Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/cis
Abstract
Three mechanisms have been previously proposed to explain the complex process of oil uptake during deep-fat frying. The mechanisms
reviewed are water replacement, cooling-phase effect and surface-active agents. The former mechanism describes mainly oil uptake of
relatively large voids in the fried food created due to water evaporation. The second mechanism furnishes an explanation for the significant
amount of oil absorbed when the food is removed from the fryer. At this point, product surface characteristics and oil viscosity play paramount
roles. Surface- active agents formation provides only a limited explanation for the increased oil uptake during prolonged frying. Reviewed
literature, theory and
new data show contradicting values and do not support the myth that during extended frying time the surfactants generated reduce the contact
angle and/or the interfacial tension, and consequently, influence oil uptake significantly. Higher oil uptake after extended frying time is
probably related to higher oil viscosity caused by polymerization reactions and oil adherence to the product surface. Further research is
needed for establishing the interrelationships between surface-active agents formation and their effect on fried product oil uptake and quality
to resolve this myth.
2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Contact angle; Surface-active agents; Viscosity; Interfacial tension
Contents
1.
2.
3.
4.
Introduction........................................................................................................................................................................................................... 267
Oil uptake............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 268
Oil-uptake mechanism.......................................................................................................................................................................................... 268
Water replacement................................................................................................................................................................................. 269
Cooling-phase effect.............................................................................................................................................................................. 269
Surface-active agents............................................................................................................................................................................. 269
Conclusions........................................................................................................................................................................................................... 271
References........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 271
1. Introduction
Frying is a widespread process, as reflected by extensive
sales and a large spectrum of products. The palatability of
fried foods lies in their unique organoleptic characteristics,
including flavor, texture and appearance. Deep-fat frying is
Corresponding author. Tel./fax: +972 8 9489019.
E-mail address: ssaguy@agri.huji.ac.il (I.S. Saguy).
0001-8686/$ - see front matter 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.cis.2006.11.013
268
D. Dana, I.S. Saguy / Advances in Colloid and Interface Science 128130 (2006) 267272
Table 1
Mean oil content of selected deep-fried foods (compiled from [9])
Food item
Potato chips
Tortilla chips
Donuts
Fried tofu
Onion rings
Chicken, battered/breaded, light meat
French fries
Shrimp, breaded
Fish fillet, battered/breaded
37.5
23.4
22.9
20.2
18.7
18.1
17.1
15.2
12.3
D. Dana, I.S. Saguy / Advances in Colloid and Interface Science 128130 (2006) 267272
Water replacement
During frying (basically a drying process), oil replaces the
water that has evaporated. When the food is exposed to frying
temperatures, water evaporates rapidly, the outer surface
becomes dry and a crust forms. Moisture within the fried
product is converted to steam, creating a positive pressure
gradient. The steam escapes through cracks, defects, open
capillaries and channels in the cellular structure and membranes. As the process progresses, oil adheres to the food,
entering the large voids, product imperfections and crevices
left by the changes in structure due to frying and water
evaporation. As the voids are quite large, there is no inner
resistance due to positive water vapor pressure. This
mechanism could furnish a possible explanation for the direct
relationship observed between water loss and oil uptake
[29]. Oil that enters the voids left by the evaporated water
could play a dual role, as it also helps maintain structural
integrity by preventing shrinkage and collapse. Consequently,
oil uptake may also play a role in water loss [4]. However,
this mechanism offers only a partial explanation for oil
uptake, since several studies have shown that oil absorption
occurs mainly during the cooling phase [14,26]. Hence, the
water replacement mechanism is mainly related to large
voids, cracks and crevices that typically characterize reformed
and battered, as well as many starchy products.
It is worth noting that in non-reformed products, most of
the capillaries that were initially filled with water may not fill
with oil as long as water continues to evaporate. Initially, this
phenomenon can be described as an explosion created
when a higher steam pressure forces its way out from the
product into the oil bath. If the capillary is closed on one
side, oil cannot
penetrate, as the inner steam pressure prevents it. This can be
easily demonstrated by inserting a glass capillary into a hot oil
bath and observing how the evaporating water leaves an
empty capillary. It is only when the capillary is removed
from the fryer that the oil is sucked inside, due to cooling and
water vapor condensation. The fact that oil penetration was
reported to be limited to the immediate crust layer of
non-reformed
products [10,17,27,30] indicates that capillaries are not
playing a major role in the uptake mechanism.
Cooling-phase effect
When frying is completed, the food is removed from the
fryer and the product starts to cool, leading to water vapor
condensation and a subsequent decrease in internal pressure.
