not toll-free numbers). This accounting treatment prevents
Assets Cease To Be Public Utility SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: the immediate flow-through to utility
Property ratepayers of the reduction in current
Background taxes resulting from the use of
AGENCY: Internal Revenue Service (IRS), This document contains proposed accelerated depreciation. Instead, the
Treasury. amendments to the Income Tax reduction is treated as a deferred tax
ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking, Regulations (26 CFR Part 1) relating to expense that is collected from current
notice of public hearing, and the normalization requirements of ratepayers through utility rates, and
withdrawal of previous proposed sections 168(f)(2) and 168(i)(9) of the thus is available to utilities as
regulations. Internal Revenue Code (Code), section investment capital. When the
203(e) of the Tax Reform Act of 1986, accelerated method provides lower
SUMMARY: This document contains depreciation deductions in later years,
Public Law 99–514 (100 Stat. 2146), and
proposed regulations that provide only the ratemaking tax expense is
former section 46(f) of the Code.
guidance on the normalization collected from ratepayers and the
Proposed regulations relating to the
requirements applicable to public difference between actual tax expense
normalization requirements applicable
utilities that benefit (or have benefited) and ratemaking tax expense is charged
to electric utilities that benefit (or have
from accelerated depreciation methods to ADFIT.
benefited) from accelerated depreciation
or from the investment tax credit
methods or from the investment tax Excess Deferred Income Tax
permitted under pre-1991 law. The
credit permitted under pre-1991 law
proposed regulations permit a utility The Tax Reform Act of 1986 (the 1986
[REG–104385–01] were published in the
whose assets cease to be public utility Act) reduced the highest corporate tax
Federal Register on March 4, 2003 (the
property to return to its ratepayers the rate from 46 percent to 34 percent. The
2003 proposed regulations). The 2003
normalization reserve for excess excess deferred federal income tax
proposed regulations would have
deferred income taxes (EDFIT) with (EDFIT) reserve is the balance of the
provided rules under which electric
respect to those assets and, in certain deferred tax reserve immediately before
utilities whose electricity generation
circumstances, also permit the return of the rate reduction over the balance that
assets cease to be public utility
part or all of the reserve for accumulated would have been held in the reserve if
property, whether by disposition,
deferred investment tax credits (ADITC) the 34 percent rate had been in effect for
deregulation, or otherwise, could
with respect to those assets. This prior periods. The EDFIT reserves were
continue to flow through certain
document also provides notice of a amounts that utilities had collected
reserves associated with those assets
public hearing on these proposed from ratepayers to pay future taxes that,
without violating the normalization
regulations and a withdrawal of as a result of the 1986 Act reduction in
requirements. In response to public
proposed regulations [REG–104385–01] corporate tax rates, would not be
comments and after further analysis, the
published March 4, 2003, at 68 FR imposed.
2003 proposed regulations are
10190. Section 203(e) of the 1986 Act
withdrawn, and new regulations are
DATES: Written or electronic comments proposed in this document. specifies the manner in which the
must be received by March 21, 2006. EDFIT reserve must be flowed through
Requests to speak and outlines of topics Normalization Method of Accounting to ratepayers under a normalization
to be discussed at the public hearing Section 168 of the Code permits the method of accounting. It provides that
scheduled for April 5, 2006, at 10 a.m. use of accelerated depreciation the EDFIT reserve may be reduced, with
must be received by March 15, 2006. methods. Section 168(f)(2) provides, a corresponding reduction in the cost of
ADDRESSES: Send submissions to: however, that accelerated depreciation service the utility collects from
CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG–104385–01), Room is permitted with respect to public ratepayers, no more rapidly than the
5203, Internal Revenue Service, PO Box utility property only if the taxpayer uses EDFIT reserve would be reduced under
7604, Ben Franklin Station, Washington, a normalization method of accounting the average rate assumption method
DC 20044. Submissions may be hand- for ratemaking purposes. (ARAM). For taxpayers that did not
delivered Monday through Friday Under a normalization method of have adequate data to apply the average
between the hours of 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. accounting, a utility calculates its rate assumption method, subsequent
to CC:PA:LPD:PR (REG–104385–01), ratemaking tax expense using guidance permitted use of the reverse
Courier’s Desk, Internal Revenue depreciation that is no more accelerated South Georgia method as an alternative.
rmajette on PROD1PC67 with PROPOSALS

