Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Aerospace Applications
Darren Pyfer, P.E.
Engineering Specialist Senior
October 16, 2001
Agenda
Vought Aircraft Industries Corporate Overview
Material Selection Criteria
Material Types
Material Forms
Examples
10/16/01
2
10/16/01
5
10/16/01
6
737
747
GV
777
757
CFM56
CF6
GIV
10/16/01
767
HAWKER 800
CF34
7
C-17
S-3
F/A-18E/F
F-14
E-8C/JSTARS
E-2C
EA-6B
V-22
Global Hawk
10/16/01
8
P-3
T-38
747
757
767
777
GV
C-17
10/16/01
9
Wings
Nacelle Control
Comp Surfaces
Static Strength
Material Must Support Ultimate Loads Without
Failure. Material Must Support Limit Loads Without
Permanent Deformation.
Initial Evaluation for Each Component
Usually Aluminum Is the Initial Material Selection
If Aluminum Cannot Support the Applied Load
Within the Size Limitation of the Component,
Higher Strength Materials Must Be Considered
(Titanium or Steel)
If Aluminum Is Too Heavy to Meet the
Performance Requirements, Graphite/Epoxy or
Next Generation Materials Should Be
Considered
10/16/01
11
Stiffness
Deformation of Material at Limit Loads Must Not
Interfere With Safe Operation
There Are Cases Where Meeting the Static
Strength Requirement Results in a Component
That Has Unacceptable Deflections
If That Is the Case, The Component Is Said to Be a
Stiffness Design
10/16/01
12
10/16/01
13
10/16/01
14
Weight
Low Weight Is Critical to Meeting Aircraft
Performance Goals
Materials Are Tailored for Specific Requirements
to Minimize Weight
Materials With Higher Strength to Weight Ratios
Typically Have Higher Acquisition Costs but Lower
Life Cycle Costs (i.e. Lower Fuel Consumption)
10/16/01
15
Corrosion
Surface Corrosion
Galvanic Corrosion of Dissimilar Metals (see
Chart)
Surface Treatments
Proper Drainage
10/16/01
16
10/16/01
17
10/16/01
18
Producibility
Commercial Availability
Lead Times
Fabrication Alternatives
Built Up
Machined From Plate
Machined From Forging
Casting
10/16/01
19
Cost
Raw Material Cost Comparisons
Aluminum Plate = $2- $3 / lb.
Steel Plate = $5- $10 / lb.
Titanium Plate = $15 - $25 / lb.
Fiberglass/Epoxy Prepreg = $15- $25 / lb.
Graphite/Epoxy Prepreg = $50- $100 / lb.
Specialized Requirements
Temperature
Lightning and Static Electricity Dissipation
Erosion and Abrasion
Marine Environment
Impact Resistance
Fire Zones
Electrical Transparency
10/16/01
21
10/16/01
22
Material Types
Aluminum
Aluminum Accounts for ~80% of the Structural
Material of Most Commercial and Military Transport
Aircraft
Aluminum (cont.)
7000 Series Alloys (Aluminum-
zinc
- magnesium
copper) Are High Strength With Improved Stress
Corrosion Cracking Resistance but Most Have No
Better Fatigue Properties Than 2000 Series
7050 and 7075 Alloys Are Widely Used
7475 Alloy Provides Higher Fatigue Resistance
Similar to 2024
- T3
10/16/01
25
Aluminum Tempers
10/16/01
26
10/16/01
27
10/16/01
28
Typical Application
High Strength Tension Applications. Best
Fracture Toughness/Slow Crack Growth Rate
and Good Fatigue life. Thick Forms Have Low
Short Transverse Properties including Stress
Corrosion Cracking.
2324-T3
8% Improvement In Strength Over 2024-T3 With
Increased Fatigue And Toughness Properties.
7075-T6,
High Strength Compression Applications.
T651, Higher Strength Than 2024-T3, But Lower
T7351 Fracture Toughness. T7351 has Excellent
Stress Corrosion Cracking Resistance and
Better Fracture Toughness Than T6.
7050-T7451 Better Properties Than 7075-T7351 In Thicker
Sections.
10/16/01
29
Titanium
Better Strength To Weight Ratio Than Aluminum or
Steel
Steel
Steel May Be Selected When Tensile Strengths
Greater Than Titanium Are Necessary
10/16/01
31
Steel (cont.)
