You are on page 1of 86

Pumping stations and water

transport
Water quality aspects of drinking water
networks
ct5550

Introduction

Water quality changes during transport


through the network
Chemical processes: interaction between
pipe material and water
Biological processes:
development/regrowth of bacteria and
invertebrates
Physical processes: sedimentation and
resuspention

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Material composition network


120000
100000

rest
pvc
nod CI
Cast Iron
ac

km pipe

80000
60000
40000
20000

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

2000

1995

1990

1985

1980

1975

1970

1965

1960

1955

Present material composition


rest
4%

Asbestos cement
33%

pvc
50%

Cast iron
nod CI
2%

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

11%

Physical processes

Main problem: discoloured water


Primarily a customer related problem:
discoloured water is harmless

Although relation with bacteriological


problems

Focus because of changing attitude of


both customer (more critical and out
spoken) as water company (more
customer oriented)

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Early 90s: red water on the


agenda in the Netherlands

Increased customer complaints

Unexpected

more critical attitude


more professional registration
decrease in cast iron
also in new plastic networks

Unsatisfactory results of (costly) cleaning


programs

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

100 Cast Iron (1900)

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Basic questions

What is discoloured water


How to measure discoloured water
What is the cause and nature of
discolourde water
What can we do about it

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

What is red water?

Water with a turbidity that can be noticed


by a customer

Turbidity is the key factor in red water

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

How to measure red water:


Monitoring System
Monitor 1

Monitor 2

Monitor 3

flow

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

pH
Oxygen
Turbidity
Temperature

Conductivity
Pressure
(Velocity)

Single Monitoring system

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Results monitoring turbidity


Continuous monitoring turbidity
0,5

Turbidity [FTU]

0,4

0,3

Treatment
Location 1
Location 2

0,2

0,1

0,0
04-jun

05-jun

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

06-jun

07-jun

08-jun

09-jun

Closer detail
Continuous monitoring turbidity
0,5

Maximum

Turbidity [FTU]

0,4

0,3

Treatment
Location 1
Location 2

0,2
Minumum
0,1

0,0
05-jun 00:00
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

05-jun 12:00

06-jun 00:00

Continuous monitoring of
turbidity
Turbidity [FTU]

begin pipe
end pipe

2
complaint
sample

0
mo

tu

we

thu

fr

sa

su

Week days
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Cause of discoloured water

Resuspension of sediment
Sediment originates from

source/treatment plant
network (corroding cast iron, biofilm)
mixing different water types

Sedimentation is promoted by low


velocities in the network
Sudden changes in velocity promote
resuspension

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Mass balance in a network

Suspended
solids

Biofilm
formation &
sloughing

Particles
Deposition &
resuspention

n
io
t
en
p
us
s
re

Corrosion

Suspended
solids

Formation & Particles


coagulation

J.H.G. Vreeburg

Bed load
transport
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Actions to prevent red water:


a three stage rocket

Prevent the sediment from entering the


network

Remove sediment swiftly en effectively

Improve the treatment of water


Conduct cleaning programmes

Prevent sedimentation of suspended


matter

Design small diameter pipes: design for


self-cleaning capacity

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Variation of production
capacity and water quality

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Turbidity different pumping


stations
0,4

0,35

0,3

Turbidity (FTU)

plant C
0,25

0,2

0,15

plant B

0,1

plant A
0,05

0
22

24

26

28

30

Tim e (days, reference is location ps A)

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

10

12

14

16

First stage: improve treatment

Goal: steady process with low turbidity


Tools: demand forecasting and clever
use of balancing reservoirs

But: conventional treatment leaves


sediment in the water

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Second stage: Remove


sediment

Cleaning the network, available


techniques

Flushing
Water/air scouring
Pigging

Measuring method:

Resuspension potential

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Research tools

Continuous monitoring turbidity and


Particle counts
Resuspension Potential Method
Experimental pipe test rig
Analysis of concentrate MF-installation

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Resuspension Potential
Method

Principle

resuspension of sediment by sudden increase


of velocity
0,35 m/s on top of normal velocity
turbidity monitoring
no impact on the customer

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Resuspension Potential
Method
Monitor

V (m/s)

Closed valve

Cause a sudden increase in velocity


V = 0.35

Normal velocity

t1
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

t2

Time

Typical RP curve
High resuspension
potential indicates
polluted network:
cleaning network, e.g.
flushing

Turbidity

Time
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Effect of flushing monitored


with resuspension potential
Turbidity

Turbidity
Before
cleaning
After
cleaning

Time
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Time

Pictures monitor connection

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Resuspension Potential
Method

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Resuspension Potential
Method

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Resuspention potential method


Sample measuring

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Turbidity [FTU]

Typical RPM curve


First 5 min

Last 10 min

Base level

Disturbance
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Resettling time

Relative interpretation RPM


5 aspects determine the RP:

Absolute maximum turbidity first five minutes


Average turbidity first five minutes
Absolute maximum turbidity last ten minutes
Average turbidity last ten minutes
Resetling time
First 5 min Last 10 min

