Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ae
Current Medicinal Chemistry, 2015, 22, ????-????
Please provide
corresponding author(s)
photograph
Please provide
corresponding author(s)
photograph
size should be 4" x 4" inches
Abstract: Cholesterol-5,6-epoxide hydrolase (ChEH) in mammals is a heterooligomeric complex of two cholesterogenic enzymes that control mammalian
developmental programs. Following the identification of this complex, it was
Marc Poirot
S. Silvente-Poirot
hypothesized that a new metabolic pathway existed that centered on 5,6-epoxy
cholesterols (5,6-EC). Conjugation products of 5,6-EC with biogenic amines known to interact with ChEH
subunits were synthesized. According to their structures, these steroidal alkaloids showed the specific potency
to induce cell differentiation at low doses, suggesting their possible existence as metabolites. One of these
compounds, named dendrogenin A (DDA), was recently discovered in mammalian tissues. It was shown that
DDA arises from the stereoselective enzymatic conjugation of 5,6-epoxy-cholesterol with histamine by an
as-yet-unidentified enzyme. DDA was detected in normal tissues from several organs but not in cancer cells
and its level was decreased in breast tumors from patients, evidencing a deregulation of DDA metabolism
during carcinogenesis. DDA was also able to control the growth of tumor cells implanted in mice and improve animal survival. In addition, DDA efficiently restored hearing in a preclinical model of deafness. These
biological properties of DDA, as well as its decreased levels in tumors, suggest a physiological function in
maintaining cell integrity and differentiation. DDA is the first steroidal alkaloid found to date in mammals. Its
discovery reveals the existence of a new metabolic pathway in mammals at the crossroads of cholesterol and
histamine metabolism that leads to the production of a metabolic tumor suppressor and neuroprotective agent.
Dalenc et al.
Cl
HO
4-Hydroxytamoxifen
4OHTam, afimoxifene
Tamoxifen
ICI 46,474, Nolvadex
Clomiphene
clomid
N
N
O
OH
S
Cl
HO
Raloxifene
keoxifen
Toremifene
Fareston, Acapodene
HO
Lazofoxifene
OH
N
O
N
HO
HO
Bazedoxifene
HO
HN
Dendrogenin A
DDA
N
N
H
Fig. (1). Chemical structure of some selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERM) and dendrogenin A.
N
O
In addition to their estrogen receptor modulating activity, both Tam and Toremifene (see Fig. 1) are reported to induce zymostenol accumulation, suggesting
that Tam inhibits cholesterol biosynthesis in patients at
the 3-hydroxysteroid-8,7-isomerase (D8D7I/EBP)
step [45, 46].
The impact of AEBS ligands on cholesterol biosynthesis was studied in breast cancer (BC) cell lines
where it was found that both Tam and PBPE induced a
significant accumulation of zymostenol in BC cells
[14]. These data suggested that Tam and PBPE inhibited D8D7I in BC cells, which was in accordance with
data published by other groups studying yeast and other
cell lines [47-49]. In addition, it was found that PBPE
inhibited 3-hydroxysteroid-7-reductase (DHCR7),
thereby
inducing
the
accumulation
of
7dehydrocholesterol as expected based on its structural
similarity to boxidine [12]. D8D7I and DHCR7 are
involved in the late stages of cholesterol biosynthesis
Fig. 3). Depending on the chemical structure of the
AEBS ligand and the different cell lines used [8, 11,
12, 48, 50-52], additional cholesterol precursors
O
O
N3
N
O
PBPE
DPPE, tesmilifene
Azido-MBPE
MBOPE
N
Cl
OH
C F
F F
Triparanol, Mer 29
Boxidine
Fig. (2). Chemical structure of selective AEBS ligands and cholesterol biosynthesis inhibitors. DPPE and PBPE are prototypical selective AEBS ligands in the DPM series. Azido-MBPE and MBOPE were synthesized to allow photoaffinity labeling
of the AEBS. Triparanol is an analogue of the triphenylethylenic antiestrogens depicted in Fig. (1). Boxidine is a diphenyl analog of PBPE.
Dalenc et al.
