Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2, 181187
contents near the plastic limit, the relationship between logarithmic depth of fall-cone penetration and water content has been
used to estimate the value of the plastic limit. Based on the
critical state theory, Wood & Wroth (1978) and Belviso et al.
(1985) suggest that the logarithmic depth of penetration against
water content relationship is linear between the liquid limit and
the plastic limit, and the slope of this relationship is equal to
one half of the plasticity index. Then, the plastic limit can be
computed by subtracting the plasticity index from the liquid
limit. However, the relationship has been found to be highly
non-linear for a number of soils (e.g. Karlsson, 1961; Wood,
1985; Wasti & Bezirci, 1986; Harison, 1988).
The penetration depth corresponding to the liquid limit is
20 mm for the 308 British cone. Hansbo (1957) proposes the
following equation:
INTRODUCTION
su k
W
d2
(1)
181
182
FENG
Specimen ring
In order to estimate the plastic limits, the non-linear regression curves shown in Figs 26 may be manually extended with
(a)
60
Sinjun clay
PL(conventional) = 19%
Soil
10 cm
Soil
Glass plate
(b)
(c)
Soil
Soil
(d)
(e)
Water content: %
50
40
30
20
Fig. 1. Side views of (a) the specimen ring, (b) the soil mound and
the glass plate, (c) the specimen ring placed on top of the soil
mound, (d) the specimen ring fully penetrating the soil mound, and
(e) excess soil removed from the top of the specimen ring
10
30
20
10
7
5
3
Penetration depth: mm
Fig. 2. Logarithm of penetration depth against water content relationship for Sinjun clay
60
Taipei clay
PL(conventional) = 24%
40
30
300
200
100
20
10
30
20
10
7
5
3
Penetration depth: mm
Panama clay
PL(conventional) = 59%
90
60
30
30
20
10
7
5
3
Penetration depth: mm
20
10
7
5
3
Penetration depth: mm
150
120
30
Water content: %
Bentonite
PL(conventional) = 37%
400
Water content: %
Water content: %
50
(2)
60
Kaolin
PL(conventional) = 25%
Bentonite
Water content: %
50
Water content: %
183
40
30
100
Panama clay
Kaolin
20
Sinjun clay
10
Taipei clay
10
30
20
10
7
5
3
Penetration depth: mm
30
20
10
7
5
3
Penetration depth: mm
184
FENG
It may be noted from Table 1 that the bentonite samples have
liquid limits of about 423% and 526%, the kaolin samples have
liquid limits of 50% and 59%, and the other 22 natural soils
show a wide range of liquid limits ranging from 30% to 125%.
Both of the bentonite specimens gave the same m value of 1,
which is much larger than the m values from 0216 to 0569 for
the natural soils. A large value of m indicates a higher rate of
decrease in water content with decreasing depth of penetration.
A large value of c implies a large value of the plastic limit. The
Panama clay specimen tested has an organic content of 12%,
which is probably responsible for its large c value of 47%. The c
values of the Bandung clays are rather high, that is 3039%;
probably these soils are organic to some degree, but information
on the composition of these soils is absent.
