Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: The design of compression-t joints, based on the theory of thick-walled cylinders,
is usually referred to shafthub couplings carried out between two elements that have an axial
symmetric shape. The stress distributions both inside the elements and on the contact surfaces
can be dened by the equilibrium and by the compatibility formulae once the total radial interference and the internal and external pressure (the boundary conditions) are known. The complete
tensile state of the coupling is dened by two principal stresses: the radial and the hoop tensions.
The present article aims at extending the analytic calculation valid for two elements to a number
of n elements by means of a sequential solution of the governing equation system. The elements in
contact can rotate at a generic angular velocity and can, also, be made of different materials. The
overall solution has been derived starting from the hypothesis of the simultaneous presence of
axial symmetric geometries and axial symmetric loads. The mathematical model has been veried
by comparing the theoretical results with some nite-element analysis calculations performed
on the same coupled elements.
Keywords: shafthub couplings, thick-wall cylinder theory, interference, angular velocity,
generalized theory
INTRODUCTION
Downloaded from pic.sagepub.com at Alma Mater Studiorum - Universit di Bologna on May 31, 2015
2232
Fig. 1
METHODOLOGY
Bi
3 + i 2
+ i 2 ri1
Qg_i
2
ri_tot = Ai Qg_i
8
1 + 3i 2
Bi
2 2
Qg_i
ti_tot = Ai + 2 + i ri1
8
Qg_i
rg_i
Qg_i =
; i = 1, . . . , n
ri1
two results will be combined together to have the overall solution. The tensile state is assumed to be always
below the linear elastic limit.
Referring to Fig. 2, the input data are the external
p0 and the internal pn pressures applied to the series
of n elements and the total actual radial interference
Ztot_i produced at the n 1 coupling surfaces, which
can be, easily, dened by the difference between the
radius dimensions, in the unstressed state, of the elements in contact (ith and i + 1th). Therefore, the ith
element is loaded by an internal pressure pi and by
an external pressure pi1 , with i = 1, . . . , n. From now
on, the subscript s identies the quantities related
to the static effect, that are the ith interference, the
p0 , and the pn , whereas the subscript d identies the
quantities related to the rotating effect.
The ith radial and hoop stresses in equation (1)
can be therefore computed by solving the following
n system of equations
2
1
Q
1 2
= pi1_s + (pi_s pi1_s )
ri_s
1 Qi2
Qg_i
1
Qi2
1 Qi2
Qg_i
Qg_i =
rg_i
ri
, Qi =
; i = 1, . . . , n
ri1
ri1
(2)
The n systems dened by equations (2) for n different values of the ith element cannot be directly solved
by a simple substitution of the unknown quantities,
e.g. starting from the external element and moving
towards the internal one or vice versa, because the
pressures pi are unknown for i = 2, . . . , n 1.
In fact, n 1 equations are linearly dependent
because of the radial equilibrium on the contact
surfaces of the n 1 couplings: on these surfaces
ri_s_int = ri+1_s_ext = pi_s . Therefore, the total system
of equations has (n1) solutions.
The n 1 missing equations can be deduced by the
compatibility conditions of the displacements on the
(1)
Fig. 2
JMES1437
1
Zi
(ti_s i ri_s ) =
Ei
ri
Zi_int =
Zi+1_ext
be further compressed as
Ki =
(3)
p
i
i_s
Ei
1 Qi2
(4)
2
2Qi+1
ri
pi_s + (pi+1_s pi_s )
=
2
Ei+1
1 Qi+1
(5)
+ i+1 pi_s
p
i i_s
Ei
1 Qi2
2
2Qi+1
ri
2233
Li =
Ni+1
(8)
(9)
(10)
Ztot_i
+ pi+1_s Ni+1
ri
(11)
(12)
(13)
I2 = N2
(14)
J1_s = p0 L1 +
Ztot_1
r1
(15)
pi_s = pi+1_s
Ki+1
Ni+2
Ztot_i+1
pi+2_s
Li+1
ri+1 Li+1
Li+1
(16)
Ki+1
Ni+2
Ztot_i+1
Hi
pi+2_s
pi+1_s
Li+1
ri+1 Li+1
Li+1
= Ji_s + pi+1_s Ii+1
(17)
pi_s =
Ki+1
Hi Ii+1
Li+1
Ni+2
Ztot_i+1
= Ji_s +
Hi + pi+2_s
Hi
ri+1 Li+1
Li+1
pi+1_s
(18)
(19)
with i = 1, . . . , n 1.
