Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chiinu
p.4
Citys in transition_Chiinu
KTH_ Royal Institute of Technology
K 4/5 School of architecture
Stockholm 2011
p.6
CONTENTS
THE PROJECT BACKGROUND AND THE PARTICIPANTS 5
INTRODUCTION 6
Study assigment
PHD REPORT 9
Abstract 10
Biography 11
Urban Transformabilities 12
The Context and History of Chisinau The State in Transition
15
Legality of illegality 24
The hybrid frameworks 31
The planning process and shifting power balance
34
Bibliography 42
Student proposals
Juha Kivist 72
Cecilia Rudstrm 76
Justina Bieksaite 80
Luca Gramaglia 86
Cyprien Lger 88
Yun Zhang 92
Patricia Alejos Monsn 96
Daniel Edenius 100
Denis Trax 102
THE PROJECT
BACKGROUND AND
THE PARTICIPANTS
This project is the result of collaboration of
people and institutions.
The Urban studio instructors and the projet
organisers:
Bojan Boric and Bjrn Ahrenby.
Special thanks goes to:
Professor Ivan Kucina, University of Belgrade.
He held a workshop and a lecture in Chisinau.
Vladimir Us, who was our host and organised
all the tours, meetings, supplied us with
important data about Chisinau, etc.
Joackim Granit and Thomas Lund,
Frgfabriken who initiated the New Urban
Topologies project.
Swedish Institute, sponsored the project and
this publication.
Rebecca Rubin, who designed and organised
the publication.
INTRODUCTION
COURSE CONTENT
AIM
p.10
INTRODUCTION
p.11
p.12
_URBAN TRANSFORMABILITIES
Chisinau, Moldova
Self-Regulation as an Alternative
to Institutionalized Planning Processes
ABSTRACT
The global upsurge of unplanned
urban development and its various
manifestations have opened the door to
challenging the norms of the modernist
planning model. The principles of
modernist planning mechanisms and
practices, regulatory systems expressed
through zoning regulations, land use
and urban coding can be seen today as
obsolete. The new and perhaps radical
departure from the established methods
and norms, the new alternatives to
conventional planning practices need
to be developed that are based on
learning from experiences from selfregulated and unplanned urban areas.
The unplanned developments need
be seen not as an illness but a part of
the solution to the present and future
urban problems and the role of the
professionals involved, their methods
of work, level and form of involvement
needs to be reexamined.
BIOGRAPHY
Bojan Boric (born
in
Belgrade
in
1968),
moved
to
The United States
in 1986. Received a
Bachelor Degree in
Architecture at Irwin
S. Chanin School of Architecture,
Cooper Union, New York in 1993,
and in 1999 a Masters Degree in
Architecture and Urban Design at the
GSAP Columbia University, New York.
Since 1993, he has been a practicing
architect (RA in New York State and
Virginia) working on a wide range of
projects from interiors to housing,
public buildings and urban design
projects throughout the New York
City metropolitan area, Scandinavia
p.14
URBAN TRANSFORMABILITIES
p.18
p.22
GARAGE/HOUSE
Photo 11.
Housing extensions
and faade renovations
p.26
p.28
LEGALITY OF ILLEGALITY
alternative form of housing options.
The urban complexity produced by
spontaneous urbanizations, is evident in
many areas left to develop on their own in
Chisinau. However, this proposition is not
without controversy since there are often
disputes and conflicts arising between
different users where there is not enough
of the common basis upon which the
ground rules can be established.
The public administration of the Chisinau
Municipality Public Adminisntration is
based on a group of legal acts such as the
Law of special Status of Municipality and
the Law of Local public Admininstration.
