Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Infection of the central nervous system (CNS) by Mycobacterium tuberculosis is invariably secondary to a primary
focus elsewhere in the body. The avium, bovine, and atypical mycobacteria are rarely isolated from the nonimmunocompromised host.The primary sites are usually pulmonary,
bone, and gastrointestinal tract; genitourinary sites are less
common. The incidence of CNS tuberculosis (TB) is a
reflection of the overall incidence of TB in a population.
A third of the global population (i.e., 2 billion people)
harbors the M. tuberculosis bacillus and is at risk of developing active disease. It is still a leading cause of mortality from
a single infectious disease.1 The epidemiology of the disease has been greatly affected by the advent of the human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV);2-5 emergence of multidrugresistant TB (MDR TB) and extensively drug-resistant strains
of TB (XDR TB); widespread intravenous drug abuse; inadequate case detection, diagnosis, and therapy; collapse of
health infrastructures due to economic crisis and war; and
continuing poverty.
The health burden related to TB has prompted the
implementation of World Health Organizations (WHOs)
Stop TB Strategy, which includes the following goals: (1)
TB incidence should fall by 2015, (2) prevalence and death
rates should be halved by 2015 from the baseline of 1990,
(3) at least 70% of incident smear-positive cases should be
detected and treated in the Direct Observation of Treatment (DOTS) program, and (4) at least 85% of detected
incident smear-positive cases should be successfully
treated.6 The WHO has also been publishing an annual
report on global control of TB since 1997 to provide a comprehensive and up-to-date assessment of the TB epidemic
and progress in controlling the disease. The trends suggest
that neither the prevalence nor the death rate would be
halved in Africa and Europe by 2015. An estimated 37%
of incident TB cases are not being treated in the DOTS
program, 96% of incident case with MDR TB are not being
diagnosed and treated according to guidelines, the majority of HIV-positive TB cases do not know their HIV status,
and of those who do, the majority do not have access to
antiretroviral therapy.1
In the United States,7 the average decline of 5% per
year in the TB case rate plateaued, and from 1986 to 1992
there was an increase in the number of reported cases.4
Subsequent to aggressive management of TB, the average
annual percentage decline in TB was 7.3% per year during
the period from 1993 to 2000 and 3.8% during the period
from 2000 to 2008, along with a 75% reduction in drug
resistance.8
Tuberculomas
INCIDENCE
The incidence of tuberculomas in India, which comprised
20% to 30% of all intracranial space-occupying lesions in
the 1950s and 1960s, has declined since 1980.13-16 Although
TB is widely prevalent in Nigeria17 and Taiwan,18 tuberculomas are rare. Tuberculomas are increasingly reported
in industrialized nations and account for 1% to 2% of all
intracranial lesions.19-22
LOCATION
Tuberculomas can occur at any site in the brain, most
commonly the various lobes and the cerebellum. Unusual
sites of tuberculomas include the dura mater,20-23 subdural
1679
1680
Meningeal
Calvarial
Spinal Tuberculosis
Vertebral
Meningeal
Parenchymal
Manifestation
Tuberculoma
Abscess
Tubercular encephalopathy
Chronic meningitis
Osteomyelitis
Potts disease of the spine
Arachnoiditis
Tuberculoma
stem,21,24-26
PATHOLOGIC FEATURES
The typical mature tuberculoma is a solid, creamy white,
well-defined, avascular mass with multiple nubbins
encased in a firm gliotic capsule and extending into and
compressing the surrounding brain. The cut section is pale
yellow with an often gritty caseating central core.40 The
immature form consists of multiple small tubercles, some
with caseating or liquefied centers dispersed within an
edematous brain. Severe edema, possibly caused by an
allergic response,40 may surround these tubercles. Tuberculomas vary in size from 1.5 to 8 cm. Giant tuberculomas can
occupy an entire cerebral hemisphere,41 and many adhere
to the dura. The dural attachment can be tenuous or so firm
that the tumor resembles a meningioma.
