Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A R T I C L E I N F O
A B S T R A C T
Article history:
Available online 20 January 2015
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) may be the most urgent problem the U.S. military is facing today.
Pharmacological and psychological interventions reduce the severity of some PTSD symptoms however
these conventional approaches have limited efcacy. This issue is compounded by the high rate of comorbid traumatic brain injury (TBI) and other medical and psychiatric disorders in veterans diagnosed
with PTSD and unresolved system-level problems within the Veterans Administration and Department
of Defense healthcare services that interfere with adequate and prompt care for veterans and active duty
military personnel. This paper is offered as a framework for interdisciplinary dialogue and collaboration
between experts in biomedicine and CAM addressing three primary areas of need: resiliency training in
high risk military populations, prevention of PTSD following exposure to combat-related trauma, and
treatment of established cases of PTSD.
The evidence for widely used conventional pharmacological and psychological interventions used in
the VA/DOD healthcare systems to treat PTSD is reviewed. Challenges and barriers to adequate
assessment and treatment of PTSD in military personnel are discussed. A narrative review of promising
CAM modalities used to prevent or treat PTSD emphasizes interventions that are not widely used in VA/
DOD clinics and programmes. Interventions reviewed include virtual reality graded exposure therapy
(VRGET), braincomputer interface (BCI), EEG biofeedback, cardiac coherence training, EMDR,
acupuncture, omega-3 fatty acids and other natural products, lucid dreaming training, and energy
therapies. As meditation and mind-body practices are widely offered within VA/DOD programmes and
services addressing PTSD the evidence for these modalities is only briey reviewed. Sources included
mainstream medical databases and journals not currently indexed in the mainstream medical databases.
Although most interventions discussed are applicable to both civilian and military populations the
emphasis is on military personnel. Provisional integrative guidelines are offered with the goal of
providing a exible and open framework when planning interventions aimed at preventing or treating
PTSD based on the best available evidence for both conventional and CAM approaches. The paper
concludes with recommendations on research and policy within the VA and DOD healthcare systems
addressing urgent unmet needs associated with PTSD.
2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Alternative
Complementary
Integrative
Military
Trauma
PTSD
Post-traumatic stress disorder
Veterans
Introduction
Post-traumatic stress disorder may be the most urgent problem
the U.S. military is facing today. The personal, social and economic
burden of human suffering, treatment costs, disability compensation, and productivity losses related to PTSD are major issues facing
14
15
16
17
18
high-quality trial [50] included in the review showed statistically signicant differences between the acupuncture and waitlist group but non-signicant differences between the acupuncture and CBT groups. Patients receiving acupuncture or CBT
continued to report clinical improvements in PTSD symptoms 3
months after study endpoint. A meta-analysis of pooled ndings
showed superiority of a combined regimen of acupuncture and
moxibustion over SSRIs and superiority of acupoint stimulation
plus CBT over CBT alone in reducing PTSD symptoms. Two other
studies included in the review (but not the meta-analysis)
reported greater but non-signicant improvement in PTSD
patients receiving acupuncture vs SSRIs, more favourable
responses to combined acupuncture plus CBT compared to
CBT alone, and greater improvement with acupuncture plus
moxibustion compared to SSRIs on three outcome measures.
These ndings are limited by the small number of trials that met
inclusion criteria (only one study reviewed was included in the
analysis), the absence of sham-controlled studies, the use of
different study designs across trials examined, and poor
methodological quality of many studies. Findings from two
randomised controlled trials and six outcome studies support
that tapping on certain acupressure points in parallel with
imaginal exposure therapy may result in rapid reduction in
maladaptive fear responses to traumatic memories in individuals diagnosed with PTSD [51].
A review of studies on acupuncture for the treatment of
symptoms that are frequently comorbid with PTSD in active duty
military returning from combat, reported promising results for
acupuncture in reducing the severity of headaches, anxiety,
fatigue, sleep disturbances, depression and chronic pain [52].
Acupuncture may be a practical and effective treatment of PTSD
in emergency room settings [53]. Acupuncture is being
investigated for its potential applications in military eld
conditions for both medical and psychological conditions with
reductions in sick leave and limited duty status resulting in
improved unit performance [54]. In contrast to conventional
pharmacological treatment, acupuncture has infrequent mild
adverse effects such as bleeding, bruising and pain on needling
[55].