Service, 1111 Constitution Avenue, than its ratemaking depreciation In general, both the average rate
NW., Washington, DC, or sent (typically straight-line). In the early assumption method and the reverse
electronically, via the IRS Internet site years of an asset’s life, this results in South Georgia method spread the flow-
at http://www.irs.gov/regs or via the ratemaking tax expense that is greater through of the EDFIT reserve over the
Federal eRulemaking Portal at http:// than actual tax expense. The difference remaining lives of the property that gave
www.regulations.gov (indicate IRS and between the ratemaking tax expense and rise to the excess.

VerDate Aug<31>2005 14:51 Dec 20, 2005 Jkt 208001 PO 00000 Frm 00018 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\21DEP1.SGM 21DEP1
Federal Register / Vol. 70, No. 244 / Wednesday, December 21, 2005 / Proposed Rules 75763

Accumulated Deferred Investment Tax 1986 Act, the entire EDFIT reserve with respect to the asset and any
Credits (ADITC) would have been flowed through to additional stranded cost that the utility
Former section 46 of the Code ratepayers when the reduction in rates is permitted to recover with respect to
similarly addressed the flow-through to became effective, whether the assets to the asset after its deregulation.
which the EDFIT reserve was Accordingly, the proposed regulations
ratepayers of the investment tax credit
attributable remained public utility permit flowthrough of the ADITC
determined under that section. Under
property for their entire useful life or reserve with respect to public utility
former section 46(f)(1), the rate base (the
were subsequently deregulated or sold. property to continue after its
amount on which the utility is deregulation only to the extent the
As noted in the preamble of the 2003
permitted to collect a return from reduction in cost of service does not
proposed regulations, the IRS and
ratepayers) could be reduced by reason exceed, as a percentage of the ADITC
Treasury have concluded that section
of the credit if the reduction in the rate with respect to the property at the time
203 of the 1986 Act provides a schedule
base was restored not less rapidly than of deregulation, the percentage of the
for flowing through the EDFIT reserve
ratably. If the rate base is reduced, the total stranded cost that the taxpayer is
but that nothing in that section suggests
credit may not also be used to reduce permitted to recover with respect to the
that something less than the entire
the utility’s cost of service. Under reserve should ultimately be flowed property. In addition, the credit may not
former section 46(f)(2), an electing through to ratepayers. Accordingly, be flowed through more rapidly than the
utility could flow through the these proposed regulations retain the rate at which the taxpayer is permitted
investment credit not more rapidly than rule of the 2003 proposed regulations, to recover the stranded cost with respect
ratably (that is, could reduce the cost of with the effective date changes to the property.
service collected from ratepayers by no described below, for generation assets As in the case of the EDFIT reserve,
more than a ratable portion of the credit) and extend the application of the rule to these proposed regulations extend the
over the investment’s regulatory life. all other public utility property. flowthrough rule for generation assets to
The balance of the credit remaining to The 2003 proposed regulations also all public utility property. In addition,
be flowed through to ratepayers would provided similar rules under which these proposed regulations provide
be held in a reserve for accumulated utilities could continue to flow through equivalent rules for property to which
deferred investment tax credits (ADITC). ADITC reserves associated with former section 46(f)(1) (relating to rate
