Professional Documents
Culture Documents
KEY WORDS
secular change
ABSTRACT
Somatometric data are presented which show that the rapid
brachycephalization in Japan has recently ceased. The causes of brachycephalization are investigated in relation to the secular change in height. Increases in head breadth have been the main cause of brachycephalization,
and its pattern of secular change is very similar to that in height. Associations between head breadth, height, and year of birth were examined by
partial correlation coefficients and through a comparison of students and the
general population. Brachycephalization is thought to result from increases
in the growth rate for head breadth caused by improvements in nutritional
levels, as seen in increases in height. Increases in height over the last 100
years have been accompanied by brachycephalization in Japanese and Koreans, but by debrachycephalization in many European populations. Increases
in lateral growth in Asian heads may be related to the facial flatness which
is characteristic to northern Mongoloid populations. Am J Phys Anthropol
112:339 347, 2000. 2000 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
Secular changes of 20-year-old Japanese investigated using the published somatometric data measured during 18921994 are as
follows (Kouchi, 1996): mean heights of both
males and females have been increasing in
last 100 years, though the rate became very
low for people born in the 1970s. Weight has
been increasing slowly for both males and
females born before 1920. For males born
after 1930, weight has been increasing more
rapidly. On the contrary, for females, the
rate of increase in weight was very low, and
has changed little in those born after 1950.
As a result, body mass index (BMI) has been
increasing for males born after 1950, but
decreasing for females born after 1930. The
head form shows a pattern of secular
340
M. KOUCHI
SES
2
S
S2
G
G
G
G
G
S
G
S
S
S
S
S
Age
2228
1826
5782
4675
3767
2757
2233
2445
1827
2029
1834
1831
1827
1822
N
517
2,824
36
136
111
129
103
68
146
503
3,066
583
658
127
5,666
Birth year
19021907
19081912
19221927
19211927
19201929
19301939
19301939
19401949
19501959
19501959
19601964
19651969
19701974
19751979
Female
SES
2
G
G2
S2,3
S2
G
G
G
G
G
S
S
S
S
S
Age
2329
1824
1721
1723
2675
1725
4168
2756
1928
1942
1735
1830
1825
1823
128
357
119
119
118
58
119
79
124
132
1,011
538
366
162
2,707
The birth year category was divided into 5or 10-year increments to ensure that each
group had enough subjects. The educational
level of the subjects was used as an indication of SES; groups for which the majority of
the members received higher education (college or university) were marked as student
group (group S), with other groups marked
as the general population (group G). The
numbers of subjects by group are shown in
Table 1.
Measurement items
Head length, head breadth, and height
were used. These are equivalent to cephalic
measurements 1 and 3, and somatic measurement 1, in Martin and Knussmann
(1988), respectively. Cephalic index was calculated as head breadth/head length 100.
Age at time of measurement varied widely.
Age changes after adulthood has been
reached are insignificant for neurocranial
measurements (Tallgren, 1974), but height
decreases significantly with aging (Takasaki
et al., 1984; Galloway et al., 1990). Therefore, height data measured for subjects aged
60 years or over were not used for the analysis.
Materials used for comparison
The materials shown in Table 2 were used
to examine the course of brachycephalization. The year of measurement, ages of subjects, and basic statistics for head length,
341
BRACHYCEPHALIZATION IN JAPAN
1
SES
Area
No. of groups
G
S
G
G
S
S
G
Fukuoka Prefect
All Japan
Hiroshima Prefect
Hiroshima Prefect
All Japan
All Japan
All Japan
7
1
6
11
1
1
1
G
S
G
G
S
Fukuoka Prefect
All Japan
Hiroshima Prefect
Hiroshima Prefect
All Japan
8
1
6
11
9
All Japan
All Japan
HQL, Research Institute of Human Engineering for Quality of Life; S, students; G, general population.
head breadth, and cephalic index are reported for these materials. The age ranges
in these materials were either limited or
subjects were divided into age groups of either 5 or 10 years. For each group of data,
average birth year was estimated from the
age range of the subjects and the year of
measurement.
Only the head breadth data were used for
Onishi (1919, 1920) due to differences in
definitions of head length. Onishi (1919,
1920) and Kakimoto (1953) did not measure
height. For the age groups of 30 years old
and over in Yanagisawa and Kondo (1973),
height was also reported (Yanagisawa,
1958; personal communication). The earliest somatometric data on Japanese by
Baeltz (1885) were not used due to differences in measurement definitions.
Statistical method
Male subjects shown in Table 1 were divided into 10 groups according to birth year
(1910 1919, 1920 1929, 1930 1939, 1940
1949, 1950 1954, 19551959, 1960 1964,
19651969, 1970 1974, 19751979), and female subjects into 8 groups (1920 1929,
1930 1939, 1940 1949, 1950 1959, 1960
1964, 19651969, 1970 1974, and 1975
1979). Equality of means was tested by
ANOVA (Statview). Only groups with 30 or
more subjects were used for the test.
