You are on page 1of 9

The Rhetoric of Ideas: Ideology and Propaganda

COMM 370
Spring 2013
Monday/Wednesday 5:00-6:20pm, ASC G38
Instructor:

L. Paul Strait

Email: strait@usc.edu

Phone: 202-270-6397

Office Hours: Mondays and Wednesdays 3:00-5:00pm, ASC G6


We hear of brainwashing, of schemes whereby an ideology is imposed upon people. But should we stop at that?
Should we not also see the situation the other way around? For was not the brainwasher also similarly
motivated? Do we simply use words, or do they not also use us? An ideology is like a god coming down to earth,
where it will inhabit a place pervaded by its presence. An ideology is like a spirit taking up its abode in a body: it
makes that body hop around in certain ways, and the same body would have hopped around in different ways had a
different ideology happened to inhabit it. Kenneth Burke
To regard rhetoric and ideology as wholly discrete realms is to be in thrall to both. Stephen Bygrave
The successor to politics will be propaganda. Propaganda, not in the sense of a message or ideology, but as the
impact of the whole technology of the times. Marshall McLuhan.

I. Rationale:
This course examines the role of communication and rhetoric in the workings of ideology and
propaganda. We will study the history of the concept of ideology, and using a mix of primary and
secondary sources we will explore the approaches of a range of important thinkers, including Louis
Althusser , Kenneth Burke, Terry Eagleton, Jacques Ellul, Antonio Gramsci, Jrgen Habermas, Herbert
Marcuse, Karl Mannheim, Karl Marx, Joseph Pieper, Slavoj iek, and others. After working out a
theoretically robust understanding of ideology, we will examine the history of propaganda, focusing on
specific artifacts from various (modern) historical eras, seeking in particular to understand how the
evolution of mass communication technology has influenced the production and reception of propaganda.
The course will also introduce students to the field of public diplomacythat is, efforts to communicate,
by both public and private organizations, to diverse publics in the context of American foreign policy.
We will review foundational work done on the study of national propaganda from a variety of
perspectives as well as conduct a historical review, emphasizing the last one hundred years of, ways in
which propaganda and public diplomacy have been central to the national security of the United States.
Finally, we will explore ways in which marketers, public relations agencies, and scientists deploy
ideological discourse and propaganda in public controversies. In the end, this course will leave you with
an advanced understanding of the interplay between rhetoric, ideology, and propaganda from an historical
and theoretical perspective, and equip you with the research skills and the critical sensibility necessary to
read and respond to instances of ideological communication. You will gain insight both into how people
use words, and more importantly, how words use people.

II. Course Aims and Objectives:


Students should review these objectives on a regular basis as they will help inform the goals of each days
readings and discussion. They will also be central themes used in written work for the course. Students
will be, by the completion of the course, able to draw upon a range of scholarship to engage these
questions.
What is ideology and how does it work? Specifically, what rhetorical motives and practices
underlie the development, circulation, and maintenance of ideological discursive formations? Is
ideology qua ideology rhetorical?

2
Revised 1/30/2013

Should ideologies be ill-reputed? Is it possible to be free/outside of ideology?


Are there any epistemological or moral reasons to prefer one ideology over another (particularly
reasons that transcend the particular ideologies in question)?
Why do people embrace ideologies? What factors (psychosocial, cultural, perhaps neurobiological) influence the degree to which one finds a particular ideology, or ideology in general,
appealing?
How can ideology be identified? Where can we find it? And how should we critically examine
it?
What is the relationship between ideology and truth? What is the relationship between
propaganda and truth?
What is the relationship between ideology and science? How can scientific discourse promote or
undermine ideological positions and beliefs? What roles can scientific research play in
propaganda?
What is propaganda and how does it differ from persuasion? Is public diplomacy propaganda? Is
advertising propaganda? Why are these distinctions meaningful?
What ethical dilemmas are entailed in the production of propaganda? What ethical dilemmas are
entailed in the consumption of information?
How can propaganda be evaluated? What are the central messages? What are the purposes and
outcomes of propaganda campaigns?
How does mass communication technology influence the evolution of propaganda?
Why is propaganda so important in modern society and in modern warfare? What role did it have
in pre-modern societies and conflicts?
What are the similarities and differences between propaganda campaigns waged by states vs.
propaganda campaigns waged by non-state actors?

