Professional Documents
Culture Documents
John Friedmann
Some fifteen years ago, Manuel Castells (1972) and David Harvey
(1973) revolutionized the study of urbanization and initiated a
period of exciting and fruitful scholarship. Their special
achievement was to link city forming processes to the larger
historical movement of industrial capitalism. Henceforth, the city
was no longer to be interpreted as a social ecology, subject to natural
forces inherent in the dynamics of population and space; it came to
be viewed instead as a product of specifically social forces set in
motion by capitalist relations of production. Class conflict became
central to the new view of how cities evolved.
Only during the last four or five years, however, has the study of
cities been directly connected to the world economy. This new
approach sharpened insights into processes of urban change; it also
offered a needed spatial perspective on an economy which seems
increasingly oblivious to national boundaries. My purpose in this
introduction is to state, as succinctly as 1 can, the main theses that
link urbanization processes to global economic forces. The world
city hypothesis, as I shall call these loosely joined statements, is
primarily intended as a framework for research. It is neither a theory
nor a universal generalization about cities, but a starting-point for
political enquiry. We would, in fact, expect to find significant
differences among those cities that have become the basing points
for global capital. We would expect cities to differ among themselves
according to not only the mode of their integration with the global
economy, but also their own historical past, national policies, and
cultural influences. The economic variable, however, is likely to be
decisive for all attempts at explanation.
The world city hypothesis is about the spatial organization of the
new international division of labour. As such, it concerns the
contradictory relations between production in the era of global
management and the political determination of territorial interests. It
helps us to understand what happens in the major global cities of the
world economy and what much political conflict in these cities is
Development urrd Churtae (SAGE, London, Beverly Hills and New Delhi), Vol. 17
(1986). 69-83
70
John Friedmann
71
72
John Friedmann
Table 1. The World City Hierarchy
Primary
Core Countriesb
Secondary
Semi-peripheral Countriesb
Primary
Secondary
London I
Paris* 11
Rotterdam I l l
Frankfurt I11
Zurich I l l
Brussels* I l l
Milan 111
Vienna* Ill
Madrid* I l l
New York I
Chicago I I
Los Angcles 1
Toronto I l l
Miami I l l
Houston 111
San Francisco 111
Sao Paulo 1
Buenos Aires* 1
Rio de Janeiro I
Caracas* i l l
Mexico City* I
Tokyo* 1
Sydney I l l
Singapore* I I I
Hong Kong 11
Taipei * I I I
Manila 11
Bangkok* I1
Seoul* I I
Johannesburg I l l
National Capital.
Population size categories (rccent estimates, referring to metro-rcgion):
1 10-20 million; I I 5-10 million; 111 1-5 million.
73
ASIA
AMERICA
AUSTRALLA
0 Semi-periphery: Seco
-Linkages
betwee
All other linkag
75
76
John Friedmann
77
John Friedmann
18
===+
EXODUS of highwage manufacturing
and routine
information
processing to lowwage areas
INFLUX of foreign
workers andabsorption into lowwage employment
M
P
Management elites
Professional business services*
(prcdoniinantly male)
C
Clerical (predominantly female)
L.SS Low-skilled. blue collar services
(predominantly male and/or foreign/ethnic)
PS Producer services (low-wage)
primarily catering to management tlites and
upper echelons of' professional business
services (employment predominantly female
and/or foreign)
/
CS Consumer services (low-wage)
I
Low-wage occupations in manufacturing industry (predominantly foreign and/or
female)
*Many professional business services engage increasingly in international trade serving
their clients, the transnational corporations, both at home and abroad. They include
accounting, advertising, banking, communications, computer services, health services,
insurance, leasing, legal services, shipping and air transport, and tourism. In 1981, US
service exports equalled 50 per cent of merchandise exports and were still rising (see
Sassen-Koob's article in this issue).
'
79
***
The following essays illustrate several facets of world city analysis.
Sassen-Koob studies the relation between employment restructuring
in New York City, local labour markets and foreign immigration.