Natural products
Omega-3s. Symptoms of PTSD may develop when consolidation of
intense fear memories takes place in the absence of neural
mechanisms that permit extinction. Increasing hippocampal
neurogenesis soon after trauma may result in more rapid
clearance of fear memories (i.e. extinction) and interfere with
consolidation of immediate post-trauma memories into longterm memories reducing the risk of developing PTSD [56]. Animal
studies conrm that Omega-3 fatty acids increase hippocampal
neurogenesis [5759]. Studies in Japan following the 2011
tsunami are investigating the effectiveness of pre-treatment with
omega-3s in preventing the development of PTSD following
exposure to trauma in rst medical responders mobilised in
national emergencies Two pilot studies found that daily supplementation with omega-3s signicantly reduces the severity of
PTSD symptoms in individuals who experienced trauma related to
accidental injury [6062].
DHEA. Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) is a prohormone that
may protect against cortisol-induced hippocampal atrophy [63].
Increased severity of PTSD is correlated with reduced DHEA
blood levels [64]. In a small open-label study (N = 5) women with
treatment-refractory PTSD related to early childhood abuse and
who had not responded to conventional pharmacological
therapy, experienced decreases in numbing, re-experiencing,
19
20
Exhibit 1
Conventional and CAM approaches used to prevent or treat PTSD, treatment evidence limitations of ndings safety issues.
Psychotherapy
Conventional drugs
Prevention
Treatment
Meditation
EMDR
Technology-based therapies
Virtual reality graded
exposure therapy (VRGET)
Chinese medicine
Natural products
None
None
None
None
None
21
Exhibit 1 (Continued )
Lucid dreaming training
None
None
Exhibit 2
Interventions used to increase resilience prior to trauma exposure, prevent or reduce the severity of PTSD following trauma, and treat chronic PTSD.
Intervention type
Target population
Proprietary multi-nutrient
supplement
Battleeld debrieng
Mindfulness training
Omega-3s
Exposure therapy
Medications
VRGET plus multi-sensory
exposure
Acupuncture
EMDR
HRV and EEG biofeedback
Healing touch and guided imagery
Note: 1st Tier interventions are supported by moderate to strong evidence; 2nd tier interventions are supported by weak or inconsistent evidence.
[11]
[12]
[13]
[14]
[15]
References
[16]
[1] North CS, Suris AM, Davis M, Smith RP. Toward validation of the diagnosis of
posttraumatic stress disorder. Am J Psychiatry 2009;166(January (1)):3441.
[2] Van der Kolk, Najavits B, Interview L. What is PTSD Really? Surprises, twists of
history, and the politics of diagnosis and treatment. J Clin Psychol
2013;69(5):51622.
[3] Schottenbauer MA, Glass CR, Arnkoff DB, Tendick V, Gray SH. Nonresponse and
dropout rates in outcome studies on PTSD: review and methodological considerations. Psychiatry 2008;71(2):13468.
[4] Corrigan P. How stigma interferes with mental health care. Am Psychologist
2004;59:61425.
[5] Mohamed S, Rosenheck RA. Pharmacotherapy of PTSD in the S. Dept of
Veterans Affairs: diagnostic and symptom-guided drug selection. J Clin Psychiatry 2008;69:95965.
[6] Capehart B, Bass D. Review managing posttraumatic stress disorder in combat
veterans with comorbid traumatic brain injury. J Rehabil Res Dev
2012;49(5):789812.
[7] Hermes E, Rosenheck R, Desai R, Fontana A. Recent trends in the treatment of
posttraumatic stress disorder and other mental disorders in the VHA. Psychiatr
Serv 2012;63(May (5)):4716.
[8] Gartlehner G, Forneris CA, Brownley KA, Gaynes BN, Sonis J, Coker-Schwimmer
E, et al. Comparative Effectiveness Review No. 109, Interventions for the
prevention of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in adults after exposure
to psychological trauma. AHRQ Pub. No. 13-EHC062-1-EF; 2013.
[9] Adler A, Bliese PD, McGurk D, Hoge CW, Castro CA. J Consult Clin Psychol
2009;77:928.