If the utility elected ratable flow- deregulated generation assets without base restoration) applies.
through of the credit, the rate base could violating the normalization
not be reduced by reason of any portion Proposed Effective Date
requirements. The proposed regulations
of the credit. did not address the treatment of The 2003 proposed regulations would
deregulated assets under former section have applied to public utility property
Private Letter Rulings
46(f)(1) (relating to the use of the deregulated after March 4, 2003.
The IRS has issued a number of investment credit to reduce the Utilities would have been permitted an
private letter rulings holding that flow- taxpayer’s rate base). After further election to apply the proposed rules to
through of the EDFIT and ADITC consideration, the IRS and Treasury property that was deregulated on or
reserves associated with an asset is not have concluded that flowthrough of the before that date.
permitted after the asset’s deregulation, ADITC reserve should not continue after Comments suggested that
whether by disposition or otherwise. deregulation except to the extent the deregulation agreements between
These rulings were based on the utility is permitted to recover stranded utilities and their regulators entered into
principle that flow-through is permitted costs after deregulation. before the March 4, 2003 proposed
only over the asset’s regulatory life and If an asset qualifying for the effective date were based on the only
when that life is terminated by investment tax credit is purchased by a guidance then available (i.e., the private
deregulation no further flow-through is utility, the allowance of the credit, letter rulings issued by the IRS) and that
permitted. After further consideration, without flowthrough, lowers the the availability of a retroactive election
the IRS and Treasury have concluded utility’s actual tax expense but does not could effectively change the terms of
that former section 46(f) does not, in all result in higher tax expense for those agreements. Although private
cases, prohibit flowthrough of ADITC ratepayers than would have been the letter rulings are directed only to the
reserves after deregulation and that case if the asset had not been purchased. taxpayers who requested them and may
section 203(e) of the Tax Reform Act Thus, in the absence of flowthrough, the not be used or cited as precedent, the
does not preclude flowthrough of the investment tax credit is a subsidy from IRS and Treasury have concluded that
EDFIT reserve with respect to the Federal government for the purchase the Secretary’s authority under section
deregulated property. of the asset rather than a transfer from 7805(b)(7) to provide for retroactive
ratepayers to the utility. The underlying elections should not be exercised in a
Explanation of Provisions
policy of former section 46(f) is to share manner that impairs existing agreements
The 2003 proposed regulations this subsidy between ratepayers and between utilities and their regulators.
provided that utilities whose generation utilities in proportion to their respective Accordingly, these proposed regulations
assets cease to be public utility contributions to the purchase price. In do not include a similar election to
property, whether by disposition, general, former section 46(f) treats apply the regulations retroactively.
deregulation, or otherwise (deregulated ratepayers as contributing to the As noted above, these proposed
public utility property), may continue to purchase price when ratemaking regulations are broader in scope than
flow through EDFIT reserves associated depreciation expense with respect to the the 2003 proposed regulations.
with those assets without violating the asset is included in the rates they pay, Accordingly, these regulations are
rmajette on PROD1PC67 with PROPOSALS

