Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
As the future of modern days banking became uncertain the fate of Islamic banking is
not sparred. The sub-prime issues, deterioration of worlds fiat money, the uprising of
consumer good prices are a major cause of concerned in todays economic zone (FT
2007). This colossal financial wreckage to the world economy does not only affect the
conventional banks but to the Islamic banks as well. It simply can be seen by looking at
the interest charges of conventional banks that has been lowered and so does the profit
rate for the Islamic banks (BIMB 2009). If Islamic banking is immune from the present
crisis then it should not lower down their profit rate. This evidence gave another chance
for the dinar and dirham scholars to promote the dinar and dirham economy. The best
medium to show the beauty of the dinar and dirham economy which promotes just and
equitable economy has to be from the souk or physical market. However since
todays economic activity catalyst by the banking system, therefore its high time that
the Islamic banks take the bold step to use the dinar and dirham in its banking practice.
Evidence, showing that the dinar can curb inflation and loss of fiat money value over
time, has been proven (Halim 2008). Islamic banking must be free from todays fiat
money system because banks that exist today are based entirely on the concept of
interest-bearing instruments (Bexley et.al 2000) and money creation (Fabozzi et.al
1998). This paper intend to clarifies most confusion arises out of the usage of the dinar
and dirham as well as to show the setbacks of todays fiat money system in detail and
morale boost the ummah in meeting the challenges in order to re-established the Sunnah
economy practice in Madinah more than 1400 years ago.
Introduction
Escalating gold price since the beginning of the millennium and constant
devaluation of the US Dollar (USD) has somehow retarded the trust
67
towards todays fiat money, (see graph 1). In 1970, 1 ounce of gold cost
USD35, while today it has skyrocketed to almost USD950. A merely
more than 2500% increased. What is actually increased? An ounce of
gold in the 1970s does not differ with an ounce of gold today. So why
does the price increased? A thorough studies has to be ascertained in
order to identify why price increase when majority of the goods or
commodity remain to be same in terms of its quality or size over time.
For example a chicken in the 70s does not differ if we were to compare
with the chicken in the year 2009 on the basis of its size, shape, taste,
colour, etc. Some economist when questions towards this situation will
simply say it was due to the cost of production. But why does the cost of
production increase when everything is the same? Then you will find the
famous answer that was promoted by the majority economic school of
thought which put the blame on inflation. And so the phenomenon
answered without further clarification. The word inflation has become
a taboo for common people to question. So the public was left with an
answer that they do not understand. Some minority of the public would
tend to ask what the meaning of inflation is and the common answer they
will receive was inflation is the general price increase of all goods and
services over time (Webster, 09). Is that the real meaning of inflation or
is it just a camouflage to hide the act of printing money. The hidden
hand as described by the so called father of modern economy Adam
Smith in his prime work: The Wealth of Nation. The truth is, the
definition of inflation is merely the effect of inflation and not inflation
itself.
69
Basic misconception
The statistics shows as if
my money increase in
value.
2006
80
70
60
Dinar
90
50
40
30
20
10
0
1960
1970
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010Year
18.00
1970
16.00
14.00
12.00
10.00
8.00
6.00
4.00
2.00
2006
0.00
1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 Year
20
Fig. 1: Price increase was due to money supply increase causing its value
to decrease.
Money is created out of thin air thats benefits few but oppressed
many others. This act is certainly unacceptable, not just because its has
Riba factor in it (Riba literally means increase and in the case of todays
fiat money, the supply of fiat money increases over time) but also an act
of zulm (injustice) and oppressive. It is injustice because it does not give
freedom to the keeper of the fiat money. If they kept it in the house they
will loose its value over time because they did not get the interest income
in order to compensate the money devaluation factor or so called
inflation. Over and over again, several studies show that, over time
compensation given in the form of interest gain does not match to the
inflation loss of the money value. A better illustration of money
multiplier and the inflation effect can be seen from figure 2.
70
Bank A: Received
USD100M as
initial deposits
Debit
Bank A
Credit
R.Reserve
Loan (B)
USD 100M
Bank B: Received
USD90M deposits
from Bank A
R.Reserve USD 9M
Loan (C)
USD 81M
Bank C: Received
USD81M deposits
from Bank B
Debit
Debit
Bank B
Deposits
Bank C
Credit
USD 90M
Credit
USD 81M
61
the limelight due to their robust and resilience act towards the crisis.
However in actual fact the Islamic banking system was not affected badly
is not because they are Islamic but because the rules and guidelines use in
practising the system is much tighter than compared to the conventional
practice that is more open to high risk.