[10] Jonas DE, Cusack K, Forneris CA, Wilkins TM, Sonis J, Middleton JC, et al.,
editors. Psychological and pharmacological treatments for adults with post-
[17]
[18]
[19]
[20]
[21]
[22]
[23]
[24]
22
[25] Grodin MA, Piwowarczyk L, Fulker D, Bazazi AR, Saper RB. Treating survivors of
torture and refugee trauma: a preliminary case series using qigong and tai chi.
J Altern Complement Med 2008 Sep;14(7):8016.
[26] Shepherd J, Stein K, Milne R. Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing
in the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder: a review of an emerging
therapy. Psychol Med 2000;30(July (4)):86371.
[27] Hertlein KM, Ricci RJ. A systematic research synthesis of EMDR studies:
implementation of the platinum standard. Trauma Violence Abuse 2004;5(July (3)):285300.
[28] Seidler GH, Wagner FE. Comparing the efcacy of EMDR and trauma-focused
cognitive-behavioral therapy in the treatment of PTSD: a meta-analytic study.
Psychol Med 2006;36(November (11)):151522.
[29] Jeffries FW, Davis P. What is the role of eye movements in eye movement
desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) for post-traumatic stress disorder
(PTSD)? A review. Behav Cogn Psychother 2013;41(May (3)):290300.
[30] Karatzias T, Power K, Brown K, McGoldrick T, Begum M, Young J, et al. A
controlled comparison of the effectiveness and efciency of two psychological
therapies for posttraumatic stress disorder: eye movement desensitization
and reprocessing vs. emotional freedom techniques. J Nerv Ment Dis
2011;199(June (6)):3728.
[31] Russell MC. Scientic resistance to research, training and utilization of eye
movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) therapy in treating postwar disorders. Social Sci Med 2008;67(December (11)):173746.
[32] Wood DP, Wiederhold BK, Spira J. Lessons learned from 350 virtual-reality
sessions with warriors diagnosed with combat-related posttraumatic stress
disorder. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw 2010;13(February (1)):311.
[33] Reger GM, Holloway KM, Candy C, Rothbaum, Difede J, Rizzo AA, et al.
Effectiveness of virtual reality exposure therapy for active duty soldiers in
a Military Mental Health Clinic. J Traumatic Stress 2011;24(February (1)):93
6.
[34] Vakili V, Brinkman W, Neerincx M. Lessons learned from the development of
technological support for PTSD prevention: a review. Stud Health Technol
Inform 2012;181:226.
[35] Wood DP, Webb-Murphy J, McLay RN, Wiederhold BK, Spira JL, Johnston S,
et al. Reality graded exposure therapy with physiological monitoring for the
treatment of combat related post-traumatic stress disorder: a pilot study. Stud
Health Technol Inform 2011;163:696702.
[36] Roy MJ, Costanzo ME, Jovanovic T, Leaman S, Taylor P, Norrholm SD, et al. Heart
rate response to fear conditioning and virtual reality in subthreshold PTSD.
Stud Health Technol Inform 2013;191:1159.
[37] Hourani L, Kizakevich PN, Hubal R, Spira J, Strange LB, Holiday DB, et al.
Predeployment stress inoculation training for primary prevention of combatrelated stress disorders. J Cyber Ther Rehabil 2011;4:101.
[38] Rizzo, Parsons ATD, Lange B, Kenny P, Buckwalter JG, Rothbaum B. Virtual
reality goes to war: a brief review of the future of Military Behavioral
Healthcare. J Clin Psychol Med Settings 2011;112.
[39] Rizzo A, Parsons TD, Lange B, Kenny P, Buckwalter JG, Rothbaum B, et al. Virtual
reality goes to war: a brief review of the future of Military Behavioral
Healthcare. J Clin Psychol Med Settings 2011;18:17687.
[40] Rizzo A, Buckwalter JG, John B, Newman B, Parsons T, Kenny P, et al. STRIVE.
Stress resilience in virtual environments: a pre-deployment VR system for
training emotional coping skills and assessing chronic and acute stress
responses. Stud Health Technol Inform 2012;173:37985.
[41] Repetto C, Gorini A, Vigna C, Algeri D, Pallavicini F, Riva G. The use of
biofeedback in clinical virtual reality: the INTREPID project. J Vis Exp
2009;12:1554.