HO
lanosterol
DHCR24
HO
Tam
PBPE
tesmilifene
HO
zymostenol
D8D7I/EBP
lathosterol
raloxifene
D8D7I/EBP
boxidine
PBPE
tesmilifene
7-dehydrocholesterol
raloxifene
DHCR24
HO
SC5D
SC5D
HO
zymosterol
HO
DHCR24
HO
7-dehydrodesmosterol
DHCR7
DHCR7
DHCR24
HO
cholesterol
HO
desmosterol
triparanol
4OHTam
Fig. (3). Scheme describing some of the enzymatic steps in the post-lanosterol cholesterol biosynthesis pathway. Steps
inhibited by the AEBS ligands, triparanol and boxidine, are specified.
2.2. The Discovery that AEBS Carried Out Cholesterol-5,6-Epoxide Hydrolase Activity
5,6-EC (the substrates of ChEH). These results paralleled the typical behavior of substrates and product
for their enzyme. To determine the level of similarity
between AEBS and ChEH, ChEH inhibition was
measured for a number AEBS ligands with affinities
ranging from nM to M. A series of steroids was also
tested. A positive correlation between AEBS affinity
and inhibition of ChEH activity was established,
which showed the pharmacological identity between
ChEH and AEBS [9]. In addition, knock down of
each AEBS sub-unit in the breast cancer cell line
MCF-7 led to a concomitant loss of AEBS binding
capacity for Tam and a loss in ChEH activity. Conversely, the over expression of each subunit in COS
cells led to the reconstitution of ChEH activity. Altogether, these results established that ChEH was
molecularly identical to the AEBS (see Fig. 5) [7].
The AEBS was first reported as an oxysterol binding protein [53-55]. Oxysterols are oxygenation
products of cholesterol and some are known to be
produced by Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) [53].
Among the oxysterol family of compounds, 6- and 7oxocholestanol (see Fig. 4a) were reported to bind
competitively to Tam with a high affinity for the
AEBS [54, 55]. Interestingly, these oxysterols were
also known to be competitive inhibitors of the microsomal cholesterol-5,6-epoxide hydrolase (ChEH)
[56], an unidentified enzyme at that time. ChEH catalyzed the hydration of 5,6-epoxy-cholesterols (5,6EC) into cholestane-3,5,6-triol (CT) (see Fig. 4b).
These oxysterols were tested in AEBS binding assays
and it was found that 5,6-EC, the substrates of ChEH,
were potent and competitive inhibitors of Tam [9]. At
the same time, CT (the product of ChEH activity),
was found to have a weaker affinity for AEBS than
(a)
HO
O
6-ketocholestanol
HO
O
7-ketocholestanol
(b)
HO
O
5,6!-epoxycholesterol
5,6!-EC
ChEH
HO
HO
O
5,6"-epoxycholesterol
5,6"-EC
HO
OH
cholestane-3",5!,6"-triol
CT
Fig. (4). Some AEBS ligands from the oxysterol series and inhibitors of ChEH activity. a) Chemical structure of 6- and 7ketocholestanol. b) Cholesterol-5,6-epoxide hydrolase catalyzes the hydration of 5,6-EC and 5,6-EC.
Dalenc et al.
This established that 5,6-ECs are epoxides of exceptional stability under non-acidic conditions, ruling out
any direct carcinogenic activity. The same experiments
performed in the presence of a catalyst (Lewis acid or
heat) showed that a reaction was possible but only with
5,6-EC and not with 5,6-EC (Fig. 7) [63]. Importantly, only a single product was obtained from the four
possible (see Fig. 6b), showing a strict stereoselectivity
in the reaction with 5,6-EC (Fig. 7a). The weak reactivity of the epoxides was explained by the location of
the epoxide on the steroid backbone. This stereoselective transformation opened up a possible metabolic
pathway centered on 5,6-EC transformation [17, 18,
57].
