Professional Documents
Culture Documents
REFERENCE: Robertson, A. F. and Gross, Daniel, "Fire Load, Fire Severity, and Fire Endurance," Fire Test Performance, ASTM STP 464, American Society for Testing and Materials, 1970, p p . 3-29.
ABSTRACT: A review is presented of fire studies beginning with the work
of Ingberg at the National Bureau of Standards, who attempted to relate
the severity of a fire endurance test in the laboratory to the conditions existing during actual building fires. He showed the importance of weight of
combustibles per unit floor area as a major factor. H e recognized the importance of ventilation in controlling fire behavior but did not specify it as
a separate variable. Fujita in Japan is credited with emphasizing the importance of ventilation. His work has been followed and enlarged by others
around the world. Ventilation parameters, compartment geometry, and fuel
arrangement have been shown to exert a powerful influence. The radiance
from a burning building is dependent to a large extent on the nature of the
ventilating openings. Fire severity is not well defined, since it depends on
the interaction of the temperature-time curve developed during a fire and
the thermophysical properties of the materials exposed. There is a great
need for further research on the influence of fuel arrangement, building
geometry, and ventilation on fires in buildings.
KEY WORDS: fires in buildings, burn-out, fire severity, fire endurance, fire
ventilation, experimental fires, evaluation, tests
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
UniversidadCopyright^
Catolica De La
Santisima
Concepcion
- UCSC (Universidad
Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
1970
by ASTM
International
www.astm.org
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
-<:
FIG. 1The interior of small test building representing office occupancy with metal
furniture on concrete floor. The exposed papers were intended to represent the probable maximum of exposed material in an occupancy of this type.
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
FIG. 2The interior of the small test building after a fire test with office occupancy, metal furniture on concrete floor. This was an exposure fire test, the rack in
the right background of the picture being filled with kindling wood surrounded with
a shield which was drawn back after it was burning briskly, thus simulating the
condition of an exposure fire.
control did
quantitative
to a given
the furnace
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
cooling process after termination of the fire test comprised a part of the
thermal exposure. While recognizing the technical questions posed [8]
it was assumed that by matching areas below the average burn-out
temperature curve with that below a combined heating and cooling
curve in a furnace, the severity of furnace specimen exposure would
correspond to fire.^ Figure 3 presents the derived relationship between
fire endurance and fire load together with the results of burn-out tests
on which it was based.
50
1
100
1
250
1
/
6
X
X
"
X/*
30
40
1
50
FIRE LOAD, I b / f t ^
During the period from 1928 to 1940, surveys were made of the fire
load (that is, combustible contents) of residences, offices, schools, medical
buildings, and a few mercantile buildings [9]. In 1947, an enlarged
survey was made of the combustible contents of mercantile and manu3 The areas measured in this matching process were either above 150 C, representing temperatures at which records or thin partitions would be damaged, or above 300
C, corresponding to the lowest temperature at which thicker partitions or walls may
be assumed to be influenced by the thermal exposure conditions.
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
C}
60
a
p.
1o
<N
sm
.s
13
o
a.
ca
K
a>
's
5
o
"c
0
11
C/3
ID
l-l
4-*
IP
ft
,^
V
bo
to
ca
Ui
a
o ft
O o
CA
1!
O)
*
en
:
135
05 CO
KM
'
'
00
iH
4-
a
'
(-.
^w
ID
ft
' 3 tS
>3 .
Pi
i> * t T-IOCD
1:~
CO
in
oc
O
ID
3w
3
Hi
i-H
CO
oo
CO
t^
^
o
tj
c
o
60
UH
a?
E
S
<>
=3 S
03
00
ira
S jjSS
CD
^<
CO
f(
00
N
00
tCO
*
I1
CO
tin
i-H
P H
in
oo
CO
cq
t~
0-*
in-*'
CMt-
CO
M
CO
in
m
05
o
in
o
111
CD g
OJ5
coin
05in
ooin
l-HCO
iniI
p-H
II
1
S
^,TJ
U V
IIII
CO
t-H
I(
CO
'QT
(H
>,
s
2
<3J
t-(
rt
ft
&
g
s
^
(D
O
'B,
3
*crt
o
c
u
c/:
c'l"
g o
C3
0)
bOiJ
c c
OP4
bo
C
c
S
3
O
IS
13
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
facturing buildings [10]. These surveys involved the weighing of all the
movable combustible contents of the buildings studied. In cases where
furnishings were fixed in place estimates of the weight were made on
the basis of dimensions. Additionally, weights were estimated for combustible flooring and exposed woodwork other than flooring. These
items were reported separately as well as combined with movable fire
load to show the total fire load present. The results of these surveys are
summarized in Table 1 and have been used [9] as a basis of defining the
fire endurance performance requirements for fire resistive buildings
in building codes.