The Chisinau Municipality consists of
a group of territorial-administrative
units: The city of Chisinau (divided in
five districts), six urban mayoralities,
and 26 rural localities represented by 11
mayoralties. All territorial-administrative
organisations except the Chisinau city
enjoy local autonomy in regards to the
finances, public services, etc. This larger
Deputy Minister 1
Analytic Department
Monitoring and
Evaluation
of Policies
Audit Department
Deputy Minister 2
Deputy Minister 3
General Direction:
Architecture, Construction
and Housing
General Direction:
Regional Development
Direction: Architecture
Projects, Urbanism and
Spatial Design
Direction: Policy
and Regional Cooperation
Direction: Construction,
Building Materials
and Modern Technologies
Direction: Relationships
with Regional
Development Institutions
Direction: Housing
Department of Regional
Statistics
Direction: Relations
and Attracting
International
Investment
Legal
Department
Financial
Department
Management
Department
Human
Resourse
Department
Department
Secretary
Photo 14.
The decision making hierarchy.
p.30
approach in planning.
The present ambiguities in the legal
framework and selective tolerance
towards
some
forms
of
illegal
construction allow authorities to
establish a permanent state of tension
and control by maintaining the sense
of instability among the population
since the ilegaly obtained privilege
can be taken away at any moment. One
could relate this idea as the metaphor
for disciplining and controlling of the
urban space through Foucalts critique
of institutionalization of society through
spatial organization but also of more
psychologically rather then physical
methods of restraint. (Foucalt 1977)
some cases of illegal construction of
objects (without proper permission,
infringement of building norms and
rules, inefficient use of the land...) have
been observed. The legal framework
concerning the legalisation of the
p.34
p.40
Oberliht Association
PHD Repport URBAN TRANSFORMABILITIES
by Bojan Boric
BIBLIOGRAPHY
p.44
p.46
p.48
p.49
'(")*(+,*+(-.
$%3L%%%0F+4%/1J%M1'+3G%4F3"*G%H1%+/6
&* #) !&&*##
%+ " &## %"6
"%%%- " 6
-3
L'$40'"#0"'1S
1$41% 1#3/3(+#% 4M$#1% +/% EF+4+/$"%
!%"#! "% "" "#1% %"
1G%(3H+*+0I%+/%0F1%("/+#+M$*+0I%3L%
p.50
p.51
Comunications to
Chisinau
COMUNICATIONS TO
CHISINAU
The most important suburbs are
connected by interurban buses
nowadays; they are thinking about
integrate some train stations in a future
subway network to include suburbs in
the main network transport.
This plan try to merge underground
and aboveground rails (some of them
are now working as train stations).
FUTURE PLANS
present situation
PUBLIC TRANSPORT
Future plans
Street and road system , Existing
p.53
Traffic intensity
p.54
p.55
p.56
p.57
p.58
knowledge of how to
grow food.
In a sustainable
way, chisinau will
grown a part of
its own food and
developt jobs.
In this perspective,
places to sell the
production could be
developped, to become
civic center.
ECONOMIC
VALUES
WHY URBAN
AGRICULTURE
COULDGreenary
BE A GOOD
WAY TO DEVELOP
CHISINAU ?
WHY URBAN
AGRICULTURE
COULD BE A GOOD
WAY TO DEVELOP
CHISINAU ?
Chisinau is known as
a green city with lined
trees and lots of wide
green spaces.
The problem is that some
of those green spaces
create a gap in the city,
cutting it into pieces.
SOCIAL
VALUES
p.59
MOLDAVIA
ECONOMY
WAS BASED ON
AGRICULTURE
Moldavia stays the poorest
country in Europe despite all
the improvements that have
been observed. Business is
mainly slowed because of
issues to access financing,
corruption and government
bureaucracy.
Moldavia has experienced
economic difficulties, like
many other former Soviet
republics. Since its economy
was highly dependent on
the rest of the former Soviet
Union for energy and raw
materials, the breakdown in
trade following the breakup
of the Soviet Union had a
serious effect, exacerbated
at times by drought and civil
conflict but economic growth
has been steady since 2000.
The
government
has
liberalised most prices and
has phased out subsidies on
most basic consumer goods.
