Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I.
Page 1 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
and highlighted within the countries so that the laws in these respective countries would mirror
the over-arching goals of Advisory board and in particular the European Union.
The advisory council propagates the view that for reaching its goals the European Union needs to
revisit some of its policies and that there is a need for close co-operation between the European
Union, United Nations and specialized committees. In order to reach this goal it pursues ensuring
this continued and close co-ordination so that the goals can be achieved in the shortest period of
time.
II.
There have been large movements of population within the European Union in the past because
of a number of reasons in different eras and time periods. These eras include the period followed
by the late middle ages and post-classical era, for the reasons ranging from Reformation to the
European wars of religion. Similarly, this also happened immediately after the Second Great
War.
Today this is not an issue largely because of the reason that under the Schengen agreement the
natives and citizens of any one of these countries can freely move to any other country that is
part of the European Union.
Countries in European Union themselves had the highest ratio of flight of population and
immigration out of them in 1960s and 70s. This immigration was in most cases to United States
of America, Australias and to other European countries that are part of the European Union
today.
The relative economic prosperity of the European countries a few years after the second Great
War and the eventual revival of the economy of the countries in the European Union have
brought about a transformation in the immigration trends. Today there is clear reversal of these
trends and within two decades these countries have become the destination for the immigrant
workers around the globe because of the higher wages and pay rates offered to them. Both
Page 2 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
skilled and non-skilled labor earns more on average than in their native countries and hence these
countries in the European Union have become a magnet for workers and individuals looking for
immigration. Over the past few decades (since Schengen agreement was signed in 1985) the
demand and advantage of citizenship in an EU country increased phenomenally because the
same laws of EU are applicable to all the countries.
III.
The problems regarding immigration to European Union range from the dangerous and often
illegal ways the potential migrants use for reaching their destinations to the violence, abuse and
exploitation the workers may face when they reach these countries. People have moved from one
region to another and this phenomena existed even before the demarcation of boundaries
between the countries themselves. Therefore, it can be safely said that the vulnerability of
foreign workers in European Union is by no means a new concept. In many instances it is the
genuinely free and informed choice of the migrant workers that leads them to look for
opportunities outside their native countries. On the hand, the over-riding majority of immigrants
who look for relocation to European Union consist of those people who want to move because of
being stuck in a cycle of poverty, having indecent work, being socially excluded, and being
caught in an armed conflict1. Other such reasons can include xenophobia, human rights violation
and even environmental degradation. Any one of these aforementioned reasons can make the
migrants resort to many illegal ways which include- but are not limited to - seeking help from
smugglers and subsequently-in their quest of moving out of their home country- falling prey to
human traffickers. Similarly, even at the places the migrants live or work they can be a target of
racism and be exploited in their public, private and social life instead of being welcomed and
amalgamated into society they have become a part of. The problems of workers are not limited to
this as the illegal migrant can get stranded in transit because of being caught on their way to their
destination which leads not only to their inability to move forward but also being subjected to
long detentions which can stretch from a few months to a year.
There are a series of other problems that have risen from the immigration as the inhabitants of
the host countries felt that they were being overlooked and a large share of the work and their
1
http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Issues/Migration/MigrationHR_improvingHR_Report.pdf
Page 3 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
employment opportunities were being reduced because of the increased competition they faced
from the migrant workers for the jobs.
An issue felt keenly in many countries in European Union is that some of the governments feel
that they are already overcrowded. Therefore, an influx of migrant could possibly lead to a
rapid fall in the living standard of the natives. For instance -as the case study that will follow
shows in detail- a rapid increase in the population due to migration could also lead to acute
housing shortages, congestion and urban pollution. Therefore, while analyzing the increase in
GDP we have to see the effect on quality of life.
Another issue that rises from migration and is of primary concern for countries is whether and
to what extent- the migrant worker drive down the wage rates. One perspective is that there will
definitely a decrease in the wages because of an increase in supply of labor. This follows the
basic law of demand and supply. In addition to that, there are instances of supernormal drop in
wage rates in the European Union because the foreign workers are in a urgent need of getting a
job and may be willing to bypass the traditional union bargaining. For instance if the wages are
low in a particular market like agriculture, the falling wages in these markets would be a high
possibility as the work force from a low income country will certainly drive down the wages 2.
In addition to the problems in the host countries there are various issues that the migrants face in
their quest to be amalgamated into the society. The residents of a country in EU are the passport
holders or citizens of another country who have a legal right to live there. Unfortunately, the
residents/migrants are usually ignorant of the laws of the country and the way to apply for
citizenship. This problem usually arises from expensive legal advice and because the dealings
with the government officials are usually in a foreign language.
The migrants can be largely classified into four broad categories and the laws to deal with them
also differ. The largest category of those seeking migration is for work or employment purposes.
The economic migrant can be defined as someone who has travelled from one country to another
for purposes of seeking employment or for an improvement in his/her financial position.