Ingberg had shown through his burn-out studies [7, 8, 9] that when
combustibles were stored in metal furniture and filing cabinets, only a
fraction of the material so stored would become involved in fires that
might occur. Apparently at that time the use of wooden furniture and
cabinets was so common that when Ref 9 was prepared no consideration
was taken of the lower fire loads and the lower fire performance requirement for the structure that would have been possible by the use of
metal furniture.
This work in measuring combustible loads in buildings served to close
the gap between fire endurance tests in the laboratory and the experimentally measured fire severity as a function of fuel load during actual
building fires. The surveys were performed from 20 to 40 years ago,
and there is today some question as to the relevance of the findings at
that time when compared with present trends in occupancy of buildings.
As a result there are plans in several countries to update these studies.
The meager evidence available to date does not suggest a need to revise
the original findings.
Postwar Japanese Studies
The work of Ingberg apparently represented the most progressive
thinking on this subject until sometime after World War II. At this
time, the Japanese, because of their serious losses to fire during the war
and the obvious need for better understanding of the problem, assumed
leadership in the theoretical and experimental study of fire problems.
Fujita* started work on spread of fire between buildings by radiation
and convection in 1940 and by 1948 had published ten papers on this
subject. During this period his attention was directed to fire development within enclosures. His first study on this subject involved the
analysis of the thermophysical problem of gas flow through the windows
of a compartment involved by fire. He then proceeded to study the heat
balance between a fire, the enclosing walls, and the surroundings. In
* Fujita, K., Building Research Station, Japan, private communication.
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
10
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
11
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
12
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
13
1600 u.
30
40
TIME min
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
14
FI RE TEST PERFORMANCE
1200
1-5
."lOOO
13 800
<
a:
111
OL
UJ 6 0 0
400
2
- 200
<
O
7.5
15
30
45
Q ^4 ventilation
O ^i ventilation
FIG. 5Maximum average temperatures inside fire compartment as a function of
fire load per unit floor area and two window ventilation conditions (from Ref 20).
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
O Fibre insulating
15
board
Kerosine
5
1
, 5
RATE OF BURNING/VENTILATION AREA kg nnin"'m"'
+
O
A
15
''j-ventilation
V4-v(2ntiiaiior(
''a-vantilation
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
16
100
200
300
400
500
2400
10
20
30
40
50
60
FIRE LOAD/VENTILATION(L/A\/H),lb/ft^'^
FIG. 1Maximum average gas temperature rise for compartment fires as a function
of fuel load per unit ventilation parameter Ay/iT; points marked F, G, and K refer
to fiberboard, gasoline, and kerosine fuels, respectively. Symbols used correspond to
different floor fuel loadings *-7.5 kg/m^ (1.55 psf), X-13 kg/m^ (3 psf), 0-30
/tg/m (6 psf), A-60 kg/m^ (12 psf). (Experimental data from Refs 20 and 21).
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
17
10
1
2000
60
^
A
<&
1000
1600
<
X
X
<
a:
800
400
<
_-
S
a.
LLI
1-
- 6 0 0 UJ
o
<t
a:
Ld
LlJ
800
o
o
UJ
(S
"Kt
UJ
Q.
Lu 1200
o
uJ
a:
400
>
X
200
1
1
10
FIRE LOAD/FLOOR AREA.ib/ft"^
1
1
8
<
1
12
Margaret Law has analyzed the data on radiation from the windows
during these 24 experimental fires [23], She has shown good correlation
between thermal radiation theory and the data for window irradiance and
compartment temperatures. The line shown in Fig. 9, reproduced from
her paper, is the theoretical relationship for window irradiance on the
assumption that the effective emissivity of the cavity is unity. The correlation is surprisingly good. In plotting other total irradiance data, she
also used fuel burning rate per unit window area as an independent
variable. However, it seems preferable from a practical point of view
to plot the data as shown in Fig. 10. It is evident that total irradiance
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
18
6-0
o/
4-0
80
oP
E
n/
S 2-0
D
Slope a 4
Q.
O
f= 1-0
<
/c
5 0-8
D/
^0-6
z
0-4
UJ
o/
X 0-2
<
o /
7o
1
/ 1
1
0-1
400
6 0 0 8 0 0 1000
2000
MAXIMUM TEMPERATURE (Tp) dcgK
FIG. 9Maximum intensity of window radiation as a function of maximum compartment gas temperature (from Ref 23J.
of these fires with wood-crib fuel arrays correlates in nearly linear fashion
with the fire load ventilation parameter up to the point that the fire
becomes ventilation limited, after which radiation levels start to decrease.