Microscopically, the central zone of caseous necrosis
is surrounded by tuberculous granulation tissue consisting of epithelioid cells, Langerhans giant cells, and some
lymphocytes, polymorphonuclear leukocytes, and plasma
cells (Fig. 148-1). Acid-fast bacilli, although sparse, are usually present in both layers. The brain surrounding a tuberculoma may show degenerated axons and nerve cells,
thrombosed vessels, and occasionally, swollen astrocytes
and oligodendroglial cells. The changes in the small vessels
can lead to microhemorrhages or microinfarcts, and these
areas may coalesce.42 Smaller satellite tuberculomas may
surround the main mass.
Tuberculomas can take several unusual forms,43,44 representing the spectrum of inflammatory reaction: (1) incipient
tuberculoma, which may appear as an irregular, fleshy, gray
cortical mass with associated meningeal tuberculomatosis
or even grape-like clusters of tuberculoma along cerebral
vessels; (2) subdural cyst overlying an intracerebral tuberculoma; (3) cystic tuberculoma; (4) tubercular abscess;
(5) extensive edematous encephalopathy without a tuberculoma; (6) severe cerebral edema with a small, inconsequential tuberculoma; and (7) rarely, tuberculoma that
has spread transdurally to the calvarium.
TB is a classic example of a disease the resistance to
which is mediated by cellular immunity. The nature of the
immunologic compromise in HIV, with its major effect on
cellular immunity, increases host susceptibility to TB and
abscess formation. Chronic inflammatory granulomas seen
FIGURE 148-1 A photomicrograph of a typical tuberculoma with Langerhans giant cells, epithelioid cells, and lymphocytes. Hematoxylin and
eosin stain, magnification 100.
CLINICAL FEATURES
Tuberculoma is a disease of the young, with 70% of patients
younger than 30 years. However, it is uncommon in children
under 4 years of age. Both sexes are equally affected.40,49
The signs and symptoms of tuberculomas resemble
those of other intracranial space-occupying lesions. As
they enlarge gradually, the clinical picture is one of a slowly
progressive lesion, although in at least 50% of patients, the
symptoms are less than 6 months in duration. Features helpful in distinguishing tuberculomas from other brain tumors
are constitutional symptoms, such as weight loss, fever, or
malaise; a history of active or known TB elsewhere in the
body; close contact with a patient with an open case of
TB; a high frequency of seizures, even in association with a
cerebellar lesion; a positive result on the Mantoux test; and
an increased sedimentation rate. Infants and young children may have an enlarging head. The clinical diagnosis
is often presumptive. Pyrexia is variable and may not be
present in more than 20% to 25% of patients,49 and the Mantoux test result may be negative.40 The clinical course may
uncommonly show spontaneous remissions and relapses.24
RADIOGRAPHIC FEATURES
An abnormal chest radiograph is a pointer to the diagnosis of a tuberculoma.57-60 More sensitive is a computed
tomography (CT) scan of the chest in picking up a tubercular involvement. Calcification occurs in fewer than 6%
of tuberculomas and is rarely extensive or dense,41 with
the striking exceptions of the Inuit (Eskimos) and North
American Indians, in whom nearly 60% of tuberculomas
are known to have calcifications.46 Calcification does not
indicate an inactive lesion. Cerebral angiography invariably reveals an avascular mass, although surface tuberculomas adherent to the dura may show some peripheral
vascularity.41,60 An associated vascular spasm may be seen
that is ascribed to tuberculous vasculitis. These angiographic findings may also be seen on magnetic resonance
angiography.