The existence of the linear relationship as expressed by
equation (2) is useful for estimation of the plastic limit. For a
soil, c and m can be determined from results of as few as four
fall-cone tests with depths of penetration evenly distributed
between 25 mm and 3 mm. Equation (3) can then be used to
compute the plastic limit:
PL c(2) m
(3)
185
Table 1. Values of c and m parameters of clays and water contents computed from strength ratios of 50, 100 and 200
Soil
LLCasagrande : %
c: %
w1:4 : %
w2 : %
w2:8 : %
w1:4 =w2 :
w2:8 =w2
36
43
125
50
423
97
73
30
80
83
70
63
54
35
59
65
526
110
52
100
86
78
72
65
63
59
14
17
47
20
17
26
21
13
28
26
25
22
21
12
21
23
16
20
21
39
31
30
30
32
30
31
0322
0322
0321
0301
1
0436
0410
0266
0352
0425
0360
0360
0308
0350
0343
0345
1
0569
0335
0312
0341
0318
0292
0237
0239
0216
16
19
52
22
24
30
24
14
32
30
28
25
23
14
24
26
22
24
24
43
35
33
33
35
33
33
18
21
59
25
34
35
28
16
36
35
32
28
26
15
27
29
32
30
26
48
39
37
37
38
35
36
20
24
66
27
48
41
32
17
40
40
36
32
29
17
30
33
45
36
30
54
44
42
41
41
38
39
089
090
088
088
071
086
086
088
089
086
088
089
088
093
089
090
069
080
092
090
090
089
089
092
094
092
111
114
112
108
141
117
114
106
111
114
113
114
112
113
111
114
141
120
115
113
113
114
111
108
109
108
Sinjun clay
Taipei clay
Panama clay
Kaolin
Bentonite
Shellhaven clay
London clay
Horten clay
Gosport clay
Swedish clay
Swedish clay
Swedish clay
Swedish clay
Drammen clay
Kaolin
Gault clay
Bentonite
Turkey soil
Turkey soil
Bandung clay
Bandung clay
Bandung clay
Bandung clay
Bandung clay
Bandung clay
Bandung clay
Table 2, both the logarithm of penetration depth against logarithm of water content relationships and the (c, m) data of
kaolin obtained by ve persons demonstrate excellent repeatability of the fall-cone test. It is worthy of note that four of the
ve persons had no previous experience with the fall-cone test
and were taught only once how to run the test. It is clear from
the present investigation that mixing the soil specimen thoroughly during preparation is one of the most important steps in
the fall-cone test.
STRAIN RATE EFFECT
Reference
Present investigation
Present investigation
Present investigation
Present investigation
Present investigation
Skempton & Northey (1953)
Skempton & Northey (1953)
Skempton & Northey (1953)
Skempton & Northey (1953)
Karlsson (1961)
Karlsson (1961)
Karlsson (1961)
Karlsson (1961)
Wood (1985)
Wood (1985)
Wood (1985)
Wasti & Bezirci (1986)
Wasti & Bezirci (1986)
Wasti & Bezirci (1986)
Harison (1988)
Harison (1988)
Harison (1988)
Harison (1988)
Harison (1988)
Harison (1988)
Harison (1988)
(4)
186
FENG
on undrained shear strength is computed using equation (6) to
be 7% between 20 mm and 4 mm penetrations.
CONCLUSIONS
Water content: %
Kaolin
10
30
20
10
7
5
3
Penetration depth: mm
PL (measured):
%
c: %
PL (computed): %
1
2
3
4
5
25
25
25
25
25
20
19
19
20
21
0301
0295
0316
0281
0281
25
23
24
24
26
t20
_ 4
5
_ 20
t4
(5)
su(20)
_ 4
_ 20
C =Cc
(6)
REFERENCES
Belviso, R., Ciampoli, S., Cotecchia, V. & Federico, A. (1985). Use of
the cone penetrometer to determine consistency limits. Ground
Engng 18, No. 5, 2122.
British Standards Institution (1990). Methods of test for soils for civil
engineering purposes. British Standards Institution BS 1377. London.
Canadian Standards Association and Bureau de normalisation du Quebec
(1986). Soils-Determination of liquid limit by the Swedish fall cone
penetrometer method and determination of plastic limit. CAN=BNQ
2501-092-M-86.
Farrell, E., Schuppener, B. & Wassing, B. (1997). ETC 5 fall-cone
study. Ground Engng 30, No. 1, 3336.
Garneau, R. & Le Bihan, J. P. (1977). Estimation of some properties of
Champlain clays with the Swedish fall-cone. Can. Geotech. J. 14,
No. 3, 571581.
Hansbo, S. (1957). A new approach to the determination of the shear
strength of clay by the fall-cone test. R. Swedish Geotech. Inst.
Proc. No. 14, 747.
187