Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CITATIONS
READS
103
457
2 AUTHORS:
Marie Foley Kijewski
Harvard University
67 PUBLICATIONS 899 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Philip F Judy
Partners HealthCare
141 PUBLICATIONS 2,406 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
CT
images
1. Introduction
565
566
2. Theory
In thissection, we derive an expressionforthe
NPS which includesthe effects o f
interpolation and of all sampling operations. We use parallel geometry and assume
thatthenoise
in the rawprojection data is stationary,additiveanduncorrelated
(white).Theprojection NPS is constant, with independentcomponents confinedto
frequenciesbelowtheNyquistfrequency,which
is determined by theprojection
samplingdistance.Becausetheprojectionsarediscrete,however,thespectrum
is
replicated at intervals of twice the projection Nyquist frequency (Barrett and Swindell
1981). This can be expressed by (see figure l ( a ) )
u2 *
N ( f )= p
u2
rect[a(f-2kffl)]
k=-*
=-
rect(af-k)
where a is theprojectionsamplingdistance,
ffl= 1/2a is theprojectionNyquist
frequency, U' is the variance, P is the number of projection elements, and rect( . . . )
is the rectangle function (Gaskill 1978),
rect(x) =
if 1x1 <t
otherwise.
Filtering the projections multiplies their power spectrum by the squared magnitude of
the filter frequencyresponse. Theconvolution-backprojectionalgorithm
filters the
projections by a ramp filter which may be apodised by a function H ( f ) . The NPS then
becomes (see figure l ( b ) )
The points of the projection atwhich data are required for backprojectionwill not,
in general, correspond to points at which data were measured. The projection values
between the measured points must be estimated; interpolation converts the discrete
CT
images
567
l
i
Spatlal f r e q u e n c y i x p r o l e c t l o n N y q u l s t
frequency I
is (figures I ( c ) and ( d ) )
568
(see figure 1). Interpolation, furthermore, is the only mechanism for removing veryhigh-frequencynoisepowercomponents.
The NPS is not apodised, as is thesignal
spectrum, by the physical aperture.
According to thewell known projection-slice theorem (Deans 1983), backprojecting
a projection at a given angle superimposes its power spectrum along a spoke through
thefrequencyspace originat thatangle.The(two-dimensional)
NPS of animage
formed by backprojection of L projections over T radians is
-x,
noise
The
power spectrum of
CT
images
569
interpolation are the most commonly used methods. If the pixel dimension, 6, equals
the projection sampling distance, a, then the NPS becomes
(8)
where f A
570
subtracting sequential pairs. We used difference images to ensure that the estimate of
the rips of the CT scanner was free of artefactsduetoscatter,uncorrectedbeam
hardening or other systematic errors. Spectra were estimated using a two-dimensional
extension of the method proposed by Welch (1967), similar to that used by Hanson
(1979). NPS of the simulated images were calculated from the central 128 x 128 pixels.
Spectra of the Technicare 2020 images were calculated from the central
256 x 256
pixels. In order to reduce truncation errors, the sub-arrays were windowed by
~,~=1-{[(i-1)-((~-1)/2)]~+[(j-l)-((~-1)/2)]*}[((~+1)/2)-~]
(10)
fx
CT
images
57 1
Figure 3. Two-dimensional image NPS calculated from 2000 images reconstructed from a single simulated
noise projection at 10". Zero frequency is at the centre of the plane. The image was reconstructed using a
ramp filter and linear interpolation. The pixel dimension was equal to the projection sampling distance.
NPS is composed of contributions from all projections; the agreement between the
predicted spectra and those calculated from the simulated images is excellent (figure
4). The major features predicted by our formulation, i.e. the apodisation due to linear
interpolation, the rotational asymmetry and the additionallow-frequency components,
Figure4. ( a ) Image NPS predicted by equation (8) (ramp filter, nearest-neighbour interpolation). ( b ) Image
NPS predicted by equation (9) (ramp filter, linear interpolation). ( c ) Image NPS calculated Prom 2000 images,
each reconstructed from 200 simulated noise projections, using a ramp filter and nearest-neighbour interpolation. ( d ) Image NPS calculated from 2000 images, each reconstructed from 200 simulated noise projections,
using a ramp filter and linear interpolation.
572
CT
are also present in the NPS of images from the Technicare 2020 (figure 5 ) , although it
does not agree exactly with the predictions. The discrepancies in the low-frequency
components probablyreflect deviations of the noisein the Technicare projections from
the assumed model, i.e. stationary white noise. The minor discrepancies in the highfrequency components are not surprising, since the images were reconstructed in a
fan-beam geometry rather than
in the parallel-beam geometry assumedfor theanalysis.
The rotational asymmetry can be seen in a plot of noise power against angle for a
constant radial frequency (figure 6). The NPS calculated from the simulated images
agree closely with the predictions; the spectrum calculated from the Technicare images
agrees qualitatively. The implication of a NPS which is not rotationally symmetric is
that the detectability of an object, or the precision of an estimate of the average CT
number over an area, will depend on the orientation of theobject or area with respect
to the pixels.