Inquiring into the impact of the production of global control
capacity on New York Citys labour force, she first reviews the
dramatic economic restructuring taking place throughout the world
and traces its specific effects on the citys economy. With this
portrayal as a background, she describes the recent changes in New
Yorks job supply and labour markets, giving particular attention to
how these transformations have affected patterns of immigration
from abroad and growing internationalism of the citys labour
force. She concludes that (1) the rise of high-level control functions
typical of current economic restructuring is accompanied by a
massive expansion of low-wage jobs across a wide spectrum of
employment sectors; and (2) the new spatial and socio-economic
arrangements lead to a growing polarization of interests and the
potential for heightened conflict, as middle-income occupations
decline and the upward mobility of immigrant labour is effectively
blocked.
Rimmer finds that Tokyo may indeed be regarded as a link in a
system of world cities, though its internal structure corresponds as
much to influences of history and national policy as it does to
influences that result from its dominant global position. Thus, his
80
John Friedrnann
I wish t o thank Edward Soja and Coetz Wolff for the close reading they have given the
earlier version of this paper and for their many helpful suggestions.
I . See Browning and Roberts (1980), Cohen (1981), Portes and Walton (1981),
Friedinann and Wolff (1982), Walton (1982), Soja, Morales and Wolff (1983). Ross
and Trachte (1983), Thrift (1984), Hill and Feagin (1984), Glickman (1984), arid thc
article by Sassen-Koob in this issue.
2. The sectoral theory of economic growth, such as that of Colin Clark which
culminates in the growth of the secondary sector of manufacturing, must therefore
be at lcast partially revised. So far as metropolitan economies are concerned.
manufacturing has bccome less important than in the past, and the so-callcd
81
quaternary sector of advanced business services now accounts for most of the
observed differential growth in income and employment (Gershuny, 1983).
3. This is not to claim that international labour migrations d o not occur elsewhere
as well. Most significant are labour flows to the oil-rich countries of the Arabian
peninsula and the migrations from the countries of the Sahel to the coastal states of
West Africa.
Capital cities of the peasant periphery frequently display social, economic, and
physical characteristics that are structurally similar to those of world cities in the semiperiphery. What they often d o not have in common is the latters economic power.
REFERENCES
Apter, David & Nagayo Sawa (1984) Against the State: Polilics and Social Protest in
Japan. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Browning, Harley L., & Bryan R. Roberts (1980) Urbanisation, Sectoral
Transformation and the Utilisation of Labour in Latin America, Comparative
Urban Research, 8 (l), 86-104.
Castells, Manuel (1972) La question urbuine. Paris: Maspero.
-- (1983) The City and the Grassroots. London: Edward Arnold.
Cohen, R.B. (1981) The New International Division of Labor, Multinational
Corporations and Urban Hierarchy, Chapter 12 in Michael Dear & Allen J. Scott
(eds), Urbanization and Urban Planning in Capitalist Society. London and New
York: Methuen.
Development and Dialogue (1981) Special issue on Towards a New Information and
Communication Order.
Ecodevelopment News (1984) Special issue on The Informal Economy and Beyond,
31 (December), 25-37.
Friedmann, John & Goetz Wolff (1982) World City Formation: An Agenda for
Research and Action, lnternational Journal for Urban and Regional Research,
6 (3), 309-44.
Gershuny, Jonathan (1983) Social Innovation and the Division of Labour. New York:
Oxford University Press.
Glickman, Norman J. (1984) Cities and the International Division of Labor. Paper
presented at the Second World Congress of the Regional Science Association,
Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 10 June 1984.
Hall, Peter & Dennis Hay (eds) (1980) Growth Centers in The European Urban
System. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Harvey, David (1973) SocialJustice and the Ciry. London: Edward Arnold.
Hill, Richard Child & Joe R. Feagin (1984) Detroit and Houston: Two Cities in
Global Perspective. Paper presented at the 79th Meeting of the American
Sociological Association, San Antonio, Texas, 29 August.
Iglesias, Enrique V. (1984) Balance Preliminar de la economia latinamericana
durante 1983, Revista de la CEPAL (April): 7-38.
Jacobson, Robert (1984) Global Information Technology Networks and the WorldCity World. Unpublished paper.
Jao, Y.C. (1979) The Rise of Hong Kong as a Financial Center, Asian Survey, 19,
674-94.
Kannappan, S. (1983) Employment Problems and rhe Urban Labor Marker in
82
John Friedmann
83