Gov.
Brewer Writes Anti-Health Bill Letter
Mobile News Twitter Facebook FOX 10 Events
Site Map Submit Photos Job Shop
HOME NEWS MORNING SHOW WEATHER
CLASSIFIEDS
Home : News : Politics : State Politics :
Gov. Jan Brewer gives the State of the State address on Jan. 11,
2010.
Related Stories
Democrat Rep. Boccieri Flips Vote to…
Rep. John Boccieri (D-Ohio) announced
Friday that he would vote…
Ariz. Officials Calculating Health…
State officials say they're trying to
compute what costs the …
Cornhusker Kickback Gets the Boot
in…
Bye bye, Cornhusker Kickback. Hello,
special treatment for …
Obama Ramps Up Health Care
Campaign
President Barack Obama was teaming up
with Democratic allies …
Brewer, Lawmakers Slam National
Health…
Gov. Jan Brewer said Thursday that the
federal health overhaul …
Democrats Post Health Care Bill Online
The updated version of the U.S. health
care reform bill was …
House Dems on Track for Vote on
$940B…
House Democrats are pushing to the brink
of passage a landmark,…
Fox News Poll: 55 Percent of
Americans…
Some 55 per cent of Americans oppose
the health care reforms …
CBO: Health Care Will Cost $940 Billion
http://www.myfoxphoenix.com/dpp/news/politics/state_politics/brewer-anti-health-bill-3-17-2010
3/19/10 11:02 AM
Search Site Web
American Idol Contests Contact Us Dating Place My 45 TV Listings
SPORTS TRAFFIC HEALTH ENTERTAINMENT ABOUT US SEEN ON TV
Gov. Brewer Writes Anti- EmailThis
Health Bill Letter
Updated: Wednesday, 17 Mar 2010, 9:50 PM MDT Print this story View Story on a Single Page
Published : Wednesday, 17 Mar 2010, 9:47 PM MDT
PHOENIX - Arizona Governor Jan Brewer sent a letter to Latest News
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Majority Leader Larry
Reid Wednesday, challenging the President's health care Sen. Leader Promises Public Option Vote
bill. AG Backs Lawyers for Terror Detainees
MySpaceTrail Leads Cops to Teen Burglar
She says, "Arizona simply cannot afford the unfunded Ellen Presents $30K to McMillen
mandate that will result from this legislation and outlined Obama to Visit Capitol Hill on Saturday
the disproportionate impact it will have on Arizona
More News »
citizens."
She also notes that the expansive health care bill will rob
Most Read Stories on MyFoxPhoenix.com
citizens of their individual liberties and rights.
"By requiring all citizens to purchase health insurance or Popular Pages Today
1. Warren Buffett Plays Axl Rose in New GEICO
be penalized, this bill would impose on the people an Commercial 20.96%
unprecedented mandate by the federal government." 2. FOX 10 | Local Phoenix and Valley news
headlines - myfoxphoenix.com 18.55%
3. Late Night Shooting Leaves 1 Dead 13.83%
4. Ellen Presents $30K to Constance McMillen in
Prom Flap 10.17%
The full letter:
5. Immigration Sweep in Metro Phoenix: Day 2 9.10%
6. SWAT Team Called to Home in Buckeye 8.39%
On December 30, 2009, the Attorneys General from
several states wrote you expressing grave concerns 7. Michael Tinkham Sticks Austin Police Officer with
Drug Needle 6.07%
about the Senate version of the Patient Protection and
8. Mich. High School Basketball Player Shatters
Affordable Care Act (H.R. 3590). Although amendments Backboard in Playoff Game 5.35%
have been made to this bill since then, the primary 9. 'World's Largest' Chicken Fried Steak Served in
constitutional defects remain. It is reported that Fort Worth 4.10%
Democratic Congressional leaders intend to move 10. In Denver, Marijuana Sparks Counterculture
forward with legislation that uses this bill as its starting Clash 3.48%
point. I therefore, on behalf of the State of Arizona, join
these Attorneys General and urge you to reject H.R.
3590 and any legislation that contains similar legal Advertisement
deficiencies.
As Governor and the statutory officer authorized to
communicate with Congress on behalf of the State of
Arizona, I have contacted Arizonas delegation on more
than one occasion expressing my serious policy concerns
with H.R. 3590. Last week I wrote President Obama and
told him quite clearly that Arizona simply cannot afford
the unfunded mandate that will result from this legislation
and outlined the disproportionate impact it will have on
Arizona citizens.
The devastating impacts of the federal legislation will rob
Arizonans of their rights and pocketbooks alike. One of
the core principles of our nations system of government
is the critical balance between the power of the federal
government and the protection of individual liberties. The
constitutional framers granted Congress only certain Suggested Search
enumerated powers and provided that all other powers
white house - health bill - congressional budget office -
are reserved to the states or the people pursuant to the
Tenth Amendment. health vote - president barack obama
Page 1 of 3
Gov. Brewer Writes Anti-Health Bill Letter 3/19/10 11:02 AM