The low-frequency portion of the NPS (figure 7) departs from the ramp function
which would describe it in the absence of two-dimensional aliasing; furthermore, the
zero-frequency (DC) component is non-zero. The increase in low-frequency noise is
Figure 6. ( a ) Noise power plotted against polar angleat Nyquist frequency (along a semi-circle in frequency
space) for ramp filter, linear interpolation. The data points are from the NPS measured from simulated
images and the full curve indicates predictions of equation (9). The corresponding complete spectra are
shown in figures 4(b) and 4 ( d ) . The variation with angle is a result of two-dimensional aliasing due to
pixel sampling; the broken line shows predicted NPS without aliasing. ( b ) Noise power plotted against
polar angle at Nyquist frequency, images from commercial CT scanner. The complete spectrum is shown
in figure 5.
of cr images
noise
power
The
spectrum
573
4.8
3.6
2.4
1.2
0
S p a t l a l frequency l
t
l
L , *b.:,, l
CL
~
L"
.-. ...
0.4
0.8
1.2
Spatlal frequency l X Nyqulst frequency)
Nyqulst frequency)
1
I - >
3L
.'
.*
0.4
a/
574
We wish tothankDrStefanMuellerandDrStephenMooreformanyvaluable
discussions. We are grateful to Dr NorbertPelc for his careful readingof the manuscript
and useful suggestions. This research was supported by USPHS Grants CA 32813 and
CA 40444.
CT
images
575
Resume
Spectre de puissance de bruit des images.
Les auteurs ont ttabli une expression du spectre de puissance de bruit pour des images reconstruites suivant
un algorithme de rttroprojections filtrtes tchantillonntes. La formulation comprend explicitement Iichantillonnage des projections ichantillonnage anguiaire et implicitement Itchantillonnage bi-dimentionnel suivant
la representation discrtte de Iimage. Les effets dinterpolation ont considirt aussi. Le spectre de puissance
de bruit obtenu par cette analyse difftre sur deux plans de ceux obtenus en utilisant la thtorie continue:
ils ne prtsentent pas de symttrie circulaire et ne tendent pas vers ztro i la frtquence nulle. Lensemble de
ces propriitis peut &re attribut au recouvrement bi-dimensionnel dfi i Iichantillonnage des pixels. Les
pridictions sont confirmtes par les mesures des spectres de puissance de bruit pour des images simultes et
pour des images obtenues i partir de scanneurs X i transmission distributs commercialement.
Zusammenfassung
Das Rauschleistungsspektrum von CT-Bildern.
Entwickelt wurde ein Ausdruck fur das Rauschleistungsspektrum von Bildern,
mit Hilfe
die eines Riickprojektionsalgorithmus mit diskreter Filterung rekonstruiert wurden. Die Formeln behandeln insbesondere die
Abtastung innerhalb der Projektionen, die Winkelauswahl und die zweidimensionale Abtastung bei der
diskreten Bilddarstellung. Der EinAuJ3 von Interpolationen wird ebenfalls beriicksichtigt. So vorhergesagte
RauschleistungsspektrenunterscheidensichvondennachderkontinuierlichenTheorievorhergesagten
Spektren in zwei Punkten: sie sind rotationsasymmetrisch und sie nahern sich nicht null bei der Frequenz
null. Diese beiden Eigenschaften sind auf zweidimensionale Abtastdefekte aufgrund der Bildelementauswahl
zuriickzufiihren.DieVorhersagenwerdenbestatigtdurchMessungenderRauschleistungsspektrender
Rontgentransmissions-CT-Scanners.
simulierten Bilder und von Bildern eines kommerziell erhaltlichen
References
Barrett H H and Swindell W 1981 Radiological Imaging: The Theory of Image Formation, Detection, and
Processing (New York: Academic)
Dainty J C and Shaw R 1974 Image Science (London: Academic)
Deans S R 1983 The Radon Transform and Some of Its Applications (New York: Wiley)
Phys. Med. Bio!. 29 1343
Faulkner K and Moores B M 1984
Gaskill J D 1978 Linear Systems, Fourier Transforms, and Oprics (New York: Wiley)
Hanson K M 1979 Med. Phys. 6 441
James F 1980 Rep. Prog. Phys. 43 1152
Joseph P M and Schulz R A 1980 Med. Phys. 7 692
Joseph P M, Spital R D and Stockham C D
1980 Comput. Tomogr. 4 189
Kijewski M F, Judy P F, Swensson R G and Toltzis H 1983 Med. Phys. 10 525
Parker J A, Kenyon R V and Troxel D E 1983 IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging MI-2 31
1978 Phys. Med. Biol. 23 446
Riederer S J, Pelc N J and Chesler D A
Wagner R F, Brown D G and Pastel M S 1979 Med. Phys. 6 83
Welch P D 1967 IEEE Trans. Audio Electroacousr, AU-15 70