Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ROUND:
NEGATIVE:
NEGATIVE POINTS:
Award speaker points to each debater: 20-21 Below Average --- 22-23 Average --- 24-26 Good --- 27-28 Excellent --- 29-30 Outstanding
Decision: Affirmative Negative
Comments: provide detailed comments (both positive feedback and constructive criticism) designed to help both the debater and the coach;
for example, suggestions on improving case construction, refutation, logic, delivery, etc
Reasons for Decision (provide a detailed justification, referring to central issues debaters presented in the round):
Pgina 1
RESULTADO PARCIAL
20-21 Below Average --- 22-23 Average --- 24-26 Good --- 27-28 Excellent --- 29-30 Outstanding
3 15
15
3. Weighing Importance:
B. Argumentation
15
1. Proof:
2. Organization:
C. Presentation
15
1. Expression:
2. Delivery:
(gesture,moviment, eye contact,persuasive comunication)
.3. Rate
2 15
A. Preparation:
15
B. Debate
15
Affirmative 6 minutes
Cross-examination by Negative 3 minutes
Negative 7 minutes
Cross-examination by Affirmative 3 minutes
Affirmative Rebuttal 4 minutes
Negative Rebuttal 6 minutes
Affirmative Rebuttal 3 minutes
5 30
Pgina 2
SCORE
ORIENTAES
B. Argumentation
1. Proof:
Did the evidence orally presented pragmatically justify the affirmative or negative stance?
Did the reasoning orally presented philosophically justify the affirmative or negative stance?
2. Organization:
Are the ideas presented clearly, in a logical sequence, and with appropriate emphasis?
3. Extension, Clash, and Rebuttal:
Did the debaters fulfill their obligation to extend their own arguments?
Did they appropriately refute the contentions of their opponents by exposing weaknesses or
inconsistencies?
C. Presentation
1. Expression: Were language, tone, and emphasis appropriate to persuasive
communication?
2. Delivery: Were gestures, movement, and eye contact audience oriented and natural
components of
persuasive communication?
3. Rate: Was rate of delivery conducive to audience understanding?
B. Debate
Affirmative 6 minutes
Cross-examination by Negative 3 minutes
Negative 7 minutes
Cross-examination by Affirmative 3 minutes
Affirmative Rebuttal 4 minutes
Negative Rebuttal 6 minutes
Affirmative Rebuttal 3 minutes
Pgina 3