3.2. Synthesis of Steroidal Alkaloids from 5,6Epoxycholesterol and Biogenic Amines: The Genesis of Dendrogenins
The AEBS was first described as being tightly associated with a histamine (HA) binding site (HIc) by
Brandes' group in the eighties [64, 65]. After establishing the identity between AEBS and ChEH [7], it
was hypothesized that 5,6-EC could concentrate with
HA and favor their conjugation at the 5,6-epoxyde
group. This hypothesis was chemically evaluated and
the reactivity of 5,6-EC and 5,6-EC with HA in the
presence of a catalyst such as a Lewis acid was tested.
As expected, 5,6-EC but not 5,6-EC reacted with
HA [66].
Interestingly, while three different products of substitution at the C6 were possible (see Fig. 8a), only one
was obtained, with a 6 substitute product resulting
from the trans diaxial ring opening of the epoxide by
the primary () amine of HA (see Fig. 8b). Other 5,6epoxysterols such as 5,6-epoxycholest-7ene-3-ol or
5,6-epoxystigmastan-3-ol were next tested and one
single 6 product of conjugation was obtained in each
case (C15 and C16 respectively, see Fig. 9). Since
other biogenic amines were reported to interact with
this HIc [67], different biogenic amines such as spermine, spermidine and putrescine were used and 6
products of conjugation with the 5,6-ECs were obtained (compounds C21, C23, DDB, C28, C29, see Fig.
9). All conjugation products of 5,6-EC and biogenic
amines are steroids with one or more protonable basic
nitrogen atoms, which belong to the steroidal alkaloid
(SA) class [66].
#$
O
(a)
#+
#$
#+
Nu
R'
(b)
!
HO
HO
"
"
HO
Nu
Nu
!
OH
:Nu
5
HO
6
?
"
HO
5,6-EC
HO
HO
Nu
Nu
"
OH
Fig. (6). Possible products of the addition of an epoxide to a nucleophile through an SN2 mechanism. a) The two carbons
of the epoxide ring can be attacked by a nucleophile. b) 5,6-EC can give 4 different products by addition via a trans diaxial ring
opening.
(a)
Ethanolamine
HO
Catalyst
5,6!-EC
HO
Ethanolamine
O
HN
OH
5!-Hydroxy-6"-[2-hydroxyethylamino]-cholestan-3"-ol
(HAC)
(b)
HO
HO
"
Catalyst
5,6"-EC
No reaction
Fig. (7). Reactivity of 5,6-EC with ethanolamine. a) 5,6-EC gives a single product when added to ethanolamine in the
presence of a catalyst. b) No reaction occurred with 5,6-EC even under the same conditions.
4. PHARMACOLOGICAL
DENDROGENINS
PROPERTIES
OF
(a)
Dalenc et al.
!
H2N
HA
H
N
"
(b)
HA
HO
HO
Catalyst
!
HO
$
H
N
HN
5,6!-EC
Dendrogenin A
DDA
Fig. (8). The addition of 5,6-EC to HA. a) HA contains three nitrogen atoms (, and ) that can react via an SN2 reaction.
b) 5,6-EC gives a single product of conjugation with the primary () amine of HA.
HO
HO
HO
HN
HO
N
H
DDA
HA, GID, Cyt
HO
HN
HO
N
H
C15
WA, GID, Cyt
HN
C16
HA, GID, Cyt
N
H
NH2
HO
HO
N
HO
N
NH2
HO
C17
NA, GID, Cyt
HO
HN
HO
NH2
C21
WA, GID, Cyt
HN
H
N
C23
HA, NID, NCyt
NH2
HO
HO
HN
H
N
HO
H2N
DDB
HA, NID, NCyt
HO
HO
HN
N
H
C28
HA, NID, NCyt
NH
H2N
HO
HN
NH
N
H
C29
HA, NID, NCyt
Fig. (9). Chemical structure and biological properties of some of the products of condensation of 5,6-epoxysterols with
biogenic amines. HA: highly active; WA: weakly active; NA: not active; GID: general inducer of cell differentiation; NID:
Selective inducer of cell differentiation into neurons; Cyt: cytotoxic; NCyt: not cytotoxic.
Fig. (10). Cell differentiation tests. a) U937 can differentiate into dendritic cells. b) P19 cells can differentiate into neurons. c)
P19 cells are pluripotent cells that can differentiate into different cell types.