1681
Microtuberculomas
The CT scan also picks up small lesions that are less than
1.5cm in size, disc-like or ring shaped, and single or multiple; have slightly increased attenuation that enhances with
contrast; and are surrounded by disproportionately extensive low-attenuating white matter edema. Bhargava and
Tandon58 labeled them microtuberculomas. Careful review
of these cases suggests that not all of those lesions are
tuberculous in etiology. Indian neurologists and neurosurgeons encounter these lesions frequently in children and
young adults, but reports have come from other countries
as well. The patients usually present with focal epilepsy and
no neurologic deficit. Although some of these cases are
definitely tuberculomas, as proved by biopsy, others result
from a variety of causes.67-75
Goulatia etal.70 suggested that edema and increased vascular permeability due to seizures may be responsible for the
CT appearance. Chandy etal.68,69 found cysticercosis as the
most common cause, and Ahuja etal.67 noted that 12 of their
38 patients were seropositive for cysticercosis and two were
seropositive for TB. On CT scan, tubercular lesions tend to
be larger than 20 mm, more frequently irregular in outline,
with a midline shift. Cysticercus cysts, in contrast, tend to be
smaller than 20 mm, with a regular outline and no midline
1682
FIGURE 148-4 A, An MRI scan of a tuberculoma shows on T1-weighted images a slightly hyperintense rim (gliosis) surrounded by a complete or
partial rim of slight hypointensity (inflammatory cellular infiltrate) and central isointensity or of mixed isointensity and hypointensity (caseation necrosis and cellular infiltrate). B, On T2-weighted MRI images, the granuloma was hypointense (predominantly consisting of paramagnetic free radicals
in the macrophages and gliosis). This characteristic hypointensity of intraparenchymal tuberculomas is not found in most other space-occupying
lesions. Lesions may be hyperintense as well on T2-weighted images when the histology is of marked cellular infiltration with minimal gliosis.
Courtesy of D.C. Aggarwal, New Delhi, India.
Voxel location
1683
FIGURE 148-6 This clinical presentation was of a progressive paraparesis. The T2-weighted image shows
an intramedullary hyperintense lesion with a thin rim
of hypointensity around it. The surrounding cord is
swollen and edematous. The gadoliniumdiethylene
triamine penta-acetic acidenhanced image highlights the lesion. Courtesy of Rajiv Gupta and Harsh
Mahajan from Mahajan Imaging, New Delhi.
1684
Dosage
Contraindications
Drug-induced liver disease
Rifampicin
Pyrazinamide
Ethambutol
Streptomycin
Liver damage
Optic neuritis
Pregnancy
MEDICAL TREATMENT
Antituberculous Drugs
Jaundice, pregnancy
Side Effects
Peripheral neuritis, psychosis, optic neuritis,
occasionally lupus syndrome, convulsions
Liver toxicity, gastrointestinal symptoms, rarely
shock, respiratory collapse
Hepatitis
Optic neuritis, color blindness, peripheral neuritis
Ototoxicity, renal damage
Drug Resistance
Drug resistance of M. tuberculosis has been recognized
since the early days of streptomycin therapy. More recently,
there has been an emergence of MDR TB, defined as TB
that is resistant to the two most effective first-line therapeutic drugs, isoniazid and rifampicin. There are also virtually
untreatable strains of MDR TB labeled as XDR TB that are
also resistant to the most effective second-line therapeutic
drugs: fluoroquinolones and at least one of three injectable
second-line drugs used to treat TB (amikacin, kanamycin,
or capreomycin). Because of the limited responsiveness of
XDR TB to available antibiotics, mortality rates are similar
to the preantibiotic era. The mechanism is by chromosomal
mutation with emergence of resistant clones on the backdrop of inadequate drug therapy. The incidence of acquired
multidrug resistance (i.e., resistance to both isoniazid and
rifampicin) ranges from 0% to 48%.93,94 The WHO estimates that there are nearly 0.5 million new cases of MDR
TB, which accounts for 5% of the total of 9 million new TB
cases. The highest rate is in Baku, the capital of Azerbaijan,
where 22.3% of new cases were MDR TB.95 High rates were
reported from New York City,96 Estonia, and Latvia. A subsequent report of a decline in the prevalence of drug resistance in New York97 and in the United States as a whole,98
as well as the two Baltic countries,95 highlights the effectiveness of a strong TB program and the need for continuous
surveillance of drug resistance.99
Second-line drugs include the bactericidal drugs, fluoroquinolones, amikacin, kanamycin, ethionamide, capreomycin, prothionamide, and the bacteriostatic cycloserine.