[42] Ginsberg JP, Berry ME, Powell DA. Cardiac coherence and posttraumatic stress
disorder in combat veterans. Altern Ther Health Med 2010;16(JulyAugust
(4)):5260.
[43] Tan G, Dao TK, Farmer L, Sutherland RJ, Gevirtz R. Heart rate variability (HRV)
and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD): a pilot study. Appl Psychophysiol
Biofeedback 2011;36(March (1)):2735.
[44] Lande RG, Williams LB, Francis JL, Gragnani C, Morin ML. Efcacy of biofeedback for post-traumatic stress disorder. Complement Ther Med 2010;18(December (6)):2569.
[45] Othmer S, Othmer S, Legarda S. Clinical neurofeedback: training brain behavior treatment strategies. Pediatric Neurol Psychiatr 2011;2(1):6773.
[46] Legarda S, McMahon D, Othmer S, Othmer S. Clinical neurofeedback: case
studies, proposed mechanism, and implications for pediatric neurology practice. J Child Neurol 2011;26(8):104551.
[48] Othmer S. Psychological health and neurofeedback: remediating PTSD and TBI.
EEG Institute; 2012.
[49] Hollield M. Acupuncture for posttraumatic stress disorder: conceptual,
clinical, and biological data support further research. CNS Neurosci Therapeut
2011;17:76979.
[50] Hollield MN, Sinclair-Lian TD, Warner R, Hammerschlag. Acupuncture for
posttraumatic stress disorder: a randomized controlled pilot trial. J Nerv
Mental Dis 2007;195(6):50413.
[51] Feinstein D. Rapid treatment of PTSD: why psychological exposure with
acupoint tapping may be effective. Psychotherapy (Chic) 2010;47(September
(3)):385402.
[52] Lee, Crawford C, Wallerstedt D, York A, Duncan A, Smith J, Sprengel M, et al.
The effectiveness of acupuncture research across components of the trauma
spectrum response (tsr): a systematic review of reviews. Syst Rev 2012;1:46.
[53] Fleckenstein, Schottdorf JJ, Kreimeier U, Irnich D. Acupuncture in emergency
medicine: results of a case series. Der Anaesthesist 2011;60:85462.
[54] Spira A. Acupuncture: a useful tool for health care in an operational medicine
environment. Mil Med 2008;173(July (7)):62934.
[55] White A, Hayhoe A, Hart A, Ernst E. Adverse events following acupuncture:
prospective survey of 32 000 consultations with doctors and physiotherapists.
Br Med J 2001;323(7311):4856.
[56] Pitman RK, Delahanty DL. Conceptually driven pharmacologic approaches to
acute trauma. CNS Spectr 2005;10:99106.
[57] Beltz BS, Tlusty MF, Benton JL, Sandeman DC. Omega-3 fatty acids upregulate
adult neurogenesis. Neurosci Lett 2007;415:1548.
[58] Kawakita E, Hashimoto M, Shido O. Docosahexaenoic acid promotes neurogenesis in vitro and in vivo. Neuroscience 2006;139:9917.
[59] Kawakita E, Hashimoto M, Shido O. Docosahexaneoic acid promotes neurogenesis in vitro and in vivo. Neuroscience 2006;139(3):9917.
[60] Matsuoka Y, Nishi D, Yonemoto N, Hamazaki K, Hashimoto K, Hamazaki T.
Omega-3 fatty acids for secondary prevention of posttraumatic stress disorder
after accidental injury: an open-label pilot study. J Clin Psychopharmacol
2010;30(2):2179.
[61] Matsuoka Y, Nishi D, Yonemoto N, Hamazaki K, Hamazaki T, Hashimoto K.
Potential role of brain-derived neurotrophic factor in omega-3 fatty
acid supplementation to prevent posttraumatic distress after accidental
injury: an open-label pilot study. Psychother Psychosom 2011;80(5):
3102.
[62] Matsuoka Y, Nishi D, Nakaya N, Sone T, Hamazaki K, Hamazaki T, et al.
Attenuating posttraumatic distress with omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids
among disaster medical assistance team members after the Great East Japan
Earthquake: the APOP randomized controlled trial. BMC Psychiatr 2011;11(August):132.