Congress' health care reform bill is
estimated to cost $940 …
Lawmakers Struggle to Finish Health…
Pushing toward a history-making vote,
Democrats struggled to …
Tenth Amendment.
H.R. 3590 represents a sweeping violation of these
fundamental principles established by the founding
fathers. By requiring all citizens to purchase health Advertisement
insurance or be penalized, this bill would impose on the
people an unprecedented mandate by the federal
government. As emphasized by the non-partisan
Congressional Budget Office:

The government has never required people to buy any

good or service as a condition of lawful residence in the
2550% Penny Stock Gains?
United States. This mandate violates the founders intent
Our last pick exploded 2550% - Join our newsletter for
free picks! to limit the intrusion of the federal government upon the
www.PennyStocksExpert.com rights of the individual.
Marketplace
The Commerce Clause is erroneously cited as a
legitimate basis for Congress to impose the requirement 2550% Penny Stock Gains?
Buy a link here Our last pick exploded 2550% - Join our newsletter for
to purchase insurance. As you are aware, the
free picks!
congressional power to regulate commerce is not without www.PennyStocksExpert.com
limits. The sole basis for claiming constitutional authority under the Commerce Clause is seemingly derived by coercing
Americans to engage in commerce through the purchase of insurance and then regulating that coerced transaction. Even College Degree Online
the non-partisan and independent Congressional Research Service raised serious concerns about the constitutionality of Get your college degree online and jumpstart your
this proposal, noting that it may very well go beyond the bounds of the Commerce Clause. career. Cally today!
www.JustClickLocal.com
I must also strenuously object to the benefit exchanges the proposed legislation would impose upon states. H.R. 3590
requires states to either enact state legislation and regulations to implement these exchanges or be forced to allow the
Bank of America Refinance
Secretary of Health and Human Services to take over and do it for them. This requirement is not a condition to receive
Take Advantage Of Low Refi Rates. For Home Loans
federal funding, but rather an absolute mandate to the states in direct contravention of the Tenth Amendment. Up To $3 Million.
www.bankofamerica.com
For the foregoing reasons, I will coordinate with the other State Attorneys General on behalf of the State of Arizona to
challenge H.R. 3590 or any health care proposal that becomes law with any of the unconstitutional provisions I have Scottrade® Online Trading
outlined in this letter. Thank you on behalf of the citizens of Arizona for your consideration of these matters. $7 Stock Trades - No Share limit. Real Time Quotes &
Investor News.
Sincerely, www.Scottrade.com
Janice K. Brewer
Buy a link here
Governor

Share this: Twitter Facebook Myspace Google Tumblr Digg Fark More Send us news tips

Add Your Comments Here

Login Your name (required)

Share This Page

What's on your mind...

Follow Cancel Post

Echo 3 Items Admin

john
Brewer finally does something that I agree with!!!!!
2 days ago, 10:30:47 PM HST – Flag – Like – Reply
Liked by 2 Guests

PHoeniX News
Brewer Writes Anti-Health Bill Letter: Arizona Governor Jan Brewer sent a letter to House Speaker Nancy
Pelosi and...
2 days ago, 6:16:44 PM HST – Flag – Like – Reply via Twitter

Phoenix News
Brewer Writes Anti-Health Bill Letter http://tinyurl.com/yhqac72

http://www.myfoxphoenix.com/dpp/news/politics/state_politics/brewer-anti-health-bill-3-17-2010 Page 2 of 3
Gov. Brewer Writes Anti-Health Bill Letter 3/19/10 11:02 AM

2 days ago, 6:16:44 PM HST – Flag – Like – Reply via Twitter

Social Networking by

Outbrain

rated 5.0 by 1 person [ ?]

Selected for you by a sponsor:

Bounce back from the recession with the top 5 jobs (Knowledge Network)
7 Reasons Why Most People Can't Afford to Retire! (BeamaLife)
You might also be interested in:
Arizona Governor Plans Washington Trip
Suit Challenges Constitutionality of Arizona Law
Tempe Officer Dated Women He Pulled Over
Arizona Governor Wants More Nuclear Power in State
Arizona Budget Shortfall Projection Reaches $2B
Cornhusker Kickback Gets the Boot
Texas AG Threatens Lawsuit Over Health Insurance (MyFox Houston)

Home News Morning Show Weather Sports Traffic Health Entertainment About Us Seen on TV Classifieds

Terms of Service Privacy Policy Contact Us Advertise with Us News Corp

Many pages in this Fox Television Stations, Inc. web site feature links to other sites, some of which are operated by companies unrelated to Fox Television Stations, Inc. Fox Television Stations, Inc. has no control over the
content or availability of any linked site. TM and (c) 2010 Fox Television Stations, Inc., and its related entities. All rights reserved. Any reproduction, duplication, or distribution in any form is expressly prohibited.

http://www.myfoxphoenix.com/dpp/news/politics/state_politics/brewer-anti-health-bill-3-17-2010 Page 3 of 3