Guidelines for treating MDR TB involve the use of at least
four new drugs never used by the patient, including a fluoroquinolones and at least one of the three injectable drugs
(amikacin, kanamycin, or capreomycin). Resistance to pyrazinamide and ethambutol is less likely, and they can be
included in the initial treatment. The initial treatment is for
at least 6 months, followed by a continuation phase of 12
to 18 months with the three most active and best tolerated
drugs.88 Patients with organisms resistant to rifampicin and
isoniazid have a high rate of treatment failure. Patients with
HIV infections not only are more prone to TB but also are
more susceptible to drug-resistant TB.100-102 Such patients
require a longer duration of therapy and may still die of TB
despite optimal treatment.102
Corticosteroids are used in the presence of elevated ICP
or severe cerebral edema as noted on imaging. Treatment is
seldom prolonged beyond 2 to 3 weeks, during which time
the corticosteroid therapy can produce dramatic improvement in the patients clinical state. Occasionally, patients
require steroids for a much longer period.
Anticonvulsant Medications
The high incidence of seizures with tuberculomas mandates the routine use of anticonvulsants. The commonly
used drugs are phenytoin, carbamazepine, oxcarbamazepine, and sodium valproate. Patients taking phenytoin and
isoniazid may acquire phenytoin toxicity because high levels of isoniazid in the serum can block metabolism of the
anticonvulsant.
SURGERY
A tuberculoma that severely elevates ICP and threatens life
or vision merits emergent surgical excision. In addition, surgical intervention comes into consideration in (1) patients
who do not respond clinically or radiographically to antituberculous drugs; (2) patients whose diagnosis is in doubt,
such as those with an atypical CT or MRI scan of the lesion;
and (3) patients with obstructive hydrocephalus.
Complete excision of tuberculomas is usually reserved
for smaller lesions in noneloquent areas of the brain. Larger
lesions require subtotal excision when they cause pressurerelated symptoms. An insistence on total excision at the
cost of an undesirable neurologic deficit is to be discouraged. In cases of multiple tuberculomas, only the largest
mass need be decompressed.
An appropriate craniotomy or craniectomy is performed
over the site of the lesion. Perioperative ultrasonography and
image guidance are useful for accurate localization of small,
deep-seated lesions. A clear plane of cleavage40,41 exists
between the firm, avascular tuberculoma and the edematous brain. The edema is usually not as pronounced as that
associated with metastatic deposits. Tuberculous lesions are
often on the cortical surface and adherent to the overlying
dura. Although dural adhesions are usually separable with
ease, the dural attachment at times can be extremely vascular, resembling that of meningiomas.41 After the tumor surface is identified, it is removed piecemeal from within the
confines of the granuloma. The ultrasonic aspirator is a useful aid in decompression. Where the center is liquefied or
necrotic, aspiration of the contents is sufficient; no attempt
should be made to excise the capsule. Subcortical lesions
are approached through a small corticectomy with preservation of as many vessels as possible. Parts of the tuberculoma
adherent to major vessels, venous sinus, or brain stem are
left in situ. The practice of frontal and temporal lobectomy or
excision of edematous brain is seldom necessary to achieve
decompression. Antitubercular chemotherapy is mandatory
even after a complete excision of a tuberculoma. After several months of administration of antituberculous drugs, the
lesion may be tough in consistency and resistant to curetting.
CT- or MRI-guided stereotactic biopsy and aspiration
constitute the preferred mode of diagnosis and treatment
1685
RESULTS
Initial reports of mortality ranged from 10% to 27% for intracranial tuberculomas, but the results have improved dramatically in recent years. Harder etal.59 reported no deaths
in 20 cases. In our experience of 50 consecutive cases,49
1 patient died in the hospital and 1 died 2 years after treatment, probably as a result of infection with a drug-resistant
organism. Both of these patients had multiple tuberculomas and markedly elevated ICP. Numerous reports have
been published of patients with deep-seated, inaccessible
lesions and lesions in the brain stem who have had excellent
recoveries.