normalization requirements. The rate of resulting in full flowthrough over the proposed to apply to public utility
flowthrough was limited to the rate that asset’s regulatory life. In the case of a property that becomes deregulated
would have been permitted under a deregulated asset, the contribution of public utility property after [DATE OF
normalization method of accounting if ratepayers can be appropriately PUBLICATION OF FINAL RULE IN
the assets had remained public utility measured by the ratemaking THE Federal Register]. For public
property. But for section 203(e) of the depreciation expense they are charged utility property that becomes

VerDate Aug<31>2005 14:51 Dec 20, 2005 Jkt 208001 PO 00000 Frm 00019 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\21DEP1.SGM 21DEP1
75764 Federal Register / Vol. 70, No. 244 / Wednesday, December 21, 2005 / Proposed Rules

deregulated public utility property on or The rules of 26 CFR 601.601(a)(3) property that becomes deregulated
before [DATE OF PUBLICATION OF apply to the hearing. public utility property is restored
FINAL RULE IN THE Federal Register], Persons who wish to present oral ratably during the period after the
the IRS will follow the holdings set comments at the hearing must submit property becomes deregulated public
forth in the private letter rulings that comments and submit an outline of the utility property if the amount of the
prohibit flow-through of the EDFIT and topics to be discussed and the time to reduction remaining to be restored does
ADITC reserves associated with an asset be devoted to each topic (signed original not, at any time during the period,
after the asset’s disposition. and eight (8) copies) by March 15, 2006. exceed the restoration percentage of the
Flowthrough will be permitted, A period of 10 minutes will be recoverable stranded cost of the
however, if it is consistent with the allotted to each person for making property at such time. For this
2003 proposed regulations, and occurs comments. purpose—
during the period March 5, 2003, An agenda showing the scheduling of (A) The stranded cost of the property
through the earlier of the last date on the speakers will be prepared after the is the cost of the property reduced by
which the utility’s rates are determined deadline for receiving outlines has the amount of such cost that the
under the rate order in effect on [DATE passed. Copies of the agenda will be taxpayer has recovered through
OF PUBLICATION OF FINAL RULE IN available free of charge at the hearing. regulated depreciation expense during
THE Federal Register], or [DATE 2 the period before the property becomes
YEARS AFTER PUBLICATION OF Drafting Information deregulated;
FINAL RULE IN THE Federal Register]. The principal author of these (B) The recoverable stranded cost of
regulations is David Selig, Office of the the property at any time is the stranded
Special Analyses cost of the property that the taxpayer
Associate Chief Counsel (Passthroughs
It has been determined that this notice and Special Industries), IRS. However, will be permitted to recover through
of proposed rulemaking is not a other personnel from the IRS and rates after such time; and
significant regulatory action as defined Treasury Department participated in (C) The restoration percentage for the
in Executive Order 12866. Therefore, a their development. property is determined by dividing the
regulatory assessment is not required. It reduction in rate base remaining to be
also has been determined that section List of Subjects in 26 CFR Part 1 restored with respect to the property
553(b) of the Administrative Procedure Income taxes, Reporting and immediately before the property
Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 5) does not apply recordkeeping requirements. becomes deregulated public utility
to these regulations and, because the property by the stranded cost of the
regulations do not impose a collection Withdrawal of Proposed Regulations property.
of information on small entities, the Under the authority of 26 U.S.C. 7805, (ii) Cost of service reduction.
Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. the notice of proposed rulemaking Reductions in the taxpayer’s cost of
chapter 6) does not apply. Therefore, a (REG–104385–01) published in the service on account of the credit with
Regulatory Flexibility Analysis is not Federal Register on March 4, 2003 (68 respect to public utility property that
required. Pursuant to section 7805(f) of FR 10190) is withdrawn. becomes deregulated public utility
the Code, this notice of proposed property are ratable during the period
rulemaking will be submitted to the Proposed Amendments to the after the property becomes deregulated
Chief Counsel for Advocacy of the Small Regulations public utility property if the cumulative
Business Administration for comment Accordingly, 26 CFR part 1 is amount of the reduction during such
on its impact on small business. proposed to be amended as follows: period does not, at any time during the
Comments and Public Hearing period, exceed the flow-through
PART 1—INCOME TAXES percentage of the cumulative stranded
Before these proposed regulations are cost recovery for the property at such
adopted as final regulations, Paragraph 1. The authority citation
for part 1 continues to read, in part, as time. For this purpose—
consideration will be given to any (A) The stranded cost of the property
comments that are submitted (in the follows:
is the cost of the property reduced by
manner described in the ADDRESSES Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * * the amount of such cost that the
caption) timely to the IRS. All Par. 2. Section 1.46–6 is amended by taxpayer has recovered through
comments will be available for public adding paragraph (k) to read as follows: regulated depreciation expense during
inspection and copying. Treasury and the period before the property becomes
IRS specifically request comments on § 1.46–6 Limitation in case of certain deregulated;
the clarity of the proposed regulations regulated companies. (B) The cumulative stranded cost
and how they may be made clearer and * * * * * recovery for the property at any time is
easier to understand. (k) Treatment of accumulated deferred the stranded cost of the property that
A public hearing has been scheduled investment tax credits upon the the taxpayer has been permitted to
for April 5, 2006, at 10 a.m. in room deregulation of public utility property— recover through rates on or before such
7218 of the Internal Revenue Building, (1) Scope. This paragraph (k) provides time; and
1111 Constitution Avenue, NW., rules for the application of former (C) The flow-through percentage for
Washington, DC. Because of access sections 46(f)(1) and 46(f)(2) of the the property is determined by dividing
restrictions, visitors will not be Internal Revenue Code with respect to the amount of credit with respect to the
admitted beyond the Internal Revenue public utility property that ceases, property remaining to be used to reduce
Building lobby more than 30 minutes whether by disposition, deregulation, or cost of service immediately before the
rmajette on PROD1PC67 with PROPOSALS