A program begun in March
1993 has privatised 80% of
all housing units and nearly
2,000 small, medium, and
large enterprises. Other
successes
include
the
privatisation of nearly all
of Moldavias agricultural
land from state to private
ownership, as a result of
an
American
assistance
program, completed in 2000.
p.60
MOLDAVIA
ASSETS
Moldavia has few natural
resources but a lot of arable
lands.
Chiinu has a continental
climate,
characterised
by hot dry summers and
windy winters. Winter
temperatures are often
below 0 C , although
they rarely drop below
10 C. In summer, the
average temperature is
approximately
25
C,
however,
temperatures
sometimes reach 35 to 40
C.
So, Moldavia is a good
place for farmlands and
agriculture. The fertile
soil
supports
wheat,
corn,
barley,
tobacco,
sugar beet, and soybeans.
Beef and dairy cattle are
raised, and beekeeping is
widespread.
Moldavias
best-known product comes
from its extensive and
well-developed vineyards
concentrated in the central
and southern regions.
It is also known for its
sunflower seeds, walnuts,
apples, and other fruits.
FARM MARKETS
A NEED IN
CHIINU?
The Central Market
has since 1825 been
the
place
where
Moldavians
haggle
over prices for fresh
products.
But according Vasile
Bumacov, the Minister
of Agriculture and
Food Industry of
Moldavia, the Central
Market of Chiinu
is monopolised. It
deprives direct farm
goods producers of
access to the Market.
The Central Market
is
a
municipal
enterprise, but almost
80% of its territory is
privatised.
Beside the Minister
underlines the lack
of sanitary conditions
especially for fish and
meat.
But the main issue
is that despite many
markets in the capital
of Moldavia, they all
are
uncomfortable,
ordinary farm goods
producers can not get
access to them.
p.61
by Rostdeore
Selected for Google Earth
ID: 23847325
p.62
WATER
p.63
PRESSENT CONDITIONS
STRUCTURE
-PRESSENT AND FUTURE.
Suburbs would get a better connexion
between them and also with the main
city.
Stormwater pond
p.64
Stre
POTENTIALS
Adding different
importaint aspects.
people density
interaction points
potential developing area
water
PROPOSED STRUCTURE
p.65
p.66
p.67
p.68
CHISINAU IMPLANTATION
SCHEME
CHISINAU STRUCTURAL
SCHEME
NET
GRID
p.71
Former theater
Columna Cinema,
unfinished
Abandoned housing
construction facility
p.73
p.74
Juha Kivist
Cecilia Rudstrm
Justina Bieksaite
Luca Gramaglia
Cyprien Lger
Yun Zhang
Patricia Alejos Monsn
Daniel Edenius
Denis Trax
p.75
INCEPTION
EXISTENCE
_DENIS TRAX
p.76
11
ECONOMIC APPROPRIATION
index of formal & informal usage
in puplic spaces
p.77
CONTEXT
MEANS
IN
F
AL
MAL
OR
FOR
M
TYPE #1
SCALE
Is planned prior to
construction or to
existing structures to
be transformed. Close to
the center and easily
accessible location is
an advantage. Requires
high economic capital and
statutory authorization.
CONDITIONS
LOCATION
MEANS
SIZE
IN
F
AL
MA L
CONTEXT
Marketplace is built
very open and easily
accessible. Many people
share an open space for
their economic benefit
and create a dense market
space. The formal planned
roof structure creates a
place for informal trade.
OR
FOR
M
TYPE #3
SCALE
Needs easy access for
people and motor vehicle
and enough parking space
in relation to the
vendors and customers.
Requires permission
to sell? Who has the
authority?
CONDITIONS
LOCATION
p.78
SIZE
MEANS
IN
F
AL
MA L
CONTEXT
Economic use in
additional formal shop
structure radiates
physically into the
public space and uses
the existing conditions.
Can be created
retrospectively to
existing building fabric
like an underpass.
OR
FOR
M
TYPE #5
SCALE
Is planned to
existing structures &
infrastructure to be
transformed. Close to
the center and easily
accessible location is
an advantage. Requires
high economic capital and
statutory authorization.