Tuberculous Meningitis
TBM is a major cause of morbidity and mortality in countries where pulmonary TB is still common. TBM is a disease of childhood whose highest incidence is in the first
3years of life.104 An increasing incidence in adults has been
reported, and in our experience, adults account for 50% of
all patients. The incidence of TBM is five times higher in
patients with HIV.105
The major neurosurgical interest in TBM is the occurrence of hydrocephalus, tuberculomas, and rarely, chiasmal
and spinal arachnoiditis. In the acute stage, increased ICP is
related to the general inflammatory process, increased CSF
proteins, and impaired CSF absorption. When the disease
becomes subacute or chronic, the inflammatory basal exudates extend along small proliferating blood vessels into the
brain substance, leading to a border zone encephalitis associated with diffuse or focal ischemic changes due to vasculitis. Larger vessels, commonly the internal carotid artery
siphon, its bifurcation, proximal segments of the middle
cerebral artery, and sometimes the anterior cerebral artery,
1686
FIGURE 148-7 This MRI scan of a 25-year-old woman who had headache and seizures for 5 months shows a thickened leptomeninges over
the parietal convexity. Courtesy of Rajiv Gupta and Harsh Mahajan
from Mahajan Imaging, New Delhi.
PROBLEMS OF DIAGNOSIS
In many patients, the diagnosis of TBM still poses considerable difficulties. Examination of CSF is often inconclusive,
IMAGING
Computed Tomography
1687
MEDICAL TREATMENT
There is evidence that bacille CalmetteGurin vaccination
offers some protection against TBM.147,148 Once meningitis
is established, drug therapy similar to that for tuberculomas
is initiated (Table 148-2). Short-course chemotherapy is well
established for treatment of pulmonary TB but not for extrapulmonary disease. Goel etal.149 reviewed 35 cases of TBM
in which chemotherapy was given for periods of less than
2 years. Short-term therapy was associated with recrudescence of TBM and, in some cases, with the development
of deep cerebral infarcts and permanent neurologic deficit.
In a critical reappraisal of the literature on adjunctive
corticosteroid therapy in TB, Dooley etal.150 concluded steroids did not reduce the efficacy of adequate antimycobacterial therapy and appeared to offer significant short- and
long-term benefits in TBM. Several randomized trials of steroids in TBM have appeared in the literature. In the first prospective, randomized, controlled trial of dexamethasone in
TBM, Kumarvelu et al.151 concluded that dexamethasone
appeared to be a useful adjunct, especially in patients with
severe disease. A similar prospective, randomized, controlled trial of steroids in TBM in 141 consecutive children
concluded that the survival rate and intellectual outcome
were significantly better with steroids. There was enhanced
resolution of basal exudates and tuberculomas on serial CT
scanning. However, ICP and the incidence of basal ganglia
infarction remained unchanged.152 In a randomized, doubleblind trial involving 59 adults with TBM, prednisolone
was not found to be beneficial in patients with poor neurologic status, increased ICP, and cranial nerve palsies.153
A controlled trial on 545 adults with TBM demonstrated
1688
SURGERY
Cairns157 first advocated ventricular decompression during the acute stage of TBM. Since then, numerous procedures have been tried, and reports have conclusively
documented the efficacy of ventriculoatrial or ventriculoperitoneal shunts for this condition.146,157-160 The fear of
spreading tubercle bacilli through the shunt is unfounded.