[63] Sapolsky RM. Glucocorticoids and hippocampal atrophy in neuropsychiatric
disorders. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2000;57:92535.
[64] Rasmusson AM, Vasek J, Lipschitz DS, Vojvoda D, Vojvoda D, Mustone ME, Shi
Q, et al. An increased capacity for adrenal DHEA release is associated with
decreased avoidance and negative mood symptoms in women with PTSD.
Neuopsychopharmacology 2004;29:154657.
[65] Sageman S, Brown RP. 3-Acetyl-7-oxo-dehydroepiandrosterone for healing
treatment-resistant posttraumatic stress disorder in women: 5 case reports. J
Clin Psychiatry 2006;67:4936.
[66] Rucklidge JJ, Johnstone J, Harrison R, Boggis A. Micronutrients reduce stress
and anxiety following a 7.1 earthquake in adults with attention-decit/hyperactivity disorder. Psychiatry Res 2011;189:2817.
nder E, Tural U
, Aker T. A comparative study of uoxetine, moclobemide, and
[67] O
tianeptine in the treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder following an
earthquake. Eur Psychiatry 2006;21:1749.
[68] Basoglu M, Salcioglu E, Livanou M. A randomized controlled study of singlesession behavioral treatment of earthquake-related post-traumatic stress
disorder using an earthquake simulator. Psychol Med: J Res Psychiatry Allied
Sci 2007;37:20313.
[69] Konuk E, Knipe J, Eke I, Yuksek H, Yurtsever A, Ostep S. The effects of eye
movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) therapy on posttraumatic stress disorder in survivors of the 1999 Marmara, Turkey, earthquake. Int J
Stress Manag 2006;13:291308.
[70] Abbasnejad M, Mahani KN, Zamyad A. Efcacy of eye movement desensitization and reprocessing in reducing anxiety and unpleasant feelings due to
earthquake experience. Psychol Res 2007;9:10417.
[71] Brylowski A. Nightmares in crisis: clinical applications of lucid dreaming
techniques. Psychiatr J Univ Ottawa 1990;15(2):7984.
[72] Brylowski A, McKay. Lucid dreaming as a treatment for nightmares in
posttraumatic stress of Vietnam combat veterans;Paper presented at the
meeting of the Southern Association for Research in Psychiatry, Tampa, FL.
1991.
[73] Spoormaker V, Van den Bout J. Lucid dreaming treatment for nightmares: a
pilot study. Psychother Psychosom 2006;75(6):38994.
[74] Hankey A. Are we close to a theory of energy medicine? J Altern Complement
Med 2004;10:836.
[75] Jain S, McMahon GF, Hasen P, Kozub MP, Porter V, King R, et al. Healing touch
with guided imagery for PTSD in returning active duty military: a randomized
controlled trial. Mil Med 2012;177(September (9)):101521.
[76] Zonderman R. The Upledger Foundation Vietnam veteran intensive program.
Palm Beach, FL: The Upledger Institute; 2000.
[77] Herbert JD, Gaudiano B. The search for the Holy Grail: heart rate variability and
thought eld therapy. J Clin Psychol 2001;57(10):120714.
[78] Church D, Brooks AJ. CAM and energy psychology techniques remediate PTSD
symptoms in veterans and spouses. Explore (NY) 2014;10(JanuaryFebruary
(1)):2433.
[79] Tanielian T, Jaycox LH, editors. Invisible wounds of war: psychological and
cognitive injuries, their consequences, and services to assist recovery. Santa
Monica, CA: RAND Corporation; 2008.
[80] Berger W, Mendlowicz MV, Marques-Portella C, Kinrys G, Fontenelle LF,
Marmar CR, et al. Pharmacologic alternatives to antidepressants in posttraumatic stress disorder: a systematic review. Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol
Psychiatry 2009;33(March (2)):16980.
[81] Brouwer A, Neerincx MA, Kallen V, van der Leer L, ten Brinke M. EEG alpha
asymmetry, heart rate variability and cortisol in response to virtual reality
induced stress. J Cyber Ther Rehabil 2011;4(1):2740.
[82] Nelson DV, Esty ML. Neurotherapy of traumatic brain injury/posttraumatic
stress symptoms in OEF/OIF veterans. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci
2012;24(Spring (2)):23740.
23