III. Course Materials


Required
Michael Freeden. (2003). Ideology: A very short introduction. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
$9.50 new, $1.06 used
Garth S. Jowett & Victoria ODonnell. (2005). Propaganda & persuasion. (4th edition).
Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications. $16.71 new, $15.61 used [note, not 5th edition, which is
$112 new]
Garth S. Jowett & Victoria ODonnell, eds. (2006). Readings in propaganda & persuasion: New
and classic essays. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications. $40.07 new, $22.26 used
Josef Pieper. (1992). Abuse of language, abuse of power. Translated by Lothar Krauth. San
Francisco: Ignatius Press. $9.95 new, $4.80 used

3
Revised 1/30/2013

Recommended/Supplementary
Kenneth Burke. (1989). On symbols and society. Edited by Joseph R. Gusfield. Chicago: The
University of Chicago Press. $15.76 new, $6.77 used
Terry Eagleton. (2007). Ideology: An introduction. London: Verso. $14.26 new, $8.99 used
Anthony Pratkanis & Elliot Aronson. (1992). Age of propaganda: The everyday use and abuse of
persuasion. New York: Henry Holt & Co. $5.42 new, $3.89 used
Slavoj iek, ed. (1994). Mapping ideology. London: Verso. $17.79 new, $16.88 used
IV. Tentative Course Schedule: **This syllabus represents my current plans and objectives. As we go
through the semester, those plans may need to change to enhance the class learning opportunity. Such changes,
communicated clearly, are not unusual and should be expected.

Date

Main Topic(s)

Work to do at home

Evaluation

Readings to be completed before class

1/14
1/16
1/21
1/23

1/28

1/30

2/4

2/6

2/11

Introduction
Defining Ideology

Kenneth Burke, Definition of Man BB

No Class Martin Luther King


Day
What is Ideology? An
introduction to the concept(s)

Terry Eagleton, What is Ideology? BB


Reinhard Bendix, The Age of Ideology: Persistent and
Changing BB

Classical Marxist/Materialist
Theory of IdeologyThe birth of a
concept

Karl Marx & Frederick Engels, On the German Ideology


(Selections) BB
Freeden, Chps 1 Should Ideologies Be Ill-Reputed?
Terry Eagleton, From the Enlightenment to the Second
International BB
Murray N. Rothbard, The Marxian Doctrine of
Ideology, BB

20th Century Western Marxist /


Materialist Theories of Ideology

Freeden, Chp 2 How Ideologies Came to Stay


Louis Althusser, Ideology & Ideological State
Apparatuses BB
Michel Pcheux, The Mechanism of Ideological
(Mis)recognition) BB

Ideology as Rhetorical Form

Burke Terms of Order BB


Burke Ideology & Myth BB
Michael McGee, The Ideograph: A link between
rhetoric and ideology BB

Ideology as a Cultural System

Freeden, Chp 3 Ideology at the Crossroads of Theory


Clifford Geertz, Ideology as a Cultural System BB

Ideological Strategies

Freeden, Chp 4 Struggle over political language


Terry Eagleton, Ideological Strategies BB

4
Revised 1/30/2013

Paper 1
Assigned

2/13

2/18
2/20

2/25
2/27
3/4

3/6

3/11

3/13

3/18
3/20
3/25

3/27

Categorizing Ideologies

Freeden, Chp 5 Thinking about Politics


Freeden, Chp 6 Macro-ideologies
Freeden, Chp 7 Micro-ideologies

Presidents Day / Professors


Birthday No Class
Ideology Discourse in Practice

Freeden, Chp 8 Discursive Realities and Surrealities


Freeden, Chp 9 Stimuli and Responses: Seeing and
Feeling Ideology
Freeden, Chp 10 Conclusion: Why Politics cant do
without ideology
Alberto Melucci, Collective Action and Discourse BB
Eagleton, Conclusion BB

Paper 1 Due

Ideological Criticism

Foss Ideological Criticism

Final Project
Assigned

Exam 1
Truth, Reality, and Communication

Friedrich Nietzsche, On Truth and Lies in a Nonmoral


Sense BB
Josef Pieper, Abuse of Language, Abuse of Power, pp. 7-54
George Orwell, Politics and the English Language, BB

Defining and Introducing


Propaganda

Beth S. Bennet & Sean Patrick ORourke, Rhetoric and


Propaganda: Critical Foundations, Readings in
Propaganda & Persuasion, pp. 51-72
Jowett & ODonnell, Chapter 1, What is propaganda and
how does it differ from persuasion? pp. 1-50

The History of Propaganda

Gladys Thum and Marcella Thum, War Propaganda and


the American Revolution: The Pen and the Sword,
Readings in Propaganda & Persuasion, pp. 73-82
Thomas C. Sorenson, We Became Propagandists,
Readings in Propaganda & Persuasion, pp. 83-110
Jowett & ODonnell, Chapter 2, Propaganda Through the
Ages, pp. 51-96