The data for fiberboard emphasize the importance of the way in which
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
19
FIRE L 0 A 0 / V E N T I L A T I 0 N ( L / A y H ) , k g / m ^ ^ 2
200
400
600
800
1000
20
40
60
80
100
120
FIRE LOAD/VENTILATION ( L / A / H ) , I b / f t ^ ' Z
1200
140
FIG. IQMaximum total intensity of radiation as a function of fuel load per unit
ventilation parameter AVET, see caption of Fig. 7 for symbol legend. (Experimental
data from Ref 23).
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
20
500
FIRE LOAD/VENTILATION ( L / A N / H ) , I b / f t ^ ^ ^
FIG. 11Average consumption rate of wooden cribs during compartment fires as
a function of fire load per unit ventilation parameter L/AVn; see caption of Fig. 7
for symbol legend. (Experimental data from Ref 23j.
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
21
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
22
the single room in which they were placed of about 14.6 kg/m^ (3 psf)
of floor area.
A large variety of measurements were made during these tests. The
only ones relevant to the subject of this paper appear to be those for
exterior radiation and equivalent black-body temperatures within the
building. It was proposed that measured irradiance levels could be best
expressed as a hypothetical irradiance. This property was defined by
the ratio of measured irradiance to the geometric configuration factor
appropriate in describing the sum of the solid angles subtended by the
ventilation openings viewed from the radiometer. Configuration factor
is defined as the ratio of the solid angle subtended by an object, as
viewed from a receiver, to that occupied by a hemisphere.
The main findings from this work may be summarized as follows:
1. When fiberboard linings were involved the radiation levels from
the building were about twice those measured during fires in plaster finished buildings. The hypothetical window irradiance values observed
were as high as 40 cal/cm^ s in the case of fires involving fiberboard
lined buildings. This is a level about eleven times the irradiance that
would be expected, on the basis of the radiation pyrometer temperature
measurements, from an area confined to the windows alone.
2. Maximum radiation measurements were influenced significantly by
winds, but not by the type of exterior wall cladding used.
3. The radiation pyrometer measurements made during these experiments showed equivalent black-body temperatures within the burning
buildings to be significantly higher than would be expected on the basis
of the standard temperature-time curve used in laboratory tests.
The immediate conclusion drawn from the experiments was that the
fiberboard lined homes presented fire severities of a much more serious
character than developed in the plaster finished homes. Certainly this
was the case for the fire experiments conducted, but the lack of normal
combustible occupancy in the homes may have tended to exaggerate
the difference. Thus while in both cases the crib presented a fire load
of about 15 kg/m^ (3 psf) of floor area for the single room in which it
was placed, the other rooms had no occupancy fire loads. For one of the
buildings studied, the weight of fiberboard used as interior finish was
estimated at somewhat over a ton. If this were to be considered as an
occupancy load, it would amount to a fire load of about 13.6 kg/m^
(2.8 psf) for the building as a whole. Neglecting floor and exposed
trim, this would have the effect of nearly quadrupUng the readily exposed
fire load. It is not surprising that this significant difference in readily
available fuel should impose quite different fire severity conditions on
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
23
the buildings. From both the academic and practical point of view, it
would be desirable to perform further experiments in which a normal
occupancy load was used to clarify the situation.
These experiments remain today one of the few reliable published
records of radiation measurements on fires involving complete buildings.
The higher hypothetical irradiance values reported of up to 40 cal/cm^ s
(167.3 W/cm^) were undoubtedly influenced by winds, through ventilation, and probably also by flames projecting from windows not directly
visible from the radiometers. These levels are about eight times the
maximum values reported by the British [23] and similar values measured
by NBS [29]. The fact that the fires involved more than a single floor
of the building surely contributed to the size of, and thus radiation from,
the flames.
Discussion
This review of the literature relating to fire loads and fire severity has
presented much of the published information available on this subject.
The excellent works of the IIT Research Institute and others have not
been included primarily because of lack of open-literature publications
on the findings. There has been little discussion of the basis on which
severity may be measured or assessed. It seems important to consider
this subject here.
Severity of a building fire may be defined as a measure of its potential
for damage to contents or structure. However, assessment of severity in
any given situation must be of a subjective nature until more adequate
definition is provided of the way in which the fire damage is caused.
Thus fires may result in damage through any or a combination of the
following mechanisms:
1. Growth and spread of fire to involve combustibles other than those
originally ignited in the compartment of origin.
2. Overheating of fire-protective covering of structural elements with
resulting mechanical failure of the protection and exposure of the structural element to direct heating by the fire.