before the hearing starts. Due to otherwise, to be public utility property property becomes deregulated public
building security procedures, visitors (deregulated public utility property). utility property by the stranded cost of
must enter at the Constitution Avenue (2) Ratable amount—(i) Restoration of the property.
entrance. In addition, all visitors must rate base reduction. A reduction in the (3) Cross reference. See § 1.168(i)–(3)
present photo identification to enter the taxpayer’s rate base on account of the for rules relating to the treatment of
building. credit with respect to public utility balances of excess deferred income

VerDate Aug<31>2005 14:51 Dec 20, 2005 Jkt 208001 PO 00000 Frm 00020 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\21DEP1.SGM 21DEP1
Federal Register / Vol. 70, No. 244 / Wednesday, December 21, 2005 / Proposed Rules 75765

taxes when public utility property tax reserve. A reduction in the 8 a.m. and 4 p.m., Monday through
becomes deregulated public utility taxpayer’s excess deferred income tax Friday, except Federal holidays.
property. reserve will be treated as ratable if it is FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Bill.
(4) Effective dates—(i) In general. This consistent with the proposed rules in H. Brazier, Bridge Management
paragraph (k) applies to public utility regulation project REG–104385–01 Specialist, Fifth Coast Guard District, at
property that becomes deregulated (2003–1 C.B. 634) and occurs during the (757) 398–6422.
public utility property after [DATE OF period March 5, 2003, through the SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
PUBLICATION OF FINAL RULE IN earlier of the last date on which the
THE Federal Register]. utility’s rates are determined under the Request for Comments
(ii) Application of regulation project rate order in effect on [DATE OF We encourage you to participate in
REG–104385–01 to pre-effective date PUBLICATION OF FINAL RULE IN this rulemaking by submitting
reductions in cost of service. A THE Federal Register], or [DATE 2 comments and related material. If you
reduction in the taxpayer’s cost of YEARS AFTER PUBLICATION OF do so, please include your name and
service will be treated as ratable if it is FINAL RULE IN THE Federal Register]. address, identify the docket number for
consistent with the proposed rules in this rulemaking (CGD05–05–131),
regulation project REG–104385–01 Mark E. Matthews,
indicate the specific section of this
(2003–1 C.B. 634) and occurs during the Deputy Commissioner for Services and document to which each comment
period March 5, 2003, through the Enforcement.
applies, and give the reason for each
earlier of the last date on which the [FR Doc. E5–7583 Filed 12–20–05; 8:45 am] comment. Please submit all comments
utility’s rates are determined under the BILLING CODE 4830–01–P and related material in an unbound
rate order in effect on [DATE OF format, no larger than 8’’ by 11 inches,
PUBLICATION OF FINAL RULE IN suitable for copying. If you would like
THE Federal Register], or [DATE 2 DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND a return receipt, please enclose a
YEARS AFTER PUBLICATION OF SECURITY stamped, self-addressed postcard or
FINAL RULE IN THE Federal Register]. envelope. We will consider all
Par. 3. Section 1.168(i)–3 is added to Coast Guard submittals received during the comment
read as follows: period. We may change this proposed
33 CFR Part 117 rule in view of them.
§ 1.168(i)–(3) Treatment of excess deferred
income tax reserve upon disposition of [CGD05–05–131] Public Meeting
deregulated public utility property. RIN 1625–AA09 We do not now plan to hold a public
(a) Scope. This section provides rules meeting. But you may submit a request
for the application of section 203(e) of Drawbridge Operation Regulations; for a meeting by writing to Commander