The n 1 equations generated by the iteration of
equation (7) at the n 1 interfaces provide the n 1
coupling pressures as a function of the p0 and pn . This
system of equations can be automatically solved for
example by means of a spreadsheet or of a specic
programming language. In this case equation (7) can
JMES1437
Ki+2
Hi+1 Ii+2
Li+2
Ni+3
Ztot_i+2
= Ji+1_s +
Hi+1 + pi+3_s
Hi+1
ri+2 Li+2
Li+2
pi+2_s
Downloaded from pic.sagepub.com at Alma Mater Studiorum - Universit di Bologna on May 31, 2015
(20)
2234
where
2 2
i ri1 (3 + i )/8
1 + 3i 2
2 + Qi2
Qi
Ei
3 + i
(29)
(21)
(22)
(23)
(24)
The decrease of contact pressure because of an angular velocity in rotating ts between only two elements
was investigated by Biezeno and Grammel [5]. In the
case of n elements rotating at an angular velocity ,
the ith radial and hoop stresses of equation (1) can
be computed by solving the following n system of
equations
3 + i
Qi2
2
2
2 2
1 + Qi 2 Qg_i
ri_d = i ri1 8
Qg_i
2
3
+
Q
1
+
3
i
i
i
2
1 + Qi2 + 2
Q2
ti_d = i 2 ri1
8
3 + i g_i
Qg_i
Qg_i =
rg_i
ri
, Qi =
; i = 1, . . . , n
ri1
ri1
ti_s
Ei
As the Ztot_i are also equal to zero, the value of the ith
pressure on the ith interface can be deduced from the
following equation
(27)
2
2
+ {[1 i+1 + (2Qi+1
)/(1 Qi+1
)]/Ei+1 }
Vi
Ki
or
pi_tot Ki =
Ztot_i
+ pi1_tot Li1 + pi+1_tot Ni+1 + Vi (32)
ri
(33)
H1 = K1
(34)
I2 = N2
(35)
J1_tot = p0 L1 +
Ztot_1
+ V1 = J1_s + V1
r1
(36)
and for i = 2, . . . , n 1
pi_tot =
where for i = 1
(26)
2
{i 2 ri1
[(3 + i )/8]/Ei }
2
[2 + Qi (1 + 3i )/(3 + i )Qi2 ]
{[(1 + Qi2 )/(1 Qi2 ) + i ]/Ei }
pi_tot =
(25)
2
(1 + 3i+1 )/(3 + i+1 )]
[1 + 2Qi+1
2
{i 2 ri1
[(3 + i )/8]/Ei }
2
[2 + Qi (1 + 3i )/(3 + i )Qi2 ]
(28)
Ki
Hi1 Ii
Li
Ni+1
=
Hi1
Li
Hi =
(37)
Ii+1
(38)
JMES1437
JMES1437
0.0000
0.0250
0.0100
0.0000
1.61E-05
7.32E-06
3.97E-03
4.59E-03
4.20E-05
2.75E-05
5.48E-06
3.07E-06
1.01E-05
1.61E-05
7.78E-06
1.98E-05
4.47E-05
1.75E-05
4.20E-05
4.63E-05
0.71
0.60
0.67
35.000
24.988
14.995
10.000
70.000
50.000
30.000
49.950
29.980
20.000
7850
2770
7850
Vi
Hi
(MPa1 )
Ii
(MPa1 )
Ji
206 000
70 000
206 000
0
1
2
3
Fig. 3
420
(rad/s)
Ei (MPa)
4011
(r/min)
i
Table 1
(41)
0.29
0.33
0.29
3 + i
= i 2 ri1
Qi2
1 + 3i 2
1 + Qi + 2
pi1_tot
Q
3 + i g_i
Qg_i
1
Qi2
1+ 2
+ (pi_tot pi1_tot )
1 Qi2
Qg_i
Ni
(MPa1 )
Qi2
3 + i
2
2
2 2
= i ri1
1 + Qi 2 Qg_i
8
Qg_i
Qi2
p
+
(p
p
)
i1_tot
i_tot
i1_tot
1 Qi2
1 2
Q
g_i
Li
(MPa1 )
Ki
(MPa1 )
(40)
Qi
pi_tot Ii + Ji1_tot
Hi1
ri
(mm)
pi1_tot =
Di ext
(mm)
Equations (34), (35), (37), and (38) are equal to equations (13), (14), (22), and (23), respectively, whereas
equations (36) and (39) are different from equations (15) and (24) because they contain the rotating
velocity contribution.