0 to 3 points per aspect

Turbidity [FTU]

Base
level

Disturbance Resettling time


CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Ranking RPM
Turbidity Dr Lange, Hydrant measuring
points
Category
Absolute max
first 5 min
Average first 5 min
Absolute max
last 10 min
Average max
last 10 min
Time to clear
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

<3 ftu

3 10 ftu 10-40 ftu >40 ftu

<3 ftu

3 10 ftu 10-40 ftu >40 ftu

<3 ftu

3 10 ftu 10-40 ftu >40 ftu

<3 ftu

3 10 ftu 10-40 ftu >40 ftu

< 5 min. 5-15 min 15-60 min >60 min

Typical RPM results


Pre and Post cleaning
Turbidity w ith RPM, before cleaning
Disturbance 13:09 - 13:23

Turbidity w ith RPM, after cleaning


Disturbance 9:59 - 10:15
50
Turbidity [FTU]

Turbidity [FTU]

50
40
30
20
10
0

40
30
20
10
0

13:09 13:11 13:13 13:15 13:17 13:19 13:25

09:59

10:02

10:05

Tim e

Score 12

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

10:08

Tim e

Score 0

10:11

10:14

Resuspension Potential Method


Particles

Hypothesis effects improved


particle load

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Effect cleaning

Effect improved
treatment

Critical
level

Effect
Q21 ?
Cleaning
frequency 1

Cleaning
frequency 2

Additional research

Particle load present system

Large volume sampling


Test rig 100
new test rig multiple pipes

Goals:

Determine characteristics present drinking


water
Develop new measurement methods and
tools
Trigger students

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Test pipe rig 100

Charge with
concentrate
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Original set up test rig

layer development

2
1

time

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Practical set up

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

First observations

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Some more observations

Iron Chloride 0.06 m/s

Iron Chloride 0.14 m/s

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Kaolinite 0.06 m/s

Kaolinite 0.14 m/s

Drinking water quality aspects:


Remove the sediment

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Remove the sediment

Water flushing is effective if:

1,5 m/s is reached


Flush volume is 3 times the pipe content
Clear water front

Alternative methods as water/air scouring


and pigging only when water flushing
boundaries are not met

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Results of cleaning program

City of Venlo
Red line are CI
Rest is PVC/AC

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Measuring equipment

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

RPM results individual location


Turbidity data RPM 100 mm AC
200
180

22-10-2001
15-5-2002
22-10-2002
17-11-2003
10-11-2004
28-11-2005
1-11-2006

Turbidity [FTU]

160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
1

11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41

RPM data 100 mm AC

time [minutes]

12
10

RPM [-]

8
6
4
2
0
2001

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

2002

2003

2004

2005

year

2006

2007

2008

RPM results CI-location


Turbidity data 4" CI
350
4-3-2002
9-7-2002
7-5-2003
27-5-2004
26-4-2005
9-5-2006

Turbidity [FTU]

300
250
200
150
100
50
0
1

5 7

9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41

RPM data 4" CI

Time [min]

12
10

RPM [-]

8
6
4
2

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

0
2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

Overall results
Average RPM
cast-iron/steel

12,0

non ferrous

10,0

RPM [-]

8,0
6,0
4,0
2,0
0,0
2001

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

Innovative cleaning methods


water direction

high velocity

low velocity

ball
re-suspension of sediment

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

transport

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Foto ballcleaning

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Water/air scouring

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Pigging

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Result of aggressive cleaning cast


iron (pigging or W/A scouring)
Post-cleaning turbidity
1,00

Turbidity [FTU]

0,75
Loc 2 post
Loc 4 post
Loc 5 post

0,50

0,25

0,00
13-06-00
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

15-06-00

17-06-00

19-06-00

21-06-00

Third stage: prevent


sedimentation

Design drinking water networks instead of fire


fighting networks
Main characteristics of drinking water network

Looped transport network


Branched district areas with up to 200 connections
Velocity in branches 0,4 m/s once a day

Result: self cleaning network

Large draw back: less fire fighting capacity

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Self cleaning network


Looped network (disturbed)
V = > 0,4 m/sec

Looped network
V = 0,07 m/sec

sediment

Drinking water network (self cleaning)


V = > 0,4 m/sec

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

sediment

Conventional network
75
110
Flat

VP 350 kPa

Flat

house

Hospital
VP 350 kPa

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

New network
40
63
110

VP 350 kPa
64

116

85

60 m3/h

Hospital
VP 350 kPa

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Pumping stations and water


transport
Water quality aspects of drinking water
networks
ct5550

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Chemical processes

Materials used in drinking water transport and


distribution

Materials used in house plumbing

Cast Iron
Asbestos Cement
Plastics as PVC and PE
Lead
Copper
Plastics, mainly PE

Other materials as concrete, (galvanised) steel,


GRP act chemically in similar ways

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Cast Iron: corrosion products