Oil adhered to the food surface is sucked in due to the
consequent vacuum effect. Therefore, oil uptake is a surface
phenomenon, involving equilibrium between adhesion and
drainage of oil as
the food is removed from the oil bath [26]. Because the
surface plays such an important role, oil uptake and its
distribution are determined by the crust microstructure
developed during the frying process [17]. It is worth noting
that even at this stage the oil is restricted to the immediate
crust and product surface [10,17,27,30]. Also note that oil
viscosity increases consider- ably with extended frying time.
269
270
D. Dana, I.S. Saguy / Advances in Colloid and Interface Science 128130 (2006) 267272
Table 3
Advancing (ad), receding (re) and apparent (ap) contact angles of canola oil
on Teflon FEP surfaces during frying (n = 3; 25 2 C; [38])
Frying time (h)
ad ()
re ()
0 (fresh)
10
20
30
40
68.7 1.2
68.8 0.6
69.1 0.2
69.8 1.3
70.2 0.3
55.0 0.6
54.9 2.2
57.1 0.9
55.2 1.1
57.3 1.4
ap
()
63.4
0.1
63.8
0.2
63.3
0.1
63.2
0.1
63.3
0.6
Table 2
Effect of frying (180 5 C) time on interfacial tension and apparent contact
angle of canola oil (n = 3; at ambient temperature of 25 2 C; [38])
Frying time
(h)
Surface tension
(mN/m)
Interfacial tension
(mN/m)
ap ()
32.6 0.2
24.4 0.3
63.4 0.1
10
0.2
20
0.1
30
0.1
40
0.6
32.6 0.2
16.5 0.2
63.8
32.5 0.2
15.0 0.2
63.3
32.5 0.1
14.3 0.3
63.2
32.6 0.1
13.0 0.2
63.3
D. Dana, I.S. Saguy / Advances in Colloid and Interface Science 128130 (2006) 267272
Table 4
Surface tension and interfacial tension between water and fresh canola oil with
or without additives (n = 3; 25 2 C; [38])
Additive
None
Silicaid F-1000 (10
ppm) DMPS (2 ppm)
Mono- and diglycerides (10
ppm)
Surface
tension
(mN/m)
32.6 0.2
28.6 0.7
32.5 0.0
32.5 0.0
Interfacial
tension
(mN/m)
24.4 0.3
20.8 0.3
24.2 0.4
23.8 0.4
271
Table 5
The effect of added Silicaid F-1000 on advancing (ad), receding (re) and
apparent (ap) contact angles of canola oil (n = 3; 25 2 C; [38])
Concentration (ppm)
ad ()
re ()
N
o
n
250
68.7 1.2
68.3 1.2
66.1 1.3
55.0 1.7
55.8 2.2
48.9 1.2
ap
()
63.4
0.1
63.2
1.4
272
D. Dana, I.S. Saguy / Advances in Colloid and Interface Science 128130 (2006) 267272
[17] Bouchon P, Hollins P, Pearson M, Pyle DL, Tobin MJ. J Food Sci
2001;66:918.
[18] Pedreschi F, Moyano P. J Food Eng 2005;70:557.
[19] Rayner M, Ciolfi V, Maves B, Stedman P, Mittal GS. J Sci Food Agric
2000;80:777.
[20] Garcia MA, Ferrero C, Campana A, Bertola N, Martino M, Zaritzky N.
Food Sci Technol Int 2004;10:339.
[21] Moreira RG, Xiuzhi S, Youhong C. J Food Eng 1997;31:485.
[22] Bouchon P, Pyle DL. J Food Sci 2004;69:E115.
[23] Pinthus EJ, Weinberg P, Saguy IS. J Food Sci 1995;60:767.
[24] Llorca E, Hernando I, Perez-Munuera I, Fiszman SM, Lluch MA. Eur
Food Res Technol 2001;213:448.
[25] Rimac-Brncic S, Lelas V, Rade D, Simundic B. J Food Eng 2004;64:237.
[26] Ufheil G, Escher F. Food Sci Technol 1996;29:640.
[27] Saguy IS, Gremaud E, Gloria H, Turesky RJ. J Agric Food Chem
1997;45:4286.
[28] Aguilera JM, Gloria H. J Agric Food Chem 1997;45:781.
[29] Rice P, Gamble MH. Int J Food Sci Technol 1989;24:183.
[30] Tangduangdee C, Bhumiratana S, Tia S. Int Commun Heat Mass Transf
2004;31:73.
[31] Tseng YC, Moreira R, Sun X. Int J Food Sci Technol 1996;31:287.
[32] Benedito J, Mulet A, Velasco J, Dobarganes MC. J Agric Food Chem
2002;50:4531.
[33] Fritsch CW. J Am Oil Chem Soc 1981;58:272.
[34] O'Brien RD. Fats and oils: formulating and processing for applications.
Lancaster: Technomonic Publishing Company; 1998 [chapter 3].