Political and Psychological


Dimensions of Propaganda

Jacques Ellul, The Characteristics of Propaganda,


Readings in Propaganda & Persuasion, pp. 1-50

Spring Break No Class


Spring Break No Class

Propaganda and the Rise of Mass


Communication

Jowett & ODonnell, Chapter 3, Propaganda


Institutionalized, pp. 97-164

Propaganda and Persuasion


Examined

Jowett & ODonnell, Chapter 4, Propaganda and


Persuasion Examined, pp. 165-210
Anthony Pratkanis & Elliot Aronson, Chp. 1, Our Age of
Propaganda, pp. 1-20

5
Revised 1/30/2013

4/1

4/3

4/8

4/10
4/15

4/17

4/22

4/24

Propaganda in World War I and its


Aftermath

Philip Taylor, The Bolshevik Revolution and the War of


Ideologies (1917-1939), Readings in Propaganda &
Persuasion, pp. 111-120
Paul M. A. Linebarger, The Function of Psychological
Warfare, Readings in Propaganda & Persuasion, pp.
189-200
Jowett & ODonnell, Chapter 5, Propaganda and
Psychological Warfare, pp. 211-259

Allied Propaganda

David Culbert, Why We Fight: Social Engineering for a


Democratic Society at War, Readings in Propaganda &
Persuasion, pp. 169-187
Martin Herz, Some Psychological Lessons from Leaflet
Propaganda in World War II BB
Claudia Springer, Military Propaganda: Defense
Department Films from World War II and Vietnam, BB

Nazi Propaganda

David A. Welch, Restructuring the Means of


Communication in Nazi Germany, Readings in
Propaganda & Persuasion, pp. 121-148
Kenneth Burke, The Rhetoric of Hitlers Battle,
Readings in Propaganda & Persuasion, pp. 149-168
Leonard W. Doob, Goebbels Principles of Propaganda,
BB

Triumph of the Will Viewing

Paper 2
Assigned

Triumph of the Will Discussion

David Hinton, Triumph of the Will, Document or


Artifice?

Post World War II Propaganda

Harold Lasswell, The Strategy of Soviet Propaganda,


BB
Garth S. Jowett, Brainwashing: The Korean POW
Controversy, Readings in Propaganda & Persuasion, pp.
201-212
Jowett & ODonnell, Chapter 5, Propaganda and
Psychological Warfare, pp. 259-288

Public Diplomacy and the War on


Terror

Nancy Snow, U.S. Public Diplomacy: Its History,


Problems, and Promise, Readings in Propaganda &
Persuasion, pp. 225-242
Stuart J. Kaplan, Visualizing Absence: The Function of
Visual Metaphors in the Effort to make a Fitting Response
to 9/11, Readings in Propaganda & Persuasion, pp. 243258
Margaret Cavin, Evening Gowns to Burqas: The
Propaganda of Fame, Readings in Propaganda &
Persuasion, pp. 259-280
John Brown, Public Diplomacy & Propaganda: Their
Differences, BB

Case Studies

Paper 2 Due

6
Revised 1/30/2013

4/29
5/1
5/8

Case Studies
Final Presentations

Final Project
Due

FINAL EXAM 4:30-6:30pm

V. Course Requirements:
Class Participation - On a daily basis, this is an intensive reading and discussion based course. The
daily assignment is to read and be prepared for in-depth discussion of the readings. Students should
assume that they will be asked to discuss specific aspects of the readings each day. If there are
difficulties with completing daily readings, the instructor may assign unannounced quizzes which
will be factored into the overall grade.
Essays At two points during the semester you be required to complete a 6-8 page essay. The essay
will be on the following subjects and ask you to combine analysis and research into a coherent
argument. Specific guidelines for written assignments will be distributed during the semester.
Before the final draft of each essay is due, a rough draft is due, and you will get feedback from (and
give feedback to) your peers, as well as from me. As the peer feedback component is an important
part of the assignment, it is essential that you adhere to the due dates.
Essay 1 In the first part of this course, we will study a variety of different theoretical approaches to
the concept of ideology. For the first essay assignment, you will compare and contrast two (or more)
of the approaches we have studied, and argue for the superiority of one of the approaches. Your
argument will be at least partially grounded in a case.
Essay 2 Reviewing Triumph of the Will. Nazi Propaganda remains one of the most controversial
applications of propaganda technologies to modern communication. Review the film Triumph of the
Will based on the criteria discussed throughout the course, focusing on the material reviewed on the
Analyzing Propaganda day. In your evaluation, you should incorporate both the ethical and
campaign based dimensions of the film.
Exams We will have two exams that combine short answer and essay formats. The final exam will
focus on the second half of the course material, but will require students to have developed a core
competence from past materials.
Group Project Along with three of your colleagues, you will conduct original critical research on an
artifact of your choosing. Your object of inquiry will consist of a text (artifact) that bears
relevance to the kinds of issues of ideology and propaganda we discussed in class, introduce an
explicit research question, and justify why the text you're analyzing is significant or important (i.e.,
ask yourself what will be gained by taking a detailed scholarly look at the ideological functions of the
artifact). Your study will culminate in a collectively written final paper, and you will present your
findings to the class at the end of the semester.
VI. Grading Procedures:
Students will earn grades based on the following assignments. Specific instructions for each assignment
will be provided in class. Final course grades are assigned on the following scale:

