Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This aesthetic problem did not exist during the early periods when the composer
invariably played his own composition. Today, however, it is necessary to distinguish
between the composers contribution and the performers in order to evaluate the
source of artistry in the rendition of musical composition.
What does the composer expect from his interpreter?
Strange enough, to a composer, technique and tonality are not as important as the
character of composition. To him all performing power is wasted if the work does not
communicate as it was intended. Hence, to a composer, a singer with nice
personality and good technique may not be adequate if she does not have the
tragic sense needed by the composition.
When we listen to a performer interpret a composition it is necessary to interpret
also the interpreter himself so that we may know how much he is contributing to the
composition. To judge this fairly, we must distinguish between the composer
thoughts and the degree in which the interpreter is reproducing it. for this, our
equipment must be:
a. An understanding of the style appropriate to the historical period of the
composition and to the composers development at that time
b. The ability to describe precisely the nature of the execution so that we may
particularize the qualities special to the performer.
Expressive level
In much the same way that we follow the complication of plays plot,
we listen to the meaning of music all listeners tell us that they hear
what music is saying ; the difficulty is that they cannot tell exactly
what they hear.