CONDITIONS
CONTEXT
MEANS
SIZE
AL
IN
MAL
OR
FOR
M
LOCATION
TYPE #4
SCALE
Needs easy access for
people and motor vehicle
and enough parking space
in relation to the
vendors and customers.
Requires permission
to sell. Who has the
authority?
CONDITIONS
SIZE
LOCATION
p.79
MA L
CONTEXT
IN
Economic use in a informal
F
stall structure mostly
AL
surrounded by public space.
Often provides access for
people and motor vehicle and
partly hidden visibility
SCALE
to the public.Permanent/
temporary location by
Is (NOT!/) planned to existing
temporary stall interior.
open space structures. Requires
Very flexible economic
low economic capital and (NO!/)
structures.
statutory permission. Ability to
MEANS
very easily change the location.
Often hidden in marginal public
area. Often illegal but partly
tolerated activity.
OR
FOR
M
TYPE #9
CONDITIONS
SIZE
MEANS
IN
F
AL
MA L
CONTEXT
OR
Stand-alone building
structure as formal
shop of smaller sizes
in existing public
space. Often functional
lightweight construction
for low-priced high
usability of space.
FOR
M
LOCATION
TYPE #7
SCALE
CONDITIONS
SIZE
LOCATION
p.80
CONTEXT
MEANS
AL
IN
F
AL
M
OR
Stand-alone building
structure as formal
shop of different sizes
in existing public
space. Often functional
lightweight construction
for low-priced high
usability of space.
FOR
M
TYPE #6
SCALE
Is planned to existing
open space structures to
be transformed. Close to
the center and easily
accessible location is
an advantage. Requires
high economic capital and
statutory authorization.
CONDITIONS
SIZE
MEANS
IN
F
AL
CONTEXT
AL
M
OR
Economic use in a
informal stall structure
mostly surrounded by
public space. Often
provides easy access
for people and motor
vehicle and good
visibility to the public.
Permanent location by
lockable (in-)formal
shop interior. Flexible
economic structures.
FOR
M
LOCATION
TYPE #8
SCALE
Is planned to existing open space
structures. Close to the center
and easily accessible location is
an advantage. Requires economic
capital and statutory permission.
Ability to easily change the
location.
CONDITIONS
LOCATION
SIZE
p.81
LOCATIONS IN CHISINAU
p.82
p.83
1ST: THE OLDEST PART OF THE CITY HAS BEEN CUT INTO TWO BY A NEW
CIRCULATION AXIS AND DOESNT DEVELOP AS AN ACTIVE CITY CENTER
2ND: A LOT OF PUBLIC SPACE IS UNUSED BY THE CITIZENS
OBJECTIVES:
p.84
SITE
CIVIC CENTER PROJECT
SITE
Bank
Student residence
Unfinished Tower
Sport complex
p.85
ROJECT
CONNECTION
CONECTION
CONECTION
CONTINUOUS
PUBLIC SPACE
..... THAT COULD
EXPAND....
TROUGH THE
OTHER BLOCKS
CONTINUOUS
PUBLIC SPACE
..... THAT COULD
EXPAND.....
METOLOGY
CIVIC
CENTER PROJECT
PROGRAMATIC INTENTIONS
PROGRAMMATIC INTENTIONS
Workshop
Associative
Sport
Art
Events
Organises
Piazza
part of
Student
Accomodation
Planning
Office
Civic urban
development
exposition
public
meeting
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
Urban
laboratories
Civic
appropriation of
public spaces
Urban
museum
Occupy
youth
A continuous pedestrian
boulevard
CONECTION
CONECTION
Symbolic sign :
Cars zebra crossing
instead of pedestrians
REMOVE
TOWER in construction :
H
UG
RO
TH
G
IN
GO
H
UG
RO
TH
TH
RO
UG
H
G
IN
GO
GO
IN
G
REMOVE
GO
IN
G
TH
RO
UG
H
OPEN GROUND
FLOOR
Piazz
Sport
Art
Events
contempl
CONTINUOUS
PUBLIC SPACE
Linking with the
boulevard:
PAND.....