While 5,6-EC or biogenic amines alone or in association did not induce dendritic outgrowth, some but
not all SA induced dendrite outgrowth at low nanomolar concentrations. The HA adduct on 5,6-EC gave a
compound that was named dendrogenin A (DDA).
DDA induced dendritic outgrowth on both U937 and
P19 cells at low doses and was cytotoxic at M concentrations. This property was observed for all sterols
containing the histamine motif except those in which
the sterol side chain was not present and those in which
a double bond was present between C7-C8. Replacement of HA by diaminobutane (putrescine) (C21, see
Fig. 9) gave a less efficient compound than DDA but it
did stimulate dendrite outgrowth in both cell lines and
induce cytotoxicity when used at higher concentrations.
Replacement of HA by spermidine (C23 and DDB, see
Fig. 9) or spermine (C28 and C29) affected their biological properties. These compounds were not cytotoxic at concentrations up to 1 mM and stimulated dendrite outgrowth only in P19 cells and not in U937 cells,
suggesting a different mechanism of action than that
observed with DDA. Of these, the use of 7dehydrocholesterol as a template for epoxidation and
conjugation gave the most active compound, and induced dendrite outgrowth specifically of P19 cells but
with no cytotoxicity up to 1 mM (DDB, see Fig. 9).
When looking at other cancer cells, DDA was found
to induce a dose-dependent cytotoxicity in all cell lines
tested with IC50 values ranging from 0.4 M in an intestinal carcinoma cell line (SW620) to 5.5 M in an
acute myeloid leukemia cell line (KG1) following a 72
Dalenc et al.
Fig. (11). DDA-induced cancer cell re-differentiation into normal cells. a) DDA induced lactation in BC cells of ductal origin. b) DDA induced melanoma cell differentiation into melanocytes. c) DDA induced the differentiation of cancer cells of
neuronal origin into neurons.
11, 51, 72]. DDA was then tested on the human melanoma cell line SKMEL-28 and these cells were observed to morphologically change from spindle to dendritic morphology upon DDA treatment. Ultrastructure
analysis by electron microscopy revealed the presence
of melanosomes in the dendrites. Biochemical analysis
revealed that DDA also activated melanin biosynthesis
in these cells. Cell cycle analyses showed that DDA
had arrested cells in the G0-G1 phase of the cell cycle
[66]. These characteristics are typical of melanocytes
[73, 74], evidencing a stimulation of melanoma cell redifferentiation into melanocytes by DDA (see Fig.
11b). When tested on cancer cells of neuronal origin,
DDA displayed a similar differentiation profile as that
determined for DDB, by stimulating neurite outgrowth
(see Fig. 11c). Interestingly, DDA also induced the selective differentiation of P19 cells into neurons [66].
To complete these studies, DDA was tested on normal cells from the brain. Neuronal progenitor cells
from mice were collected. They normally spontaneously produce neurospheres in vitro. It was found that
DDA stimulated the proliferation and expansion of
these neurospheres at a low dose (10 nM), as observed
for EGF and FGF2 treatment. In addition to stimulating
proliferation, DDA stimulated dendrite outgrowth and
the appearance of -tubulin-positive cells, strongly
suggesting their differentiation into neurons (see Fig.
12) [75]. Altogether these data showed that DDA had
very interesting pharmacological properties and de-
served further in vivo studies for its anticancer and neurodegenerative disease applications.
4.2. In vivo Anticancer and Chemopreventive
Activities of DDA
The impact of DDA was then studied in vivo on tumors implanted into normal immunocompetent mice.
In the first set of experiments TSAH2d cells were implanted into the mammary fat pad of BALB/cJ mice.
TSAH2d cells are breast adenocarcinoma cells (ER(+))
obtained from BALB/cJ mice and are syngeneic for
this strain of mouse [17].
