Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Seoul, the capital of South Korea, has been known for its original landscape, which has been molded for centuries within
and around the surrounding natural topography. As a result of rapid urbanization and growth beginning in the 1960s, however,
there has been signicant deterioration. New and re-development in the downtown area, which have been characterized as
high-rise and massive in particular, have been and are continuing to be detrimental to the landscape. In recent years, a number
of attempts towards urban landscape management have emerged in the form of legislation and policies. But relevant tools to
support the implementation of such attempts have unfortunately been insufcient, resulting in inefcient, unsystematic, and
inaccurate urban landscape management efforts.
Subsequently, this study developed the LandScape Information System (LSIS) for the purpose of managing urban landscape
information and analyzing visual impacts of proposed development projects. Employing Geographic Information System
(GIS) and computer graphics simulation techniques, LSIS performs such functions as, input and management of graphic and
attribute data, query analysis of attributes related to urban landscape elements, and visual impact (view obstruction) analysis of
development proposals. The database for LSIS was prepared in consideration to the urban information systems (UIS) database
framework of Seoul in order to ensure the maximum data transferability between them.
Through the application of LSIS to a sample visual impact analysis of urban redevelopment projects, it was found that
valuable landscape resources could be damaged by the proposed projects. Moreover, by using LSIS, subsequent mitigation
measures for such impacts could be effectively tested and developed. Therefore, it is believed that in general, LSIS can be used
as the basis for decision-making in resolving urban landscape problems experienced by local governments. In addition, with
the trend toward promoting more information-based societies, LSIS can be instrumental in sharing substantial amounts of data
with those for UIS, developed by central and local governments. This in turn can foster maximum effectiveness and value of
computer-based urban landscape management. # 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Landscape management; Urban development; Visual impact assessment; GIS
1. Introduction
Unprecedented changes toward promoting information-based societies are occurring ubiquitously, and so
too are the corresponding challenges. Urban landscape
*
Tel.: 82-2-2290-0336; fax: 82-2-2291-4739.
E-mail address: ksoh@hanyang.ac.kr (K. Oh).
80
problems in our cities, requires new approaches. Technological advancements in computer-related elds are
providing a variety of new tools and techniques which
allow speedy digital processing of data. Subsequently,
these advancements require greater shifts from the use
of conventional paradigms of problem-solving to more
systematic and automated ones.
In Korean society, urban landscape management
has been recognized as a signicant challenge as well
as dilemma, due to rapid urbanization and quantitative
growth-oriented development strategies booming
since the 1960s. This is especially evident in Seoul,
the nation's densely populated capital; 10.2 million
people residing within roughly 605 km2. Many efforts
have been made in recent years to protect the landscape from further deterioration, including establishing the Urban Landscape Management Plan of Seoul,
demolishing apartment buildings on Mt. Nam in
downtown Seoul to recover the mountain's original
landscape, and designating Landscape Management
Zones in the Mt. Nam area for protection from the
current trend of high-rise and massive development.
Despite such efforts for improving Seoul's overall
landscape quality, a major problem in its landscape
management lies in the lack of specic, established
tools needed for long-term, effective support. The
essential key in implementing effective landscape
management has been the need for systematic processing of diverse and large amounts of geo-spatial data.
Using traditional methods, it has been difcult to
manage landscape information effectively and therefore, substantial results of analyses have been difcult
to render. Such difculties are greater when dealing
with urban landscape problems. For instance, effective
landscape management requires not only obvious
attention to physical elements, both natural and
human-made, but also more complicated consideration
for non-physical aspects underlying the landscape,
such as socio-economic factors. Under these circumstances, this study developed the LandScape Information System (LSIS) for supporting decision-making
activities in the urban landscape management process.
2. Downtown Seoul: landscape conditions and
problems
In Korea, downtown Seoul (Fig. 1) has been the
center for administration, commerce, business, and
81
urbanized setting. It can be an effective way of achieving amenity in cases where physical access to natural
areas in the city has become more difcult. In a recent
study, Oh and Lee (2001) investigated the visual value
of natural landscape resources in Seoul, and found that
the value of the visibility of mountains was substantial
enough to be included in housing prices.
