Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.jmwh.org
Original Research
Introduction: This study sought to identify womens concerns regarding breastfeeding during the prenatal period and determine whether women
thought that health care providers addressed these concerns.
Methods: A structured interview with both open-ended and closed-ended questions addressing the study objectives was administered to a crosssectional sample of 130 English-speaking or Spanish-speaking postpartum women at Yale-New Haven Hospital.
Results: When asked an open-ended question regarding whether they had concerns about breastfeeding while making their decisions about
feeding their infants, 81.5% of women identified at least 1 concern. Of these women, only 25.4% reported that this concern was addressed by the
provider during prenatal care. When prompted with 8 common concerns regarding breastfeeding during the prenatal period, 95.4% of women
identified at least 1 of these preidentified concerns. Only 17.4% of women who identified any of these 8 concerns reported that the concerns had
been discussed with a provider.
Discussion: Womens recall of prenatal health care discussions strongly suggests that providers are not adequately addressing womens concerns
about breastfeeding.
c 2011 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives.
J Midwifery Womens Health 2011;56:27
Keywords: breastfeeding, concerns, counseling, prenatal care
INTRODUCTION
METHODS
The benefits of breastfeeding to infants and mothers are welldocumented.1 The American College of Nurse-Midwives and
the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
recommend that providers encourage breastfeeding.2,3 As
providers for women from the preconception period through
postpartum, midwives, obstetrician-gynecologists, and family medicine practitioners have a unique opportunity to promote breastfeeding throughout womens lives and particularly
in the prenatal period. National as well as various local surveys
indicate that 75% to 100% of prenatal care providers report
recommending breastfeeding to their patients, and a similar
percentage believe they play an important role in womens decisions regarding infant feeding.46,7
In contrast, patients report being advised to breastfeed by
their providers only 40% to 60% of the time (estimates range
from 23% to 73%).812 One possible explanation for the difference in perception of breastfeeding advice is the method
of communication used by providers. Communication centered on patients and their concerns rather than on biomedical information has been shown to be more effective at increasing patients abilities to synthesize information and make
decisions.13
The aims of this study are to describe womens concerns
about breastfeeding during the prenatal period and to determine whether women perceived that their prenatal care
providers addressed these concerns.
We conducted a cross-sectional study with convenience sampling. Eligible participants included all English-speaking or
Spanish-speaking postpartum women who had a live birth
at Yale-New Haven Hospital between October 20, 2006, and
January 9, 2007. Women with medical conditions such as
HIV, in which breastfeeding is not recommended, or with infants unable to suckle secondary to congenital anomalies or
other medical conditions such as extreme prematurity were
excluded from participation. The Human Investigation Committee at Yale University approved this study.
Measures
c 2011 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives
1526-9523/09/$36.00 doi:10.1111/j.1542-2011.2010.00006.x
Data analysis was performed with the SAS 9.1 (SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC) statistical analysis software package.
Bivariate analyses were performed to describe associations
between maternal characteristics, feeding choice, concerns
about breastfeeding, and provider communication about concerns. Categorical variables were compared by use of chisquare tests and the Fisher exact test, when appropriate. Responses to the open-ended and closed-ended questions were
analyzed separately. Statistical significance was defined as a
P value less than or equal to .05.
RESULTS
During the study period, 146 women meeting inclusion criteria were approached during postpartum hospitalization,
which ranged from postpartum day 1 through 4. Four women
(3%) declined participation, and 12 (8%) deferred the interview to a later time but were subsequently not able to be interviewed. A total of 130 women completed the study, yielding
a participation rate of 89%. Because of the convenience samJournal of Midwifery & Womens Health r www.jmwh.org
Table 1. Characteristics of Women Whose Concerns About Breastfeeding Were and Were Not Addressed During Prenatal Care.