Mil-
Hdbk
- 5List of Aerospace Steel Alloys:
10/16/01
32
Composite
The Embedding of Small Diameter High Strength High
Modulus Fibers in a Homogeneous Matrix Material
Fibers
Graphite (High Strength, Stiffness)
Fiberglass (Fair Strength, Low Cost, Secondary
Structure)
Kevlar (Damage Tolerant)
Matrix
Epoxy (Primary Matrix Material) to 250 F
Bismaleimide (High Temp Applications) to 350 F
10/16/01
33
Ftu
Fty
(ksi) (ksi)
64
47
78
71
134
126
Fcy
(ksi)
39
70
132
E
Density
6
3
(10 psi) (lb/in )
10.5
.101
10.3
.101
16.0
.160
150
140
145
16.0
.160
154
145
152
28.5
.283
80
60
.065
170
140
22
.056
10/16/01
34
10/16/01
35
Mil-Hnbk-5 Overview
Document Contains Design Information On The
Strength Properties of Metallic Materials and
Elements for Aerospace Vehicle Structures. All
Information and Data Contained in This Handbook
Have Been Coordinated With the Air Force, Army,
Navy, Federal Aviation Administration and Industry
Prior to Publication and Are Being Maintained As a
Joint Effort of the Department of Defense and the
Federal Aviation Administration.
10/16/01
36
Basis of Properties
Material Property Selection Is Dependant on the
Criticality of the Structural Component
Critical Single Load Path Structure
A Basis (99% Probability of Exceeding)
S Basis (Agency Assured Minimum Value)
Other Primary Structure With Redundant Load
Paths
B Basis (90% Probability of Exceeding)
Without a Test, A or S Basis May Be Required
Secondary Structure
B Basis (90% Probability of Exceeding)
10/16/01
37
Grain Direction
10/16/01
38
10/16/01
39
Material Forms
Sheet
Rolled Flat Metal Thickness Less Than .25
Fuselage Skin
Fuselage Frames
Rib and Spar Webs
Control Surfaces
Pressure Domes
Plate
Rolled Flat Metal Thickness Greater Than .25
Wing and Tail Skins
Monolithic Spars and Ribs
Fittings
10/16/01
42
Extrusion
Produced By Forcing Metal Through a Forming Die At
Elevated Temperature To Achieve The Desired Shape
Stringers
Rib and Spar Caps
Stiffeners
10/16/01
43
Forging
Produced by Impacting or Pressing The Material Into
The Desired Shape
Large Fittings
Large Frames/Ribs
Odd Shapes
Control Grain
Orientation
Residual Stresses
Can Cause
Warpage
Tooling Can Be
Difficult
10/16/01
44
Casting
Produced By Pouring Molten Metal Into A Die To
Achieve The Desired Shape
Nacelle/Engine Components
Complex Geometry
10/16/01
45
Composite
Produced By Laying Fabric, Laying Tape, Winding,
Tow Placement and 3D Weaving or Stitching
Skins
Trailing Edge Surfaces
Interiors and Floors
Properties Can be
Oriented To Load Direction
Excellent Strength To
Weight Ratio
Examples
7075
- T651 Aluminum
Plate
Stringers-
7075
- T6511
Aluminum Extrusion
Compression Dominated
Reduces Compressive Yield
Strength
2024
- T351 Aluminum
Plate
Tension Dominated
Good Ultimate Tensile
Strength
Stringers-
7075
- T73511
Aluminum Extrusion
Spars
7050- T7451 Aluminum Plate
High Tensile and
Compressive Strength in
Thick Sections
10/16/01
50
Fiberglass/Epoxy Fabric
Corrosion Barrier
Secondary Structure
Stiffness Design
10/16/01
51
Leading Edge
2024- 0Clad Aluminum
Heat Treated to- T62 After Stretch Forming to Shape
Clad For Corrosion Resistance
Polished For Appearance
De- icing by Hot Air/Bird Strike Resistance
10/16/01
52
4V Annealed
Forging
Annealed Form
Is Good For
Fatigue And
Damage
Tolerance
10/16/01
53
Good Corrosion
Resistance
10/16/01
54
Flap Tracks
PH13- 8Mo Cres Steel Bar
Geometry Is Very Limited
By Requirement To Be
Internal To The Wing
Good Corrosion
Resistance
10/16/01
55