Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dr Lixiong Guo
Semester 2, 2015
the economy?
The answer is that it produces an efficient allocation of capital,
which contributes to higher production and efficiency for the
overall economy.
Suppose you have saved $1,000 this year and you do not have
any investment opportunities yourself. If there is no financial
markets, you will just hold on to the $1,000 and earn no interest.
However, Carl the carpenter can use your $1,000 to purchase a
new tool that will shorten the time it takes him to build a house,
thereby earning an extra $200 per year. If there is a financial
market, you can lend him the $1,000 at a fee of $100 per year,
both of you would be better off.
You would earn $100 on your $1,000 and Carl would earn $100
more income per year.
Financial
Markets
Borrowers-Spenders
(Mostly Firms and
Governments)
Lender-Savers
(Primarily households)
Funds
Secondary
Securities
Financial
Institutions
Indirect Finance
Primary
Securities
Funds
Funds
Primary
Securities
Direct Finance
In direct finance, corporations borrow funds directly from
Households
Household savers face several costs and risk when they invest
directly in corporations.
Information and monitoring costs:
High cost of information collection before the transaction.
High cost of monitoring after the transaction.
6
Price risk:
Even if financial markets exist to provide liquidity services, household
investors face the risk that the sale price of the direct claim will be lower
than the purchase price of that claim. This is another disincentive for
household to invest directly in corporations because household savers
are usually more concerned with preserving the value of their saving
than earning high returns.
Given the usually small size of household investments, they do not
have the scale to diversify the price risk.
Direct Finance
Transaction costs:
Household investors often face prohibitively high transaction costs
when investing directly in corporations because of the usually small size
of their investments.
In our previous example of the carpenter, suppose you need to pay a
lawyer $500 to write up the loan contract to protect yourself. When you
figure in this transaction costs for making the loan, you realize that you
cannot earn enough from the deal and will regrettably tell Carl to look
somewhere else.
Indirect Finance
However, the economy has developed an alternative way to
How does the FIs solve the problems of liquidity costs and price
risk?
The securities the FI buys are the primary securities issued by
corporations but the securities the FI issues to household lenders
are what we call the secondary securities.
Although the secondary securities are backed by the primary
securities the FI holds, they are claims on the FIs future income
and assets not that of the corporations that have issued the
primary securities.
The secondary securities are designed to appeal to households.
For example, they are highly liquid and have very low price risk.
10
e.g. Bank deposits are almost risk free and can have very short maturities.
11
Households
FI
Assets
Liabilities
Assets
Liabilities
Assets
Real
Assets
Primary
securities
Primary
securities
Secondary
securities
Secondary
securities
Liabilities
Risk Transformation
The real puzzle is how FIs can offer highly liquid and low price
The answer for risk transformation lies in the ability of the FIs to
Instead, the FIs can invest in many different firms at the same
A Review of Statistics
Suppose there are two assets, A and B. The variances of the
If =1, then = +
If =0, then 2 = 2 2 + 2 2
If =1, then = . If we choose the portfolio weight
to be
13
then = 0.
Diversification
Suppose we have N assets available, the variance of the i-th
2 =
=1
2
=1
2
=
Liquidity Transformation
Liquidity transformation exposes modern banks to a potential
Liabilities
Reserves $100,000
Loans
$900,000
15
Liquidity Transformation
What about having 1,000 depositors of $1,000 each, assuming
16
17
Adverse Selection
Suppose there are two firms in the economy, one has a safe
18
Adverse Selection
As a result, if you do not have the information to distinguish the
two firms, you may decide not to make a loan to any firm.
However, if you know which firm is safe and which is risky, you
would not have the problem and the safe firm will be funded.
One solution to adverse selection is screening. This requires the
lenders to be good at collecting and analysing information.
FIs have a distinct advantage over individual households in this
aspect because:
They have developed expertise in information collection and
screening.
They can take advantage of economy of scale to significantly lower
the average cost of information collection.
Moral Hazard
Moral hazard is the problem created by asymmetric information
20
as brokers.
The FIs are involved as agents not principals and are usually
compensated with a fee for performing the services.
The FIs mainly provide information and transaction services.
The FIs can perform these services more efficiently than
individuals can because of economy of scale.
21
Depository Institutions
There are many different types of FIs, each plays one or more
23
Insurance Companies
Life insurance companies insure people against financial hazards
following a death and sell annuities. They acquire funds from the
premiums that people pay to keep their policies in force and use
them mainly to buy corporate bonds and mortgages. They also
purchase stocks, but are restricted in the amount that they can
hold.
Property-causality insurance companies insure their policy
holders against loss from theft, fire, and accidents. They are very
much like life insurance companies, receiving funds through
premiums fro their policies, but they have a greater possibility of
loss of funds if major disasters occur. For this reasons, they use
their funds to buy more liquid assets than life insurance
companies do.
24
of funds transfer funds to net users of funds at a low cost and with
a maximum degree of efficiency.
Unlike other types of FIs, securities firms and investment banks
do not transform the securities issued by the net users of funds
into claims that may be more attractive to the net suppliers of
funds. Rather, they serve as brokers intermediating between fund
suppliers and users.
Investment banking involves the raising of debt and equity
securities for corporations or governments. This include the
origination, underwriting, and placement of securities in money
and capital markets for corporate or government issuers.
Security services involve assistance in the trading of securities in
the secondary markets (brokerage services and/or market
making).
25
26
Regulations of FIs
FIs are special because the services they provide are crucial to
27
28
29