Therefore, an economic migrant differs from a refugee in all respects. The other categories
include families and student seeking migration. The last two categories can be defined as asylum
2
http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/6399/economics/impact-of-immigration-on-uk-economy/
Page 4 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
seekers and Illegal migrants. Illegal migrants enter clandestinely usually helped by a contact or
relative who helps them in doing so- while others overstay their visas. Yet some others dont go
home even after their asylum applications have been refused by the government authorities.
The illegal workers themselves face many problems if they try to enter EU illegally. The deaths
at sea are an instance of how workers desperately trying to get into Europe fail to do so because
of capsizing boats. These deaths are usually unaccounted for and the statistics are far more than
those reported. A case in point is of 1500 people who died in their desperate attempt to reach the
shores, according to the human rights watch. This shows that there is an urgent need for EU to
respond to problems pertaining boat migration as instances of deaths at in the Mediterranean
because of hunger are particularly disturbing and alarming. These deaths only stand to
underscore the need for increased vigilance.
Page 5 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
Many independent agencies have therefore advised the European Union governments to give a
official amnesty to the illegal migrants. The governments, however are opposed to an official
amnesty that amnesties- when given in the past by some countries that are part of EU todayencouraged illegal immigration.
Another way to curb illegal immigration and its problems can be to maintain a border security
force in EU which is capable of maintaining the security on an increased scale. Unmanned aerial
vehicles, cameras and sensors can help curb the illegal immigration too.
Instead of using raw force in order to stop the migrants another more effective way can be to
promote economic development and good governance in South Asia and Somalia. This will
reduce the disparity in the standard of living in the two countries. The EU can also give
temporary-worker program so that there can be rotating workforce that can stay legally in
European countries for a limited time period. This can help reduce the illegal economic
Immigration.
V.
The first question is whether the migrants are skilled workers or not. Currently Great
Britain is strictly allowing only the skilled and qualified workforce.
The ease with which the workers are able to become a part of the society is also of
immense importance. For instance, during the second half of the twentieth century
migrants belonged mainly to the sub-continent and because of their poor English were
subjected to racial discrimination and were unable to get any good jobs.
The effect of the influx of migrants and its impact is also dependent on the age group of
the workers. A high percentage of middle-aged workers would mean that the migrant
population would use less government budget as this would also help in the reduction of
dependability ratio.
The type of skills of the labor force is also important as the skilled labor has a higher
chance of returning to their home countries. Whereas, the unskilled workers are more
Page 6 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
likely to stay in the country they have migrated to because of being structurally
unemployed in instances of recession.
The immigrants send remittances to their kin and facilities abroad which substantially
reduces the wealth of Great Britain leading to the flight of capital. In other instances the
migrants can use the facilities of the host countries such as education etc. and becoming a
source of foreign income.
The most pertinent question is whether the Great Britain in the past has been able to
absorb the large intake of migrants and to what extent it has affected the public services,
housing and the levels of congestion in the largest cities across EU.
(http://www.migrationwatchuk.com/Briefingpaper/document/48
Page 7 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
The foreign migrants came mainly from Somalia, Pakistan and India. And the migrants settled
mainly in large cities to seek employment. Therefore, London has the largest immigrant
population in Britain and has completely altered the demographics of the metropolis. The largest
effect of migration was on the difference between the governments expectations of the extent to
which the population would multiply and the reality. This resulted in the shortage and
misallocation of services as more than fifty percent of the net increase in the population of UK
was directly contributed by the increase in net migration4.
The Net migration graph shows the effect migration will have from the year 2012 to 2037. Over
the many years Great Britain has experienced many problems because of the influx of migrant
population. These problems include- but are not limited to the local inhabitants feeling insecure
in their country and starting physical and verbal racist attacks on the foreign migrants. The large
number of immigrants meant that there was an increase in the total workforce that led to a
decrease in the wage rates as the supply increased relative to the demand. Many economists
opine that the immigration led to an increase in the employment rates. Migrants have therefore
been blamed by the native populace for taking our jobs- especially in the periods of high
unemployment.
The following chart illustrates the projected increase in population and differentiates the increase
in population because of Net migration from the natural change in population (assuming that
there is no net-migration)
http://www.migrationwatchuk.com/Briefingpaper/document/48
Page 8 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
Page 9 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
5. To what extent should the laws and regulations for the migrant workers, illegal migrants, and
asylum seekers differ?
6. Is it the responsibility of countries that are a part of EU to monitor the Mediterranean to stop
the deaths at sea of workers wishing to enter Europe?
Page 10 of 11
MUN 2015
Advisory Panel to the European Union
Immigration to the European Union
Bibliography.
1. file:///C:/Users/rht11/Downloads/Economic%20and%20Social%20Committee%20The%20Financial%20Implications%20of%20Humanitarian%20Aid%20 (Sample)
%20(1).pdf
2. http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Issues/Migration/MigrationHR_improvingHR_Report.pdf
3. http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/6399/economics/impact-of-immigration-on-uk-economy/
4. http://www.migrationwatchuk.org/briefing-paper/11.28
5. http://www.migrationwatchuk.org/briefing-paper/11.17
6. http://www.hrw.org/news/2011/06/24/eu-summit-misses-opportunity-migration
7. http://solutions.heritage.org/immigration
Page 11 of 11