3. Melting or otherwise destroying the fire-exposed surface of a diaphragm type fire barrier in such a way that fire ventilation is modified,
fire activity'is increased, and flames and hot gases project from the opening.
4. Overheating of a structural element resulting in loss of strength and
mechanical failure.
5. Excessive heat transfer through a fire barrier causing ignition of
material and thus spread of fire on the unexposed side.
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
24
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
25
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
26
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
27
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
28
References
[i] Ingberg, S. H. et al, "Fire Tests of Building Columns," Technologic Papers,
National Bureau of Standards, No. 184, April 1921.
[2] "Intensity and Duration of Fires," Technical News Bulletin, National Bureau
of Standards, No. 68, Dee. 1922.
[3] "Intensity and Duration of Fires in Buildings," Technical News Bulletin, National Bureau of Standards, No. 114, Oct. 1926, pp. 10-11.
[4] "Intensity and Duration of Building Fires," Technical News Bulletin, National
Bureau of Standards, No. 116, Dec. 1926, pp. 5-8.
[5] "Bureau of Standards Fire Test Activities," Quarterly, National Fire Protection
Association, Vol. 19, No. 3, Jan. 1926, pp. 234-237.
[6] "Report of Committee on Protection of Records," Proceedings, National Fire
Protection Association, May 1927, pp. 295-297.
[7] "Fire Tests of OfHce Occupancies at U.S. Bureau of Standards," Quarterly,
National Fire Protection Association, Vol. 20, No. 3, Jan. 1927, pp. 243-252.
18] Ingberg, S. H., "Tests of the Severity of Building Fires," Quarterly, National
Fire Protection Association, Vol. 22, No. 1, July 1928, pp. 43-61.
[9] "Fire Resistance Classifications of Building Constructions," Building Materials
and Structures Report 92, Superintendent of Documents, Washington, D.C.,
Oct. 1942.
[10] Ingberg, S. H., Dunham, J. W., and Thompson, J. P., "Combustible Contents
in Buildings," Building Materials and Structures Report 149, National Bureau
of Standards, Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office,
1957.
[11] Kawagoe, K., "Fire Behavior in Rooms," Report No. 27, Building Research
Institute, Japan, Sept. 1958.
[12] Kawagoe, K. and Sekine T., "Estimation of Fire Temperature-Time Curve in
Rooms," Occasional Report No. 11, Building Research Institute, Japan, June
1963.
[13] Kawagoe, K. and Sekine, T., "Estimation of Fire Temperature-Time Curve in
Rooms, Second Report," Occasional Report No. 17, Building Research Institute,
Japan, March 1964.
[14] Kawagoe, K., "Estimation of Fire Temperature-Time Curve in Rooms, third
report," Research Paper No. 29, Building Research Institute, Japan, 29 Oct.
1967.
[15] Thomas, P. H., "Research on Fire Using Models," Institute of Fire Engineers
Quarterly, 1961.
[16] Gross, D. and Robertson, A. F., "Experimental Fires in Enclosures," Tenth
Symposium (International) on Combustion, Combustion Institute, Pittsburgh,
1965, pp. 931-42.
[17] Thomas, P. H. and Heselden, A. J. M., "Fully-Developed Compartment Fires
Two Kinds of Behavior," Fire Research Technical Paper No. 18, Her Majesty's
Stationery Office, 1967.
[18] Odeen, K., "Theoretical Study of Fire Characteristics in Enclosed Spaces,"
Bulletin No. 10, Division of Building Construction, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, 1963.
[19] Odeen, K., "Experimentellt och Theoretiskt Studium an Brandforlapp i Byggnader" (Experimental and Theoretical study of Fire Characteristics in Enclosed
Spaces), Report 23/68, National Swedish Institute for Building Research, 1968.
[20] Butcher, E. G., Chitty, T. B., and Ashton, L. A., "The Temperature Attained
by Steel in Building Fires," Fire Research Technical Paper No. 15, Her Majesty's Stationery Office, 1966.
[21] Butcher, E. G., Bedford, G. K., and Fardell, P. J., "Further Experiments and
Temperatures Reached by Steel in Building Fires," Behavior of Structural
Steel in Fire Symposium No. 2, Proceedings of a symposium held at the Fire
Research Station, Boieham Wood, Herts, on 24 Jan. 1967, Her Majesty's
Stationery Office, 1968, pp. 2-17.
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct
29
Copyright by ASTM Int'l (all rights reserved); Mon Nov 23 23:44:50 EST 2015
Downloaded/printed by
Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC (Universidad Catolica De La Santisima Concepcion - UCSC) pursuant to License Agreement. No further reproduct