Concerns Addressed
Total
Characteristic
(N = )
29.5 (6.3)
Yes (n = )a
26.3 (6.6)
No (n = )a
P valueb
31.0 (5.6)
.001
.054
Parity, n (%)
Nulliparous
63 (48.5)
26 (60.5)
37 (42.5)
Multiparous
67 (51.5)
17 (39.5)
50 (47.5)
Yes
50 (38.5)
9 (20.9)
41 (47.1)
No
80 (61.5)
34 (79.1)
46 (52.9)
.004
.001
Race/ethnicity, n (%)
White
72 (55.3)
15 (34.9)
57 (65.5)
African American
23 (17.7)
15 (34.9)
8 (9.2)
Hispanic
22 (16.9)
7 (16.3)
15 (17.2)
Asian
7 (5.4)
0 (0)
7 (8.1)
Other
6 (4.6)
6 (14.0)
0 (0)
.246
101 (77.7)
36 (83.7)
65 (74.7)
29 (22.3)
7 (16.3)
22 (25.3)
Yes
88 (67.7)
21 (48.8)
67 (77.0)
No
42 (32.3)
22 (51.2)
20 (23)
Other
0.001
Married, n (%)
0.412
97 (74.6)
34 (79.1)
63 (72.4)
No
33 (25.4)
9 (20.9)
24 (38.1)
Private
90 (69.2)
22 (51.2)
68 (78.2)
Hospital clinic
40 (30.7)
21 (48.8)
19 (21.8)
.002
.081
Provider, n (%)
Physician
47 (36.2)
16 (37.2)
31 (35.6)
Midwife
21 (16.2)
11 (25.6)
10 (11.5)
Both
62 (47.7)
16 (37.2)
46 (52.9)
.002
Education, n (%)
High school or less
37 (28.5)
21 (48.8)
16 (18.4)
Some college
25 (19.2)
8 (18.6)
17 (19.5)
College graduate
35 (26.9)
6 (14.0)
29 (33.3)
Postgraduate
33 (25.4)
8 (18.6)
25 (28.7)
$10,000
29 (22.3)
12 (27.9)
17 (19.5)
$10,000-$24,000
16 (12.3)
13 (30.2)
3 (3.5)
$24,000
85 (65.4)
18 (41.9)
67 (77.0)
.001
Income, n (%)
.337
78 (60)
22 (51.2)
56 (64.4)
Formula
26 (20)
10 (23.3)
16 (18.4)
Mixed
26 (20)
11 (25.6)
15 (17.2)
a
Percentages
b
Total
Breastfeeding
Formula Feeding
Mixed Feeding
N = n ()
n = n ()
n = n ()
n = n ()
P Value
106 (81.5)
63 (80.8)
22 (84.6)
21 (80.8)
.903
Lifestyle/flexibility
21 (16.2)
9 (11.5)
8 (30.8)
4 (15.4)
Pain
17 (13.1)
9 (11.5)
3 (11.5)
5 (19.2)
Confidence
47 (36.2)
35 (44.9)
6 (23.1)
6 (23.1)
Work
17 (13.1)
8 (10.3)
3 (11.5)
6 (23.1)
4 (3.1)
2 (2.6)
2 (7.7)
0 (0.0)
24 (18.5)
15 (19.2)
4 (15.4)
5 (19.2)
33 (25.4)
17 (21.8)
8 (30.8)
8 (30.8)
.138
Primary concern
Medications
None identified
.512
Responses in this table come from the open-ended question, While making your decision about how to feed your baby, did you have concerns about breastfeeding?
The overwhelming majority of women have concerns regarding breastfeeding during prenatal care. Although 81.5%
of women initially identified a primary concern regarding
breastfeeding, 95.4% reported sharing at least 1 of the 8
common concerns identified in the literature. The concerns
women identified in this study were similar to those previously identified. The majority of the literature on this topic
comes from qualitative focus groups and interviews. A focus group of upper-middle-class and middle-class women
Table 3. Prevalence of 8 Common Concerns Regarding Breastfeeding by Feeding Choice and Percentage of Women Who Reported That These
Concerns Were Addressed in Prenatal Care.a
Total
Reporting
Concern
Breastfeeding
Formula Feeding
Mixed Feeding
Reporting
Reporting
Reporting
Concern N =
Addressed
Concern n =
Concern n =
Concern n =
Valuec
61 (46.9)
13 (21.3)
29 (37.2)
16 (61.5)
16 (61.5)
.024
57 (43.9)
12 (21.1)
37 (47.4)
8 (30.8)
12 (46.2)
.321
Pain
55 (42.3)
15 (27.3)
31 (39.7)
11 (42.3)
13 (50.0)
.657
Difficulty sharing
45 (34.6)
6 (13.3)
22 (28.2)
14 (53.9)
9 (34.2)
.059
Anxiety/embarrassment
42 (32.3)
0 (0.0)
28 (35.9)
12 (46.2)
2 (7.7)
.007
Difficulty maintaining
31 (23.9)
8 (25.8)
12 (15.4)
12 (46.2)
7 (26.9)
.006
19 (14.6)
1 (5.3)
9 (11.5)
6 (23.1)
4 (15.4)
.351
Body image
18 (13.9)
2 (11.1)
12 (15.4)
4 (15.4)
2 (7.7)
.597
Concern, n ()
feeding responsibility
mothers diet/health
a
Responses in this table come from
b
Among total reporting concern.
c
Chi-square analysis comparing the percentage reporting this concern by infant feeding choice postpartum.