Due to urban redevelopment projects (Fig. 3), buildings along main streets in downtown Seoul have been
increasing not only in number, but in height, width,
and overall scale as well. Moreover, a recent amendment to an architectural ordinance in Seoul has eased
Floor-Air Ratio (FAR) drastically. As a result, newly
constructed buildings in redevelopment areas are now
82
1
VTCC can be generally defined as the visual standard by which
the value and significance of landscapes can be maintained. The
term `standard' refers to the limit and basis upon which future
development activities on the landscape can be appropriately
managed. In assessing the value of landscape visibility in urban
settings, the amount of a landscape resource to be seen and the
importance of that portion, need to be evaluated together.
Considering both factors, the quality of landscape visibility can
be categorized as follows: (1) the visible area including the central
part of landscape resource is substantial, (2) the visible area
including the central part of landscape resource is less substantial,
or the visible area is substantial without the central part of
landscape resources, and (3) the landscape resource is not visible,
or its visible area is minimal. The VTCC for visibility needs to be
recognized primarily for landscapes which are equivalent to or
better than the level 1), and consists of horizontal and vertical
frames which form visual corridors toward such landscape
resources (Oh, 1998).
from a distance, the outline of human-made, architectural elements often reveals the skyline against the
natural topography. If the city is observed more
closely, the detailed atmosphere of the streetscape
which includes shapes, colors, textures of building
facades, signs, and trees can be viewed. Third, `landscape (building) envelope' is the invisible, threedimensional contour of maximum allowable space
for a building or structure in relation to landscape
management strategies, as well as pre-established
architectural and planning controls. In Seoul, allowable or permitted building spaces are calculated
mainly by lot coverage and FAR determined by
zoning, building spacing and height, and setback
controls. If the area becomes more densely developed, the formation of the landscape will be heavily
affected by such controls. For an effective understanding of landscape structure and its elements, it is
therefore essential to consider not only visual
aspects, but institutional ones as well, including
regulations, policies, plans, and proposals. The information related to urban landscape elements and their
management activities can be organized with the
framework as shown in Table 1.
3.2. Database for LSIS
The database for LSIS was prepared in consideration to the urban information systems (UIS) database
framework of the City of Seoul (the city has been in
the process establishing its UIS database following the
standard mapping scheme suggested by the National
Geographic Information System (NGIS) project in
Korea). This ensures the maximum data transferability
between different, local databases, while minimizing
unnecessary duplication and redundancy in data
acquisition, processing, and management, which
may otherwise result in substantial extra costs. Most
of the basic information in LSIS encompassing
topography, roads, buildings and structures, zoning,
land ownership, etc. can be acquired from the UIS
database.
Information not collected from the UIS database,
such as development proposals, and elements in the
category of `landscape management' including, viewpoints for landscape control, landscape resources, and
development limits for landscape management, has to
be acquired from other individual sources. This results
Table 1
Information related to urban landscape elements and their management
Landscape elements
Landscape types
Baseline landscape
Land cover/related
developments
Road facilities
Proposed developments
Landscape management
Lot boundaries
Zoning, lot coverage, FAR,
building spacing and height,
setback, other architectural
and planning controls
83
84
85
landscape, and the result is displayed on the computer screen for the appraisal of visual impact.
Although this type of visual simulation technique
results in abstract landscape images, it is fairly
simple to implement and conveys essential information for analyzing actual landscape problems and
generating solutions. It is also effective in terms of
preparation cost.
Fig. 13 is the result of view obstruction analysis.
Through a series of feedback processes, mitigation
86
87
88
Fig. 15. A mitigated development scheme (with building setback and upper portion indented).
due to data sharing, and thereby improving the efciency of data management.
Fourth, examinations can be rendered on visual
aspects in the urban landscape, as well as for legal
relevancy of development proposals, such as issues
relating to architectural and planning regulations.
In addition, further integration of other information
not discussed in this study, relating to social, economic, and demographic aspects, used in conjunction
with LSIS, can help to provide professionals with a
more thorough understanding on how to successfully
89