In a chemopreventive setting, DDA was injected at
the same time as the tumor cells were implanted. Mice
were treated every day over a 30 day period by subcutaneous peri-tumoral injection of DDA. DDA was
found to be very effective at controlling tumor development and, importantly, on improving mouse survival. Dose escalation was limited due to drug solubility, but a strong efficacy of DDA was observed even at
extremely low doses (3.7g/kg). Similar effects of Tam
were seen at 5.6 mg/kg, which corresponded to a 1500
fold greater concentration than that of the injected dose
of DDA. Importantly, although Tam controlled tumor
development it did not improve mouse survival, in contrast to DDA. A similar efficacy was obtained for the
treatment of established breast tumors implanted 10
days before DDA treatment (tumors detected by man-
11
Fig. (12). DDA induced the differentiation of normal progenitor cells. DDA stimulated the multiplication of neurospheres
and activated the differentiation of progenitor cells into neurons.
ual palpation), showing that DDA also displayed anticancer properties on BC cells [17]. DDA was next
tested on the very aggressive mouse melanoma cell line
B16F10 implanted in immunocompetent syngeneic
C57/Bl6 mice and it was found that DDA was extremely efficient at delaying tumor development and
improving mouse survival. Again, it was extremely
efficient even at low doses [17], suggesting that DDA
is a good candidate for melanoma treatment and prevention. Analyses of the phenotypic characteristics of
BC and melanoma tumors from DDA-treated animals
showed that DDA induced the same differentiation
characteristics as those observed in vitro. Additionally,
the use of immunocompetent mice made it possible to
check tumor infiltration by immune cells after DDA
treatment. It was found that DDA strongly stimulated T
lymphocytes and dendritic cells, suggesting that the
immune system contributed to the anticancer activities
of DDA.
Among neurodegenerative diseases, deafness represents one of the major neurosensory deficits occurring
around the world [76]. Hearing impairment involves a
progressive degeneration of structures within the inner
ear including the auditory nerve and spiral ganglion
neurons (SGN). Based on in vitro data, DDA and DDB
were tested in vivo on deafened guinea pigs to determine whether they could restore auditory function. It
had been previously established that neurotrophic factor
instillation of the cochlea could restore auditory nerve
excitability through the stimulation of SGN number on
5. DDA IS A METABOLITE
5.1. DDA is Present in Healthy Mammalian Tissues
Dalenc et al.
testinal and lung cancers [17]. DDA content was analyzed in tumor biopsies from patients with breast cancers and compared to DDA levels measured in normal
matched tissues. It was found that while DDA was present in normal breast tissue its concentration drastically
decreased in tumors. Altogether these data established
that DDA metabolism is decreased in cancers, suggesting a deregulation of DDA metabolism during carcinogenesis.
CONCLUSION
Natural compounds extracted from plants, microorganisms and marine organisms are the main source of
natural chemopreventive and anticancer agents [84-90].
The human metabolome has not been fully explored so
far to determine whether pharmocologically active metabolites against degenerative diseases can be identified. The discovery of DDA occurred 100 years after
the seminal discovery of all-trans retinoic acid (ATRA)
by Elmer McCollum as the first natural compound metabolized by mammalian cells from retinol [91]. He
later also discovered vitamin D [92]. ATRA and vitamin D are potent inducers of cancer cell differentiation
that are currently used in the treatment of myeloid leukemia and are currently being evaluated for other cancers [93-95]. The discovery of dendrogenins has now
opened up new and very exciting fields of research and
defining the mechanisms of action of dendrogenins
Fig. (13). Steroidal alkaloid metabolites of cholesterol are present in different plants, fishes and mammals. Tomatidine is
found in green tomato roots, squalamine in fishes and dendrogenin A in mammals.
remains a major project. The identification of their biosynthetic enzymes is also a major challenge since no
similar enzymatic conjugation of epoxides with histamine or other biogenic amines has been reported to
date. These two thema are currently under investigation
in our team. 5,6-EC are known as autoxidation products of cholesterol, which makes people think that they
can only be artefactually produced [57], however the
discovery of DDA has established that a metabolic
pathway indeed exists and is involved in the transformation of 5,6-EC. Interestingly, 5,6-EC is more than
just an autoxidation product of cholesterol since an asyet-unidentified cytochrome P450 has been reported to
catalyse the stereoselective biosynthesis of 5,6-EC in
bovine adrenals [96]. These data strongly suggest that
the 5,6 double bond of cholesterol is a template for its
steroselective transformation to produce compounds
such as DDA. The tumor suppressive, chemopreventive
and neuroprotective properties of DDA make this compound a very promising one for the complementation
therapy of degenerative diseases in which its biosynthesis is already known to be altered.