Todays economy can be divided into two, where one is the real
economy and the other known as the financial economy. According to
Joel Kurtzman in his book titled The Death of Money, the real
economy is where products are made, trade is conducted, research is
carried out and services are rendered. The real economy is where factory
workers toil, doctors tend the sick, and where teachers teach and where
roads, bridges, harbors, airports and railway systems are built. He further
mentioned that, the other economy, the financial economy, is
somewhere between twenty and fifty times larger than the real economy.
It is not the economy of trade but of speculation.5 Its commerce is in
financial instruments. Mostly, it is concerned with the exchange of
equities, such as stocks, and securities, such as bonds and other forms of
debt. The latest and largest type of debt that the financial economy trades
from a technical standpoint is money.6 The banking system today either
Islamic or not is the prime mover to this financial economy. The money
supply will continue to grow under this evil system. Price will continue
to hike and debt of nations or people will also tend to increase and more
people will be in the poor state of economy as compared to the rich
community. To gain prosper and just equitable economy can never be
achieved with the present banking and economic system. A total
abandoned and halt of the existing economy system cannot be denied.
Fig. 3 gives a simple explanation of the modern day banking scenario.
72
Surplus
Surplus
unitunit
(those
(those
with excess
with excess
of
of
money)
money
Deficit unit
(those that short
of money
RICH
Both unit
match by
Banking
institution
using interest
rate as the
attracting
factor
through
loans and
deposits
Ultimately
Widening
The gap
Between
The
Rich &
Poor
POOR
55
73
mind its not the diminishing practice of the dinar and dirham that
diminished Islamic civilization but because of the diminishing of Islamic
practice by the Muslims was the major setbacks that cause the downfall
of once noble empire.
Anyway, since the oppressive economic system today has taken our
peaceful life for more than 200 years already, therefore it is vital that the
dinar and dirham need to be re-established. In the dinar and dirham
system, real gold and silver is used as money. Dinar will have 4.25 grams
of pure fine gold and dirham will contain 3.0 grams of pure fine silver.8
Dinar and dirham is real money or live money and it is difficult to
simply create or print or controlling its supply and demand through the
use of interest rate. This is due to the fact that gold and silver is limited in
supply by natural factors and requires scarce resources to produce.9
Furthermore, in dinar and dirham economy system, a hundred percent
reserve and liquidity requirement is required. Therefore, it is different
from fiat money, in which its existence promotes money multiplier and
interest charges.
Like it or not our todays banking system need to be totally reformed
if not it should face total abandonment. Therefore its vital that the
banking system need to change the role it plays in the economy. At
present they couldnt careless the state of the economy as long as they are
making money they are fine with it. As far as they are concern, as long as
the car manufacturer pays its loan and the car buyer pays their car loan
dues they will be happy. An ah-long business mentality, the only
difference is, one is legal and the other is not. They dont care whether
the car manufacturer manage to sell the car and to profit or not, viceversa they couldnt care less whether the car loan buyer afford to pay the
loan or not. Whatever it is they will benefit from both transactions.
So therefore, how the banking reform should be? When banking
with dinar and dirham is established, bank should not act as a merely
loan provider but should play the role as an entrepreneur or fund manager.
Which means the bank will require its own capital to invest. It should
accept deposits only in terms of dinar and dirham and it operates
electronically based on dinar and dirham. All dinar and dirham deposited
into the bank is real money with a hundred percent reserve requirement.
Banks will act as a safe keeper or trustee for dinar and dirham depositors.
Fig. 4 shows banking with dinar and dirham supposedly is.
74
RICH
Gap
between
rich and poor
will be narrowed
down by the dinar & dirham
economy system through
Islamic muamalat institution;
e.g. zakat, baitulmal, waqf, infaq,
Wakala, qirad, etc.
POOR
57
75
It is He who hath made you (His) agents, inheritors of the earth: He has raised you in
ranks, some above others: that He may try you in the gifts He hath given you: for thy
Lord is quick in punishment: yet He is indeed Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.(AlAnaam: 165)
Allah further forbid taking extra money out of debt, and He and his
messenger declare war to those who commit Riba. In addition, He said
without Riba, one will do justice to others, and others towards him or her.
As mentioned in the al-Quran:
O ye who believe! Fear Allah, and give up what remains of your demand for usury, if ye
are indeed believers (al-Baqarah: 278).
If ye do it not, take notice of war from Allah and His Messenger; but if ye turn back, ye
shall have your capital sums; deal not unjustly; and ye shall not be dealt with unjustly.
(al-Baqarah: 279)
76
78
Create a saving
Account.
Service fee is charged
Bank
Act as trustee or
Wakala.
Create an investment
fund account
to promote
Musyarakah
activities
(profit / loss)
basis.
58
Conclusion
Finally, banks should be more innovative, creative, more sophisticated
and more professional when dealing with dinar & dirham economic
system. The electronic payment system may take most of banks role as
the medium for payment.15 It is only a matter of times that dinar and
79
80
End Note
1
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
81
82