Fe

CO

23

FeCO3

2+

O2

Fe

3+

O2
FeOOH Fe3O 4

FeOOH

Protective layer

bad layer

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Cast Iron: corrosion problems

Graphitisation: weakening of pipe


material and strength
Loss of hydraulic capacity due to
voluminous corrosion products
Deterioration of water quality

Discolouration
Biofilm formation

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

100 Cast Iron (1900)

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Cast Iron: prevention of


corrosion

Water composition at pumping station

pH > 7,5
TIC > 2 mmol/l
(Total Inorganic Carbon [HCO3-])
(Cl- + 2SO4)/TIC < 1

Coatings

Cement mortar lining


PE-sleeves

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Asbestos Cement

Corrosion process: Leaching of Calcium


Hydroxide
Corrosion problems:

Loss of strength
Increase of pH
Release of asbestos fibres
Precipitation of calcium carbonate

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Prevention AC corrosion
problems

Water composition

-0,2 < SI < 0,3


TIC > 2 mmol/l

Ca 2+ CO32-
SI = log
Ca 2+ CO32-
eq

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

= pH - pH eq
eq

Plastics

No chemical processes known at the


moment
(limited) Lead destabilisation at the start
of the life time

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Lead and copper

Corrosion process: release of lead


Corrosion problem: public health
Prevention

Water composition: pH > 7,8


Coating
replacement

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Optimal composition of
drinking water

7.8 and (0,38 TIC + 1.5 SO24 + 5.3) < pH < 8.3
TIC > 2
0.2 < SI < 0,3
Cl + 2 SO42

<1
TIC
TIC = HCO3 (if 7.8 < pH < 8.3)
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Chemical en biological
processes

The following slides are optional and can


be put in an appendix.

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Biological processes

Biological water quality will change in the


distribution system
Changes are governed by:

initial water quality


chemical and biological processes
hydraulics
pipe material
system integrity

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Goal in-pipe water quality


control

Hygienic water safety control

limitation of regrowth
prevention of recontamination

Controlling chemical and physical


composition

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Hygienic water safety control:


limitation of regrowth

Disinfectant residual

May have some effect


Not applied because of adverse effects
(disinfection by-products, taste, odour)

Controlling the source of regrowth


problems

biologically unstable water


biologically unstable pipe materials

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Causes for degradation of the


microbial in-pipe water quality

biofilm formation

attachment and growth of micro-organisms


onto surfaces exposed to drinking water
entrapment of (inorganic) particles in biofilm

sediment accumulation

environment for multiplication of microorganisms (Aeromonads, invertebrates)

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Biofilm formation

Biofilm formation is promoted by


microbial utilisation of biodegradable
compounds
Sources for biodegradable compounds:

treated water
pipe material in contact with drinking water

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

The Unified Biofilm Approach

Biofilm
Formation
Characteristics
of Water
Biofilm monitor

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Biofilm
Density on
Pipe Walls
Observations on
pipe segments

Biofilm
Formation
Potential of
Materials
BFP-test

Assessing biofilm formation

Kiwa Biofilm Monitor

assessment of rate (BFR) and extent (BFP) of biofilm


formation on surfaces exposed to water under test
BFR = Biofilm Formation Rate (pg ATP/cm2.d)
BFP = Biofilm Formation Potential (pg ATP/ cm2)

provides information on the biostability of the water

Biomass Production Potential (BPP) test

assessment of the growth promoting characteristics of


materials in slow sand filtrate
BPP = BFP + Suspended Biomass Production (SBP)

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Biofilm Formation Rate (BFR)


in water:Kiwa Biofilm Monitor
Biofilm formation
equilibrium
- growth
- sloughing effect

lineair growth

exponential growth
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Biomass Production Potential


(BPP)

BPP of materials in
contact with (tap) water
BPP/BFP test

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

Slow sand filtrate


(600 ml)
12 pieces of material
S/V = 0.15 cm2/cm3
Duplicate flasks
Incubation at 25 C
Period: 16 weeks
Biomass parameters:
- ATP
- HPC
- Legionella, ..

Biofilm Formation on materials


in slow sand filtrate (BFP-test)
Biofilm Concentration (pg ATP / cm2)
105

pPVC
104

PE

103

PTFE

102

uPVC
10
0
CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

25

50

75

Incubation period (days)

100

The Unified Biofilm Approach:


a framework for evaluation
104
Drinking water from
groundwater (highest
value)
Drinking water from
anaerobic groundwater
Drinking water from
surface water

Plasticized PVC
Natural rubber
1000

100

Filtrate GAC filter


(fresh carbon)
Drinking water from
aerobic groundwater

10

CT5550: water quality aspects DW networks

PTFE
Stainless steel

Filtrate slow sand filters

Water

Glass fiber reinforced


polyester
PE materials
Silicone tubing
Glassfiber reinforced
epoxy
uPVC materials

Glass
1

BFP (pg ATP/cm2)

Materials

You might also like