USING VEGETATION
Linking
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
SPORTS
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
EVENTS
CIVIC CENTER PROJECT
Urban
museum
URBAN CULTURE
p.88
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events CIVIC CENTER PROJECT
CIVIC APROPRIATION OF PUBLIC SPACE
contemplation
Workshop
Associative
Sport
Art
Events
1st Floor
Planning
Office
Civic urban
development
Workshop
Associative
Sport
Art
Events
WORKING TOGETHER
Piazza
Sport
Art
Events
contemplation
1st Floor
Plannin
Office
Civic urba
developme
p.89
CIVIC
CENTER
Recycling center
National
d
ance Blv
Renaiss
aM
le
Ca
lor
oi
4H farm
Position
Leaving the circus - the icon - alone,
but connecting with it since the
program links with the restaurant is
important, and still keeping in contact with the street
Protective bank
POSITION
Site isometry, 1:1000
Play sculptures
and things to discover are placed
along the promenade
p.90
KIDS' HAVEN
Additional activities:
A restaurant with outdoor
seating is added
Exhibitions in the lobby
Veterinarian for both the circus
animals and
pets
Circus school for kids
Opportunity for young people
to be involved in
the care of the animals
The basement is retained in
abandoned
condition.
Besides horror rounds, it hosts
laser tag games.
Legend has it that in the basement
of the circus
a child is often heared crying.
People who
worked in the circus, tied it to
the place where it
was built - a former City cemetery.
It got to the
point that any failure, bankruptcy
or artist death
was attributed to the site on
which the Chisinau
Circus stands.
PROGRAMMATIC IDEAS
SITE ANALYSI
S
CHISINAU CIRCUS [CLOSED]
SIS
SITE ANALY
down)
Concrete plant
Rcani
Preliminary working
area
P
Housing
Buiucani
Ciocana
Green slope, former
Central
Zoning map
cemetary
Vet
+41
Botanica
Historical (inner)
Old pool
+54
Housing
Magnolia/Dan
buildings
Mostly apartment the ground
on
with businesses
floor and in extensions
"
The
ate
+49
+41
Italian restaurant
and club
+41
Housing
Ma
tern
ity
+51
+50
+47
Ho
rist
1:5000
unbuilt
Monument of
Olympic Stadium
ce Planet
+52
+42
"Tu
used
Green valley that
populated.
to be densely
Place for the planned
National Stadium.
+44
Closed circus
city
High-rise
Hospital
height
Average
Low houses
Industrial
Underground
passage
Kiosks
Mall
Housing
+45
Oce "Bioprotect"
Housing
+42
Housing
Apartments
Apartments
School
Hotel "Gloria"
Ho
spi
tal
Hospital
p.91
DEVELOPMENT 2020
According to the concept,
proposed by Chisinau
Project, all industrial areas
alongside the river will be
converted to residential areas.
Selected site is included in
concept and in the future is
going to cause a lot of urban
and infrastructure problems
because at the moment very
intensive street of Mihai
Viteazul which continues to
the bridge, is separating green
areas.
p.92
p.93
p.94
Existing inventory of selected site was analyzed by layers, separating few important assets that this area provides. Schemes above proved
once again that very intensive street of Mihai Viteazul became a boundary. Earlier done workshop and programmatic diagram of selected
site shows that at fi rst sight it seems that activities people do in this site are not linked to each other but when analyzing possible existing
connections it is obvious that everything is related and could not be cut down. The aim of the project should be the design of network of old
and new activities, routes, paths, exchanges, connections and everything must lead to one destination - recharge of unused public spaces
WORKSHOP IN CHISINAU:
programmatic diagram
During the workshop I was asked to explore my selected site and write a story what Ive experienced there in simple words. Somehow all
the action happening in my selected site reminded me of a movie with people, motions, emotions, speed, scents, colours, etc. Analyzing
my story word by word, I came up with few keywords which illustrated the main actors in selected site, as well as showed the problems and
led to possible solutions. Explanation of keywords: By MOVEMENT I understand the action of cars, public transport marshrutkas, railway,
trains and people. In this case, very intensive street becomes both a separation and connection, as well as railways or people. By HABITS
I tried to illustrate activities people are doingin this site which I noticed, such as fi shing, growing a tomato tree, going to work and man
more. By EXCHANGE I was trying to explain that these habits are sort of connected to each other and probably could lead to new assets.
