Professional Documents
Culture Documents
'i/-^'
C'>p\nehi ^ l'}9'') b\ Anruat Revie»i Irt. •\'l
331
0084-6S70/90 1015-03^1502 00
332 MCGOVERN
NORSE NORTH ATLANTIC 333
cumpolar circuit and link the Old Worid with the New in the early Middle
Ages However, this early medieval connection to the Westem Hemisphere
remained unexploited Vinland failed shortly after AD 1000. Norse Greenland
dwindled to extinction about 450 years later, and Iceland slipped from a
Scandinavian cultural and literar\' center to an lmpovenshed marginal
backwater hy 1500 While the islatids of the eastem North Atlantic fared far
better in the later Middle Ages and early modem penods, their integration mto
the early European world-system camed a heavy pnce in hazardous offshore
fishing and ruthless mercantile exploitation (66. 69. 194)
Why were early North American discovenes not followed up hy permanent
European colonies as in the 16th century^ ^ What caused the decline or collapse
of the other westem hemisphere colonies m Iceland and Greenland^ For the
past 15 years, research teams employing modem archaeological and
paleoecological techniques have begun to address these complex questions,
repeatedly documenting what appears to be a marked shift in adaptive strat-
egy Early colonists seem to have heen remarkably flexible and resilient,
swiftly altenng a generalized herding fishing/hunting economy to fit local
resources and environmental constraints Within a hundred years of settle-
ment, political stratification and centrahzation appear to correlate with in-
creasingly conser\^ative stabilized" economic strategies These strategies
sometimes failed to respond effectively to changing climate (onset of the
Little Ice Ageof ca 1250-1880). unintended degradation of groundcover and
grazing, and culture contact Especially in the Westem North Atlantic, lost
adaptive resilience, declining prosperity and population, and local extinction
were the result, dooming a possible North Atlantic route to New W^orid
colonization and condemning the sur\i\ing Norse colonies to an exploited
marginalization
Broad similanties with some Polynesian cultural trajectones and models of
island biogeographers (126) suggest the wider evolutionar\^ significance of the
Norse North Atlantic cases These diverse island laboratones" with differing
distances from mainland markets (and from emerging state systems) and
diffenng environmental vulnerability to changing climate and overgrazing
provide excellent opportunities for both selectionist and adaptationist analy-
ses
RESEARCH HISTORY
The North Atlantic islands were tirst subjects of systematic archaelogical
research in the last quarter of the 19th century, during a period when the
Faroes. Iceland, and Greenland were part of Denmark's colonial holdings
The work of the Danish Captain Daniel Bruun in the 1890s-1920s spanned
virtually the entne region but concentrated tn Iceland and Greenland Bruun
334 MCGOVERN
CURRENT RESEARCH
Arctic Norway
Much recent research m Viking Age-Medieval arctic Norway has cetitered on
the prohlem of the tell-like 'farm mounds"' These massive accumulations
represent up to 2000 years of continuous occupation and often contam a
mixture of midden matenal and structural remains Most modem work on
these rich deposits has been camed out by teams from the University of
Troms0 led by Reidar Bertelsen and Inger-Mane Holm-Olsen (25-29. 94).
who have combined meticulous stratigrapbic excavation with innovative sta-
tistical analyses The deposits document a mixed herding-fishing economy
with a strong mantime orientation and appear to reflect a northward expansion
of Norse populations roughly contemporary with the migrations to the west
The mteraction of Norse and local Sami populations is also a major research
interest to north Norwegian scholars, and this culture-contact situation is
becoming increasingly well documented (28)
Shetland
Systematic Norse archaeology in the Shetland Islands began with the ex-
cavations of Curie and Hamilton at the multi-component site of Jarlshof in
Dunrossness on the southemmost tip of the archipelago In Norse times, this
site grew to become a large estate, and the excavations produced an ex-
emplary site monograph by Hamilton (84)
Excavations by Small at the site of UnderhouU on Unst (169) documented a
senes of stmctures first thought to be Viking Age but subsequently dated to
later medieval pbases Ongoing excavations at Da Biggins site on the small
island of Papa Stour by Barbara Crawford (55) have uncovered traces of later
medieval structures that are probably associated with an elite residence known
from documentar}' sources In 1977-1980, Gerald Bigelow camed out a
multidisciplinar>^ investigation of sites around Sandwick hay on Unst His
team documented a two-phase i2th-14th-century small farm whose deposits
yielded large collections of artifacts and an enormous archaeofauna (31-34)
Simon Buttler has camed out a thorough study of Norse steatite (soapstone)
production in Shetland, documenting several types of quarrying activity (45,
46)
NORSE NORTH ATLANTIC 337
Faroes
The Faroe Islands have long supported a highly sophisticated local antiquanan
tradition, which played a significant role histoncally in fostenng national
consciousness (156, 194. 195) Place-name analyses have received much
attention in Faroe (IOO), and techniques fn^t developed there have been
applied in the Shetlands. Orkneys, and northem Scotland (144) in attempts to
trace settlement history and land use Systematic Faroese archaeology is
somewhat more recent, beginning in the post-WWII penod with the work of
Sveni Dahl (63) and continued under the leadership of Ame Thorsteinsson
(187) Much recent work has centered on the dating and character of the initial
settlement Pioneenng palynologicai work by Johatmes Johansen (102-104)
claimed to have identified evidence of early cereal cultivation by pre-Nor^
Celtic monks ca AD 600 This claim has proved controversial (105. 115), and
the status of the Celtic pengnni in Faroe remains ambiguous A recent review
of Viking Age archaeological evidence by Simun Arge (10. 11) concludes
that there is in fact little hard evidence to support the traditional Norse
settlement date (ca AD 825), with most radiocarbon and artifactual dates
clustering several generations later Arge notes that many early sites may have
been removed by ongoing manne erosion, and that the present archaeological
record probably does not reflect the earliest settlement pattem
Excavations directed by Steffen Suimmann Hansen at the site of Toftanes
NORSh NORTH AT1,ANTIC 339
Iceland
Archaeological research in Iceland began in the late 19th centur>- (38. 73).