the Tax Reform Act of 1986, Public Law New Jersey Intracoastal Waterway, (obr), Fifth Coast Guard District at the
99–514 (100 Stat. 2146) with respect to Manasquan River, NJ address under ADDRESSES explaining
public utility property (within the why one would be beneficial. If we
AGENCY: Coast Guard, DHS.
meaning of section 168(i)(10)) that determine that one would aid this
ceases, whether by disposition, ACTION: Notice of proposed rulemaking.
rulemaking, we will hold one at a time
deregulation, or otherwise, to be public SUMMARY: The Coast Guard proposes to and place announced by a later notice
utility property (deregulated public change the regulations that govern the in the Federal Register.
utility property). operation of the Route 35 Bridge, at New
(b) Amount of reduction. If public Background and Purpose
Jersey Intracoastal Waterway (NJICW)
utility property of a taxpayer becomes The New Jersey Department of
mile 1.1, across the Manasquan River, at
deregulated public utility property to Transportation (NJDOT) owns and
Brielle, New Jersey. The proposal will
which this section applies, the operates the Route 35 Bridge, at NJICW
allow the drawbridge to provide vessel
reduction in the taxpayer(s excess tax mile 1.1., across the Manasquan River,
openings upon four hours advance
reserve permitted under section 203(e) at Brielle, New Jersey. The current
notice from December 1 to March 31.
of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 is equal operating regulations set out in 33 CFR
This proposal will reduce draw tender
to the amount by which the reserve 117.733(b) requires the drawbridge to
services during the non-peak boating
could be reduced under that provision open on signal except as follows: from
season while still providing for the
if all such property had remained public May 15 through September 30, on
reasonable needs of navigation.
utility property of the taxpayer and the Saturdays, Sundays and Federal
taxpayer had continued use of its DATES: Comments and related material holidays, from 8 a.m. to 10 p.m. the
normalization method of accounting must reach the Coast Guard on or before draw need only open 15 minutes before
with respect to such property. February 6, 2006. the hour and 15 minutes after the hour;
(c) Cross reference. See § 1.46–6(k) for ADDRESSES: You may mail comments on Mondays to Thursdays from 4 p.m.
rules relating to the treatment of and related material to Commander to 7 p.m., and on Fridays, except
accumulated deferred investment tax (obr), Fifth Coast Guard District, Federal Federal holidays from 12 p.m. to 7 p.m.
credits when utilities dispose of Building, 1st Floor, 431 Crawford Street, the draw need only open 15 minutes
regulated public utility property. Portsmouth, VA 23704–5004. The Fifth before the hour and 15 minutes after
(d) Effective dates—(1) In general. Coast Guard District maintains the hour; and year-round from 11 p.m. to 8
This section applies to public utility public docket for this rulemaking. a.m., the draw need only open if at least
property that becomes deregulated Comments and material received from four hours notice is given.
rmajette on PROD1PC67 with PROPOSALS

public utility property after [DATE OF the public, as well as documents The Route 35 Bridge, a bascule-type
PUBLICATION OF FINAL RULE IN indicated in this preamble as being drawbridge, has a vertical clearance in
THE Federal Register]. available in the docket, will become part the closed position to vessels of 30 feet,
(2) Application of regulation project of this docket and will be available for at mean high water.
REG–104385–01 to pre-effective date inspection or copying at Commander The NJDOT has requested a change to
reductions of excess deferred income (obr), Fifth Coast Guard District between the existing regulations for the Route 35

VerDate Aug<31>2005 14:51 Dec 20, 2005 Jkt 208001 PO 00000 Frm 00021 Fmt 4702 Sfmt 4702 E:\FR\FM\21DEP1.SGM 21DEP1

You might also like