By RECHARGE I suggested to create new HABITS or activities that could help to develop the site, to connect different parts which are now
separated and to link important objects. These factors infl uenced my further concept of development
p.95
p.97
p.98
THE BICYCLE
NETWORK:
THE LANDSCAPE
ROLE:
BUILDINGS
REUSE:
NEW BUILDINGS
INTRODUCTION:
NEW FACILITIES
FOR STUDENTS
AND BIKES:
GREEN AREAS:
p.99
Industry areas
Site
Street
Structure
Street
Structure
p.100
Current situation
GroupEnlarge
: stable
low-income
people
at about 22 square
meters in
self build house when
Chisinau
family
grows build house
Enlarge
self
Average cars per household :1.2
Per-capita living
space : 11.6
( 14
when family
grows
Perperson living together), 2001-2008,
Use of garden : drying clothes,
capita living
space remained
capita per
living
space
: pets
11.6%
planting,
storing
things,
stable
at about
22 square
meters
in
Chisinau living together),
( 14 person
Average cars per household :1.2
2001-2008,
per capita living
Use of garden : drying clothes,
space planting,
remained
stable at
storing things, pets
about 22 square meters
in Chisinau Average cars
per household :1.2 Use of
garden : drying clothes,
planting, storing things, pets
p.101
p.102
p.103
CULTURAL+SOCIAL+ COMMERCIAL+
EDUCATIONAL+SUSTAINABLE
Chisinau is the capital of Moldavia with a population of 665000. The aim of work there is try to create a new civic center, because they do
not have a real place to meet each other and be able to enjoy time. When we visit the city and we participated in a workshop there I could
understand Chisinau has so much potential but the most of the city is still underdeveloped. In my tours along Chisinau I noticed there were
so many buildnings unfinished or abandoned. So it does not need more new buildnings but it would be great to recover these existing
buildnings with new uses.
My project try to connect the most importaint points of activity in Chisinau along the main axe, which also joining green areas. But the
studdy of all the axe showes discontiuities in the last part. So my project is focused in the development of these three points to create the
continuity which is lacking now. To improve this continuity is also necessary a good network of public transportation, which is already running along all this axe but goona create also a bike lane to enhance the use of bikes. It also will reduce the use of the private cars because
it is a problem in Chisinau nowadays.
I did a research about what kind of activities are missing there, I discovered so many interesting things about what this city needs, like
places to take care of old people, student accomodations, libraries, exhibition space, skate parcs, concert halls.... My project is about all city
but had to focus just in one point. I chose the middle one, the merged bridge for pedastrian and bicycles. The aim is not just to join green
areas, but also produce different kinds of activity in the same place, like a civic center should be.
p.104
p.106
p.108
Auditorium
p.110
p.111
Urban strategy
Site analysis
existing green
area
Chisinau
Moldova
industry
green
polluted water
railway
public
connective
movement
pedestrian
service
reusing
pedestrian connections
borders
industrial areas
borders
connections
green park
clean river
library
railway museum
speed train
site
green park
_JUHA KIVIST
p.112
proposal
clean river
railway museum
Functions
existing green
area
Site analysis
service
ing
pedestrian connections
borders
industrial areas
site
green park
proposal
river
p.113
_green plaza
_platform
Functions 1. level
railway
museum
library
passenger
platform
Functions 2. level
railway
museum
shop spaces
plaza
library
restaurants
cafe
building
market
park
agricultural
market
housing
civic
center
station
p.115