LIST OF CHEMICAL NAMES AND ABBREVIATIONS
4-hydroxytamoxifen
D8D7I
13
= EBP, 3-hydroxysteroid-8,7isomerase
= Cholest-5,24-dien-3-ol
DHCR24
= 3-hydroxysteroid-24-reductase
DHCR7
= 3-hydroxysteroid-7-reductase
DPM
= Diphenylmethane
ER
= Estrogen receptor
HA
= Histamine
Lanosterol
= Lanosta-8,24-dien-3-ol
Lazofoxifene
= (5R,6S)-6-phenyl-5-[4-(2pyrrolidin-1-yletho xy)phenyl]5,6,7,8-tetrahydronaphthalen-2-ol
MBOPE
= [4-(2-morpholin-4-ylethoxy)phenyl]-phenylmethanone
PBPE
= 1-[2-[4-(phenylmethyl)phenoxy]
ethyl]-pyrrolidine
Raloxifene
SA
= Steroidal alkaloid
SC5D
= 3-hydroxysteroid-5-desaturase
SERM
Tamoxifen
5,6-EC
5,6-EC
= 5,6-epoxycholes terol
7-dehydro
cholesterol
= Cholest-5,7-dien-3-ol
AEBS
Azido-MBPE
= 4-[2-(2-azido-4-benzylphenoxy)ethyl]morpholine
Tesmilifene
Bazedoxifene
= 1-{4-[2-(azepan-1-yl)ethoxy]benzyl}-2-(4-hydroxyphenyl)-3methyl-1H-indol-5-ol
= DPPE, N,N-diethyl-2-[4-(phenylmethyl)phenoxy]-ethanamine
Triparanol
BC
= Breast cancer
Boxidine
= (1-[2-[[4'-(Trifluoromethyl)-4biphenylyl]oxy] ethyl]pyrrolidine)
Zymostenol
= 5-Cholest-8-ene-3-ol
ChEH
= Cholesterol-5,6-epoxide hydrolase
Zymosterol
= 5-Cholesta-8,24-dien-3-ol
Cholesterol
= Cholest-5-en-3-ol
Clomiphene
= 2-[4-[(E)-2-chloro-1,2diphenylethenyl]phenoxy]-N, Ndiethylethanamine
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
Dendrogenins are developed for clinical applications by the company AFFICHEM, of which MP and
SSP are founders.
Dalenc et al.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
All authors contributed to the writing of this manuscript. This work was founded by the institute National de la sant et de la recherch mdicale, the University of Toulouse III, and the Institut Claudius Regaud. This work was supported by the Agence Nationale pour la Recherche (ANR): ANR 11-RPIB-015-02
DAML, ANR-11-PHUC-0001, the DIRECCTE
Midi-Pyrnes and the Communaut Urbaine de Toulouse mtropole : Onco San Tech (projet DEMODA
RMN13001BBA) and by the Labex Trail (Universit
Bordeaux).
[13]
[14]
[15]
[16]
REFERENCES
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[17]
[18]
[19]
[20]
[21]
[22]
[23]
[24]
[25]
[27]
[28]
[29]
[30]
[31]
[32]
[33]
[34]
[35]
[36]
[37]
[38]
[39]
[42]
[43]
[44]
[45]
[46]
[47]
[48]
[49]
[50]
[51]
[52]
[53]
[54]
15
[59]
[60]
[61]
[62]
[63]
[64]
[65]
[66]
[67]
[68]
[69]
[70]
[71]
[72]
Dalenc et al.
[73]
[74]
[75]
[76]
[77]
[78]
[79]
[80]
[81]
[82]
[83]
[84]
[85]
[86]
[87]
[88]
[89]
[90]
[91]
[92]
Received: ????????????????
Revised: ????????????????
Accepted: ????????????????
[93]
[94]
[95]
[96]
17