7
Revised 1/30/2013

94-100 % = A

80-83 % = B-

67-69 % = D+

90-93 % = A-

77-79 % = C+

64-66 % = D

87-89 % = B+

74-76 % = C

60-63 % = D-

84-86 % = B

70-73 % = C-

59 % and below = F

Your final grade will be determined by the following components:


Class Participation 10%
Papers 30%
Exams 30%
Group Project 30%
Attendance I take attendance regularly, and expect you to be in class or have a legitimate
excuse (e.g., illness, approved extra-curricular/sports travelling, etc.). If you miss more than
three sessions without a valid excuse, it will negatively affect your grade. If you miss more than
six sessions without an excuse, you may fail.
VII. Academic Integrity
The Annenberg School for Communication is committed to upholding the University's academic integrity
code. It is the policy of the School of Communication to report all violations of the code. Any serious
violation or pattern of violations of the academic integrity code will result in the student's expulsion from
the Communication major or minor. The University presumes that you are familiar with its standards and
policies; should you be found to have committed a violation, ignorance of these standards and policies
will not be accepted as an excuse. You should be familiar with the following resources:
* "Guide to Avoiding Plagiarism" addresses issues of paraphrasing, quotations and citations in written
assignments, drawing heavily upon materials used in the university's Writing Program (by Student
Judicial Affairs) http://www.usc.edu/student-affairs/SJACS/docs/tig.pdf
* "Understanding and Avoiding Academic Dishonesty" addresses more general issues of academic
integrity, including guidelines for adhering to standards concerning examinations and unauthorized
collaboration (by Student Judicial Affairs) http://www.usc.edu/student-affairs/SJACS/docs/tio.pdf
* The "2012-2013 SCampus" (the student handbook) contains the university's Student Conduct Code
and other student-related policies. http://www.usc.edu/scampus
* The Code of Ethics of the University of Southern California:
https://about.usc.edu/files/2011/07/USC_Code_of_Ethics_2004.pdf

VIII. Other University Notices and Policies


Use of E-mail for Official Correspondence to Students All students should become familiar with the
University's official e-mail student notification policy. It is the student's responsibility to keep the
University informed as to changes in his or her e-mail address. Students are expected to check e-mail on
a frequent and regular basis in order to stay current with University-related communications, recognizing
that certain communications may be time-critical. It is recommended that e-mail be checked daily, but at a
minimum, twice per week.

8
Revised 1/30/2013

Late & Unfinished Work Students must complete all assignments in order to earn a grade in the
course. Any material turned in late will be reduced one letter grade per calendar day late. Each speaking
assignment must be given on the day assigned. No makeup sessions will be available.
Final Exam The Final Exam is on May 8, from 4:30-6:30 PM. Do not plan to leave campus before this
date. There will be no alternative exam times except in cases of extreme illness or acts of God.
Grievance Procedure - Occasionally, students are dissatisfied with some dimension of a course. In such
cases, students should first provide a written argument in support of their position to the instructor and
request a meeting with the instructor. All grade appeals on specific assignments must be made within one
week of the return of the assignment.
Special Assistance - Any student requesting academic accommodations based on a disability is required
to register with Disability Services and Programs (DSP) each semester. A letter of verification for
approved accommodations can be obtained from DSP. Please be sure that the letter is delivered as early in
the semester as possible. DSP is located in STU 301 and is open 8:30 a.m. - 5:00 p.m., Monday through
Friday and can be reached at (213) 740-0776.

A Word about Conduct in a College Classroom


To make our time together as valuable as possible, we all have to work hard at it. The following basic principles
may give us some guidelines:
Every student has the right to learn as well as
the responsibility not to deprive others of their right to learn.
Every student is accountable for his or her actions.
In order for you to get the most out of this class, please consider the following:
a.

Attend all scheduled classes and arrive on time.


Late arrivals and early departures are very disruptive and violate the first basic principle listed above.

b.

Please do not schedule other engagements during this class time.


You probably wouldn't appreciate it if I did! I will try to make class as interesting and informative as
possible, but I can't learn the material for you.

c.

If you have trouble hearing the lecture or media presentation because of distractions around you, quietly ask
those responsible for the distraction to stop.
If the distraction continues, please let me know. It is often impossible for me to hear such things from my
position in the classroom.

d.

Please let me know immediately if you have any problem that is preventing you from performing satisfactorily
in this class.

I am looking forward to working with you this semester.


_____________________________________________________________________________

9
Revised 1/30/2013