Description
GCS 15
Headache, vomiting, fever with or without neck
stiffness, no neurologic deficit
GCS 15
Neurologic deficit present
GCS 9-14
Neurologic deficit may or may not be present
GCS 3-8
Neurologic deficit may or may not be present
RESULTS
The prognosis of TBM depends on the delay in treatment,
the patients level of consciousness, the presence and
degree of exudates, and the presence of hydrocephalus
and cerebral infarcts.109,160-168 After TBM, there is frequent
marked, generalized impairment of cognitive and motor
development.169 Palur etal.160 reviewed 114 patients with
TBM and hydrocephalus who underwent shunt surgery
and followed them for a period ranging from 6 months to
13 years (mean 45.6 months). They described a grading
score at admission based on sensorium and neurologic
deficit, which was found to correlate statistically significantly with the outcome (p < 0.001) The grading system
has since been modified to include the Glasgow Coma
Scale to improve reproducibility170 (Table 148-3). The
utility of this grading system has been ratified by other
researchers.171,172
Early shunt surgery is advocated for patients in grades I
and II. For patients in grade III, surgery may be performed
either without a trial of external ventricular drainage or
when an improvement in sensorium occurs after such a
trial. All patients in grade IV should undergo external ventricular drainage, and only those who show a significant
change in their neurologic status within 24 to 48 hours
of drainage should undergo shunt surgery. There would
be a few patients in this group who show no improvement on drainage yet may show improvement after shunt
surgery.173
Nadvi etal. compared two groups of 15 patients each,
one with TBM and the other whose patients were also
HIV positive, and concluded that the mortality and outcome following shunt surgery was significantly worse
in patients who were HIV positive even though at initial
presentation they had a better sensorium and fewer neurologic deficits. None of the HIV-positive patients had a
good recovery, and there were no survivors in grades
1689
III and IV. They concluded that all patients of TBM who
were HIV positive should be given a trial of CSF drainage, and only those who show an improvement should
undergo shunt surgery.174
CLINICAL FEATURES
The appearance of root pain, weakness of the lower limbs,
and sphincter disturbances in a patient with TBM suggests
the diagnosis of an evolving spinal arachnoiditis. Examination reveals a mixture of upper and lower motor neuron
signs with patchy sensory deficits.
IMAGING
Tuberculous arachnoiditis on myelography shows an
irregular thecal sac; nodularity; thickening of the nerve
roots, with clumping of the roots to one another and the
thecal sac; and CSF block. These findings are reflected on
MRI scans. In addition, there are CSF loculations and an
increase in CSF intensity on T1-weighted images, leading
to loss of cordCSF interface or a shaggy outline. Cord
involvement is seen in more than 80% of cases in the form
of increased intensity on T2-weighted images and cord
cavitation. With contrast, there is meningeal enhancement in 80% of cases (Fig. 148-10), although enhancement
of the roots and cord is less frequently seen. Associated findings of tuberculous spondylitis, basal exudate,
and intracranial granulomas are additional clues to the
diagnosis.181-183
TREATMENT
It is generally accepted that steroids are a useful adjunct
in treating patients threatened with paraplegia. Intrathecal
steroids may help in further resolution of the exudate. Gourie-Devi and Satish Chandra184 have advocated intrathecal
hyaluronidase to lyse the adhesions. Recurrence is common, and available treatments are not very effective. The
outcome of surgical intervention is quite unpredictable, and
it may be offered as a treatment option if the diagnosis is in
doubt, in localized lesions, or if imaging suggests a cyst at
the expected clinical level.
1690
KEY REFERENCES
Ahuja GK, Behari M, Prasad K, etal. Disappearing CT lesions in epilepsy:
Is tuberculosis or cysticercosis the cause? J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1989;52:915-916.
Ahuja GK, Mohan KK, Prasad K, Behari M. Diagnostic criteria for
tuberculous meningitis and their validation. Tuber Lung Dis.
1994;75:149-152.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Plan to combat extensively
drug-resistant tuberculosis: recommendations of the Federal Tuberculosis Task Force MMWR Recomm Rep. 2009 Feb 13;58(RR-3):1-43.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Trends in tuberculosis
United States, 2008. MMWR. March 20, 2009.
Chandy MJ, Rajshekhar VR, Ghosh S, et al. Single small enhancing
CT lesions in Indian patients with epilepsy: clinical, radiological
and pathological considerations. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry.
1991;54:702-705.
Cho SN, Brennan PJ. Tuberculosis: diagnostics. Tuberculosis. 2007;
87:S14-S17.