The sequential system of equations (34) to (39)
developed starting from the external element and
moving towards the internal one is, at all, useful
to calculate the unknown pressures pi by means of
equation (40), which has to be solved starting from
the pn1 and moving towards the p1
Zi
(mm)
(39)
Di int
(mm)
Hi1
pi tot
(MPa)
i
(kg/m3 )
Ji_tot = Ji1_tot +
Ztot_i
Vi
+
ri L i
Li
Geometrical parameters and mathematical model development for the studied coupling
2235
150.00
161.39
175.01
30
2236
Table 2
Geometrical parameters and stress values calculation for the studied coupling
420
4011
Di int
(rad/s)
(r/min) i
Ei (MPa) i
(kg/m3 ) (mm)
0
1
2
3
206 000
70 000
206 000
0.29
0.33
0.29
7850
2770
7850
Fig. 4
Di ext
(mm)
ri
(mm)
Zi
(mm)
pi tot
(MPa)
r i int
(MPa)
r i ext
(MPa)
t i int
(MPa)
t i ext
(MPa)
VM i int
(MPa)
VM i ext
(MPa)
139.31
154.24
353.74
Contour plot of the total radial tension ri_tot for the studied coupling
JMES1437
Fig. 5
Table 3
ptot
ps
Mt_tot
1 + 3
r1 2 3 + 2
=
r1 1
=1+
Mt_s
EZtot_1 8
3+
1 + 3 2
r02 2 + Q12
(42)
Q
3+ 1
Contour plot of the total hoop tension ti_tot for the studied coupling
Stress values given by the FEM analysis and errors calculated with respect to the theoretical values
%
FEM result
r i int
n (MPa)
r i ext
(MPa)
t i int
(MPa)
0
1 160.70
2 173.80
3 37.50
150.00
160.40
173.30
JMES1437
2237
t i ext
(MPa)
VM i int VM i ext r i int r i ext t i int t i ext VM i int VM i ext
(MPa)
(MPa)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
(%)
139.96
153.58
350.24
0.43
0.69
1.67
0.00
0.61
0.98
2.22
0.10
1.23
1.43
0.15
0.99
0.07
0.50
1.31
0.47
0.43
0.99
2238
The same result may be obtained by applying equations (43) and (44) as presented in reference [1]
2
Mt_tot
=1
(43)
Mt_s
L
4 EZtot_1
L =
(44)
3 + r02 r1
4
DISCUSSION
Authors 2009
REFERENCES
1 Niemann, G., Winter, H., and Hohn, B. R. Maschineelemente B.d. I, 2005 (Springer, Berlin).
2 Kollmann, F. G. Welle-Nabe-Verbindungen Konstructionsbucher Bd.32, 1984 (Springer, Berlin).
3 Strozzi, A. Costruzione di Macchine, 1998 (Pitagora
Editrice, Bologna).
4 Hall Jr, A. S., Holowenko, A. R., and Laughlin, H. G.
Metal ts and tolerances. In Shaums outline of theory
and problems of machine design, 1961, pp. 1821 (Shaum
Publishing Co., New York).
5 Biezeno, C. B. and Grammel, R. Rotierende Scheiben,
Technische Dynamik, vol. 2, 2nd edititon, 1971 (Springer,
Berlin).
6 Gao, B., Shi, X., Liu, H., and Li, J. Separation of primary stress in nite element analysis of pressure vessel
with the principle of superposition. In Proceedings of the
Asian Pacic Conference Fracture and Strength 2006
APCFS06, 2006, pp. 373376.
7 Zao, H. Numerical analysis of the interference tting
stresses between wheel and shaft. Int. J. Mater. Prod.
Technol., 1997, 12(46), 514526.
8 Croccolo, D., Cuppini, R., and Vincenzi, N. The design
and optimization of forkpin compression coupling in
front motorbike suspensions. Finite Elem. Anal. Des.,
2007, 43, 977988.
APPENDIX
Notation
Ei
Mt_s
Mt_tot
n
pc
CONCLUSION
pint , pext
pi_d
pi_s
pi_tot
pn , p0
Qg_i
rc
ri , ri1 , rg_i
Zi
Zi_ext
Zi_int
JMES1437
ZR
Ztot_i
i
i
ri
ri_d
ri_FEM
ri_s
ri_s_ext
JMES1437
ri_s_int
ti_d
ti
ti_FEM
ti_s
VM_i_ext
VM_i_int
2239