and popular interest in the physical evidence for the dramatic saga-history of
Iceland has probably always been strong As in the Faroes, linguistic and
antiquanan scholarship has played a significant role in the movements
towards home rule and eventual independence from Denmark
The most ambitious archaeological project of the pre-independence penod
was the joint Scandinavian Thjorsardalur Project mentioned above (174).
which excavated or tested a series of neighboring ahandoned farms in the
Thjorsa valley in southem Iceland The project hegan the use ot dating by
volcanic tephera layers now extensively employed by Icelandic archaeologists
(184-186, but also see cntiques in 70. 188. 190) The onginal conclusions of
the project have been modified in recent work by Vilhjalmur O Vilhjalms-
son. who demonstrated that the abandonment bad been gradual rather than
abrupt and that some occupation persisted to the beginning of the 13th centur\-
(189) Since independence. Icelandic archaeologists have been active
throughouttheislandl7l. 72. 80. 81. 117. 118. 149, 150. 157. 176). mainly
publishing their findmgs in the yearbook of the Icelandic National Museum
{Arbok hins Islenzka Fornleifafelagsi Some of the strengths of modem
Icelandic archaeology are us continued interest in all phases of the island's
settlement history (not only the Viking Penod) and its strong commitment to
multidisciplinar>' investigations involving geo- and bioarchaeological col-
laboration The possibilities for ethnoarchaeological investigation (97). re-
gional settlement modeling (170), and histoncal agncultural reconstmction
(1) are also beginning to be fully exploited
Recently a debate has developed over the datmg of the fist Norse Settle-
ment in Iceland (traditionally cd AD 874) Margret Hermanns-Audardottn-'s
excavations of an early site at Herjolfsdalur on the Westman Islands off the
south coast produced some radiocarbon dates indicating occupation in the 7th
centur>' (90) Her claim of a pre-Viking Scandinavian colony has drawn
cnticism from botb archaeologists and natural scientists, and the topic re-
mains controversial
The Celtic monks (Icel papar) traditionally beheved to have preceded the
340 MCGOVERN
Greenland
After a long hiatus. Greenlandic Norse drchaeoJogy has seen a rapid expan-
sion in both fieldwork and laboratorv' analysis since the mid-1970s (for
summaries of earlier research see 39. 99, 145. for cntical review see 101.
112) Projects involving both excavation and sur\ ey were camed out between
1976 and 1984 in the Westem Settlement (Inuit-Norse Project 1976-1977.
342 MCGOVERN
SUMMARY
The archaeology of the Norse North Atlantic has a long scholarly history, hut
the region has only recently emerged as a well-defined area of intemational
interest A senes of recent meetings has ser\'ed to strengthen ties among
workers in Scandinavia, the United Kingdom, and North Amenca and has
contnbuted to an emerging consciousness of shared research goals and
NORSE NORTH ATLANTIC 345
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
1 would like to thank all the many scholars in North Amenca. Greenland.