Of the groups by birth year and SES,
shown in Table 1, and the groups from ma-
342
M. KOUCHI
Fig. 1.
Fig. 2.
Secular change in head length for Japanese born between 1870 1980. *Student group.
Secular change in head breadth for Japanese born between 1860 1980. *Student group.
343
BRACHYCEPHALIZATION IN JAPAN
Fig. 3.
Secular change in cephalic index for Japanese born between 1870 1980. *Student group.
344
M. KOUCHI
Fig. 4.
Secular change in height for Japanese born between 1890 1980. *Student group.
BRACHYCEPHALIZATION IN JAPAN
0.527 **
0.323 ns
0.921 **
0.937 **
0.324 ns
0.938 **
0.961 **
0.955 **
Female
(df 25)
0.204 ns
0.003 ns
0.910 **
0.914 **
0.151 ns
0.919 **
0.906 **
0.862 **
0.052 ns
0.491 *
0.565 **
0.363 ns
0.539 **
0.363 ns
0.044 ns
0.204 ns
0.235 ns
0.330 ns
0.464 *
0.620 **
1
HL, maximum head length; HB, maximum head breadth; Ht,
height; Ceph, cephalic index; BY, birth year; ns, not significant.
* Significant at the 5% level.
** Significant at the 1% level.
345
Causes of brachycephalization
Changes in head shape that have accompanied increases in height in recent years
have tended toward brachycephalization in
Japan. As shown in Table 4, a similar phenomenon also occurred in Korea. Studies of
Chinese immigrants to Hawaii (Appleton,
1927) and the United States (Lasker, 1946),
as well as Japanese immigrants to California (Shapiro, 1939) and Brazil (Beiguelman,
1963), revealed that increases in height
were accompanied by increases in head
breadth for these Asian populations. In contrast, the changes in head shape which have
accompanied increases in height in recent
years have tended toward debrachycephalization for European populations (Dornfeldt, 1941; Billy, 1975, 1979; Facchini and
Gualdi-Russo, 1982; Kobyliansky, 1983; Susanne et al., 1988). Although the direction is
opposite, head breadth is the key characteristic in both brachycephalization and debrachycephalization. Explanations concerning the cause of brachycephalization must
be able to account for both systematic increases and decreases in head breadth associated with increases in height. In this
sense, explanations in terms of heterosis,
migration, social class, and allometry alone
are insufficient.
Secular changes in body dimensions are
the results of changes in growth rate. For
linear dimensions, the direction of growth
accords with the longitudinal axis of the
part. However, for spherical forms, such as
the head, the directions of the growth will be
more complicated. The cephalic index is a
practical indicator of overall head shape,
but it oversimplifies the head form and
growth directions.
The form of the normal neural skull is the
result of the preferential direction of the
growth vectors of the expanding neural
mass by dural fiber systems (Moss and
Young, 1960). Small increases in the growth
rate in a specific direction during the first
year of life would lead to changes in head
form. For Japanese and Koreans, this increase has occurred in a lateral direction.
For European populations, decrease in head
breadth must have been accompanied by
increases in other directions, probably the
346
M. KOUCHI
Head
length
Male
Head
breadth
19081909
1930
1986
181.4
182.0
180.0
150.9
153.0
158.0
Height
Head
length
Female
Head
breadth
Height
Reference
161.4
163.6
167.7
175.7
174.5
174.0
146.3
145.6
151.0
147.5
150.1
155.4
Kubo, 1913
Arase et al., 1934
KRISS, 1986
vertical direction (Angel, 1976), for European brains have shown secular increases
(Miller and Corsellis, 1977).
The neurocranium and the face are functionally different units, but they are connected. Thus, the growth potential of one
will influence growth in the other. The direct causes of brachycephalization in the
Japanese may have been the preferential
increase in growth rate of the neural skull
in a lateral direction, which in turn may be
related to facial characteristics, i.e., the facial flatness in the frontal and zygomaxillary regions which are characteristic of
northern Asian populations (Ishida, 1992).
Many Japanese textbooks on child care
include prone sleeping position as an index item, and explain that such posture
does not mean the baby is in ill health (e.g.,
Suzuki, 1977). This suggests that supine
sleeping posture has been considered normal, but that prone sleeping posture is not
corrected. Since a flat occiput is called zeppeki (precipice), and is not preferred from
an aesthetic point of view, many mothers
prefer a prone sleeping posture for their babies. Though the changes in sleeping position of babies are not clearly known, it
would have been an increase in prone rather
than supine sleeping posture if there had
been any. Since such changes would promote antero-posterior rather than bilateral
growth of heads, changes in sleeping posture cannot be a candidate for causes of
brachycephalization.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I am grateful to Professor Akio Yamauchi,
Department of Anatomy, Faculty of Medicine, The University of Tokyo, for permitting me to use the data for the series by
Nishi (1953) stored in the University Museum, The University of Tokyo. I thank Pro-
BRACHYCEPHALIZATION IN JAPAN
347