Iceland. Faroe, the United Kingdom. Norway, and Denmark who have so
generously shared data, ideas, cnticism. and tent space over the past two
decades My gratitude is especially due to those who participated in fieldwork
in W'est Greenland. Shetland, and Iceland and to our kind hosts in all these
places Tom Amorosi provided the map and much unpublished data Research
reported here was made possible by grants trom the US National Science
Foundation, the National Geographic Society, the Wenner-Gren Foundation
tor .Anthropological Research. The NATO Scientific Grants program, the
Amencan-Scandinavian Foundation, and the PSC-CUNY Grants Program
Ali errors are the author's responsibilitv
Literature Cited
82a Hallgnmsdottir, M 1989 Videv die Society and Economy during the
Fornleifarannsoknir 1988-1989 Revk- Commonwealth Period l930-'!262}
javik Arbaejarsafti Paper presented at the 1989 Am An-
83 Hallgnmsdottir. M 1990 The excava- tbropol Assoc Meet . Washington.
tion on Videv a preliminary report See DC
Ref 35 In press ' 98 Ingstad. A S 1977 The Discoveri c^ a
84 Hamilton. J R C 1956 Excavations at Norse Settlement tn America NY
Jartshof Shetland Edinburgh Her Maj Columbia Umv Press
Stat Off 99 Ingstad, H 1966 Land Under the Pole
85 Hansen. F C C 1924 Anthropologia Star NY Random House
medico-histona Groeanlandiae antiquae 100 Jakobsen. J 1904 Faer0sk Sagnhistor-
I Herjolfsnes Medd Grontand le Copenhagen Licde
67(1)293-547 101 Jansen, H M 1911 A cntical account
86 Hansen. S S 1989 Toftanes—en of the wntten and archaeoiogicai
faeresk landnamsgaard fra 9-10 sources' evidence concemmg the Norse
aarhundrede Hikuin 15 129-46 settlements in Greenland Medd Gront
87 Hansen, S S 1990 Toftanes A 182(41
Faroese Viking age farmstead from the 102 Johansen. J 1971 A paleobotanical
9th-10th centur\' See Ref 35 In press study indicating a pre-Viking settlement
88 Hastrup. K 1985 Cidture and Histon. tn Tjemuvik, Faroe Islands \n 600
in Medieval Iceland An An- Frodskaparrit 19 147-57
thropological Anatvsis of Structure and 103 Johansen. J 1979 Cereal cultivation in
Change Oxford Clarendon Press Mykines. Faroe Islands AD 600
89 Hedges. J W 1983 Tnal excavations Danmks Geot Unders Arbog 1978
on Pictish and Viking Senlements at 93-103
Sdevar Howe. Birsay. Orkney Glasgow 104 Jobansen. J 1985 Studies in the Vege-
Arch / 10 73-124' tational History- of the Faroe and Shet-
90 Hermanns-Audardottir, M 1989 Is- land Islands Tofshavn Faevosk For-
lands tidiga bosattntng Studier med laget
utgaangspunkt i merovingertida- 105 Jchansen, J 1986 Feroya fyrsta buset-
vikingatida gaardslamningar i Herjolf- ine—eina ferd enn Moridul 1986 (2) 3 -
sdalur, Vestmannaevjar Island Stud 6
Archaeot Umv UmensisNo I Lmeaa. 105a Jones, A 1990 Preliminary observa-
Sweden Univ Umeaa tion on fish remains from ^ Late Norse
91 Herteig. A E . Liden. H E . Blind- settlement in Caithness. North Scotland
heim. C , eds 1975 Archaeolosicat See Ref 35 In press
Contributions lo the Earh Historv of 106 Jones. G 1984 4 Htstory of the Vi-
Urban Communities m Norway Oslo ktngs Oxford Oxford Vniv Press 2nd
Universitetsforlag ed
92 Hodges, R . Whitehouse. D 1983 107 Jones, G 1985 The Worse Atlantic
Mohammed. Charlemagne, and the Ori- Saga Oxford Oxford Univ Press 2nd
gins Of Europe Ithaca Comell Univ ed
Press • 108 Jones. G 1990 The Vikine World See
93 Hodges, R 1983 New approaches to Ref 35 In press
medieval archaeology Part 1 In Twen- 109 Kaland. S H H 19'?3 Westnessut-
tv-five \ears of Medieval Archaeologv. gravningene paa Rousay. Orkny0yene
ed D Hmton. pp 24-32 Sheffield Viking 77-102
Sheffield U Press 110 Keller, C 1983 Gaard og seter paa
94 Hoim-Olsen, 1 M 1981 The Gr0nland—et fersflk paa analysere res-
archaeological results Vtr Arch Rev surstilgangen i middelalderen ved bjelp
Ul\11 av satelitthilder In Hus Gaard och
95 Hunter. J R 1983 Recent excavations Bebvggetse Rekyjavik, ed G Olafs-
on the BrouEh of Birsay Orknev Heri- son, pp 59-66 Reykjavik National
tige 2 152-70 Mus
96 Hunter. J R . Moms. C D 1981 Re- 111 Keller, C 1990 The Eastem Settlement
cent Excavations at the Brough of Bir- reconsidered some an^yses of Norse
say. Orkney In Proceedings of the Medieval Greenland Medd Gr0nl In
Eighth Viking Congress Arhus 1981, press
ed H Bekker-Nielsen. P Foote. O 112 Keller. C 1990 Vikings m the West
Olsen. pp 245-58 Aarhus Munk- Atlantic a model of Norse Greenlandic
sgaard Medieval society See Ref 35 In press
97 Ingimundarson, J H 1989 The Chief- 113 Knstjansson, L 1980-87 Islenzktr
doms of the Merckant-Farmer<i Icelan- Sjavarhaemr l-V Reykjavik
NORSE NORTH ATLANTIC 349